Great baked goods, cute little hideaway! Picked up some "birthday" bagels and the service was excellent and they even added a happy birthday message to the sack of bagels!!! Only problem is getting into the parking lot if heading south on 41...u turn will be necessary and not a lot of parking. But worth going! read more

I go here almost every morning when I'm on the west coast in Venice. I've tried their everything bagel sandwiches which are very good , and I've had their two egg breakfast - either of those every time. Their bacon is in my top 5 places ever - and their potatoes are pretty fire. Staff is friendly. read more

if you want a bagel and some fresh breakfast, this place is great, it has a nice atmosphere and they have all their bagels and baked goods on display right when you walk in, and there's a variety of types I tell you; they even have mini bagels! Which I had as a sandwich with a toasted everything-mini bagel, garlic herb cream cheese, lox, red onion, and tomato. My friend also ordered a jalapeño bagel with scrambled eggs and home fries. We ordered it all to-go. To start off -the service was friendly, and once our food was done - one of the employees brought it to us! Even though we had a number and they could've just called that, that was nice of them. Onto the food - my bagel was delicious, the garlic herb cream cheese paired extremely well with the Smokey flavour of the salmon, I wasn't a fan of the red onion and tomato so I took those off, but after taking those off, that was probably the best bagel I've ever had. On the contrary, my friends jalapeño bagel tastes just like a plain bagel, to the extent they even asked if they received the wrong one, the scrambled eggs and home fries were good, not much more to say. However, I personally appreciated how they gave us organic ketchup packets with the breakfast plate. I enjoyed it and I bet you will too. read more

See all

Missing Northeast Bagels since I move down here in 2013, this place was a godsend. Bacon egg and cheese on a toasted or non toasted bagel with spk? Thank you sir may I have another!! My neighbor told me about this place and took us there after a bike ride through Legacy Trail to give us our replenishment. I got him an amazing bagel for the sandwich that made me not so homesick anymore. That was back in 2015, and since then I've had their Bagel sandwiches several times and have never once been disappointed. If it wasn't so far away from me I would definitely make a trip there once a month to pick up some bagels for weekend breakfast. Actually now that I put words to it, I just went make it a monthly trip 20 miles each way to pick up some bagels for my family. If this locations too far south for you, the same owners also own and run Brooklyn Bagel up in Sarasota, which might be a little bit closer for those in the northern part of Sarasota County. My husband has had their bagels quite a few times and so they are just as good as Cafe Bagels. So I'd like to take this moment to thank the owners of both establishments for bringing the Northeast taste to Southwest Florida and making this New Jersey girl a little less homesick every time she takes a bite into one of their bacon egg and cheese sandwiches!!! read more

Very nice people. Get there early or reserve your bagels the day before. They were a bit chewy for my liking and hard crusty exterior. Probably won't go again, but may give them one more shot. read more

Best NY style bagels! Free with Tick Tock video shown ! Awesome deal! Will be going here often!

Stay Away if You Eggs!!!!A bagel...no brainer the old lady behind counter took my order omelette two strips of bacon on the side . I was served arunny omelette with bacon in it. That was half cooked. I asked for crisp bacon it's just a joke. Don't go there. Don't waste your money. Do you want a bagel good, buy the bagel bagels aren't really that great, but this is just for future reference people. A waste of $10.99 read more

Cafe Bagel is a dream. Definitely a well-known, local favorite. I got the Scrambagel on rye and it was delicious. I recommend signing up for their texting program because you get SIX free bagels! read more

Cafe Bagel - My six free bagels - Bagels Near Me - Venice, Florida

Great breakfast bagels. I get them on a mini bagel--it's just the right size for me. Also had a croissant there that was delicious. Wish they had cinnamon raisin bagels--my favorite! read more

On vacation to AMI and stopped at this bagel shop to get bagels and a breakfast sandwich. Very busy shop. Breakfast sandwich was yummy, however, the bagels were refrigerated cold. Not sure if they had been frozen or left over from the day before. Also, taken back with the political paraphernalia posted on the wall near the register. Is that necessary? It creates a decisive atmosphere which does not belong in a business that the public views. read more

Ordered a bagel toasted with butter. While making orders, a girl behind the counter showed off how burned a bagel was to another employee. Turns out, that was my bagel. So burned and so much butter I couldn't eat it. Very disappointing. read more

Cafe Bagel - Toasted with butter - Bagels Near Me - Venice, Florida

My goto source for New York style bagels. So fresh and full of flavor. A decent selection fo choose from.

Cafe bagel is a quaint place that has a large selection of fresh-made bagels and other baked goods. Most of their selection of bagels is of the savory variety with only a couple sweet variations to choose from. If I had any complaints/suggestions it would only be that they make a couple more sweet-type bagels for those of us that don't want to start the day off with savory bagels. read more

Huge bagels - the 'minis' are actually big enough. But check your order before you leave as it's hit or miss you get what you ordered. I've had 2 breakfast bagel orders messed up - and only found out when I had already left and didn't have time to go back which is really plain annoying. Seems to always be confusion behind the counter. read more

These have to be the most dense bagels I have ever had. You literally can't even chew them. Plus they were totally flavorless. I have no idea how this place has such good reviews. read more

Staff is soooooo unexplainably rude & truly disinterested in providing any kind of quality customer service. Between the attitudes, the dirty looks, and the bickering behind the counter: I felt like I was stuck inside of a highschool cafeteria. Also, the bagel selection was limited at a place called "Cafe BAGEL". I'll never be back here. read more

5 stars for bagel quality! Definitely delicious bagels. Family run spot in Venice with easy access and plenty of parking. Dog friendly tables outside with a huge water bowl for doggie guests. Loved the bagel selections and the family friendly vibe. Plenty of inside tables with a counter too. Taylor Ham sandwiches and platters are available and delicious. Potatoes were okay but a bit soggy for my taste. The eggs were perfect too. The coffee is too strong and limited. On this day, the Jamaica Me Crazy was done and out for the day and it was 10:00 am. There was Hazelnut and French Vanilla plus the regular and decaf. There is a wide selection of flavored creamers for those that prefer flavor in their milk. Not a fan of the styrofoam coffee cups, would have preferred a cardboard cup or real cup. Again, the major star here is the bagels and totally will go back for more. Nice family operating the cafe too. read more

Cafe Bagel - Really strong coffee. - Bagels Near Me - Venice, Florida

See all

My children and husband love their Snapple selections! I love the "Jamaican me crazy" coffee and the bagels here are good an sure beats driving 14hrs for one! read more

I am a regular at Cafe Bagel and have been going for years. The bagels are phenomenal, the cream cheese on the other hand has changed over the years and is not very good anymore. It has a weird sour taste to it. I took home bagels with no cream cheese and put my own on it and it was great. I wish they would go back to the way they used to make the cream cheese! read more

Actually I am from Brooklyn New York which is the undisputed king of bagels, pizza & hot dogs. Both my wife and I ate there several times and I have to take issue with several of the people who post negative reviews of this establishment and claim to be ex New Yorkers. The bagels were delicious last time I ordered poppy seed bagel with egg white and bacon my ordered an everything toasted bagel with cream cheese. Both were delicious and as authentic to Brooklyn that you will get in anywhere Florida. I believe there is a inherited inferiority complex with many ex New Yorkers who can not give credit when its due to so many good restaurants demonstrated by the need to post negative and totally inaccurate reviews to sound as if they have a greater knowledge than everyone else about good food. read more

Before COVID we ate there almost every other weekend and a bagel or two throughout the week. I know it's my choice but I am appalled that no one behind the counter/handling food wears a mask. I guess business is that good still to deter former customers not to come in and order. read more

Best bagels in Venice, if not all of Sarasota! The steak, egg, and cheese bagel sandwich is delicio. 5 out of 5 stars! read more

Went in Saturday for a bagel. Place was busy but greeted right away by an employee. Must be a good place to work because the counter staff is so friendly. Ordered a sesame bagel toasted with vegetable cream cheese. Just the right amount of cheese, bagel nicely toasted, just perfect! Again, the staff works together as a team and gets a lot of people through the store with a minimum wait time. Love this place! read more

We checked this place out for breakfast around 10 this morning (Saturday) and I was nervous they would be low on bagels but they still had a large selection. It was our first time in here and everyone was very friendly. We had 3 people offer to help us when we walked in and each explained different breakfast sandwiches they offer or something to us in between helping other customers. The people are nice and the bagels were great and cheap. We will be back to sample some more read more

Expensive, not great bagels. If you are from the NJ/NY area I don't think you would like these bagels at all. They are more like bread then bagels. Bought some muffins too. They were a bit dry and I thought they were day old. Will not be going back. Staff was pleasant but again, I don't think it's good. Maybe if your aren't used to NY bagels, you would like it. But to each his own. read more

With all the good reviews I thought I should try this place. We live in a borough of NYC. We thought maybe they imported the water. However, not the case. I mean, my son said just go to Dunkin Donuts - it's the same quality and cheaper. The bagel was heavy without crunch. Mine was toasted- which was better than my son's not toasted one. If you are from NYC- this isn't a bagel from there. It's something you would expect from Florida water. read more

this is my favorite breakfast spot. I always usually get a breakfast burrito or a breakfast bagel and it's always perfect, never had a bad one. The place is clean and the staff is friendly and they always get me out the door quick so I can get to work. I pass a lot of breakfast places from Port Charlotte to Venice and this is the best breakfast before work. read more

Snarky workers. Subpar bagels. Pricey. Too much chatter between workers about customers. Will never be back.

Was visiting in town for the Fox Lea horse show. Stopped in at 06:30am on a Sunday morning and picked up bagels with veggie cream cheese and a slice of tomato on each. Tasted great back at the hotel room. read more

See all

Have you ever felt like you miss New York ..because you have come down to live in or spend time in Venice and can not Get a real New York Bagel. Well we know the place to go. Cafe Bagel!You will be pleasantly surprised!! Not only are the bagels great but they also have honey walnut cream cheese, vegetables cream cheese and lox and cream cheese. They are. So good! They also have terrific muffins. They are great and they are really large!!we have going to Cafe Bagel for over 5 years. We went there since the original owners and I can tell you the people that took over are doing a great job !! You will not be disappointed ! No need to miss New York because Cafe Bagel is the home of the Bagel! Ruth and the staff are very nice people and know what real bagels are !! Tell them Linda and Bruce sent you! You will not be disappointed! read more

Best Bagels I have ever tasted in Florida! They remind me of NY bagels when my husband and I go visit there, it's always a must. Great taste and texture. The Lox cream cheese is phenomenal .. We love this place! Thank you!! Go try it for yourself, you won't be disappointed! read more

First off, the bagels are amazing. Please please try the bread pudding, it's the best I have ever had. I have been here 4 times in a week because I can't get enough of the food. The service is outstanding and the staff is very friendly! You won't be disappointed! read more

See all

i love this place. the workers are so nice. the vibe is immaculate. everyone deserves a raise

Very good bagels I will be back for sure!! I just moved here a month ago from N.J. And am very happy to have found Cafe Bagel. I thought I left the pork roll egg and cheese bagel behind but am happy to find a place here in Venice that dose have it!! read more

Amazing breakfast!! Prices are beyond reasonable and food comes out very quick!! I brought my dog and they were very friendly to him , Cafe bagel even provides a water bowl for the dogs!! Love this place! read more

I'm not from NYC or Chicago or Detroit so perhaps I'm not as knowledgable as some of the other reviewers about how bagels are supposed to taste, but to me these are yummy. The staff is friendly each time I visit and the only time I've been disappointed is when my husband got my order wrong. I especially enjoy the garlic bagel...so deliciously smelly! read more

Not bad for a West coast Florida bagel I have especially enjoyed their breakfast bagels. They have good variety and fresh bagels from what I can see are not available anywhere else. So you are stuck but it is not a bad place to be stuck if you know what I mean. They are the best bagels in town... take that from a Bronx boy. read more

This is my new favorite bagel place! The Lox is super fresh and is a very good price! The bagels are fluffy and dense. The salmon cream cheese is amazingly creamy. The chopped liver is really tasty! I had the "Jamaican and Crazy" coffee and it was really good! Cafe Bagel is by far the best bagel place in Sarasota County! I will be traveling down here to get my bagel fix once a month! My friend from Venice has been going here for years and has been encouraging me to come here and now I wish I had come here sooner. I love New York bagels and I love this place! read more

Came with a friend for bagel sandwiches for breakfast. We loved their bagels, they were amazing! With that said, the proportion of meat/egg on the sandwich to the size of bagel was off. It could have used more of both. Will definitely be back for some bagels though. read more

FINALLY! After months of living here in Venice/Sarasota area I found bagels that compare with those back in the NYC and NJ area. Right amount of crunch on the outside and chewy flavor on the inside. Baked fresh every morning. Open early and close by 2:00 so get there early for the best of many different flavors both fruity and savory. BONUS They do a Taylor ham sandwich sandwich as well as other breakfast items that are reasonably priced. The people who work here are very nice and greet you with a warm smile and kind service (something not always evident in the NY/NJ area). Have an assortment including "Jamaica Me Crazy" seems to be a favorite amongst local coffee lovers. The place is also immaculately clean. Choose your own coffee cup or get it to go. A GREAT FIND! I found reasonably good NJ / NY Boardwalk style pizza (took six months!) and still need to find Chinese food that isn't too far away. Any ideas would be appreciated! Now I will have to get used to 300 days of sunshine and no gray slush and potholes. read more