Our first visit and the butter crust pizza was phenomenal. Great crisp, great flavor. Really good and better than most places nearby! Service was good. We'll definitely be back! The owner went out of his way to thank us and check on us before we left. Good job! read more

Awesome pizza place. Great looking restaurant and a awesome bar. Pizza selections are unique. We had the Watertower and it was terrific. They have good drinks. The staff is very friendly. They have live entertainment on Fridays. We will be back again. read more

Buddyz Pizza - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Mchenry, Illinois

See all

Delicious pizza and wraps! We've never had a bad meal here. I love the unique pizza's with Chicago style names.

After getting a deal on a (Restaurant.com) gift certificate for Buddy'z, my mom, great aunt and I decided to put it to use last night. We ordered fried mushrooms ($6.75) and fried mozzarella cheese sticks ($6) as appetizers. The mushrooms were plentiful but a little less crispy than we're used to. The cheese sticks were far less plentiful - 8 sticks oddly paired and arranged every 1/4 around the plate. Service was a little slow, but it was dinnertime (6:30) and the restaurant was about 1/2 full. One of the appetizer plates that was already on the table had a big chunk of red food on it...gross. Thankfully the other three were clean. We had to ask for more plates after the appetizer plates were cleared...maybe we were supposed to use the same ones? We ordered an 18" thin crust with sausage, mushrooms, and extra cheese. It was hard to find the mushrooms, and it definitely didn't look like there was extra cheese (bad for my mom, but fine for me since I love saucy pizza). The crust looked very hand-tossed and was a little uneven around the crust, resulting in some of the crust being charred. The pizza was just OK; overall kind of bland and skimpy on everything except the sausage. For $2.25 per ingredient (= $25 dollar pizza), I'd have expected better. In all, it was just "OK"; I wouldn't rush back unless a friend or family member insisted. read more

They are always nice and carryout is fast but holy crap their pizza is hit or miss. My latest pizza pickup was basically garbage. uploaded picture. Absolutely disgusting. Over cooked and burned in places. Waste of money. read more

Buddyz Pizza - Burned pizza, pick up gone wrong. - Pizza Near Me - Mchenry, Illinois

Went for lunch today, good bargain salad soup bar and pizza for 9.99 deep dish pizza was wonderful. You could have an entree instead. Food there was excellent , will definitely go back. read more

This place has gone downhill. It used to be very good but the last couple of times I was disappointed. The last time I ordered a pizza from there the crust was so burnt I couldn't eat it. The staff are nice though. read more

Here's what went well, Tried the fried calamari for an appetizer. It was seasoned well and not oily, the portion size was appropriate too. The pizza really is good! We ordered both a deep dish and a thin crust. Both were hot and tasty. The table next to us had a salad that looked really yummy I would order one next time. Here is what could be better: There is not enough room for waiting. This place is busy so don't go there starving because the wait times are long. Everyone is standing in front of a revolving door squeezed together. Here's what must be better: The bartenders are really busy serving the wait staff and the regulars that sit at the bar. If you are standing waiting to order a beer it could be 10 minutes before they acknowledge you, as they are busy chatting with the regulars. If they know you - you get great service otherwise be prepared to stay thirsty. read more

Decided to go inside and eat. Great decision, the staff was super friendly and the owner Sean went out of his way to make sure everything was good. The pizza's were spot on, crispy, just how we like them. We'll be back real soon. read more

Best deep dish pizza that I can get locally without having to drive 45min-a hour to Lou's. It's sad that there's hardily any good food out here in Mchenry, but this place is by far the best besides Lou's; Mchenry needs a Lou's! read more

Great food, but I just can't handle the crappy music anymore. We take our pizza to go these days.

I find this to be a very good pizza joint. They have some very tasty pies but they are generally busy and it takes a long time to get served. They are also very pricey for pizza but I guess you pay for the quality. The different types of pizza offer very interesting flavors. read more

Love the pie from this place! I've had pizza from all over the area and IMO, this is the best, hands down..Bill's Pub in Mundelein used to be my go to, especially with their double decker. Buddyz however, has a taste and texture all their own..delicious! A little pricey, but damn good pie! read more

Great pizza! The loop is by far the best choice of you want a delicious fresh tasting pizza! Great staff as well!

So there's really only one reason I go to Buddyz and that's because of the chopped salad! It is so yummy and feeds three people! I'm writing this review today because of the price they charge for soup. The charge you $4.99 for a small container of soup and they call it a large. Most places you go to are $2.99 for that size of soup. The prices are not very reasonable to begin with. And not to mention the soup was, okay....not even that great for what they charge. Now, if the owners don't take comments seriously, that's on them. I will attach a photo of the soup. By the way, they didn't even fill it all the way...rip off. read more

Buddyz Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Mchenry, Illinois

We ordered pizza from Buddyz on Thursday. We ordered the ladle shore dr and it was by far the best pizza I've had. Because of that we decided to stop for an early dinner today which was also great. My wife said it was one of the best chicken sandwiches she's had and I had the meatball that was very tasty as well. As we were packing up the owner Sean or Shawn came up and asked if the kids wanted ice cream because they were well behaved. That surprised me on two counts, as the kids were never asked if the wanted ice cream and that the kids were behaved. This was such an appreciated gesture. I'd definitely come again because everyone is enjoying what they do. Also btw I didn't get her name but our waitress was fantastic as well read more

We went to Buddyz on a Friday night, on a friend's recommendation. BIG mistake!! We arrived around 6:30. They weren't very busy, but they were steady. There were 3 female employees at the front register, and they saw us walk in. No greeting, and they were all giggling about something. After about 5 mins, I walked closer to the register and asked if we could be seated now!! They did jump right to it, and day us. After about 15 mins, a waitress came and took our drink order, then our food order when she returned. Our pizza came in a timely manner, but soon we agreed that they could have kept it!! It was inedible! There was little sauce, and the crust hard and chewy. We looked under our pieces, and there were burnt items stuck to the crust... The crust, itself, wasn't burnt, but there was old cheese, or other old food stuffs from the oven burnt TO our crust!! We will not return!! Horrible service, and horrendous pizza!! read more

See all

Abaokutely delicious. Great place to meet up with a bigger group. Plenty of space and smiles.

For me, it is rare that I'm ordering pizza. Pizza is very personal, but this is decent thin crust pizza, ordered with my toppings, extra sauce, well done. Sure, I would eat here again. Service was positive and attentive. Looks like they offer enticing specials. Place is lively with sports fans when the games are on. read more

Service was poor - young high school kid at the counter could not have been bothered. The wedge is a stalk of Romaine (not iceberg) the drinks were weak and the pizza is very very average. Follow-up and help when asking questions were tough....finally someone from the kitchen running food helped. Pizza, barely average, everything else...eh - just a ton of high school kids wasting time and not paying attention to customers. read more

I had the pizza with a gluten free crust. Taste wise, everything was okay, but the crust was undercooked. My fiance loved his burger wrap though. read more

The pizza is excellent, never had a bad meal here thus far. Bosco sticks are a perk as well. Great Chicago-style pizza close to home. The staff is always super nice and accommodating. Another perk? My husband and I had the pleasure of watching the Cubs win the World Series here!! read more

Great pizza. Wait times in the past seemed long but they seem to have gotten better. good hangout place

First and last time I will be trying their pizza. I would rather eat an old shoe. Thin crust was so soggy you couldn't even pick it up. Absolutely disgusting. Worst $34 I ever spent. Yuck read more

They're getting better and better! New apps and specials. Erica is a great bartender. Pizza is amazing but pricey that's the only reason for the 4 stars. read more

This is going to sound Un-American, but I'm not a fan of pizza. BUT, when I found Buddyz I began to see what everyone was loving about pizza!! Nice thin crust, just enough sauce, and great toppings! read more

This place is so inconsistent every time you order its the what are you going to get pizza .never get the same pizza twice 3 strikes and your now out of strikes.stay clear of this place there business practices are very ruff also posting bad checks on a Facebook with all the persons info not what I would call a professional business practices look at others posted the same . read more

So we ordered from Buddyz in Mchenry last night. While I am sick we order out because I don't feel like cooking. Every single time they mess up. Many times we have called in, told them they made a mistake, NEVER asked for a credit (never got one by the way) and the managers argue with you and tell you that you are wrong. They are expensive food so it's a treat to order from them! I do LOVE their pizza because they offer a gluten free option. No place in Mchenry that I know of does. When I tell you they mess up every time we order, I am not kidding. It's become a joke. Usually we leave it be unless it messes with my order because I can't eat many things because of my stomach. I get sick. The last few times we have taken pictures of the food and even sent it to them. One manager in particular gets super nasty, her name is Tiffany. After telling her I don't want a replacement burger, she will sent someone out an hour later with a new one (not sure if it's out of spite?) and send it out. This last time (yesterday) order screwed up AGAIN) I called and this time she asks me "what do you want me to do?" I said " at this point I really would like to get a credit for the mistakes on both burgers because I threw it out" She says " You want me to give you a $55 dollar credit? I guess I can go that." I said " I don't think the two hamburgers really justifies a $55 dollar credit, but if you want to do that ok?" She says with complete attitude "yeah neither do I for messed up ingredients but apparently we do that a lot with you guys. We can't seem to make you happy" Right then and there I had enough. When you spend a lot of money to order food (like I don't know nearly $12 for a burger that's wrong, a half hard half soggy bun with messed up ingredients and you have an intestinal disorder that you can only eat certain things and just recovered from surgery and wanted to treat yourself and still are in pain and someone gives you total shit for screwing up) you expect your food to be right and at least to have a manager to be understanding and at LEAST apologetic. This place NEVER apologizes, THEY ARGUE. To make matters worse, the OWNER calls this am (mind you not once have they given us a credit! They replaced a pizza once we bought for friends to say THANK YOU to them which was a $27 dollar pizza they screwed up and argued with my friends husband, the manager was Josh. And Tiffany sent us out a hamburger lol after we had spent hundreds of dollars ordering from them btw!) He doesn't apologize this am, he tells us he are banned from ordering from them. Not that he is sorry they keep messing up (we have pictures and even the manager last night repeated that the order was taken correctly but it wasn't made correctly. So it wasn't the server error but cooks error) but that WE are to blame. After calling the other locations, we have learned they separated from Mike the owner because he is difficult to deal with. He is a bully. He is a nasty person. Not ONCE did he apologize for messing up anything. When someone orders something and says NO cheese because they have a dairy allergy, and you send them something loaded with cheese and the ticket says NO CHEESE, is that my fault? Am I hard to please? I don't ever do this, but for me to be blamed for being hard to please and the owner to call me and to tell me I am not allowed to order from them after spending literally hundreds a month from their establishment and never getting credited from them for their mistakes is a disgrace. Mike should be ashamed of himself. Way to go Buddy's of Mchenry. This is not the last you have heard from me. You will also not see a penny of that $55 dollars because I will dispute the charges. read more

This place used to be great but now it sucks. The food, once awesome, is now awful. All the employees that made the atmosphere what it was are now gone. It will probably be closed within a year. read more

If you want good pizza, this may be a good place for take out, because the pizza IS really good (like Lou Malnati's). That's the only reason why I gave them 2 stars. However....everything else basically sucks. - The music was BLARING to the point where we couldn't hear each other talking. - Not sure who our server was because we had about 3...and they all were inattentive. We had to ask for refills and plates, for the check, we were never checked up on, and they never introduced themselves.We waited forever for everything. - We didn't want to sit outside, so we purposefully asked to be inside. They sat us nect to the sliding door that leads to the deck. The kept leaving the door open so wasps were getting in. Not a pleasant eating experience. We even asked them to keep the door shut and they ignored us. - The girls that work there look like they are ready to go to bed (or just rolled out of bed) - sweatpants, sweatshirts, boots...and it was 80 degrees out. They need t-shirts like the guys. - The plates were way too tiny for our pizza (they were appetizer size). We asked for extra sauce on the side and it was served cold. We asked for lemons with the water. They didn't bring them so we had to ask again. Minor details. This is what it comes down to. Your food can be great, but if your service sucks, then your restaurant sucks. I shouldn't have to do more work than you do when I'm paying to be there. The staff needs to be trained, and a manager needs to be present. We all agreed that we wouldn't be coming back. read more

I ordered a deep dish pepperoni pizza tonight with a side of calamari. The calamari was very tough and the breading was pretty bland. I couldn't find any taste of pepperoni in my pizza, and tomatoes seemed like canned whole tomatoes. I haven't had Buddyz in awhile, and I'm not sure I'll go back anytime soon. read more

Poor poor customer service was there tonight with my family and will not be returning the owner has no respect for his customers either does his staff our bus boy told us to go f**** off because we told him we were not done eating and didn't want our table cleared I was shocked called over the owner he just sat there and really said nothing just wrong thats what u get for not going to the best lou malnatis read more

We came for the lunch buffet, advertised as pizza, pasta and salad for $7.49. There was a very small salad offering, a few picked over pizzas, and no pasta even offered. I ate 3 servings of salad thinking more pizzas were coming out, to no avail. Disappointed, for sure. read more

If we crave something different than giordanos, buddy is a close second. Love the flavor of the butter crust! Probably the best deep dish in McHenry! read more

Awesome pizza! Went for the first time last night with a big group ... had several different types of pizza both thin and deep dish. It was outstanding! The deep dish was especially good ... I'm going to go as far as saying it was up there with some of my fav's (Lou's and Giodano's). Great apps too ... cheddar cubes and pizza chips with Italian salsa (which was essentially bruschetta)! I'm a huge pizza snob and this place ranks way up there! So glad we tried it and we will be back. Well done Buddyz! read more

First off if this was a year ago or even 6 months ago this place would be getting 5 stars...well for the food at least the service on the other hand isn't the best. Anyways my wife and used to love making the drive from Wauconda here for the deep dish pizza because it was absolutely amazing until probably about 6 months ago I'd say when supposedly they got a new cook or something and the pizza has no gone to hell. We went there a week ago and ordered the something we always do which was mozzarella sticks and a deep dish pizza and even the mozzarella sticks were nasty. I'm very disappointed over this because I really loved that pizza and now it's gone. Get it together Buddyz read more

A week ago tonight friends, my wife and I stopped at Buddyz in McHenry to grab a bite to eat. What started as a spur of the moment "go out for pizza" ended as a really quality evening and excellent food. Quality service, food, wines, entertainment and hospitality! Our pizza and the chopped salad were both great in taste and quantity. They were perfect for the four of us. The owner even stopped by and chatted a couple times and brought us a sample of a new red blend they recently brought in. Very good! The place was crowded and lively.... an excellent experience! read more

I give Buddyz Pizza what, in my opinion, is the ULTIMATE compliment one can give on deep-dish pizza in the Chicago area: Even better than Lou's. That's all you need to know. read more

This place is amazing! It's by far and away the best place to eat and drink in McHenry County. The food is amazing, the staff is incredibly friendly and the service can't be beat. One time Josh saw us walking toward the door and had a drink ready for us before we even sat down. If I could give a higher rating, I would! Love this place! read more

My favorite pizza place and great beer selection! Only problem is service is usually pretty poor here. We've never had real good service. Also they should have a "beer menu" instead of reading the chalkboard all the time that someone is sitting in front of. A few simple tweaks and this place would be a much better dining experience! read more