We enjoyed the Paso Robles location so when we were in Cayucos we checked this place out as well. The staff were helpful and allowed us some samples. They make great gifts and are quite decadent! read more

Brown Butter Cookie - Exterior - Bakeries Near Me - Cayucos, California

brown butter cookie is def a must stop when driving by! they are known for their shortbread cookies! brown butter sea salt to be exact. service was amazing. you are offered a sample as you as you walk in. there was so much to look at. the bakery smelled so so delicious!! i wanted one of everything. so many flavors. i ended up making my own custom bag of half a dozen cookies. CHOCOLATE CHUNK SNICKER DOODLE LEMON SUGAR OATMEAL RAISIN EVERYTHING (GF FLOUR) GINGER MOLASSES my favorite was the OG chocolate chip! not as sweet as id thought it was be but sooo good. the store had samples so you could just sample your way around the store! such a cool place to visit. glad i was able to visit. clean, friendly and surprisingly quite of items to look at. parking: there is street parking everywhere. read more

See all

We were in the area and stopped by. I had one peanut butter cookie and it was $3.95. It tasted fresh and decent. We also had a coffee and it was okay. They have many kinds of cookies and treats Stop by when you are in Cayucos! read more

We arrived were greeted at entry and were offered samples. There was a few choices of samples which was nice. My husband got to try them out, Im gluten free so they kindly showed me what was available. Its a cute set up with cookies nicely displayed throughout the store. I recommend this place the flavors are wonderful. read more

See all

Brown Butter is a niche bakery whose highlight is the shortbread cookies. They do offer other cooked in packs of six that you can arrange by flavor, to your liking. There are generous samples of their baked goods. Admittedly, my husband noshed on the samples and was too full for an individual desert of which I partook. The bakery is cute and well arranged. Product is packed in their signature labels and packaging made it so tempting to want to buy all the things. Most of us opted for the custard ice cream (so rich and tasty) adorned with a shortbread cookies of the day: chocolate chip. Goodness in every bite!! Next time I'm getting the cookie 6 pack - I still haven't stopped thinking about those guys! read more

See all

A YouTube SENSATION! My Mom and I got the tip to visit Brown Butter Cookie from a YouTuber and we were so glad we bookmarked this local business! Brown Butter Cookie is growing with more stores and treats. You MUST visit this cookie shop because the sea salt treats are delicious. The titular Brown Butter Cookie is obviously fantastic, but the sea salt chocolate (made with Ghirardelli Chocolate) treats are just as amazing! The shop was spacious, clean and easy to navigate. Prices are a little high, but so is the quality. I liked the staff, they offered samples and were easy going. Brown Butter Cookie is a Cayucos favorite as I saw many locals entering the store! read more

See all

Melt in your mouth cookies! I've never had a cookie like this. They also offer samples inside so you can try before you select your flavor. They had samples of the original brown butter cookie, chocolate chip, and a chocolate cookie. I'm sure there are others but those were the samples they had out the day I went. The staff was friendly with answering questions. This location is on the main waterfront street in Cayucas which is one block from the beach and near the pier. It's the perfect place to stop before you enjoy a walk on the pier. A cookie while you walk on the pier - is there anything better? read more

See all

No trip to the central coast is complete without a trip to BBC. In fact we stopped in 3 days in a row this trip. We haven't been here in over a year/ so our cravings were high. Omg- the honey cookies are so delicious I can't stop eating them. We picked up a few packages yesterday to give to friends, but then I got a sweet tooth last night and broke into the bag... so yummy I couldn't stop. We also picked up a few of the variety packages. If you get there early they may have some that are 50% off- but these go fast. Today I got the lemon ones- again, these are amazing We have always been greeted as soon as we enter with a sample of the original flavor, and they have 3 other ones with samples set up for the taking. Can't wait to go back again tomorrow and grab some more cookies... one can never have enough Such an adorable shop, both inside and out. Friendly staff to help with suggestions for friends and family. It's the off season right now- so we have lucked out with parking right in front the last few visits. Sometimes you made need to walk a bit- but so worth it read more

See all

"Did somebody say cookies?" "Me. Want. Cookie!" "C" is for cookie, that's good enough for me. "Sometimes me think, what is a friend? And then me say: a friend is someone to share last cookie with" (and NO!!! This is not Kevin from the Office) But it is someone you might recognize from your childhood.... Any guesses on who quoted these famous words of wisdom about one of Americas favorite snacks/treats? Well, if you watched Sesame Street as a kid... You know exactly who I am referring to. And If not... Did you even have a good childhood?? I'm talkin' bout Sesame Streets Cookie Monster! And let me tell ya.... The Cookie Monster would most definitely give two thumbs up if he ever visited the Brown Butter Cookie Co. in Cayucos, California. I mean... They've got Chocolate Chunk, Snickerdoodle, Lemon Sugar, Oatmeal Raisin, Ginger Molasses, Peanut Butter... I mean, Do I really need to give the Cookie Monster or you over there, yeah YOU... reading this right now with that sweet tooth of yours... Anymore reasons to convince you to visit Brown Butter Cookie Co. while visiting the Central Coast? Well, Did I mention they give free samples!!!!! Yeah, I know! That's how they got me too! So whether you want a single cookie for $4 or half a dozen for $24 (what!! No discount for buying in bulk??)... Well unless you buy the Tower Special for $22 (which comes with an assortment of their classics)... This is your must-stop cookie destination while you're in the town of Cayucos. So.... Come get your Cookie On! And in the famous words from the man himself with a mouth full of cookies... "Om Nom Nom Nom" read more

See all

This store deserves 5 stars based on service and friendliness of the young beautiful people fronting the place. Plenty of generous samples inside to taste before deciding on which ones to bring home or for gifting. Packaging is neat and nice. I am especially loving the energy of the people working here, pls tip generously to your heart content. read more

See all

Tried in Cayucos. Will stop there if in the area. Very good cookies. Rich and dense more like a bar vs cookie. Flavors change so always good to see what's new. Customer Service is Excellent. Being able to try samples and recommendations really helps. Prices are high but make great gifts for family and friends. Definitely a unique cookie. The shop is clean and well organized. read more

Cute place!! I purchased the chocolate chip and oatmeal raise cookie. Without a doubt, the best oatmeal raisen cookie I've ever had!!

A tad pricey, but very good cookies! Good gift baskets, and nice they have samples. Always a stop.

Save your money. Def not worth the price of these cookies. 24$ for 6. Albertsons cookies are 10 times better imo. read more

Brown Butter Cookie - Bakeries Near Me - Cayucos, California

Whenever I visit the Central Coast, I always have to stop in for my sea salt cookies--they are absolutely delicious. I used to buy the cookie tower for my husband and son, but they haven't been as enthusiastic about the cookies recently, so I now only buy what I enjoy. Recently, they introduced a brown butter custard served with one of their cookies. I got that for the boys on our last visit, and they said it was much better than the cookies. Now I know what to get for them to keep everyone happy. 7-10/24 read more

See all

As a baker of excellent cookies I was blown away! The texture and flavor of these cookies made me speechless. The original sea salt cookies is a must try. They offer samples so try them before you buy. $12 for 6 cookies. They are already in packages. There's parking in front. Lots of shops nearby and even a free local museum. Workers were warm and informative. You can see them making the cookies. I'd definitely come here again in a heart beat read more

Brown Butter Cookie - Outside - Bakeries Near Me - Cayucos, California

Tho place has the best cookies. Had to get a few of them. To be exact $176 of cookies. Not all for us they are gifts too. lol. Worth the drive if you're in this area. read more

See all

A mother/daughter camping trip wouldn't be complete without a gorgeously sumptuous dessert. If you're in the area, hit the boardwalk at Leffingwell Landing in Cambria and grab yourself some Brown Butter Cookies as a ceremonial reward for a day of sun, fog, and exercise. These will definitely replace any lost carbs! The shopping experience was 'cookie boutique' - we were kindly greeted as we entered the open showroom full of delicate piles of cookies wrapped in cellophane. Free samples are hygienically served in paper cups on a tray. The lemon was no distraction from the original brown butter cookie, and I bought the chocolate shortbread as a 'wild card'. This place definitely knows where their bread is buttered - melt-in-your-mouth shortbreads and cookies that are unlike any other store-bought cookie. If you're in the area, grab a few to enjoy over coffee on a foggy morning. read more

See all

These cookies are incredible. There are so many styles and flavors to try. When you enter the shop there are people passing out samples which always feels like a special treat. Favorites are the smaller brown butter sea salt cookies in any flavor but you can't go wrong with the Origin flavor. Cocoa and Lemon are fantastic too. They now serve custard, like a soft serve ice cream. It was perfect on a hot sunny day. Has a rich, creamy taste. I would definitely get it again. Highly recommend you stop in a try some cookies! read more

Everybody talks about this place is a MUST if you are visiting morro bay, so we make the trip just now.. We are so bad y'all.. sampling cooking for breakfast is terrible but we did it while on vacation. We immediately were greetings with samples and in the 15 minutes, I purchased the following Original 1 dozen toffee 1 dozen For my clients 2 dozens of original Freebies: toffee + original for my founders I think we spent $200.. I love supporting small local businesses and eating good food... Sidebar; so the price point is worth it for me y'all... if it's not for you, perhaps y'all should diy because their cookies are a luxury item for folks who want to indulge in a opulanv read more

Cute little beachside cookie joint serving unbelievably delicious cookies. The location is easy to find and the staff are super helpful and friendly. They even gave us a sample. The name says it all. You can taste the brown butter in the cookies. I think the stars of the show are the little round short bread like cookies. All the cookies are on the soft side, and delicious however, these little cookies just melt in your mouth! read more

Brown Butter Cookie - Little variety pack - Bakeries Near Me - Cayucos, California

This location is the original spot to get their delicious cookies. When we walked in, everyone was so welcoming and asked if we wanted to try samples. They sell chocolate chunk, snicker doodle, lemon sugar, oatmeal raisin, peanut butter, everything, and shortbread cookies. We got the short bread cookies, peanut butter, oatmeal raisin, and chocolate chunk for $16. They are very soft and buttery, highly recommend. read more

Brown Butter Cookie - Original 3 pack for $5 - Bakeries Near Me - Cayucos, California

See all

They've been an amazing place for so many years, but our last visit we experienced the new square cookies and they are not as good as their original round hand rolled cookies. We used to make a special trip out to Cayucos just for their cookies, but that won't happen anymore. No longer worth the price. It's always a shame when bakeries outgrow hand made products and switch to mass production. It always turns out "similar" but never as good. It's not Brown Butter's fault...higher labor wages, inflation, recurring bird flu infected chickens all contribute to this result. If possible, please go back to your original recipe. The team there is still nice and friendly. read more

Get the Brown Butter Frozen Custard NOW! You will not regret it! Not too sweet! Not too buttery! Very subtle. Simply perfect! read more

I wish this wasn't going to be a 5 star review- but is! We had the BB chocolate chip shortbread cookies. I also brought 2 bags home to give as gifts. The cookie is decadent and literally melts in your mouth. We also tried the frozen custard that is infused with their brown butter. I wanted to share my husband's but he told me no, I had to get my own. I had every intention of eating half and putting the rest in the hotel fridge/freezer for later that night. Before I knew it, it was gone! So delicious, creamy, not your every day soft serve. I am so glad I don't live closer. I would be dropping in on a regular basis. read more

Brown Butter Cookie - Brown butter chocolate chip shortbread cookie - Bakeries Near Me - Cayucos, California

Love that right when I walked in I was welcomed with samples!! These cookies are very good. The texture of the cookies is great, they are so soft. Definitely want to go back and try different flavors. read more

Brown Butter Cookie - Bakeries Near Me - Cayucos, California

See all

These aren't your normal cookies. They don't look like, smell like, feel like, or especially taste like your typical cookie. They're a little smaller, denser, crumbly-er, not exactly "dry" but it's not a wet bendy cookie. They're so good. Maybe almost a chalky texture but that would sound gross. The original Brown Butter Sea Salt has a bit of an odd, maybe bitter taste at first, and then you just realize it's the delish salty butter flavor. Mmmmmmm. The price is a bit steep, basically over $1 per cookie, and they're a bit on the small side. But they're freakin delicious. If you have a reason to come to Cayucos, this is a must stop. At least on the way out between the Antique Shops. read more

Brown Butter Cookie - Bakeries Near Me - Cayucos, California

I have been taking my kids here for years on our annual road trip up the central coast. Honestly, I have always thought they were overpriced, but my kids liked, them and the unique hand rolled shape made the higher cost for the cookies justified, I guess. They would make good gifts as well. However, just last weekend when we were they, I noticed the shape had change to Squares, instead of the hand rolled circles. I mentioned it to someone working there and was abruptly told "They taste the same" So we bought a dozen Let me tell you. 1. They Don't Look The Same. They are the size and shape of a Fig Newton 2. They DO NOT taste the same. The hand rolled ones had a top layer that was almost crust like. The new ones do not have that. 3. I noticed that they have a "Partnership" with Ghirardelli. Seems to me maybe that "Partnership" is steering the ship as these are when these changes to shape also happened. 4. Less appealing looking & higher price 5. As a gift now.. It does not present as nice. Prob why they offer boxes to put them in. Oh, if you want to pay and extra charge! HARD PASS FROM NOW ON read more

The frozen custard is next level!!!! Lived all the samples. I have always loved the cookies but the custard is divine. A new fav! I loved the slight saltiness in the bc custard. read more

Brown Butter Cookie - This brown butter cookie frozen custard is da bomb!!! Deeply rich, buttery and supremely creamy. Must stop!!! - Bakeries Near Me - Cayucos, California

I wish they have the old Sea Salt Cocoa ones because I miss them so much and I want today but they didn't have them here now more and I wish they still have them. read more

Brown Butter Cookie - This one I miss having them now and now it's the shortbread cookies now not this ones now. - Bakeries Near Me - Cayucos, California

What a great little cookie shop! You step in and they offer you samples, so you can start your journey into the world of sweet. I loved looking around at all the flavors they offer, with packs of cookies all on the tables and shelves, plus fresh cookies ready to purchase, which they will either package for you to take to go or prepare for you to have right away. One of my favorite things about this shop is you walk in and can see all the magic, the stop is open and right on the corner a block away from the beach. You couldn't have a bad day coming here. They have a "for everyone" cookie which is gf, nut free, and I think vegan or maybe soy free. It's nice to go somewhere that has something like that but I do wish they had more gf flavors that were fresh and ready to go since I'm personally not a fan of chocolate chip and that is what they had. The lady who helped us was happy to explain all the cookie types around the room and the fresh ones, we were in and out pretty quick but we were happy! read more

Brown Butter Cookie - Bakeries Near Me - Cayucos, California

My family and I are noticing a difference in the texture. We feel they are more crumbly, and was a little off in the taste of the original this time. They don't care about the new square shape but I do! Haha There was an elegant look to the original which looked so pretty in my home dessert display. I usually buy a few flavors before heading home but not this trip. read more

Found out about this place through fellow yelper, Chris D., who recommended this place as one of few good stopping points when traveling up to Cambria. These aren't your traditional, flat round cookies. These are more like shortbread cookies, which are dense and crumbly. These are more buttery than sweet, and have a slightly salty taste from sea salt. It does offer traditional, soft cookies too, but thought they were mediocre. For first time visitors, I recommend just sticking with its specialty brown butter cookies. I really liked the original brown butter cookies, but the espresso and cocoa ones were just as good. Wanted to try more flavors but this place doesn't offer any multi-flavor pack for its signature cookies. You can only purchase as a 3-pack, half dozen, dozen, or double dozen of the same flavor, and there isn't any discount for purchasing larger quantity, with the exception of double dozen, which is only a $1 discount. At the time of my visit there were 7 different flavors for its brown butter cookies - original, cocoa, cinnamon, espresso, pecan, cocoa mint, and almond. Service was friendly, and there were staff members walking around with free samples. Ended up spending about $77 here, about half of them as gifts. read more

I normally love small local-owned shops, and really love to support them on Yelp... but this place was just ok by me. Got to sample one flavor of their shortbread. I wanted to try one of the regular brown butter cookies but she said they didn't have samples of them right then. Ok. Bought 12 shortbread cookies for $24. Ouch. They're tasty, but that's really expensive for 12 small squares of shortbread. Ah well, at least we supported the local economy... read more

Cookies are too die for all varieties original brown butter and another 5-6 options there's a combo that has chocolate chunk and dry cherries yum , choc chip, snicker doodle, oatmeal and I believe golden raisin cause I believe they are chopped giving the cookie a sweet chewy out of this world experience and more choices. Ohhhh and they now offer soft serve custard to go with cookies. Service plentiful and informative and samples to be had. Ambiance is home comfort with prepackaged marketing and custom gift packaging also. Cookie monsters beware read more

Brown Butter Cookie - The storefront main location in Cayucous - Bakeries Near Me - Cayucos, California

Where is our OG Brown butter cookie? The bourbon vanilla extract makes the cookie taste like an alcoholic drink ! Square shape is a hard No . Lost this customer and any recommendations I use to give out . read more

I stopped off at the recommendation of a coworker. The cookies were okay, but not Earth shatteringly good. Glad I tried them, but I won't be back. read more

Very disappointed to see the change in cookie. Our favorite original was the most amazing melt in your mouth cookie. What I imagine eating a (delicious) sand castle would be like. Now they are joyless shortbread. Store is clean, cute, staff is friendly but product has become disappointing. read more

Frozen custard was creamy and good. It came with a piece of the cookie. Cookies are good, but eat too sweet and dry. Too sugary for us. Like I said the cookies are just way too sweet for me. read more

Brown Butter Cookie - Frozen Custard - Bakeries Near Me - Cayucos, California

We took our friends here to check out these cookies and they have a variety of different kinds and they give you samples for you to try. We have been here many times here ourselves and this our friend's first time and they enjoyed the cookies too. The employees are friendly and helpful. read more