I would have given a 4 but a 5 was due to great customer service and quickly returned emails with a shipping issue. I have been buying Rum Cakes off and on for several years and they are always very tasty. I can buy them locally at a shop in MB but I do use their shipping to send cakes to MI and OH. read more

We were visiting from Wisconsin and stopped to buy cakes from the bakery in Wilmington then on Saturday visited a craft fair and they were there selling the rum cakes so we had to buy more because they were so delicious! What a wonderful treat! read more

These rum cakes are amazing! I'm not even a person who likes things like this, but it was sure good. We got the red velvet one and everyone loves it! read more

Cape Fear Rum Cake - Bakeries Near Me - Wilmington, North Carolina

The rum cakes are delicious, even the gluten free ones. We gave them as hostess grifts and they were very well received. We ordered seven medium cakes and one small one. I wouldn't order the small again - it's about the size of a donut, tasty but little. read more

Excellent little hole in the wall bakery downtown. So good I order by mail. Priced good for the quality you get with many options on sizes and flavors. The coconut is my favorite. They offer seasonal options throughout the year too. TRY IT! read more

I was a little skeptical about how good these rum cakes are. Well, I was wrong. These rum cakes are damn good. Several flavors to select from. I would highly recommend if you are a rum cake person. Now all that said, just be warned, the prices are high for a cake. That said, you can taste the quality. read more

I so much love this place! I actually first found them at a giant Christmas show in Cincinnati. I had heard of CFRC on a visit to Carolina Beach one summer. So I decided to stop by, buy one or so (after sampling them), and make some conversation with the owners. I found out their connection to Cincinnati/Northern Kentucky. Their cakes are so amazing! It's just $7 for the 5 oz rum cakes ($9 for gluten free). They're affordable and delicious. The service from Cape Fear Rum Cake is always amazing. It's become one of my "have to" stops whenever we head to Carolina Beach. They do have a tent at the Carolina Beach Market on Saturdays. There are 3 sizes available - 5 oz (1-2 people), 16 oz (6-8 people), and 32 oz (10-12 people). There's a variety of flavors and usually a seasonal flavor (Key Lime for July). There are also several Gluten Free options. These cakes are nice and moist with a lot of flavor. The rum isn't overpowering either. I love supporting small businesses like this! I look forward to more rum cake in future visits. I also love that I can order online, which I will likely be doing! read more

Cape Fear Rum Cake - 5 oz rum cakes! - Bakeries Near Me - Wilmington, North Carolina

Rum + cake = yum! It's a cute specialty shop with lots of tasty rum cakes! I've ordered sampler packs for family in Wisconsin since these are made locally. It was super easy to order online and made for a fun and delicious gift with nice themed packaging! During Covid-19, the store is just a walk up counter. Good display of sizes and flavors! Every flavor sounds delish and we decided on their Mystery winner-S'mores which was my favorite. Also got the Painkiller which was my husband's favorite. And then a pistachio for our 3rd one in the sampler pack. They were all really moist and had just the right amount of rum taste. These make for a perfect dessert for 2 to share! read more

See all

My husband stopped in to grab a few rum cakes while in Wilmington to bring home. You can choose a 5oz, 16oz or 32oz cake. We tried a 5oz golden vanilla, pistachio, dark chocolate and lemon. The rum cakes were good but not the best that we have had. Our favorite was the lemon. If you want to give them a try and are not close to the area, place your order online and they will ship it to you. read more

See all

Small little shop downtown but cakes are nice and moist and flavorful. Flavor options change throughout the year and have seasonal flavors and some that are year round. Only struggle is usually limited help in shop and if around holidays then order ahead to ensure you get in time. Great product reasonably priced. read more

See all

I'm not even a big fan of rum cake, but even I know we should've gotten way more of this than we did. Gotta read the Yelp reviews, my friend. Gotta read, or you'll get home, eat all the cake, and find yourself wanting way more. read more

These were perfect! They had wonderful flavor and were super moist. Ready for more!!! read more

Cape Fear Rum Cake - Bakeries Near Me - Wilmington, North Carolina

I am always beyond pleased with the rum cakes from CFRC. This most recent experience was the one that led me to finally write great review. It started back in 2017 when I didn't have quite enough wedding cake for the guests coming to our wedding. I ordered rum cakes in a frenzy and the order was filled and the guests LOVED them. Every year since, I've made sure to pass a few cakes off to friends and family for the holidays. This particular year, I ordered a huge batch of cakes to deliver to my real estate and photography clients, and the assistance from Angela and the team was incredible. I emailed her my mailing list and she communicated so efficiently with me any questions she had about my needs. The entire experience couldn't have been any easier, and I'm again THRILLED with the cakes and the service here. Support small & local biz because they are 100% invested in the consumer. read more

Not too sure about the other review, but our experience was awesome. We were visiting the Riverwalk and just happened to notice this great little bakery. As we entered this quaint establishment we were greeted with mouthwatering sensory overload. There were some fresh Rum Cakes on the rack and every flavor boxed up and ready to go. The gentleman working was apparently one of the owners and was very nice to talk with and offered to answer any questions we may have. After looking at the options of flavors to choose from, we decided on Rum Velvet. The other choices are Golden Vanilla, Dark Chocolate, Coconut, Pineapple, and Cherry Chocolate. After tasting the awesomeness of Rum Velvet, we will definitely try the others eventually! Highly recommend you give this a try. The location is great and they do ship! read more

Cape Fear Rum Cake - The box with a Rum Velvet flavor explosion inside! - Bakeries Near Me - Wilmington, North Carolina

See all

Thank you for helping us gift your cakes to our vendors and friends. 20 cakes went really quick and next year we might just double up! We loved giving these out the responses we got back were fabulous. Have great holiday season guys. read more

The most delicious, moist, flavorful cakes you can buy! We buy them for our family members' birthdays and special occasions throughout the year. We just ate the dark chocolate one for my husband's birthday. We ate every bite and we are not sweet eaters. read more

They use artificial ingredients. When you walk in it smells great, but when you read the ingredients.. No thank you. Best to make these cakes at home. read more

Brought back rum cake from visiting NC and now we bought allllll the cakes. Super most and last a long time. Shipping was delivered even faster than expected. Highly recommend! read more

The cakes are delicious. Service was good. Have a good variety of cakes. The red velvet and birthday cakes taste the best.

I had a good experience here. Great customer service and freshly made cakes! It's kimd of tucked away, but still on the riverfront. I recommend read more

See all

While staying nearby at a rental location within walking distance to Cape Fear Rum Cake their hours are posted as "Winter hours 11-5". Gosh, it is spring almost summer. Stopped by the shops in this location and Cape Fear Rum Cake no one is inside as if the place is now closed! I agree with another reviewer, they are extremely disappointing and lack basic customer service skills. Worth a walking trip in the downtown to Pink Baking and skip this hassle! 1 star but rating would not post. Let us see was happens with 2 stars! read more

This place has amazing rum cakes! I have had the Golden Vanilla and Coconut one. I can't wait to try the other flavors! I gave some to a friend and she said that it was really moist. I agree! read more

Visited last Saturday when they opened on Front St. The Golden Vanilla rum cake was SO GOOD! The owners were so friendly and accommodating for our request to eat our rum cake as we walked around Wilmington. Can't wait to stop in next time we're in Wilmington! read more

Staff was not friendly whatsoever. My family and I were interested in trying their desserts, however we were completely ignored.

The concept is super cool and the location is awesome. Very disappointed in my experience however. The cakes are wayyyy overpriced and samples are not offered. They also lack any kind of customer service skills (you fell like a burden to the owners/workers when you walk in the door) I like supporting local businesses but will not be back. read more

These cakes are AMAZING. We ordered them for wedding favors and they were a huge hit. People were trying to take multiple cakes home because these are addictive!! The owners were great to work with for our special occasion! read more

I normally dont even like rum cake but this place is fantastic!! I found this location by accident. My husband and I were taking a walk nearby when we both stopped and said "What is that, we need to find out where that crazy good smell is coming from!" We got to talking to the owners who are the sweetest of people. We dont live nearby but we vacation in Wilmington a couple times a year and can't wait to go back. We already ordered more online because we just couldn't wait till we went again and ordered extra for gifts. Love this place!! read more

Stopped in this past Sunday, awesome shop! I bought the Coconut Rum Cake and its wonderful!

Warning: Don't order if it's for a special occasion. Extremely disappointed in their customer service. Ordered 12 days before I needed them and still don't have them 18 days later. And when we inquired 10 days ago, they said they were swamped with holiday orders, so they were behind. And they weren't expecting this? (Not like we waited till the last minute. Ordered on Dec 3rd.) Then after waiting 18 days, sent another email, and they informed us that they were sending a refund as we were being jerks. And they still hadn't shipped them! Which means we wouldn't have even had them for Christmas. I'm sorry, who's the jerk here! read more

My Christmas present, original rum cake, was so moist and flavorful! Delicious! This will be the first of many!

These cakes are delicious! Cannot say enough about the quality and the taste. Great people to work with as well.