My wife and I often stop here for dinner and as always the pizza was fantastic and our waiter Anthony was awesome

I've been going to The Brothers Pizza for 50+ years. We recently went on a Thursday night and to be honest the pizza wasn't great. Something changed. When you eat the same pizza for as many years as I have, you notice a change in flavor of the pie. My go too is thin crust and sausage. Not sure if they changed the cheese or the sausage vender, but I really noticed the taste. I will always go to the Brothers and hopefully it was just an off day. read more

I've been a loyal customer for over 30 years, and Ralphie has always treated me kindly. But something has definitely changed--and unfortunately, not for the better. I recently ordered some pasta and a pizza to go. The pizza crust was nothing like it used to be--tough, bland, and cardboard-like. It felt like something pre-made from a grocery store. I used to love their pizza, but now, not so much. As for the pasta, it was overcooked, which, coming from an Italian restaurant, feels almost like a sin. Time to say a novena! On a positive note, the sauce has improved. It used to be overloaded with garlic, but now it's more balanced--decent, not amazing, but definitely a step up. Still, I can't get over how bad the pizza was. What happened? With so much local competition, you'd think Ralph would want to stand out--maybe reinvent the pizza, create buzz on social media, and bring in more customers. But letting things slide like this feels like surrendering to mediocrity. Disappointed is an understatement. read more

The best mussels and shrimp scampi pizza in the area! Nice and garlicky. Save the extra sauce for dipping the pizza! read more

The Brothers - Shrimp scampi pizza and mussels with mild marinara - Pizza Near Me - Red Bank, New Jersey

See all

Before I dive into this, the service is NOT the issue. The staff was wonderful. I have been going to brother's for as long as I can remember. I went last night for the first time in a couple of years. I'm not sure if they changed ownership, but the pizza was far different than what I remember. The crust felt and tasted undercooked, it wasn't as crispy as it used to be. I know for a fact that they are using different cheese because the pizza was incredibly oily, and the cheese had a weird flavor to it. This place has been a tradition in my family, but sadly, the tradition is ending. As crazy as it may seem, I think Domino's would have been better had I known that the pizza would be this terrible. read more

The ambiance is 1950s. The food was OK, nothing special. It was a Sunday night, restaurant was slow, but definitely not empty. The staff started to stack chairs on empty tables in full view of and near to customers who were still eating. it was still one hour before the posted closing time. My comment didn't matter. This restaurant was highly recommended to me. I live nearby. I will not go back. read more

I was Just there with friends last night, been coming here forever. I hate to agree with some of the reviews but they say "Something has changed" and last night I had to agree. We ordered pizza, salads and tort ellini. The salads were great but the pizza was dry and somewhat bland and the tortellini not much better. I hope it's just blip because I really like this old standard. read more

The Brothers is past its prime and overrated at this point. Outside of being able to seat large parties, there are many other better options in the area from a quality and cost perspective read more

This is the best crust pizza I've ever had. I got a sausage and peppers, thin crust pizza, and the pizza was not greasy at all despite the homemade sausage that you could tell was all over it. It's a must have one in the area. read more

Food is just okay. They were a little skimpy on the toppings for the pizza. Ambiance is very casual, but the service was phenomenal. read more

The Brothers - Zucchini Sticks - Pizza Near Me - Red Bank, New Jersey

See all

Probably a 3, but portions are large, service is quick, quality decent. Standard fare at this type of glorified pizzeria. Friendly staff.

Not sure what happened but this used to be great pizza. Tastes below average to me. Will try dinner entrees next time

Solid, no-frills Italian spot. Happened in on this place one Saturday night when all nearby restauraunts were quoting us an hour-plus wait without reservations. The Brothers was able to seat us immediately. While the large dining room is quite sparse and not the place for a fancy night out, the service was great and the food flavorful. I'd highly recommend their bar pies - you can't go wrong the classic margherita loaded with fresh mozzarella and basil - or their fantastic meatballs. read more

The Brothers - margherita pizza - Pizza Near Me - Red Bank, New Jersey

Pizza is phenomenal, but don't go there in the summertime especially 80° air conditioner is very bad. They need a new unit and I'm sure he can afford it but he refuses to put it in. Don't go. You'll be very uncomfortable although like I say the Pizza is gonna get it to go read more

TERRIBLE SERVICE FROM BAR SERVER/manager/hostess Well...where do I start visiting from out of town but grew up here...came in today with my 83 yr old mother and her small "service" dog in a dog stroller...greeted by bar server asking for ID for animal...my mother flustered could not find right away in wallet fast enough for bar server/managers demands (but found it in car)AFTER BEING SCREAMED AT TO LEAVE AND TOLD SHE WOULD CALL POLICE IF WE DIDNT PUT AWAY CARDS AND LEAVE!!! Again my mother just couldn't find card fast enough for her...and she WOULD NOT TAKE PICTURE I HAD OF ID ON MY PHONE....she became HYSTERICAL LOUD AND RUDE...I will NEVER return By the way...I only visited because we were meeting a retired MARINE for lunch! read more

See all

Who says you can't go home again? The Brothers serves great pizza, tasty burgers, Italian favorites, fresh pitchers of beer and prodigious drinks. Most of all it serves comfort. The dining room emanates with the sounds of happy families and pure friendship. It is one of those rare spots that is timeless, and that is priceless. Come for the delicious crispy and gooey pizza, leave with a happy heart . read more

See all

We loved this place! It came highly recommended from friends who live in Colorado too so we made it a priority to visit while we were on vacation. We went for a late lunch and were the only people dining, but it seemed like there were quite a few regulars hanging out at the bar enjoying each other. We were treated really well by Karen (I believe that's her name). We had the pepperoni garlic rolls for an appetizer- they were absolutely delicious! Then we had the Grandma's pizza which is a special square homemade thin crust pizza with fresh mozzarella, tomato sauce and basil, and then we added sausage to half. WHOA this was so good! It made us really happy. It's a large pizza (only comes in one size) but we didn't want to waste any of it so we took it back to our hotel and had it for leftovers the next day, it was that yummy. This is a big restaurant with lots of seating and good prices and a great menu. We would definitely be regulars if we lived here. You must go!!! read more

The Brothers - Grandma's Pizza perfection - Pizza Near Me - Red Bank, New Jersey

Thin crust pizza with beautiful sauce. Cold beer pints. Diverse menu. Old school bar with history. Service ok read more

Nothing fancy here but good solid basic food at reasonable prices. Beer and wine very reasonable as well.

The food and the service is excellent. And the workers are very friendly as well. Love this places been here a few time always happy when I walk out read more

Best Pizza in Jersey! Been coming since i was a kid. live in Philly now and every now and then the stars align and i can bring my college baseball team in for a meal after playing locally. FANTASTIC. Great service from my reservation to the tables being ready when we walked in. The speed of the food and speed and courtesy of the servers while keeping the rest of the diners happy and fed was impressive. My players were impressed and agreed that the one bite score should be 9.5 or higher. Well done! Keep up the good work! We'll be back! ALWAYS MY FAVORITE PIZZA JOINT! Home Sweet Home read more

Good pizza. Lunch crowd is older men with a racist attitude and women will not be comfortable. Need to take out the trash there. Still 3 stars because Ive been going there for 20 years, but it's gotten to be an old man's hangout for lunch. Not for everyone. read more

We came in on Saturday night around 8:00. Very no frills, cafeteria feel, but everyone is clearly there for the food. We ordered the penne vodka with fried chicken, the Large Extra Special Pizza and the Supreme white pie. The penne vodka portion was HUGE, it is enough to basically order and serve family style in my opinion. It was not as pink of a sauce but it was very good and I really liked it. The Extra Special pie comes with sausage, peppers and mushrooms. It was very good, super thin crust, but I almost felt like there were too many toppings if that makes sense. The toppings took away a bit, next time I think I'd just try one topping. The Supreme White Pie has ricotta, sauteed spinach, garlic and cherry tomatoes (we opted to not get these). It was tasty, a little bit strong on the garlic. They have a lot of beer choices and they are really cheap in my opinion. A pitcher of light beer is $11 and $3.25/pint. Our bill with the 2 pizzas, penne vodka and 3 beers was only $60 for 3 people and we left with a ton of leftovers. Overall, not sure how I've lived in Red Bank for 3 years and never been here but I will definitely come back. read more

See all

The hours aren't reliable. They closed a half hour earlier than posted time Which is disappointing but did not look the cleanest place so I would not eat there read more

Good stop for pizza and some appetizers. Very family friendly and a good place to bring the kiddies. Brothers is not fancy but it does have that at home feel. read more

To die for... pizza,Supreme white pie with spinach ricotta and fresh tomatoes.This place has been here forever and that's because they make the best pizza and seafood around! read more

The Brothers - Supreme pie...To die for - Pizza Near Me - Red Bank, New Jersey

What happened to this place? Let me guess, new staff, new ownership, new chef (If I should even consider him that, he's probably a short order cook at best). Not only did they not give me what I ordered, which was linguine with mussels, so when I checked my order , the lady working there, I'm assuming she was the manager, she says to me "we don't make linguine with mussels. OK so let me get this straight you make linguine, and you make muscles, but you can't make them together WTF. Plain and simple l, this establishment should close it's doors. read more

I had a small pizza with extra cheese with pepperoni It was good, not great. Will probably return to the restaurant and try other dishes read more

I live less than 2 miles from Brothers, and it USED to be my go to place for pizza. While it's been some time now since we ordered from there I came across the menu and ordered a shrimp scampi pie for $24.00 . I had to check once I got it in the car there was something in the box because it felt so light all the while knowing it is a thin crust pizza. The cardboard box probably had as much taste as the pizza dough . NEVER AGAIN!!! read more

Incredibly delicious and satisfying old school, no frills Italian food. Brings me back to my childhood and grandparents era. Good for kids too. read more

Pizza is amazing!! Love a good thin crust- they make a fantastic green salad as well!!

This place is about the food. Priced just right. Its not fancy, but they can cook. I recommended their pasta sauces. The Marinara excellent, even better the next day. The Meat sauce, also very good. Actually the left over pasta and sauce was even better later, lol. Hey if you want good italian food, dont want to break the bank, and you dont need white linen tables, then this place is great for lunch or dinner on a budget. The sauce, the sauce. read more

Pizza was pretty good. But Mixed seafood dish, OMG we smelled it from far away as it approached us, I felt embarrassed of the smells it carried. So bad I couldn't understand how it left the kitchen. The clam was ridiculously chewy. Are they joking for serving us the dish? The whole meal was overpriced. Service was terrible. Waited forever to be seated and taken ordered. Place like this should be banned from 'Cuisine' Don't use the word if you can't serve a real meal. Never go back again. read more

Love this place ! I had cheesesteak better than Philly's Chocolate cheesecake better than Juniors. This is a family owed business that really cares about quality,value and service . Thank you ! read more

Nails the old school vibe and menu. Has it all. Just about. Spacious room. Loyal customers friendly staff Big cocktails Support the Old School ! read more

The Brothers - Spacious old school room. Relaxing. I grew up in the sixties. Lots of places like this. - Pizza Near Me - Red Bank, New Jersey

See all

Great catering experience yesterday. Ordered a few pizzas, pasta, eggplant parm, etc. Everyone enjoyed the food and Victor was easy to order with. Will definitely be back. read more

A true bargain, fairly priced, great food, and Joe the bartender makes u welcome!!!Brothers Pizza!!!

Summer Friday night but tried for a little bit to call in an order and their phone was off the hook...we decided to drive over, place the order, and grab a drink at the bar. Bartender was great in helping us and handling the bar in general. They awkwardly have the big commercial ice machine in the bar room which kicks off more heat than the AC can keep up with so place was super hot. Pizza actually came out pretty quickly. Looking at it, I didn't think I would like it - thin crust, not "NY style" - looked dry and light on toppings BUT it was actually very tasty! read more

I went to this restaurant and I am very upset I have an esa dog and they asked me for the letter which I couldn't find it because my anxiety was starting and they were making me very nervous so I was never able to eat dinner at this place and I walked out, and I will not recommend this place to anybody very inconsiderate and rude to me for my disability I went there first time and walked out in 5 minutes very un happy with this place read more

Got as far as the bar and was told maybe another restaurant would be better for me because I wasn't local. Bar was full...restaurant was empty. So I left. Never said a word to anyone. If you're not a local, I'd head elsewhere. read more