I don't even know where to begin. The food, the staff, and the restaurant were amazing!!! The shrimp tacos were delicious. Best seafood tacos I've ever had. And the fresh cut fries were perfect. The staff was very nice and responsive. The restaurant was very clean. They have indoor and outdoor seating. The outdoors seating is covered. Parking is limited right by the door but it is attached to a shopping center. I had a feeling this place was going to be good when people were speed walking to get the table they wanted. Can't wait to visit again. read more

Cape Cod Fish - Seafood Near Me - Fort Myers, Florida

See all

It was a beautiful day and I decided to sit outside in their covered seating area. The waitress was very helpful with suggestions and in the end I selected the blackened halibut burger that was one of their specials. The fish itself was good, but the tartar sauce and pickles really made it a special dish. Creamy and tangy and crispy! I got the coleslaw as a side and it was fantastic! There's a lot to choose from and I'm planning on coming back to try other things. read more

Cape Cod Fish - Blackened halibut burger - Seafood Near Me - Fort Myers, Florida

Food was just OK, much better lobster roll at the ClamBake & Doug's. It was a chilly evening heater were broke Service was not good, asked several times for mayo. There is a new place in Coconut point "Mason" much better lobster roll at $22.99 when the Cape Cod Fish was $29.99 I would never go again to the Cape Cod Fish Company! After seeing the owner's reply, I would like to add that the service was terrible, you have heater on the wall. It was cold in the 50's that night. To get a table inside was 60 minute, per waitress. Maybe a lot of people like your place, none of the 6 of us will NEVER come back. It seems to me that you really do t care anyway. Good bye & good luck read more

My wife and greatly enjoyed our lobstah pie. She got the 4.5oz, I had the 6 oz portion. She had a tossed house salad and Cole slaw. I had fresh cut fries and Cole slaw. We ate inside today. Our sever was Lisa. She was a joy. Great experience' read more

Cape Cod Fish - My wife's meal - Seafood Near Me - Fort Myers, Florida

See all

Stopped for a quick lunch and was pleasantly surprised. Nice and clean, great service. Offered free refills and the fried shrimp and fries were outstanding. The lobster roll was as well but it could have used a tad more filling to at least get to the end of the roll. Would definitely stop here again if in the area!! read more

See all

We sat outside food and service was awesome . Captains basket and salmon tacos the best. We also had key lime pie and bread pudding for dessert definitely recommend. read more

Another wonderful meal at Cape Cod Fish - we had three of the specials, coconut shrimp "the best coconut shrimp I've ever had" said one of our tablemates. I had the SICILIAN SALMON BRUSCHETTA and it was excellent. One of the others had the ATLANTIC COD & JUMBO SHRIMP BASKET and she said it was also excellent and the last dish we had was the Salmon BLT - again a great meal. The fish is always cooked perfectly. read more

See all

Love the people here always friendly happy to have you there service is always great n the food is delicious Fresh served hot everything is good Highly recommend this quaint spot read more

See all

Cape Cod Fish outdid themselves for Mother's Day! We had their specials for the day and I can easily say each and every one of them were amazing! Such great flavors bursting through the calamari with banana peppers Kalamata olives and roasted red peppers sooo good! My mother had the twin lobster tails and they were done to perfection and so sweet, my brother had the stuffed halibut ( stuffed with crab&lobster ) excellent! I had the Santorini salad which had artichokes and sun-dried tomatoes along with other tasty things and blackened shrimp! So delicious! Service was top notch and friendly HIGHLY RECOMMEND! read more

See all

This place truly is a hidden gem. So happy my friend and I decided to try this place. It wasn't very busy when we got there so we got seated right away. There's outdoor and indoor seating available. Our server was amazing. Wish I could remember her name. I have to say everyone that work there were very friendly. Both my friend and I decided to get the same thing. We got the classic Lobster roll with the right amount of Mayo, lemon and herbs. For sides we got the Parmesan truffle fries and coleslaw. The whole plate was devoured in no time. There was plenty of big juicy pieces of Lobster with the perfect amount of dressing on it. It was a delicious roll. The Parmesan Truffle fries were delicious as well. We ended our dinner on a sweet note with their extremely delicious bread pudding. I highly recommend trying it, you won't be disappointed. Will be back for sure next time we are visiting. read more

Cape Cod Fish - Bread Pudding - Seafood Near Me - Fort Myers, Florida

See all

Service sweet and attentive. Food bland and forgetful. Clam chowder tasteless and missing any meaningful bits of clams-- it should have been renamed Potato soup. The lobster tacos were equally disappointing: the bare minimum tiny little cubes of lobster. Perhaps it was because we visited on the weekend just before the restaurant's closed for vacation but the owners need to step up their game. This could be a favorite local hideaway spot but currently offers little reason for anyone to return a 2d time if ever again. read more

We chose to eat in the patio area. I ordered a cup of the Clam Chowda & The Seafood Stew. My wife had the Atlantic Cod Fish & Chips. Everything was super fresh delicious delicate & top notch. The stew was the best I've ever had-Super hot fresh abundant with mussels cod fish & shrimp with small pieces of sausage. It was very satisfying and hearty I would totally expect for you to give this deliciousness a try! It was a special for a Friday, Thumbs up to the chef. The service was attentive and they treated us well. Stop in to this business establishment -you will not be disappointed. read more

Cape Cod Fish - Seafood Stew - Seafood Near Me - Fort Myers, Florida

I appreciate you reaching out thru your yelp comment to "try and make it right". There is no making it right, it is what it is. My food was very fishy and I feel it was overpriced. 3 star to 1 star is bc of you as an owner and your attitude which by the way is a quality that obviously is a part of your restaurant. Telling me that my review lost its credibility bc I didn't come back to your restaurant is ridiculous. Your passive aggression again justifies the 1 star. Face it man your food is mediocre and overpriced. Accept the constructive criticism and do better. read more

Cape Cod Fish - Menu - Seafood Near Me - Fort Myers, Florida

See all

Great customer service! Was in the mood for seafood so decided to try this restaurant after seeing the reviews. Ordered the baked stuffed shrimp & Lobster n sweet corn Chowder was which were both very flavorful! Talk avoid a burst of flavor as soon as they hit my taste buds! Highly recommend both! Also ordered a fried shrimp and scallop basket & that was ok. My fav part of the basket was the Cole slaw. read more

Cape Cod Fish - Baked Stuffed Shrimp - Seafood Near Me - Fort Myers, Florida

See all

Amazing fresh seafood! Don't hesitate to eat the fresh fish! Delish! Local, friendly and clean.... read more

Cape Cod Fish - Whole belly clams! - Seafood Near Me - Fort Myers, Florida

We were excited to come here after seeing the high ratings and reviews, but the experience left us disappointed. We called ahead for a party of 10 for a Sunday evening. They said it would be no problem and were quite nice on the phone to my wife, who called. When we arrived, the table was set up for us. All good. They were nice to let us sit even when our party wasn't all there, which was kind compared to the current trends at restaurants. As we waited, we ordered an appetizer for the table. The calamari was quite good, though I didn't try it. When ordering, my brother-in-law and I tried to order the 16oz soups, but in 8oz cups so we could each try what the other got. They would not let us order and split bowls, we had to order the cups at a higher charge. Fine, I get it, it's a 1$ dishwasher charge. The NE clam chowder was very good, the Lobster and Corn chowder was flavorless, and mildly warm, opposite of the NE clam chowder...and we soon figured out why. My wife tried to order a bowl of the Lobster and Corn chowder as her meal, only to be told they were now out of it. I'm certain ours was "extended" with some cream or stock to stretch it to the two cups we ordered, but what they added to it wasn't hot and was unseasoned. We then ordered the "Fish and Chips" from their menu. The server asked what two sides we wanted with our "Fish and Chips". We ordered two side salads - both an up charge. We got our salads first. When the main dish came out, it was a basket with three pieces of fish with no chips. When we inquired where the chips were, the server told us we got two sides, and we ordered salads. So, we quickly found out that "Fish and Chips" is "Fish with two sides", despite the menu name. We ordered a side of fries to share. The fish was flavorless, the cocktail sauce was without horseradish and tasted of a heavy ketchup base, and the fries came out unseasoned. We just laughed as to how poorly this meal went for the two of us. I really wanted to give two stars, but since the other 8 people had a good enough time, I'm giving it three stars. My brother-in-law split the bill and left. I'll never come back as they're either clueless or they like to nickel and dime you for every little request. read more

I was here for their famous lobster roll. This restaurant has good deal during the lunch time. Their lunch meal combo definitely is a good time to try. I got the lunch Lobstah Lobstah. This is combo meal with a classic lobster roll and a cup of lobster chowder. The lobster roll is a 4 ounce lobster roll with New England classic roll. The lobster meat is big enough. I like the chowder better because of taste and chunk lobster meat in the soup. Overall is a good experience. Service is attentive. Many come to enjoy their lunch specials. read more

See all

Everything went well. My best friend and I ate here before we were headed to our concert. We were greeted warmly as soon as we stepped foot on their outdoor patio. We were asked if we wanted to sit inside or outside,it was a wonderful day out so we decided to sit outside. We were served right away. I ordered the fried shrimp basket and my best friend ordered the fish and chip basket. Our orders were hot and fresh. I loved the ambiance as well with all the nautical decor. Would definitely recommend and hope to go back to eat there again in the future. read more

See all

Authentic New England Seafood--Right in Fort Myers! Cape Cod Fish Co is a total gem. My father-in-law, a Massachusetts native and lifelong New England seafood connoisseur, has been on a mission to find whole belly clams that rival his all-time favorite--Bob's Clam Hut in Kittery, Maine. Well, he found them. He declared Cape Cod Fish Co's clams the second best in the country--and if you know him, that's no small compliment. The clams were briny, perfectly crisp, and absolutely legit. As for the rest of the meal? I had the fried cod and jumbo shrimp--both cooked to perfection. The fries were golden and the coleslaw was refreshingly tangy, a perfect balance to the seafood. Even the service stood out--friendly, quick, and welcoming. We're already planning our return trip. If you crave real-deal New England seafood and don't want to book a flight north--this spot nails it. Just go. read more

Cape Cod Fish - Cod & jumbo shrimp - Seafood Near Me - Fort Myers, Florida

See all

Great lunch time spot if you work close to HealthPark and are craving excellent clam chowder and fish tacos. Our server was very kind, attentive, and food came out hot and fast. It's a nice place to sit outside on your work break enjoying some fresh seafood. read more

Cape Cod Fish - New England Clam Chowder Bowl - Seafood Near Me - Fort Myers, Florida

Best authentic New England food in town. The fry job on the fish and chips (and everything!) is perfect every time! We are regulars and come often and always leave happy. Highly recommend! read more

The food is fresh and very tasty. The servers also know what they are doing. Worth going to.

Lobstah pie is delicious, buttery, almost sweet lobster chunks, great textures all around. Fries are alright, I love the beans though, and the clam chowder was silky. read more

See all

Waitress as very sweet and attentive. We sat outside in the covered area and it was nice. We ordered Ipswich steamers (which were very fresh and delicious!), a bowl of NE clam chowder and a combo platter with cod, shrimp, scallops, French fries and coleslaw. Everything was amazing. The chowder was very good, cod was fresh, shrimp were a great size and so were the scallops. Nice crispy batter and not greasy! Fries and coleslaw were also above par. We are from the Cape Cod area and it was such a taste of home! We would happily return! Of note, the restaurant is very clean and so were the rest rooms! read more

This restaurant has been under new owner and management for almost a year. Yes they have cleaned it up, organized it, probably raised the prices when some of the food has not changed. However, I have to report they have messed around with the baked bean recipe and it is now too hot/spicy for a seniors' palate. The lobster pie is poorly prepared. It's either been undercooked on purpose, or sitting around until someone orders it. In any event, the lobster meat was tough, tasted like it was prepared from fake butter, and no herbs spices, other than cracker meal. I would go elsewhere for lobster unless roll is all you want, because all it really has is mayonnaise. Also, I would suggest staying away during the season. It's just too crowded. I'm sorry to write this, but at least it's one man's opinion. read more

Cape Cod Fish - Seafood Near Me - Fort Myers, Florida

First time here, nice little place has plenty of tables inside & also outside nice seating area with umbrellas. We had the seafood casserole & fish & chips, we both had baked beans. Both entrees were good, server was great. Not sure we'd come back as the food wasn't something to lure us back but seems like they do a great business. They do have Coke products which is important to my hub. read more

Cape Cod Fish - Seafood Casserole - Seafood Near Me - Fort Myers, Florida

See all

The food and service is always great. I love there belly clams!! Very clean and the atmosphere is typical of a fish restaurant!

Very good, we have the Manhattan clam chowder , the fish and chips, the coleslaw was great too read more

Cape Cod Fish - Seafood Near Me - Fort Myers, Florida

Always a wonderful lunch. Today we were taken care of by the friendly and professional Kate P. Their lobster corn chowder is the best!!! read more

Cape Cod Fish - Lobster corn chowder - Seafood Near Me - Fort Myers, Florida

See all

Excellent fresh ingredients, tasty and great service ! This place is amazing I got the seafood casserole. So delicious and not overcooked . Sides are fresh veggies ! Awesome waitress Kate ! read more

Cape Cod Fish - I got the Cod and clams so good and the coleslaw was so good and the sauces . - Seafood Near Me - Fort Myers, Florida

Service was awesome, simple items done extremely well. Try the Cruben and baked beans.

Fun ambiance. Seating inside and outside. Friendly and attentive service. We had everything we needed, but server still came by several times. Food hit the spot for sure. My husband and I both enjoyed our meals. Avocados are my fave, and I gravitate toward options that have avocados. One star off because avocado was cold and slightly oxidized... so, not cut to order. Would return. read more

Stopped here for Sunday lunch Good choice. Wasn't crowded as in previous attempts. Food was excellent. Old fashioned decor with 9 tables inside & 6 or so out. At 94 degrees we opted for IN. Will come again. Stephanie was our helpful server. No waits. Judy enjoyed ours & hers. read more

See all

We spent a couple of hours on Sanibel today and happened upon Cape Cod Fish Co on our way back to Fort Myers. Coming from New England, we love our fish and chips. The chowdah was the best we've ever had & thats saying ALOT! Chef Nate from New Bedford absolutely crushed it!! thank you Kate for great service - we'll definitely be back to try more menu options!! read more

We were just popping in for a quick snack and weee pleasantly surprised! The service was quick and the food was amazing. I can see why the ratings are so high. It was 93 degrees outside and the ceiling fans kept things cool. I want planning on doing a review so no food pics but we had lunch fish and shrimp with fries for 1 lunch meal and Cole slaw for the other. Order both! Draft beers were 5.5-7 and canned beer was 5.50. read more

Cape Cod Fish - Patio small section of it - Seafood Near Me - Fort Myers, Florida

See all

We were visiting fort meyers for two weeks. Discovered this wonderful seafood restaurant. We ate there three times it was that good. The food was fresh and perfectly prepared. Go you want be disappointed read more

Food was plentiful and services was helpful order to go! Would recommend any seafood meals!

Delicious! We are first timers and brought my mom here for a belated Mother's Day Dinner. Yum! read more

See all

This is a great place to stop after spending time on Sanibel Island and heading back to Fort Myers (or wherever!). It was a bit after 3:00 and we were seated (outside) immediately. Our server was there pronto to take and deliver our drink order. She was very friendly and efficient. The outside has a real island feel, laid back and casual. We didn't go inside, but I am sure it's similar. We both ordered the cod fish and chips/jumbo shrimp combo basket. The fish and shrimp tasted fresh and the batter was well seasoned. The fries were good, skin on, which we like. The coleslaw was light, a little tart and refreshing. Speaking of refreshing, try the limoncello sangria, very good! We will be back! read more

See all

We were thirsting in Fort Myers and we decided to stop for lunch. Food was excellent, service was great . Ambiance is quaint, great little restaurant. I wish we lived closer so could come again! read more