My loving husband is Brooklyn (NYC) native. With that being said we are always on the lookout for true NY style pizza. While in the Fayetteville area we stopped by Brooklyn Pizzeria (Bragg Blvd). Hubby & I gives it . On the inside it looks to be family oriented and the pizza was really good. The only exception is the crust was a bit chewy... Anyway we both agree that when we are in the area again it's worth stopping by! read more

I just realized that I've only ever ordered delivery and I've never actually been here. I have no idea what it looks like inside Their pizza though is awesome New York style thinCrust. The pizzas are huge, taste amazing, and they deliver to Ft Bragg. My favorite pizza place in the area read more

Great service great food. Although they're prices went up a little bag. It is still the best place in town to eat exclamation.

Awesome pizza, just gets busy during lunch. Recommend calling ahead of you're short on time. Chicken Parm sandwich is a must try!

Since I have been at Fort Bragg from 2016 to present this has been my favorite pizzeria I wish they delivered in to Fayetteville but they deliver on Bragg so for soldiers on base this is a perfect spot to get good pizza at a great price read more

Best pizza in town. If you're looking for authentic Pennsylvania or New York pizza, look no further. This is it.

I got a medium cheese pizza and was expecting it to be on the smaller size, but was pleasantly surprised with a huge and delicious pizza.

I love coming in here! I've been coming to Brooklyn all my life, it's a staple of life in Spring Lake. The service has always been great and the food is phenomenal. I've recently started to branch out to other things in the menu besides a slice of cheese pizza, but what can I say? I know what I like and if it ain't broke lol ‍ read more

The food is great but the customer service is lacking. It doesn't matter how busy you are that's not an excuse to treat paying customers bad. The food can be great but if the customer service sucks I rather take my business someplace else. This just happen Fri Jan 29 2021 around 3:55 pm read more

By far the closest thing to New York Pizza around here!! I'm always skeptical about trying pizzerias that have the Name Brooklyn considering I am from New York and know what good pizza is. Well they take the cake! Friendly staff good service everything was up to par! And they have beer and football on the tv!! I mean you can't get any better than that right!!!!! The pizza was AMAZING!!!!! Definitely will be coming back for more. read more

Brooklyn Pizzeria - Large half cheese half bacon and sausage - Pizza Near Me - Spring Lake, North Carolina

Tonight will be our 3rd time going. The food and prices are great. Wait times vary, but so worth it. Definitely call ahead for pick up.

Food is great. Customer service is awful. Phone etiquette is terrible. These two things keep us from spending 3x as much money as we would. Sometimes I would just prefer a mediocre pizza made or served by someone who seems happy. read more

The service and pizza, was just right! Thank you, guys! It's a nice to have a touch of home so close work!

The pizza here is truly amazing. Just walking in to the restaurant, it smelled like a NY pizzeria. Since discovering this place, have shared it with the family and have eaten here at least three times. The large cheese pizza is enormous!... get it, you won't be disappointed! read more

Not terrible, but not a place I'm willing to return. First time here. Ordered a large special pizza (has mushrooms, pepperoni, sausage, beef, onions, black olives, jalapeños, pineapple, and bacon), a salad (which had ham, pepporocini, green olives, a piece of salami and cheese), and a cannoli. Cons - Crust is way too thin! Dudes, hubby and I kept bending forward to catch our pizza slices with our mouths. Pro- pizza had a decent amount of toppings. Con- can't catch your food, which isn't what's supposed to happen! Hubby and I used our fork from the salad super often cuz we had to get/catch the toppings. There also wasn't a decent amount of cheese on the pizza. - Don't do takeout. Given the flimsy nature of the pizza, I wouldn't recommend takeout. - Overpriced! It's $2.50 for 1 friggin' cannoli!! Our large special pizza, which took extra work to eat was $24. We paid around $17 out of pocket with our restaurant.com credit. Not enough value for money. - No menu online. - Salad was mostly chopped iceberg lettuce. No nutritional value there. - Pizza had canned mushrooms, not fresh. That leads me to believe they don't have high turnover on customers, ergo food. - Staff isn't knowledgeable. My husband and I purchased a $15 credit voucher on restaurant.com. This requires us to order $30 worth of food. When we finished ordering and we're going to pay with our voucher, one of the staff was like, "Wait, they need to order $50 worth of food." We were like, "Uh that's not what the website says." If you're going to have specials and/or ads somewhere, you need to be knowledgeable as to what you're advertising. - inconvenient hours. Hubby and I came on a Sunday and this place doesn't open until 1pm. Very inconvenient so I was starving by the time we arrived. Pros (Yes, there are some upsides!) - Decent inside space. Can hold 4-6 people (depending on how small they are) per table. - The taste of the pizza itself with the toppings isn't bad, but too much work to eat. - Handmade. We could see the pizza chef tossing the dough and making the pizza. Atleast that looked legit. Final Answer- Not on my list of pizza places to go back to. I've had better quality and at better prices. Papa John's and Mellow Mushroom have better pizza and will continue to receive our business. read more

See all

This was a great place to get food. The wife and I have been buying from only local places during this pandemic and cam across this place. The pizza was delicious along with the bread sticks. Will be back for sure. read more

Pizza was good but the wings were horrible. We are not from here so I asked for recommendation on the wings and she said they were good extra crispy. Well, they were soggy and small with no flavor. They also tasted like freezer burn. So not order the wings! read more

I've frequented Spring Lake/Ft Bragg area for over 10 years and Brooklyn has always been a stop for me. It's pizza. Period. The store doesn't insist on itself. There's no frills. I can get a slice and a beer, have a seat at the counter and read a paper without having to deal with screaming kids or hipsters. I don't need pseudo-friendly servers to enjoy a good slice of pizza. I'll keep coming. read more

The only thing am disappointed about is that I've lived here for 2 years and just had Brooklyn Pizzeria for the first time last night!!! It was so good that I've already ordered it again today. And they deliver to Ft Bragg!! I ordered some wings today too so we'll see how they are but the pizza is on point!! read more

SOO good!! The garlic knots are actually delicious. The service was quick and pleasant.

Definitely a solid 4. I only didn't give it 5 because the crust was a little too hard for me and I thought the red sauce on the pizza didn't really have flavor. Not uneatable by any means, but just missing that little extra. The garlic knots were pretty good as well. read more

Brooklyn Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Spring Lake, North Carolina

See all

Do yourself the favor fam, get a pie from here. Is it pricey? A bit. Is it worth it? Hell yeah, and Im from NJ. Pizza is literally the only thing we can be proud about so I know good pizza, and this is good pizza. Good wings too. read more

Growing up in jersey and visting family in Brooklyn this pizzeria made me feel right at home ! I live in Charlotte now and I'm here visiting and this place is better than any spot I been too in Charlotte. The pizza was awesome and the Jamaican beef patty was amazing. I would give this place 5 stars if it wasn't for those dry garlic knots I had. read more

Amazing, never fail, pizza!!! Love it! Always burning hot and fresh. Taste just like NY pizza.

The pizza was greasy and delicious!!!! Never had pizza like that, huge pieces as well. Great thin slices!!!!

Good pizza a little greasy but still really enjoyable! Price is great for the size of the pizza you get ok!

First time order and it was delivery. Delivery time was great 30-35 min. Large pizza is huge but it wasn't greasy like a ny style pizza. It satisfied me. read more

Not the worst, definitely better than Some of the chain pizza places around here. Cons are that the crust is way to thin, they don't use fresh mushrooms. Once in a while it's a good place to get a pizza when you're to lazy to cook read more

I like it. I'm not really an expert on exactly what makes the perfect Brooklyn style pie but I totally recommend this restaurant. Get in there a little before 11:30 on weekdays before it gets busy and your sanity will thank you for it. read more

Above average pizza. It doesn't slap like when "Sweet Caroline" comes on 10 deep at a baseball game, but more like the song on shuffle you could skip, but you don't. If this place is local to you, it should be a staple pizza option. Slaps read more

Best pizza around Fort Bragg. The wings are alright. The inside seating alright. A party of 5 was to big for any table they had. The guy that took my order was kind. I'll definitely be back. read more

The Absolute best in all of NC! I've been in-love with this place since the early 90's. I can't speak for the other location(s) but the one in Spring Lake has never disappointed me. I usually order a beer an a slice while I wait for my large to be prepared. read more

I ordered in from my hotel which is just down the road from the restaurant. The pizza came a lot faster than they said it would I was pretty excited about that. I ordered the Brooklyn special which had a lot of toppings on it. In fact I had too many toppings which made the pizza very sloppy and very hard to eat. The center of the pizza was very watery and when they lifted it up all the toppings just fell out. The taste was good but overall I like a crispier pizza and one that stands up when I lift it up out of the box. read more

Don't come in, the outside should give you an idea how the inside is, it's actually worse. The feeling you get from the restaurant has that dirty feel to it, don't know if this is the same Pizza Restaurant as Ramsey's considering it taste the same but dang, it was an uncomfortable feeling eating pizza. I should have got up and left when me and my wife saw a cockroach. Never again. read more

Best true pizza in Fayetteville. Staff is really friendly. Pizza is cooked perfect always comes out hot with minimal grease. Go Duke!

I'm so happy that I stumbled upon this place! It's kind of a hole-in-the- wall, but their pizza is phenomenal- really reminds me of home. The cheese, the sauce, the crust was all perfect. Got two giant slices of pizza for like $5. I just moved here and I'm super picky when it comes to pizza. Let's just say I'll definitely be back. read more

Love the pizza flavor and crust. The pepperoni is always extremely greasy and even though that is our family's favorite topping we often pick something else. The lasagna is not recommended as the meat has a weird taste to it. We LOVE the garlic knots! Good sandwiches too. read more

We picked up a large everything pizza w/extra cheese. The pizza is HUGE. Coming from DC I was craving a place like Jumbo Slice and this place is the next best thing. $25 for a pizza that could easily feed a frat house. We will definitely be repeat customers read more

Brooklyn Pizzeria - Large everything w/extra cheese - Pizza Near Me - Spring Lake, North Carolina

I can't love the pizza enough. Not sure if they make their own sauce but it sure taste like it! The crisp of the crust was perfect, nice warm crispy and soft all where you want it. We were pretty simple and ordered a pepperoni and jalapeno pizza but it was worth every penny. Yumm! Coming here again! read more

First time eating here. Got it to go. Was about a 20 min wait not to bad. We got the large pepperoni, boy was it huge. Biggest pizza I had ever seen just alittle greasy. Also had the knots and a salad they were pretty good. The pizza was the best I have had in a while. Will deff be ordering again. read more

See all