I ordered a Stromboli with NO MUSHROOMS and NO SAUSAGE. Somehow it was managed to get loaded with…read moremushrooms. I tried to deal with it and pick them out but it was impossible because of how many were in it. There is also sausage in it as well but you can't see it because of how loaded up with mushrooms it is. Pretty upsetting.

Unfortunately, our experience at Geno's Pizza was very disappointing. We arrived, sat down, and…read morewaited for our order to be taken. After ordering our drinks, we noticed that the waitress was serving and bringing drinks to customers who had just arrived before bringing ours, even though we had been seated and waiting much longer. The service was very poor, and we felt overlooked for most of our visit. In addition, the restaurant did not appear to be very clean, which made the experience even less enjoyable. We expected better customer service and a more organized approach to serving guests. Overall, it was not an experience that would make us want to return

As someone born and raised in Brooklyn,NY.. this is pretty damn close! A bit too much cheese but…read moreother than that , the crust and sauce was spot on :) The garlic knots tasted just like how I remember them back home, highly recommend! Place was a bit cramped so next time I'll probably take the food to go. But the Vibe was good, service was a bit slow but we did come in durning the lunch rush. Other than that, I'd highly recommend this place if your looking for some NY style pizza :)

Not sure where in NY this pizza is trying to say they are the style of. There is enough cheese on…read morethis pizza for two pizzas. Sauce was good, crust was decent. I asked for garlic powder and he totally blew me off and told me it was in the top box. Guess he wasn't listening because I said powder not garlic knots... I've had worse pizzas out of the NY region. I would go again but as soon as I got it I would throw it in the oven for another 15 min. We had it the next day as leftovers and did this, and honestly it made for a pretty good slice,

Not bad at all....actually some good pizza and hits the spot…read more We stopped here to eat on our visit to North Myrtle Beach. The pizza itself was very good and the customer service was fine. The inside of restaurant and vibe is very old school and a bit dated, with nostalgic tabletops benches/booths. Either way, besides the dull interior, the food is good and this place continues to draw crowds. I'm sure it is very busy during peak summer season. In all, decent pizza. Good customer service. Price point average for pizza as well. I would recommend. Georgia's Pizza gets a thumbs up in my book and is a good place to eat pizza....while in the North Myrtle Beach area.

The pizza was good although a large would've been a medium in NY. The salads were a good size for…read moresmall. There's no waitress, you order the counter and wait for your number to be called and it's typical pizza place, nothing fancy. It's nice that it's right in Main Street and recommended by the locals.

Great place! We…read morewalked inside and someone served us immediately. We did a take out order. We ordered Lasagna, I believe it was a Veggie pizza, Hawaiian pizza with extra pineapples and BBQ chicken pizza (not pictured). Our friends truly enjoyed the Lasagna and gave it an 8 out of 10. The Hawaiian pizza was really good. We switched out the regular tomato sauce with alfredo sauce and it was so good. The crust was perfect. It wasn't too thick like Papa John's but also wasn't too thin like Domino's. It was a perfect medium! Honestly, I gave 4 stars because our friends did not really enjoy the BBQ chicken pizza. Also, our order was not completely correct. However, it worked out but if it was anyone else, they may not have not been satisfied. The guy took our order without writing it down and I had an interesting personal order due to my acid reflux from regular tomato sauce so I think it caused our order to get a little mixed up! All in all, it was good! We would order from there again but possibly order something different!

Carry out Sat 7-11-26…read more 6:00 pm Hot Wings Spanakopita LG House Special Pizza Chocolate Dipped Cannolis 5 All the family and staff were very welcoming, professional, and nice!!! Heres what WE did wrong----carry out on a busy Saturday night. This place was busy with a wait to dine in. I was excited, as this many people cannot be wrong!!! The restaurant was clean and organized--another plus. There's not one point person to handle the all the carry out orders--this was chaos. You tell the cashier your name, they write it on a Post-It Note, then they walk it over to the kitchen, to inform them that you're here and waiting. They use the app, Slice. You would never be able to call your order in here--it's just too busy. I ordered the pizza with no onions, extra mushrooms to take the place of the onions, light sauce and well done because this was carry out and I was trying to avoid a soggy pizza. 5-Wings were 10 , 7 drums and 3 flats. It took me a long time to find a man who does not like flats, so I can have them to myself. I got 3 flats and he got 7 drums. Unevenly yoked wing order. The Bleu cheese and wings were fantastic!!! Crispy, yet enough sauce to keep it interesting. These were AWESOME!!! 5-Spanakopita was DIVINE!!! Phylo was perfect and the filling was balanced. I could eat a whole pan of this!!! 1-House Pizza. We are definitely going to go back and dine in person. No onions as requested but not one mushroom hit my pie. The sauce and crust lost this for us. My order was to be ready at 6:20. I arrived at 6:10. I didn't receive my order until 6:38. There were a ton of carry out orders that were sitting. The kitchen lady expeditor was WEEDED. I'm almost positive it was ready when I arrived but waiting for the wings, spanakopita, and cannolis to merge with the order, cost my pizza to suck. It was cold, greasy, soggy, and not good. We tipped $20 that goes to the staff when ordering because we want a good order. It's like you have to tip the Doordasher or you won't get your order on time. The sauce was very sweet. Most Italian sauce is acidic/sour but Greek sauce does have some sugar to balance it-which we love!!! But this sauce has A LOT of sugar-maybe this batch was made by accident? The crust was weird texture and had a weird lip to it, to keep the goodness inside. It was just wonky and super hard. 5-Chocolate Cannolis were so good!!! You know it's good, when you can only eat half now and half later, with coffee the next morning for breakfast!!! I saw Baklava being served but it was unavailable on carry out!!! I would have ordered BOTH!!! We just moved here and will definitely go back! There was enough goodness to make us want to go back to change the rating. I think my timing was way off to get a good pizza here or anywhere on a Saturday night in season.

We stopped in for lunch and placed an order, then went to shop at a cute little vintage store next…read moredoor while we waited. Our order was ready before we were finished shopping and it was delicious. I got a chicken Alfredo personal pizza and they definitely did not skimp on the toppings. It was wonderful and reasonably priced. My boyfriend got an Italian sub which was also good. I highly recommend to anyone in the area!

We've had 7 pizza places in Myrtle Beach and AJs is by far the best near the ocean! NOT A TOURIST…read moreTRAP! Really great prices, pwrfect cheese and pepperoni pizza, and Hawaiian pizza. Super fast hot delivery from friendly staff. If you're debating between them and ultimate California pizza choose AJs! They were far superior over California, you can check my review of them too, they were mid and a tourist trap. NYer approved!

Great NY pizza and subs. I like the eggplant sub and Caesar salad. Service is great. Dine in or…read moretake out. Dine in is very small and no table service. Nice looking place and clean.

Delivered to Beach House In time frame stated and hot. We have been getting for a few years as a…read morelast night meal. Plain,Pepperoni, Sausage, Supreme,and Meat Lovers. All were great snd everyone in house raved about it.

New York City is in Myrtle Beach! This is hands down the best pizza I've had outside of NY and NJ…read more In fact, it's better than most places in NY and NJ. This is real NYC pizza and calzones in South Carolina. The owner hails from Astoria, Queens and has an original location still operating there. This is one of those places that is so good you shouldn't even bother trying anything else in the area.

The prices published on this restaurant's own website are apparently nowhere near the prices they…read moreare actually charging. When I brought up the discrepancy and asked about honoring the prices advertised on their own website, the response I received was simply, "Do you want to order or not?" That is an unacceptable way to handle a legitimate customer concern. Customers should be able to rely on pricing that a business chooses to publish on its official website. If those prices are outdated, update the website. Until then, management should take responsibility for the information it is advertising rather than dismissing customers who question it. I have submitted a complaint to the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) regarding the advertised pricing and the discrepancy I encountered. Regardless of how that complaint is ultimately handled, this restaurant needs to correct its online menu immediately and address how customers are treated when they raise reasonable concerns about advertised prices.

Loved it. Pizza was huge and tasted great. Staff was nice and welcoming. A great restaurant.read more

Wanted some good pizza, this place had great reviews, I know everyone has different taste but there…read morewas nothing outstanding about our pizza except service. We ordered the supreme.. It was average the crust , sauce or toppings were just okay. I wanted so bad to say it was outstanding. You decide.