Buffy&#x27;s Ice Cream

What a hidden gem in South Chatham! We stayed at a Cape house just down the block from Short N'…read moreSweet, and I am so glad we did. This ice cream is awesome! We visited twice. The first time was a Sunday night in May and the line was literally out of the door! And I quickly understood why. Their ice cream is soooo good. Like seriously AMAZING. And even better? The bang for your buck! This is some of the most price favorable and high quality ice cream I've ever tried. Their XXL, which is 6 scoops and huge, is $8.90. I am shocked! Staff is also super nice and explained all of the flavors we had questions about to us. I tried their chocolate, strawberry, raspberry chocolate chip, s'mores, and phantom berry ice cream. All were amazing. My favorites were definitely the chocolate, s'mores, and phantom berry ice creams. All amazing options, I would seriously recommend this place!

Here's all I can say: better than Sundae School!! SO good. Best selection, flavor and people!!read more

See all

2 scoops

Brick Block Ice Cream Shop

3.9(49 reviews)

0.8 mi

This is such a cute little hole-in-the-wall ice cream parlor. They have a great variety of flavors…read moreto choose from, and it makes it fun to try something new each time. The decor is also really nice and gives the place a cozy, welcoming feel. Overall, it's a simple but charming spot to grab a sweet treat, and I'd definitely come back again.

I'll say again, ice cream is pretty good. Lots of choices. Really nice service. The woman there was…read morevery attentive, going a long way to get a complicated order just right.

Black Raspberry Chip

Md Caramel Cookie dough/coffee

See all

Md Oreo/Black Reasoberry

Schoolhouse Ice Cream

4.2(116 reviews)

5.3 mi

My family visited schoolhouse ice cream for the first time. I read the reviews beforehand so I knew…read moreI had to bring cash as it's cash only. I had the Harwich mud pie and it was the best flavor I have had. Others had the mint chip and birthday cake and it was equally as delicious. I can't wait to return again before we leave the cape for home.

No bueno. Workers were great, hustling & kind to the customers…read more But the ice cream was not great & the owner should take a long look at the tubs and freezer, yuk !! Huge line, no parking, super dark out. Just an overall miss for us. Again, the staff was great, doing their best.

Mud pie!

Mud pie

See all

Emack & Bolio's Ice Cream and Yogurt

3.4(59 reviews)

0.2 mi

Ice cream was SO good! The staff working there were super…read morefriendly. Highly recommend coming here. It's a little off the beaten path from the regular stores on the main road.

Best ice cream in Chatham downtown. Hidden, just off of Main Street. Nice service. Friendly people…read more Hidden gem.

Peanut butter oreo - very good didn't taste too artificial! long lines and cash only btw

This Sundae is a work of art.

Emack & Bolio's Ice Cream and Yogurt - Menu

See all

Chatham Squire Restaurant & Tavern

3.2(750 reviews)

0.1 mi

This restaurant is a Chatham staple! I always stop in for lunch when I'm walking down Main Street…read more It has that quintessential Cape Cod feel, warm, welcoming, and filled with sailing memorabilia and nautical decor. I also love that there's both a full dining room and a separate bar area, so whether you're grabbing a quick lunch or sitting down with family, it fits the occasion. It's a popular spot, and you'll usually see plenty of families and larger groups enjoying a meal. The menu is full of fresh seafood and New England favorites. The clam chowder is a great way to start, and I always order the hot lobster roll. Great food, friendly service, and a comfortable atmosphere.

This place was a bit confusing at first because it has two different entrances--one for the bar and…read moreone for the restaurant. We started on the bar side, which was extremely busy and we couldn't find a seat for about 30 minutes. The only downside is that seating is first come, first serve, so you end up hovering around tables waiting for people to leave, which wasn't ideal. We eventually got frustrated and went next door. Even though they're separate, the bar and restaurant are connected, so you can easily walk between the two. We ended up having an amazing meal at the restaurant side, so it was definitely worth switching over. I highly recommend the lobster roll. I'm giving 4 stars mainly because of the experience on the bar side.

Can't have enough of this roll

See all

Cisco pale ale with the Costello chowder 50/50 bisque and chowder. Delish!

Chatham Penny Candy Store

2.8(20 reviews)

0.2 mi

The Chatham Penny Candy Store is a childhood favorite that never loses its charm. The nostalgic…read moreatmosphere, brings back so many core memories. They have an incredible selection of candies and treats. It's a sweet treat for all ages! The employees are friendly and helpful.

If I could give this place 0 stars I would. The staff is rude, unprofessional, mean and…read moreinappropriate to children. They demeaned and accused my son of crushing candies, when he picked up a baggie of Lego candies, and was checking if the pieces align. The older blonde woman that works there, yelled at him not to crush the candy, he replied that he was not crushing anything, just looking at the pieces. To which the woman yelled out that he was lying and she saw him. My older teen and her boyfriend, who were in charge of babysitting, came back to tell me of the incident. As I went to the store to figure out what happened, as the girls at the front were lazily sitting there without acknowledging any customers, I told them that they had accused my 9 year old son (who btw is probably one of the calmest kids I know, who just happens to love Legos and science, hence the curiosity for the Lego candy) of crushing candy. They denied knowledge of the incident and called the older woman to the front, who just started being rude, confrontational, snd paranoid as of what we were doing with our phones. Since I took some pictures prior, as I travel around the world and have a social media platform that posts about travel. She yelled for us to leave if we didn't like it, and then to just leave the store when I told her she was rude. How can an unhinged person like that run a candy store who mainly caters to children, yet seems to hate them??? As we were leaving, she just went out the store and was still yelling something, paranoid we recorded her. P.S.: This is not only a Candy Store, it's an OVERPRICED, STALE Candy, Cash only, RUDE, and unhinged Candy extravaganza store. Chatham could do so much better than this junk.

See all

Chatham Pier Fish Market

4.3(416 reviews)

0.6 mi

Best lobster rolls!!! I prefer the warm buttered version and my boyfriend has the cold mayonnaise…read moreone. Both are delicious!

Excellent lobster rolls. The lobsters are cooked right front of you and is always fresh and…read moresweetcookedmeat

Outdoor seating

See all

Outdoor Seating

Chillers

4.6(14 reviews)

1.9 mi

Hawaiian ices are incredible! Delicious flavors & combinations like Shark Attack, so fun. Service…read moreis great and ambience with colorful picnic tables and big chair for pictures. One of our all-time favorite places on the Cape!!

My friend and I were craving shave ice and to my surprise Chillers is one of the only places on…read morecape that serves it. So we drove 45 minutes from Yarmouth to come try it out totally worth it! I got the shark attack shaved ice and it was delicious and refreshing for the hot day. The lady who was working was super nice she was incredible made our food quickly. It is super affordable like $12 for 2 small ices and they were filled to the brim! The shop is super cute looks like a Hawaiian bar! This is a great spot to come during the summer!

See all

Gustare Gourmet

4.0(26 reviews)

0.1 mi

I love their vinegars and oils. If you cannot visit the store, delivery is great! You should…read morevisit their store.

So expensive but what a great selection of infused oils and vinegar. The white balsamic with…read morewatermelon/rose was our teen's favorite and pairs well over fresh summer salads and crumbled feta. I was partial to the dark balsamic infused with maple or Amarena cherries. Drizzle that over fresh fruit. Yum. The base olive oil was ok, but too high priced. That said, the gremolata infusion was very clever. Nice over lamb, oxtail and/Or pappardelle.

Gustare Gourmet Tour of Italy gift box including 100% extra virgin olive oil and traditional aged balsamic vinegars (from Mod...

See all

Inside the Gustare Gourmet store with beautiful decor and kitchen items along with olive oil and vinegars

Cape Cod Coffee

3.8(82 reviews)

1.4 mi

This coffee place has a spacious open parking lot with plenty of parking spaces, outdoor seating…read moreareas, and welcoming indoor seating. Service is very friendly. The interior decor is a perfect blend of style creating an atmosphere that is both uplifting and unpretentious. Their deli offers made-to-order sandwiches and customers can delight in ordering coffee while exploring a range of 6-8 dispensers offering several flavors and decaf options to suit every taste. The clientele is predominantly local, fostering a sense of community.

We are staying in Chatham for the week and have stopped here before. The bagel sandwiches are okay…read more Nothing fancy, quite pedestrian. The menu is limited so be sure to peruse before stopping. A bit surprised they didn't have cranberry juice but a handful of iced tea choices... on the Cape...NO cranberry juice! LOL Service was slow... noticed very difficult for the person behind the counter and a handful of customers as far as communication/ understanding. For people dining on the patio...you need to walk down a slope in back for the restroom accessed via the patio - towards the dumpsters...the wet grass made it Super Fun. The features on Yelp state outdoor seating and dogs ARE allowed yet there are two or three signs posted no pets in eating area along the picnic tables. Which is it? Are the dogs allowed inside or outside? Either update your Yelp settings or remove those signs. Can't have it both ways. Won't be back.

See all

Whoopie pie. Too much icing but very good.

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

9 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Tina M.

Elite 26

220

243

1360

1 year ago

Buffy's Ice Cream - Chatham, MA Buffy's is a bright, cheerful stop right on Main Street in Chatham and absolutely worth a visit. They're known for their creative Chatham Ice Cream Bars, but none were available during our visit. A little disappointing, but the scoops did not disappoint. We had: * Vanilla Cherry Chip (Kitty Cup) - Creamy, full of real cherry pieces, and surprisingly generous in portion. * Café Latte - Smooth, not overly sweet, with just the right coffee flavor. The menu is packed with unique flavors like Peanut Butter & Jelly, Coconut Oreo, and dairy-free options like Black Raspberry and Vanilla. Everything is homemade, and you can tell from the texture and flavor. The guy at the counter was super friendly and explained everything well. The space has a light, fun, almost retro beach-town vibe,pink walls, ice cream props, and that perfect summer energy. Buffy's is a solid pick for anyone exploring Chatham. Come back when they have the ice cream bars,they sound next level. read more

James M.

Elite 24

259

175

2927

3 years ago

Buffy's Ice Cream deserves a solid five stars! The ice cream sandwich is a heavenly treat that combines rich, creamy flavors with the perfect cookie texture, creating a delightful symphony for the taste buds. The bacon Affogato is a unique masterpiece, blending the smokiness of bacon with the boldness of espresso, resulting in a surprisingly harmonious and unforgettable experience. The innovative menu and exceptional quality make Buffy's a must-visit for any ice cream enthusiast. read more

Emma V.

2 years ago

Amazing staff, amazing ice cream, amazing atmosphere. This place as the only homemade ice cream in Chatham, the ice cream bars are out of this world. And they are very accommodating with allergens, (I have celiac and eat here without a problem) read more

Viktoriya M.

6 years ago

Absolutely disgusting place. People who work here hide their rudeness behind their mask. Do not go there! Plenty of friendly places around even during this difficult times. read more

Benjamin A.

6 years ago

Woman with curly blond hair is awfully rude to kids. Lots of ice cream shops, it's not smart business to be so rude to a 3 yr old kid. Unfortunate shameful person. read more

Jeff M.

162

113

9 years ago

Ice cream was very good a must stop and try. Staff was friendly and helpful!!!! Lots of Flavors milk shakes were awesome.. read more

C.E. D.

282

2 years ago

bla bla Bla Bla bla bla bla bla bla bla Bla-Bla bla bla bla bla bla bla bla blabla bla bla bla read more

K X.

Elite 24

736

127

2 years ago

Not memorable, but finished it all if that means anything. Nothing outstanding, nothing bad.

Hannah B.

1 year ago

Amazing ice cream & cappuccinos!! The service was great I will definitely be going back!

Buffy's Ice Cream - icecream - Updated September 2026

People who viewed Buffy's Ice Cream also viewed

Sundae School Ice Cream - Dennis Port

4.3

(373 reviews)

I genuinely cannot emphasize enough how insanely good this ice cream is. I'm not kidding when I say…read morethis is one of the best ice creams I've ever had in my entire life. The ice cream itself is unbelievably creamy, and the toppings are just as good. They don't skimp on the mix-ins either--the way they load the ice cream with toppings is honestly insane. Every bite is packed with something delicious. My two favorite flavors were Shark's Tooth, which is a blackberry-based ice cream with white chocolate chips, and Sweet Cream & Nuts, which is a sweet cream-based ice cream with walnuts. Both were AMAZING. I would genuinely do anything to go back and have those two again. We also tried a couple of the cookie dough and Oreo-based flavors, and those were incredible too. I especially don't know what they do with their cookie dough, but it is so decadent, soft, and delicious. It almost melts into the ice cream. I seriously don't know how they make their ice cream, but whatever they're doing needs to be studied lol. This place is SO good, and if you're in the area, you absolutely have to try it. They also have two locations, which makes it even better!

Always a 20-30 minute wait no matter what time of day. You'd assume it's due to the quality of the…read moreice cream and yes it's good but honestly it's just poorly run. Even if there are 15 people ahead of you it will take half an hour to get through. They have the minimum number of windows open at a time, service is extremely slow, at this point the wait seems more like a marketing thing. I'm here on a Friday afternoon mid summer and there's 3 people working here and a half hour wait with maybe 15-20 people ahead of us. You may look at the line and it seems small and manageable but it will take 3x longer than it should guaranteed. They need to get a handle on this. It's just ice cream. There's no reason to wait an hour for it. (We left. It was our second visit here and it's not worth it)

Katie's Ice Cream

4.2

(256 reviews)

Delicious ice cream and they DEFINITELY don't skimp you on the oreo! We ordered the regular oreo…read moreand coffee oreo- $6 each for a sizable "small" serving. Service was fast and there were a few outdoor tables to pick from. Ice cream tastes creamy and homemade and worth the stop!

This spot was busy every evening during my trip. After giving it a try, I totally understood why…read morethere were lines - the ice cream is good! There were plenty of flavors to select from. I chose a special, S'moreo, in a kiddie cone that was surprisingly filling. The ice cream was creamy and had the perfect amount of Oreos and marshmallow swirls. Overall, it was a good experience - the lines moved fast and the ice cream was delicious!

Buffy's Ice Cream

4.8

(13 reviews)

This is in Downtown Chatham by all the shops. at a prime location after beaching all day and you're…read moreready to unwind at the stores. Depending on the time of day, I imagine it gets crowded with nowhere to sit. For me, it was fine on a Saturday afternoon past 4, maybe. Service was friendly and efficient. There isn't much seating inside, and outside there are a few tables. Be careful getting up, because the weight can shift abruptly on the other side unexpectedly! It isn't a dealbreaker but per se but definitely something to note. Very tasty flavors for the ice cream bars! Perfect flavor variety and I love the neat packaging. The Lighthouse Beach Bar is the perfect balance of vanilla and raspberry--the flavors aren't too heavy together and were a great combination. I usually get picky when raspberry is too overdone. This was ideal for me. Really loved it, would get it again if I'm ever back. The Schoolhouse Pond Bar is for people who like espresso/coffee flavors, not my favorite, but that's because it's not a flavor profile for me. Like I said, there's a variety and probably something for most people here! Overall, great spot all round.

Sometimes on a cone, somtimes in a cup, and sometimes with hot fudge; but always, when available,…read more "Buffy's Homemade Black Raspberry Ice Cream" - MMM! Year after year, when in Chatham, one of my very first stop is to Buffy's cute cottage for a decadent treat. Friendly greetings and tastings every time. After receiving my order, outside I'll be at their Pink Bench or one of their other benches to savor my heavenly licks! CHEERS!

Holy Cow Ice Cream Cafe

4.6

(65 reviews)

Worth it!! The ice cream here tastes so so good. I've gone…read moreto the Burlington and now Dennis Port locations and Holy Cow has such great ice cream. I've had the corner piece and the salted caramel brownie, (highly recommend!!). Staff are very friendly and the inside smells delicious and looks really cool! **Only flaw is that it is pretty pricey so be prepared for that.

I have been following Holy Cow on Instagram for years and finally got the chance to go last night!…read more My favorite part was the warm waffle cone (which I actually didn't order at first but once I realized they were being made on the spot and served right away I had to get one) The flavor I had was Lunch Lady - it was really good- but I do wish they had some more traditional flavors, especially for my kids- they were having a hard time deciding because they like chocolate based flavors and there wasn't a lot of options. The line was long but moved quickly, the shop was clean but the bathroom was out of soap and toilet paper. Overall I would say if you haven't tried Holy Cow I would try it and make sure to get a waffle cone!

The House Of Ice Cream

3.9

(15 reviews)

So overpriced empty and 21$ for 3 ice creams and a mango smoothie that tastes like straight iceread more

Cute new ice cream shop. Around thirty plus flavors of frozen yogurt, sherbet and ice cream…read moreavailable. Lots of toppings too. We were able to sample before we settled on a flavor and boy that made it hard to choose! We decided on the lemon cookie, black raspberry frozen yogurt and a chocolate ice cream in a jimmy dipped waffle cone. All were really good! No crazy lines or getting eaten by bugs at this place. Try it out if you're in the area.

Seagulls Ice Cream & Soda Fountain

4.9

(15 reviews)

Another great experience at Seagulls! This time I got a cinnamon mochinut and the new honeydew…read moremelon milk tea. Both were sooo good. I'm normally a taro girl but honeydew has definitely become a new favorite milk tea flavor for me! Also their sundaes are HUGE, the ice cream is delicious and it's so cheap! The girl working there is very nice. Cant wait to come back.

I would give Seagulls 10 stars if I could. so very happy to…read morehave a place like this on Cape Cod. The service is always SO nice and warm, the food and drinks always come quickly and on the few occasions I've stayed to drink or eat there, the nice woman at the counter has made a point to ask me how everything was and if I liked it. I usually pick up a few ube mochinuts for the family to share but lately I have also been getting the chicken dumpling special. the reason it's a special is the dumplings are $11.99 but you can add ANY drink you want for $1 it's a generous portion of dumplings and I love their drinks so it's a good deal. I brought the chicken dumplings home this past visit, and my parents- both very picky eaters each tried them and said they were delicious. I like the strawberry lemonade with popping jelly pearls and you can specify how sweet you want it!

Gelato Joy Café

4.5

(25 reviews)

We stopped by here every day while in town. The ice coffee with your choice of gelato in it was my…read morego to every morning. The gelato was delicious not as sweet as other gelato I've tried which was perfect so you could indulge in more! Friendly and fast service! Enjoy your gelato or coffee outside on the rocking chair or on the tables street side!

Very bad latte. Tasted like a glass a milk that was shown a picture of espresso. Would not go to…read moreagain.

Hole In One

4.3

(236 reviews)