Mind you I got referred to the place via my hotel I'm staying at right now & my case though unable to use it because it coincided with a dinner special but nevertheless I will confess overall it is pretty much worth it. Got promptly seated at a booth & service came & my server was knowledgeable and recommended what I would do (you're gonna see what I'm referring to) & in the process got me a little bit of a bargain especially with my particular meal decision & did a prime rib with salad/bread/soup bar included. Ambience is very interesting because it seems from the 1980's music video days for few tracks I heard (not exactly bad especially now MTV no longer does music videos-?) but majority of music I heard was decent anyway. Suggestion for crew on the salad bar inform people "plates are cold, be aware" & just so people know. read more

See all

As I was by myself, I chose to sit at the bar at lunchtime. A bartender was friendly and attentive, and gave a great service. It turned out to be some kind of happy hour lunchtime so it was buy one beer get one beer free. The burger and fries I ordered were prepared perfectly and delicious. The salad bar, although kind of small was very good as well and the turkey soup was delicious. In case I forgot to mention, or you didn't know, the soup and salad bar is included in the price of the meal. Overall, I would say this was a great experience and I would recommend it to anyone. read more

food was alright service wasn't great very loud. I was eating my appetizer and the waitress came up with out meals mention she noticed I was still eating I pushed my appetizer plate to the side to make room for the meal she was delivering and she just took my appetizer plate without even asking if I was finished or done with my meal. overall it wasn't a mad restaurant just the staff needs work read more

This is a Gem. We have been there many times over the past 30 years. Everything is Amazing. A very "at home" restaurant.

Stopped at Butcher Block after finding out our plane out of the airport was delayed a couple hours. Ate at the bar area as the line was already out the door for tables. It was happy hour and the specials must have been good as the place was packed, loud, and there was a constant stream of wait staff going through. The soup and salad bar is excellent - I highly recommend it. Beers 2 for 1 during happy hour. Great service, hope to be back real soon. read more

Butcher Block - Margarita flatbread pizza - Steakhouses Near Me - Plattsburgh, New York

See all

It's a big, nice place with a great atmosphere and a salad bar. The food and drinks were both really good, and there were plenty of drink options to choose from. However, the service was on the slower side. It was very crowded, and we were seated in a corner, which made it hard to get a server's attention. We only got one round of drinks, and even after asking, it took a while for refills. We actually got our food before our first round of drinks arrived. Still, the food quality and overall vibe made it an enjoyable experience. read more

See all

Butcher Block is my favorite restaurant of all time. everything here is the best food you will ever eat. the bone ribeye is the best steak I ever have eaten in my whole life. we have to travel far to the butcher block across the lake but it is worth it every time. all off the waiters are very nice and get you whatever you want very fast. There is also a very good salad bar that has bread and many other things. after you get all your meals you have to get the cookie brownie ice cream desert. There are many nice private booths for your family to have a nice dinner in the building is very to be in. Butcher Block would get a 6/5 stars if it could. read more

Hess Chardonnay tasted watered down. Fillet tasted old with no grilled flavor and a pat of unmelted butter on top. Lettuce from the salad bar was brown around edges. Waiter was gruff and rude. This was the worst dining experience I have had in Plattsburgh. I won't go back. read more

Definitely not my favorite food spot. I wanted to love it unfortunately I feel it is overpriced for the quality of food you get. I got a steak and I'm sad to say that Chipotle has better steak. The salad bar is very nice. I did quite enjoy that. The interior of the restaurant is also nice. I just feel that it's rather overrated. read more

By far one of the best restaurants in Plattsburgh! We've been to Butcher Block many times and we always have the unlimited delicious soup and salad with our entrees. We were seated immediately on a busy Friday night. The staff is very friendly and kind. Our waiter, Jay did an outstanding job. There was a very rowdy crowd from Canada and Jay was able to make it a more enjoyable dining experience by asking them to lower their voices professionally. The food is very good, and the bread and butter amazing! We ordered the Butcher Burgers and it was perfect! We always love coming here - perfect for families and date nights. Highly recommend this family owned and operated business. read more

Hey y'all. Not a current local in P'burgh, but had a family gathering there for a few days. We took over the bar and most of the seats surrounding it. Everyone was accommodating. The service was excellent even with all the quick pick tickets rolling through. My wife and I miss it throughly. The hospitality and local kindness was amazing and the food didn't disappoint. P'burgh is not a usual destination trip, so if you find yourself there, check this place out. You will leave happy. read more

This was a very special night and I suggested to go here. WHAT A MISTAKE!!!! 80 year old on oxygen & hearing aids, 80 year old hearing aids, 55 year old with disabilities and a 65 year old. We made a reservation and requested easy access seating. we were seated close to the very loud salad bar- which two people with hearing aids is a nightmare. we asked our server if we could move to the other side of the area, sweetly and kindly- he nastily replied that this entire section was closed but he had to open it just for us and was unhappy to shift us. (it was empty) I sweetly asked for this favor. he grumbled and responded with distain and reluctantly said fine!.the place was not busy at all. He was so dismissive and rude all night. we could barely get his attention or stop him to ask for water. everything took a long time. He finally came to take our order. I told him I was allergic to pepper. (did I say black pepper or "pepper" I dont recall) I asked if the lobster had pepper- said no. He offered me 3 kinds of potatoes- I said does the mashed potatoes have pepper- oh right yes they do. Told me I had to be charged for the soup and salad but that I could not eat it. the food finally arrived (delivered by a different server) It had paprika on it. I asked her if it had paprika on it- she went and checked- it did. SHE OFFERED TO REPLACE IT! I said are you sure? she said yes and took it away. everyone had eaten salad, and their complete dinner and they were finished. I had not one drop of food the entire night. -no checking in on me. The waitress came back with my dinner in a take out container (no attempt to give me anything to eat while they were eating) AND TOLD ME I WAS GOING TO BE CHARGED FOR BOTH LOBSTERS. we argued. and the male waiter came back and yelled at us that I said BLACK pepper and was not responsible!!!! SO hostile!!! IT totally ruined the special evening we were trying to have. Then the assistant manager came back and said that we were definitely going to be charged. We explained again that I have not eaten one bite of food, please just charge us for one meal. Again adding unpleasantness to the evening. she says no, the manager above her said no while holding my dinner in a take out container. goes away and comes back and says manager gave ok to charge for one. we pay and no one ever speaks to us again. it was an awful nasty night. I went home and ate a cold rubbery lobster. I am embarrassed that I suggested this place. it ruined this special night on all levels. And if I think back on the last several times I suggested this place and had other special occasions here they were not impressive. And this night sealed its fate. I will never set foot in here again. read more

I've been here before, for happy hour and appetizers and flatbreads and it was enjoyable. Based on that, I brought an out of town friend for dinner. What a disappointment. I had the spinach and artichoke ravioli which is a casserole dish filled with a soupy sauce that had chunks of artichoke and two pieces of spinach smothering basic storebought ravioli. Not At all as described, and ridiculously priced at 24.99. My friend had the stuffed haddock for 34.99. The fish had been frozen and the ground up not fresh crabmeat was plopped on top. Again, a ridiculous price for such poorly prepared food. The salad bar that comes with the meal was very messy with food spills everywhere making it look like a starving hoard had just gone through. This was one of those experiences where you leave saying I could have made that better at home. We left half our meal untouched. read more

4 of us went for the early bird specials. Two had prime rib and two had stuffed haddock. The portions were huge and coupled with soup and salad bar were well worth the visit. Definitely the next time I'm in the area this will be a stop! read more

So far our favorite since moving to the area. The salad bar was great and kept up well. The food was excellent. We debated getting the ribs as sauce can make or break by individual taste preferences so decided to try another dish. I had a steak and it was perfectly cooked and flavored. The wait team was funny and so great they even brought us a small sample of the rib sauce we could try for next time. Our booth was cute and pretty private. Loved the ambiance. Highly recommend! read more

I really wanted to love this place, but the bad just outweighs the good for how much it costs. Ok so the good: the smoked turkey Mac and cheese was decent. Portion size is massive, and there is plenty of turkey in it. I love the ambiance of the place. It has a great country feel to it and was very clean. The not so good: potato skins were burnt, one crab cake was cold, the rice was dry and flavorless, the green beans were raw and cold. The bad: the prime rib was cold, there was so much au jus on it the waiter spilled it from the plate trying to put it down. The prime rib itself was tough and tasted of nothing but salt. The worst part: the service. Now this, I know is just my waiter. Everyone else I saw seemed to check in on their tables, and the people who brought us food and cleaned dishes were great. My waiter was none of those things. He never came by, we asked for something we waited while he walked around looking lost. So if you get the waiter with the mullet run. read more

My steak was the best one I've ever had! Great experience and I love the salad bar. My steak was lean and perfectly cooked. It was larger than expected although I don't recall any size being specified. Restaurant gets really busy so you may want to go early. read more

See all

My sons went on there limited time lunch break today and my younger son ordered a burger medium done and was served a completely raw burger and then had to get back to work and was too polite to complain but I'm doing it now ! This place is terrible!!! No more chances read more

Best Happy Hour in town. 2-1 drafts, wine and well. Clams, mussels, wings and pizza. Gets busy, but well worth it. Nice crowd also.

i wouldn't get the salad bar as it's handled in an unsanitary way but the food is great. you can sit in the bar area and play lotto games if you're into that. read more

This place was an absolutely amazing experience with amazing portions and a full salad bar you get what you pay for and more the staff are so friendly and I highly recommend coming here whenever you're in the area. read more

Nice folks, good soup from the salad bar. Ate there twice with vegetable and a cream soup (can't remember). The first time I did the soup and salad- very reasonable. The second did the prime rib... Cooked well and delicious. read more

The food at the Butcher Block is very good. Not the best I've ever had, but not the worst either. Skip the dessert, make your own at home. The salad bar included cold plates which was a nice surprise. I got the clams for an appetizer and wasn't too fond of it. Kind of tasted like seawater. Dinner: No one had any complaints with their meals. Each came with generous portions. Even the petite options were more than enough! Someone in my party got Crab legs and they were cracked ahead of time. Dessert: I would skip the dessert if you come here. The carrot cake was made with buttercream icing and not the traditional cream cheese frosting. The cheesecake was disgusting!!! Weirdest texture and flavor ever. Overall a good meal, but wouldn't rush to go back tomorrow, maybe in a little while. read more

Butcher Block - 7 Layer Carrot Cake - Steakhouses Near Me - Plattsburgh, New York

See all

Wow it was me, my mother and my wife and the Butchers Block was amazing. They had an unlimited salad bar that was amazing and amazing food. The waiter and waitress were very nice and fast. I would definitely suggest this place to anyone who likes a log cabin type place with a southern look to it. I'm definitely coming back soon! read more

Enjoyed a very nice Happy Hour Dinner Special on a Wednesday late-afternoon with the sweetness. The place was hopping, filled with laughter and the wait staff were attentive and quick to satisfy all of our questions, while the kitchen did a great job keeping up with the crush. A great restaurant experience on a rainy week. read more

Butcher Block - Run to the Butcher Block in beautiful Plattsburgh, NY. - Steakhouses Near Me - Plattsburgh, New York

I'm confused... got there for a late lunch on a busy day, about 2:30. Was told all that was available was the soup and salad bar, couldn't order from the menu. Since I was starving and there was no option close -by, I settled. The next person who came in got a menu and ordered a burger, and another group got the tavern menu. Server said they switched to the dinner menu and didn't take orders for a little while. I said the hostess could have explained that. The reply? "Oh well , she's new". Clearly communicating their business hours should be basic. The website says this: Lunch: 11:15 am - 2:30 pm Dinner: 11:15 am - 8:30 pm It does NOT say you cannot get food at certain times! read more

Food was fantastic! We were seated in a nice quiet booth. It took our server 20 minutes to bring our check but that wouldn't stop us from going back. And the salad bar is phenomenal. If you haven't gone then you need to. read more

Butcher Block - Steakhouses Near Me - Plattsburgh, New York

See all

We came here with mixed emotions after reading the different reviews on line. we came here from Copenhagen, I can highly recommend coming to this restaurant. the salad bar was fresh and has lots of variety, it also included a corn chowder soup which was great. the servers were attentive, food service was fast, the food was hot and plentiful. Can't say enough about this place. would come back next time I'm in Plattsburgh. read more

Great service, our waiter team was very attentive and helpful. We ordered prime rib. It was a bit over cooked and not super appealing to the eyes. It was tender and flavorful. Long line at the salad bar. The place is a little aged but clean. Overall we enjoyed our meal read more

Simply The Very best Bar-Tenders Any Where.... According to the "Bill Of Right s" Amendment 1... Congress Shall make NO LAW respecting an establishment of Religion Or prohibiting the free Exercise thereof, or abridging the Freedom of Speech or Of the Press, or the Right of the People To Assemble and to Petition The Government For A Redress of Grievances... Please be Advised that at this time I would like to Reserve a Table for 2 On Mother's Day at 12:01 pm (May. 10, 2020... John F. Neyenhouse, JR. ( age 74 years) Ms. Mary s. Neyenhouse ( approximately 98 years old) read more

See all

It's a shame that a place with such great ambience has such mediocre food. Straight from the frozen food truck. Salad bar is very basic and hasn't changed in 50 years. Soups ok, nothing special. I ordered a roast beef dip - beef well done served on a hot dog roll with a small cup of bouillon. Other party had a BLT- plain white bread, tasteless skinny tomato, reheated cheap bacon. If they spent a few bucks more on quality ingredients rather than the bottom line, they'd be better off. read more

Haven't been to the Block since pre-COVID and unfortunately the wait wasn't worth it. To be fair, they still have one of the best salad bars I've ever seen, with many many choices for extras. Plus great breads and always a good soup. For that, they get 5 stars. However, I ordered a Buffalo Chicken wrap, something I used to order back in the day and loved. What a disappointment this was today! Instead of crispy, seasoned chicken sliced in the wrap, this was chunks of chicken(?) swimming in a runny hot sauce. Terrible! I expect this low quality of a sandwich from a highway diner, not an upscale restaurant - especially for $18! (including the salad bar, which was why the overall rating wasn't 1 star). I used to love "The Block" for the lunch special but I sure didn't all back in love with it today. read more

Great service Great food. Great salad bar. Beware of the dessert. If you're dining alone, you won't finish it.

My daughter and I came to the restaurant on 10/26/2023 between 4 and 5:30 PM for the early bird special. My daughter got the 10 oz prime rib with French fries and I got the crabmeat stuffed flounder with almonds, perfectly cooked green bean and for the starch I chose wild rice. The prime rib was cooked exactly as ordered and appeared larger than 10 ounces, and it tasted delicious. The seafood dish was better than I have had in a long time. Our dinners were $22 each and they came with the unlimited salad, soup and bread bar. The salad bar was fresh and delicious, the raisin bread was a treat, and the potato chowder was perfect. The host was fast and brought us to a nice comfortable booth. Our table was handled by two people Lindsey and Jay. Both servers are hospitality professionals and they made a dynamic team. They knew the menu, are upbeat, their timing was spot on, and they refilled the sodas ($3.50) endlessly. read more

Awesome rustic atmosphere! Personable staff and great quality food. The salad bar is a meal in itself so I'm glad I just got the half rack of ribs. Highly recommend read more

Poor management! This one star has nothing to do with the food or staff, great food and amazing happy hour. I was sitting at the bar on 9/11/24 and some old man came out and started cussing out the bartender in front of the entire bar, making her cry and run off to the bathroom. Customers and employees were left in disbelief. It resulted in many employees coming to the bar and consoling the bartender and it was obvious everyone had distain for the manager or whatever he was. A a$$hole is what he was. Very unprofessional on his part, he should not be in charge of anything. read more

First time here, would highly recommend it. Food was great, service was great. Atmosphere has the feel of a rustic hunting log cabin. Food is home made. If you want something different than the norm, this is the place to go. Well worth the money you spend. read more

See all

Look no further!!! You've found the right place, you can't go wrong here I promise!!! read more

See all

Warm atmosphere, good service and the food was plentiful and filling. A soup, salad and bread bar is included with entrees. Decor is rustic with cozy booths. There is a bar seating area as well. Great place with reasonable pricing. Recommended. read more

See all

Was not expecting what was inside! Beautiful interior. Very glad we stopped here for lunch. Burgers were huge and delicious! Nice staff. Soup and salad bar with meal. Very large spread. Bread was hard as a rock, I wish they had single serve rolls instead of cut it your self loaves. read more

Butcher Block - Yum yum - Steakhouses Near Me - Plattsburgh, New York