Enjoyed a delicious grandma pizza. The sauce was perfection along with the crispy edges. Can't wait to try it again!

Excellent pie and garlic knots. Haven't been in the area for over a year and finally got back and went here. Highly recommend!

Do not order delivery from Beyond Delivery. Twice my order was not ordered. Tonight Brothers offered to send a new pizza but I declined.

I grew up in the area, my parents went here as a child for pizza night so I brought that to my familys pizza night. The employee, u should get to know them, bc they are the most kindhearte, considerat, carin, friendly & amazing customer servic. if you have any problems they will help. they are a small family resturant that gets busy so def be prepared to possibly wait or order early. i have tried everything on their menu - from apps, lunch, dinners & dessert. let me tell you! if you love cheesecake u need to get one from here! not only are their portions shareable, the price is best in the area! these are very hard working people who have had this restaurants as a childhood memory for me. when I got older and moved back to the area the brothers remembered my father which made me feel specia. if you love cats or need a cat rescued they helped me out there too! they always have a smile on their face & love seeing people return. idk why they have low ratings rn, maybe because no one who has been coming to this place uses the internet. everything is made to order, fresh never frozen, and being able to have a pizza night that is not killing your bank account! please give them a chance if u haven't already! understand the importance of their work knowing this has been in their family for generations & take pride in everything they make. they are small staff but who isint nowadays? I wish I had pictures to share I will asap! read more

Awesome pizza and great relaxing place my family and I have been going here for over 30 yrs and love the pizza and shrimp appetizers. The food comes fast and the waitresses are always very friendly. I highly recommend you try it read more

I've been enjoying consistently great pizza from this location. I've been ordering for about three years and the only bad experience was a pizza delivered that looked as though it were used as a frisbee! I ordered one with extra cheese and it was just all over the place, but this has also happened with other restaurants that delivered extra cheese pies, so if I want a pie with extra cheese, I will just simply drive and pick it up myself. Any other pie has always been very good, and most of the times, with toppings, you don't even need the extra cheese. Brother's is probably my favorite now and will mostly continue to use them over the other places I've ordered from. Dinners and subs are just ok, and I wasn't too pleased with their wings. Pizza is what I will stick to and I'm perfectly satisfied with that! read more

Brother's Pizza - Love it. Consistently good! - Pizza Near Me - West Long Branch, New Jersey

Always a great experience! They've been neighborhood spot for years. From enjoying pizza from all over NY & NJ - Brothers can keep up with the rest. Friendly, great prices, and always great fresh quality! Thanks for another great slice! read more

These guys make the best pie in Long Branch, BUT they have gotten way too expensive over the last year or two.

Friendly brother owners, pizza excellent and a variety of Stromboli which they call rolls or wraps really excellent. Seating area small but comfortable. A selection of soft drinks. Prices very reasonable. Broadway in West Long Branch, NJ. read more

I should have been more influenced by the negative reviews of this restaurant's poor service record and their messing up of orders! Although I had ordered here several times before and had had poor service before, I thought I'd give them another chance because I remembered that the food was quite good. But this place has gotten even worse! I ordered chicken noodle soup (and got pasta fagiole), my husband's spaghetti and meatballs arrived without the advertised salad. (I was told salad was offered on the OLD menu --- which is what I had --- and did not come with the dish anymore but they were awaiting the new menus any day!) Based on the menu that I was given on my last visit, I was, this time, overcharged $1.50 for the spaghetti, $1 for the soup and $1.50 on a half sub. I was also charged $2 for delivery whereas my menu said delivery was free for orders over $10. (My order came to $27.50!) In checking my credit card charge, I see they actually charged me $30.50!! So not only are they sloppy businessmen, they are dishonest thieves also! In addition, the order was promised in 45 minutes but, after calling to inquire about it, it didn't appear until almost twice that time. I gave Brothers one star because the food was, as before, quite good but I know I won't be patronizing them again. That's their loss. Was losing a customer and getting a scathing review worth $3 to you, Brothers? read more

I loved the pizza the first time I tried it, but every Uber order since, I have ordered topping on half the pizza, and have received toppings on the whole pizza, which means one of us doesn't get to eat. Very frustrating and a waste of money. If the kitchen could follow what their orders actually are, I would love to be a loyal customer. read more

I am a NJ native now living in TN and I have been eating pizza since I was five from all the best pizzerias in NY, NJ. This is the best Margherita Pizza in New Jersey! Louie is the best. Excellent service and food is outrageous and very reasonably priced. Best value in the state. He packed one up special for me to take back to TN... Louie and his staff make for a very pleasant experience, definitely stop by! read more

Brother's Pizza - Excellent Margherita Pizza!!! - Pizza Near Me - West Long Branch, New Jersey

This is a place that I actively stayed away from due to the low Yelp rating. We had gone to the Quick Chek next door for soup while I was sick. Dismayed to find they only had chili at the time, I thought I'd try my luck at Brothers. I'm glad I did because their chicken noodle soup is among the best I've ever had. We tried them again a few days later and their pizza is also very good, maybe the best in the city with the exception of Nunzio's. The interior though leaves much to be desired and hardly looks inviting enough to sit down and eat, so this is best as a take out option. Since I haven't had much of the menu as well, I am withholding one star. Yelp reviews generally don't lead me astray, but this one misses the mark. read more

See all

Always good. Margherita 5 out of 5 Sicilian 5 out of 5. Garlic knots 5 out of 5. Owners are great.

Pizza is good but something weird is going on here. I ordered a large pie with pepperoni and a 2 L brisk. Totaling to around 23 dollar pre tax. With tax lets say 25 I got charged 33 dollars. Unless im unaware of other fees here i dont know why there prices are so high. Probably tipping themselves??? I dont know Ps: large pie $15 Pepperoni: $3.50 Brisk: $4 read more

Went to Brothers Pizza after many years of avoiding it (Its been so long, I forgot why I stopped lol). I ordered and picked up a cali cheesesteak with a side of fries. I called ahead and the food was prepared in the time-frame they gave me. The cheesesteak was great as they stuffed it with plenty of toppings. As for the french fries, they came out a little bit mushy but still edible enough to finish. The people working the counter were friendly and bilingual as we spoke Spanglish (Spanish + English). Next time I'll go back to try out their pizza (the real test). read more

Get the grandma pie.. it's the best!!!! Anytime we want pizza, this place is our go to! The wings are great, too. read more

Brother's Pizza - a pizza in a box - Pizza Near Me - West Long Branch, New Jersey

See all

Years ago, this was my family's go to place for pizza and everything else. Not anymore. Last night I ordered through Grub Hub and the food was sub par to say the least. The pizza and hot dog were lukewarm. The pan pizza ended up in the garbage. The crust was awful, dry with no taste, there was little to no sauce on it and the cheese was flavorless. I took two bits of a slice and the rest went in the trash. What a waste of $14.00. The Italian hot dog was edible but certainly not a true rendition of an Italian hot dog. One positive thing I can say is my eggplant rollatini dinner was spot on as always and hot on arrival. Cannoli was good as well. Not sure if I'm going to order from here again. When I called to find out the status of my order which was late by almost 40 minutes, there didn't seem to be any sense of urgency. So we'll see if they respond to my review on Grub Hub. read more

Totally awesome. The most delicious meal I've had out in months! I enjoyed everything from brothers long branch pizza Italian restaurant for the last year I've been eating there. 5 STARS. If anybody says different they must be lying crazy or it was a freak accident. The owners and employees are so nice they would replace or fix any problem you have. I doubt very much they ever have to. 2 thumbs up, 5 stars, munching time!! read more

See all

Honestly this place needs a good scrubbing, top to bottom, walls and everything. The place is filthy. Sorry to say especially in times like these with businesses struggling but that should be even more reason to keep the place at least somewhat clean. The pizza was average but I would never return because of the deplorable conditions inside. read more

I have always ordered online so never had to deal with customer service issues as others reported. But our delivery guy is super friendly, courteous and always on time. We have tried four different pies; pan, Sicilian, grandma and the white with spinach. All of them were delicious and fresh. This is our go-to pizza place. Delicious!! read more

the food is absolutely a 5/5. want to give it 3 stars cause no matter what food is always late, even for pick up. wouldn't ever order for delivery cause it'll be cold. but the food is fucking fantastic. and the owners are great people. read more

Brother's Pizza - a pizza in a box - Pizza Near Me - West Long Branch, New Jersey

This calzone was ordered at 7pm with 2 Snapples, instead I was sent two slices. It arrived at 8:30. I've ordered plenty of calzones in my life, plus I am also a chef to know that this is undercooked. The inside of a calzone should not be doughy. I was told by the owner that he's been doing this for 30 years and no way is it undercooked. I told him send his driver back and you can see for yourself. He declined. You can judge for yourself by the photos below. That's dough in the photo not melted cheese. Plus he didn't have the decency to chop the ham up. Just one giant slice. Avoid this place when there's a lot of others nearby read more

Brother's Pizza - a half eaten piece of bread - Pizza Near Me - West Long Branch, New Jersey

See all

I gotta say i felt like a brother here great people working here. Pizza was awesome from north jersey and every summer when we go to the shore we always look forward to this pizza. Probably the best pizza would recommended eating in. read more

Terrible service. They don't never ever get my order right there is always something missing or switched to a different things. They say 40 mins to deliver the food they always take an hour and up and i get my food cold , they never respect the costumers on the phone they start yelling and talking with a bad way. They have the worst management i ever seen in my life !!! read more

Simply terrible. Came in from 7 hours away for a short vacation and got this place on the first night. First complaint: the employees seem to have no idea what is going on or what they have. Second complaint: the food was TERRIBLE! We ordered 3 calzones which were stuffed with very nasty tasting cheese and very little toppings considering that we ordered 3 different ones in them. I would not recommend this place to anyone. read more

Excellent raviolis and meatballs super fast friendly delivery a must try I love the pizza too

Really bad pizza. The bread tastes like a pretzel, bland tomato sauce and low quality cheese.

Travelers beware! Got menu from hotel with coupons so tried to order with a coupon and I got "coupons are only for people who live here the boss said" I asked what it would cost and he rattled off the price of aches item smh then had to ask again for a total ended up canceling my order to patronize another pizza joint. read more

If I could I would put zero stars for my experience here.!! I would have been better going to McDonald's or dominoes pizza.!!! I ordered through grubhub which i do all the time for years now and never had no problem.!! The pizza was wrong and brought it back.. This is were the drama started.!!! The man cooking the pizza was so rude screaming about how he just wasted food.. Not my fault my phone shows what I ordered and in there defense there receipt also showed different.. No problem after a few back and forth crazy talk from the cook he gets to making another pizza.!! 2nd time pizza is still wrong, right in front of me he pulls off the peppers and switches to the other side, puts it back in the oven... I also ordered French fries which u would expect to make another batch.... Well let me tell u.!! This is the worst pizza I have ever ate, it tasted like the crust had already been made, the sauce thrown on there, chesse wasn't even cooked and the crust was so hard u couldn't even eat it.!!! The French fries I returned at the same time as the first pizza, was the same French fries I took home.!! Freezing cold.!!! All in all that was a waste of my money cos no one ate any of it.!!!! What a shame cos I have ate in this place so many times and never had no problem.!!! Advice to everyone.!! Stay away.!!! Pizza was gross and the man who was cooking was so rude it isn't worth wasting your money.!!! A guy also buying a slice watched the cook pull the peppers off one side and switch to another and his face said it all as well.!!! The only advantage the nice guy who serves with the blue cap was so nice and professional but stay away.!!!! read more

The pizza here is amazing as well as the extremely friendly staff!! I don't live very close to here but I'm willing to take the drive for there quality food!!! This place is a must try!!!! read more

Great pizza delivery. Super fast and everything is delicious. Penne vodka and shrimp parmesan subs are our favorites. Best pizza I have had in Monmouth county. read more

This is probably the worst pizzeria I have ever dealt with or food I have ever had and this coming from a pizza LOVER first off u order a side of something and get there and told no we don't have with great attitude. Second I walk I and the one guy can barley even stand whatever he is on or whatever, on top of him enjoying a slice of pizza right over the counter and taking orders! Of the last is the best let's not forget the plan pizza that is straight on the counter top no tray no nothing waiting for customers to come in and get served a slice! WORST EXPERIENCE EVER!! NASTY AND DISGUSTING!!! read more

Great food! Pizza is always great. Always have ate at the place (never tried the delivery). Loses a star because the place looks like a hole in the wall. read more

I've eaten in this place several times, the service is good. The pizza is excellent. My favorite is the bacon, chicken ranch. The food is good, the soup is made fresh. read more

Ordered pizza, a medium rare burger, and garlic bread. pizza arrived in crushed box with cheese stuck to the top of the box. Burger arrived well done and hard as a rock it was hard to cut through. The only thing not effed up was the garlic bread. Everything arrived at room temperature. read more

Horrible! Ordered cavatelli and broccoli and garlic bread. The broccoli was so over cooked it turned to mush in your mouth without even chewing it. The pasta was over cooked as well. The garlic bread was more like parsley bread since it was a solid green from being fully covered in parsley and it had no garlic flavor and was very dry like it was missing the butter or oil people normally use to make garlic bread. So disappointed. Stay away. read more

horrible customer service today, plus food isnt that good. the owner told my friend he couldnt come in with a wrap he bought next door at quikchek even tho he was with me and i bought food from them. read more

I was visiting family in the area and pass this pizza joint on my way to their house and I decided to try it. Young man that was working behind the counter was very helpful and friendly. We talked the whole time I was there and I felt like I was at home. I ordered the Super sub which was their version of the Italian cold cut hero. It was so delicious. The bread was fresh and have a great pull that Italian bread is supposed to have. I was so upset when my hero was gone. Unfortunately I live in the south and was only visiting so I will not have the opportunity to visit this establishment anytime soon but trust and believe that every time I go back to visit my family I will be going to Brothers Pizza. read more

I was looking for thin crispy crust pizza in West Long Branch/Long Branch after being gone for 30 years. I stopped in at Brothers. It did not disappoint me. They served the pizza of my youth. It was just great. My wife had never had NJ pizza and was wowed by it. And the folks behind the counter were engaging and generous. Go there. It is pizza as it should be!! read more