They proved me wrong. I thought Lobster Rolls were way overrated. DJ's Clam is the BEST lobster…read moreroll., sorry Maine. HUGE chunks of lobster and the most delicate perfectly toasted bread that is like a tasty cloud that doesn't fill you up but adds to the experience. Thank you DJ is Clam Shack. Bravo.

Easy to see why this is a local favorite. They were only open from 11-4 when we're there which made…read moreit an easy lunch pick. I had the conch fritters and a shrimp po' boy with some onion rings. The fritters were stuffed with meat and delicious. The po' boy was stuffed with shrimp, pickled red onion and a tangy slaw. My wife had mahi mahi tacos which were huge and delicious. Amazing lunch spot in Old Town.

in the recommendation of a friend, we stopped here and ordered cracked conch, and a grilled wahoo…read moresandwich. The cracked conch melted in your mouth. So fresh and tender. I wanna come back and order this every day! The wahoo was delicious and fresh. We even loved the black beans and rice. I feel like anything you get here is probably amazing. We should eat here all the time. I know I will be if I can!

Food was ok. Nothing crazy good ! Sat where I could…read moreobserve kitchen prep and conditions ! Don't do this ! They need hygienic training. I know, I know every "greasy spoon" is like this. At least set a couple of spray bottles in view and wipe something down occasionally. If you wipe your brow use a paper towel ! I won't talk price because that wouldn't be fair because everything is crazy price in Key West. Except for Circle K. 44oz pop at soda fountain $1.06.

Best shrimp on the island. Outside dining is delightful. To go orders always an option if you're on…read morethe run!

Stone crab was exceptional and they have the large ones. Spiny lobster and lobster roll were just…read moreokay. It's in a nice neighborhood but we wouldn't go out of our way to come back.

I found Fisherman's Cafe after a not-so-great experience at one of the neighboring spots, and I'm…read moreglad I did. While waiting to order, I was able to browse the menu and decided on the shrimp and crab wrap with fries. The cashier answered all of my questions about the wrap, which made me feel confident in my choice. The wait wasn't long, especially since everything is made fresh. The fries came out hot and definitely needed a minute to cool down, and the wrap was warm on the outside while the inside stayed cool and fresh. Everything was tasty, and the pickle was a nice touch to round out the meal. Fisherman's is a small restaurant with limited seating, but there are several benches across the walkway where you can sit and enjoy your food while watching the boats and people nearby. A great, laid-back spot with a nice view.

Yes, please. Best little spot on the wharf next to Jimmy Buffets recording studio. No frills…read more Outdoor seating. Best blackened fish tacos Ive ever had. Cooked to order, friendly and fast. Cheap lunch time eats with options.

I liked the idea of a place based off an English pub. Needed some eats for lunch, so ordered a…read moreburger. Seated quickly in a quaint restaurant and immediately ordered above mentioned burger. Big, stupid mistake! I was expecting something lunch sized but got a fantastic burger and fries that could have held me until the next day! Unfortunately, my wife had seen the fish and chips plates coming out and actually told me, "Your order is stupid, you'll never finish!" She was so right, but damn was it good!!!

St Patrick's day happy hour 3 people…read more Sat immediately inside Ordered: Corned beef & cabbage (special) With potatoes and carrots Mustard sauce on top Shepards pie Looks small but very filling Tuna poke I wish they wouldn't put the chips in the bowl because it was so saucy that the chips got soggy Tuna and fruit good on top but the bottom of the bowl was too saturated Wings - naked with mango habanero on side Wings are brined so they are very salty I like salt so I enjoyed it but if you sensitive to salt taste, do not order the wings I love spicy foods and sauces but the mango habanero was unimpressive It honesty tasted like a weird vinaigrette Beer & tequila Our server was great With it being st pats day, it was busy and he kept the pacing of our drinks just right Very nice guy

Service was great and very friendly Killer tuna nachos were…read morethe best very fresh Would highly recommend to stop in once or twice on your visit to the keys

This was our second time here - the last time was in 2014 and it took some time to remember the…read morename of this place, but we asked a local and made it back! My parents got fried Hogfish and said their meal was delicious. I got a cheeseburger, which was fantastic. Huge portion sizes and grilled with a nice char on the outside. Came with fries, which were also really good. Our waitress was wonderful! She said she'd worked there 25 years and she had such a great personality. It was hot and they're an open air type place, so while there is shade, there isn't air conditioning but it's such a fun, island vibe that you won't care. Definitely a local establishment with a lot of character. A little outside Key West on Stockton Island.

Location- excellent located on a main walking busy popular street…read more Food- it was okay, excellent service and quick We ordered Sample platter- mainly fries on the bottle, only 4 pieces of fried conch and 2-3 fried conch fritters. The conch was good size, the ratio of the batter to conch is not balance- too much batter and dry. The Sample conch ceviche is was tiny contain in a ketchup dipping sauce container.

This shack came highly recommended from social media so I was excited to try "Key West's best conch…read morefritters". However, this was not our experience. The conch fritters were overcooked and burnt. They were extremely hard and crunchy. We did notice that the cook stepped away for a long time while our conch fritters were in the deep fryer cooking, causing them to be overcooked. However, we were the only customers there, so they could have easily remade a fresh batch that was not overcooked. I would not try this shack again or recommend it to others.

At the recommendation of my daughter, my wife and I had lunch at Caroline's during our recent Key…read moreWest cruise stop. Caroline's it not fancy - it's pure Key West. And the food is decent. But, for my wife who is Gluten Free, they scored big points by going above and beyond. She ordered a dish that had plantains, and was disappointed to hear the plantains weren't gluten free. She has been GF for years, and has become accustomed to being disappointed with what she can't have. Imagine her delight (joy!) when they brought over plantains prepared GF - just for her!!! That made her so happy - service like that isn't common these days. VERY well done, Caroline's !!!! And thank you!!!

We always make it a point to stop at Caroline's and sit at the rail by the street for some lunch…read more Service is always fast and friendly and the food is good. The Cuban Sandwich was very good. The Lettuce Wraps were good as well (the noodles were just very spicy and not the crispy style we were used to).