Nearly nondescript place side of road in a small strip mall. Quiet, a/c and clean. Traveneir sandwich, blackened frilled was very good. The tacos, same way also delicious . Blackend green beans and tasty coleslaw rounded it off. Ice tea hot the spot. The blackened here is tasty and not overtly powerful read more

Believe all the amazing reviews! This place has great food!! It doesn't look like much from the exterior but don't let that fool you!

The dive shop that we went lobster hunting with recommended that we take our lobsters here to have them cook them. Wow, so glad we listened. it was great. We had them cook 4 tails for us. 2 broiled, 1 blackened and 1 jalapeño Parmesan crusted. OMG... the jalapeño was the best lobster I've ever eaten. read more

This was an awesome place to have lunch. We had a shrimp appetizer. Excellent. I had a shrimp po boy. I could not believe the size of the shrimp. 4 gigantic shrimp filled the sandwich. Outstanding flavor. Kaboom Sauce was perfect. Not overly spicy, just great flavor. Coleslaw was perfect too. Great service. Thank You. read more

We stopped here on a whim and were so grateful. The service was personal and excellent. Nice, relaxed beach like atmosphere. The food was great for everyone. The coconut shrimp, dragon green beans. Shrimp po'boy, grilled shrimp, pasta and key lime pie. Pie was delicious but I'm not sure why the squirt extra lime juice before serving. read more

See all

We to the restaurant for a late lunch. It was fairly empty and we were immediately seated. Everyone in our group ordered something different and everyone loved their food. The fish tacos, the shrimp Poboy, and the fish sandwich were all delicious. The table next to us ordered the seafood pasta, and ended up ordering it a second time to share. It was loaded with shrimp, crab, and fish. I would definitely get that the next time I go. Highly recommend! read more

We found this place based on others review. Here's our honest review.. Amazing food and service literally everything we tried was great. 1000% totally recommend. read more

Amazing flavors, creative combinations and fresh seafood. The pasta dish had generous amounts of seafood plus delicious sauce with details like capers. I appreciated the depth of flavors and well-thought out ingredients. Nothing rushed or thrown together. Super friendly staff attentive to detail which i appreciate. True hospitality. A real stand out in the many restaurants I've sampled this vacation. read more

Captain Craig's Restaurant - Key lime pie - Seafood Near Me - Tavernier, Florida

See all

Service was fine but the food was just so-so. Just the normal fried fish and French fries. The shrimp and mahi was so over seasoned that we could not eat it all. Would not go again. read more

Very good food enjoyed that the service and the food will definitely come back recommended highly

We enjoyed our meals and service so much so that we went back the same week. The tuna sashimi was delicious, and the mahi was mouthwatering, in both the blackened and key lime/parmesan crusted preparations. Our kids were even treated well and enjoyed their meals which we appreciated. Def recommend! read more

Great little spot in Tavernier, food was excellent. Rather small so go early. Service was great as well. Definitely would go back!

My husband and I went for dinner and loved it everything was delicious and fresh. We start with the stone crab chowder and the kaboom shrimp just perfect. The fried snapper feels like they just caught and cooked it, so good. Green beans and mashed potatoes were our favorite side dishes. Service was amazing and the place is small but gets busy quickly. read more

Captain Craig's Restaurant - Seafood Near Me - Tavernier, Florida

See all

We had the beef n reef w/ chimichurri to start and boy did that not disappoint. Then went crazy over the Key Lime pie and I'm pretty sure I'll never have one as amazing as this. Holy Man! Wow! Everyone was so kind, service sincere, and we will be back! read more

Captain Craig's Restaurant - The coconut key lime martini & key lime pie. - Seafood Near Me - Tavernier, Florida

We just finished eating here. We had a wedge salad a French dip sandwich and coconut shrimp. It was all very good! The staff was very friendly, attentive, and above par! We would come back here and we recommend it! read more

A must stop place when visiting Islamarda. Food was incredible! The service was great. They were very attentive and informative to all our wants and needs. Very nice ambiance on the inside with lots of large screens for whatever you're looking for. read more

Really great fresh fish, the best key lime pie (generous portion), and service thats attentive without being overbearing. Blackened mahi was my favorite, my wife loved the grilled yellowtail. Will definitely come back. read more

Luz was an absolutely amazing server! She recommended the shrimp mushroom topped yellowtail in a garlic butter sauce but we switched it to mahi mahi and absolutely delicious. The stone crab chowder was DELICIOUS. Luz went above and beyond to be spot on. We will definitely be back! read more

Captain Craig's Restaurant - Shrimp mushroom topped mahi mahi - Seafood Near Me - Tavernier, Florida

See all

My salad was very bland. I think I just ordered the wrong thing though because other patrons seemed happy with their meals.

If you are looking for some delicious food around the keys, give Captain Craig's a go. We got the wedge salad and french dip which was amazing. I have also got the beef n reef and that was just as good if not better than anything else I've ordered. read more

The service was friendly and efficient, although we were the only customers at 11:30 a.m. we ordered crab bisque which was tasty. The fish tacos were good but not great. My husband ordered the "world famous fish sandwich " and it was not flavorful and the bread was plain toasted wheat bread. read more

Cute atmosphere and local's restaurant vibe, with fresh ingredients and seafood. The Stone Crab Chowder was tasty and filling, at a good price. Not one to order a fish sandwich, but had to try out the famous Craig's fish sandwich - and was pleasantly surprised and appreciated the good portioned, flaky Mahi and a tasty home made tartar sauce. Only knock is the $17 price tag, but everything seafood is pricey in the Keys. read more

See all

Service 5 Food quality and cook 5 Food taste 3 Unfortunately, all I care about is flavor. The food has to be delicious and this place just missed the mark. Our server (Josh?) was attentive and friendly. The restaurant was clean and nicely decorated. The quality of the food was excellent and the technical cooking of the fish was dead on. And the appetizers were fairly delicious. We had the fritters, which were among the best we had in the keys. My daughter also wanted to try both soups. Lobster bisque was OK but the stone crab chowder was a delight. Definite must. But the entrees were a relative bust. Two of us tried the famous fish sandwich, which isn't much to look at (see photos from others). The cook on the fish was technically perfect but the food was all pretty bland. Reminded me of a tuna melt. My son tried the jalapeño encrusted grouper. Yes it had jalapenos on it (see pic) but even those were bland. No spice. No strong flavors, although technically well cooked. If I didn't have taste buds, I'd give it 5 stars. Alas, I do, and can't honestly recommend this place despite how much I liked everything else about this place. Sorry Captain, but you might benefit from a sail to the spice islands. read more

Captain Craig's Restaurant - Jalapeño encrusted grouper. Looks delicious. Tastes bland. - Seafood Near Me - Tavernier, Florida

See all

Come here and get the fish sandwich !!! Upgrade it to yellowtail or triple yellowtail. It will not disappoint. Best key lime pie in the keys. I thought the hostess was lying but this is the truth folks. Best key lime pie and fish sandwich. Only disappointment is not having enough time to try this place again before we left. read more

This restaurant was soooo good!!! I loved every part of it. My boyfriend and I randomly chose this restaurant because it was near our Airbnb and it WAS AMAZING!! The tuna sashimi and shrimp kaboom appetizers were fresh and delicioussss. Not to mention, I was craving a fried snapper and they exceeded my expectations with the freshness and flavor of the fish. The key lime pie was the BEST I have ever had. It was so creamy and rich. The service was awesome and everyone was so sweet. The restaurant itself was clean, calm, and relaxing coming from a couple of ER nurses. 10/10 recommend. read more

See all

Good flavor for a basic fried fish sandwich. I didn't get what I ordered however and the server was MIA, so I ate what I was given. Took a while to refill my water.... Inside is typical keys-nothing fancy but clean read more

Delicious food and great service. We had the mahi mahi sandwich which was also delicious read more

Captain Craig's Restaurant - Fried calamari - Seafood Near Me - Tavernier, Florida

See all

This place is awesome. We stopped in on our way out of the keys because it's featured as the best fish sandwich in the keys. We have stope several times over the years and I agree, it probably one of the best fish sandwiches I have ever had. It comes with mahi-mahi but we upgraded to yellowtail snapper. We also ordered French fries WELL DONE and Believe it or not they always make them perfect. A perfect place to find in the Keys. read more

Captain Craig's Restaurant - Fish sandwich - Seafood Near Me - Tavernier, Florida

Good was really good. Service was excellent! Friendliness and excitement about the menu items was top notch. Tables and bar/counter seating available. We had Stone Crab Chowder, jalapeño encrusted Hogfish, filet with house-made peppercorn sauce and rice. Delicious unsweet tea (important to tea drinkers!), house-made key lime pie with meringue also made in house. Great experience. Found by searching for local places with the highest reviews. Glad we came here! Thank you Nataly & Blanca for a wonderful experience! read more

Loved this place and came back again for lunch. Ordered the blackened Hogfish platter - amazing! Green beans were also not my favorite veggie but these were amazing. The food was so good we asked to speak to the chef. Sure enough the owner came out and was cooking. He gave us the history of Craig's and a local fish lesson. We came back the ne t day to try the famous fish sandwich and it was also amazing. Super recommended and a rare 5 star review!! read more

Captain Craig's Restaurant - Seafood Near Me - Tavernier, Florida

See all

Great, very fresh and creative seafood dishes. Really Friendly service. Local's ambiance.

Since the new owners Craig's has improved dramatically . The ambience is friendly and very clean. The service provided both at the bar and at the tables is excellent. I usually eat the Excellent Captains chicken but last night our family of 11 went to dine. I went fishing that morning and caught many mackerel. We had them prepare the fish fried, blackened, and jalapeño encrusted. Every preparation was fabulous as were the salad and green bean accompaniments. Everything was devoured and a satisfied meal was had by all. read more

This place is very laid back and great vibe. Stopped in for dinner the other night and was pleasantly surprised how good the food and service was. I recommend the chef's prep of Snapper. They have a nice wine selection too. Tasted like everything made in-house. Don't miss the pie. read more

Really wanted to try this restaurant as we were heading back from the keys. Unfortunately the doors had pieces of paper taped to them that the business was closed from 12pm-1pm due to a meeting, but we could seat ourselves at the outdoor seating. One of the issues is that we showed up at 1:15pm and the meeting was still going on. The other issue is there was nothing telling me where the outdoor seating was - not that I would use it since it was pretty warm. Guess they didn't want the business. I would think that lunchtime may not be the best time to be closed for a meeting. Can't comment on the food, seeing as we left to find someplace else. read more

After a good part of the day spent at the John Pennekamp Coral Reef State Park, my wife and I were looking for a good lunch place for a late lunch. We focused our search in Tavernier and Islamorada since we planned on heading out to Robbie's afterwards to feed the pelicans...I mean the tarpons. Yelp highly recommended Captain Craig's so we tried it. The place befits a "hole in the wall" description with its nondescript exterior. Inside was actually quite spacious and sparsely decorated with nautical kitsch. Upon entering, we were greeted and told to find a table we wanted. We were presented the menu and the server informed us of the day's fresh catch, mahi mahi, grouper and some other fish I can't remember. I ordered the catch of the day (mahi) prepared blackened which came with one side, mashed potatoes. My wife ordered a cup of their stone crab chowder ($5) and shrimp po' boy ($14). The chowder was really good! My wife liked the huge shrimp on her po' boy, well prepared and not rubbery. She loved the kaboom sauce drizzled over the shrimp and said the bread seemed fresh. My dish was OK...thought the fish was fresh and well prepared (not overly generous portions) but the lone side of OK mashed potatoes (not garlic mashed) didn't have quite the value for $24. I thought the dish could've been much better if it came with grilled mixed vegetables and a choice of seasoned rice or garlic mashed potatoes. All in all, not a bad experience but thought the value (at least for the catch of the day) was lacking. Lunch for 2 with tip came out to just over $54. read more

See all

Highly recommend! Crab Chowder, Captain's Sandwich. Service top notch. Cool restaurant decorating. Ate twice on our 2 day trip.

Restaurant very nice with really good food. Waiter started out attentive but as it got busier, he was less interested in attended our table. All the food was hot and amazing. Remaining wait staff was on point! Happy to see restaurant had constant families entering to enjoy the food too. read more

See all

Captain Craig's doesn't look like much from the outside, but the food is worth the stop. We ordered the key lime pasta and the fried shrimp. The pasta was loaded with seafood and all was well cooked (scallops, fish, shrimp and calamari). The sauce was bright with fresh lime, and thick without being heavy. The fried shrimp were tender, plump and perfectly crispy. I would def go back. read more

Food is delicious!!! Worth it to leave your resort and check it out. We will definitely be back!

unassuming place from outside. Nice decor inside and great food. I had the shrimp and they were big and delicious. I'd recommend stopping and give them a try read more

See all