Stopped by here while traveling through - what a great find. Started with chicken wings - perfectly done. Generously sized pizza slices: chicken with bacon, veggie and meat lovers rounded out a great casual meal. Table service was on point as well. Dining room was clean and cozy. Wish this place was close to home. read more

Great food and service. I would recommend Cascarino's wholeheartedly! The pizza is outstanding.

Just tried this place. Everyone is super friendly and it seems like a well- oiled machine. The place seems really clean and perfect for a quick meal. There are a nice array of pizza options . I've been on a hunt to find a good quality slice of pizza ( I start by judging a basic plain slice). The plain was decent but not quite a stand-out. The sauce is a little too sweet and lacking a quality flavor. The crust is perfectly thin enough but flops a little too easily. It's also lacking a rustic taste. I also tried the grandma slice which was just ok. It needed more fresh basil and again the sauce was lacking. Maybe other items are better here. I'm willing to try. I'm just really particular about my pizza and have been spoiled with pizza from Westchester, Bronx, NYC area. I'm still on my hunt but this is just ok enough place to get your pizza. read more

I have been a loyal customer for years now but last nite will be my last. The last few times was bad but I gave them another shot last nite. Everything I ordered was absolutely disgusting. It's a shame that nobody cares on once the farther stopped running it. read more

Excellent menu, fresh ingredients dining in or delivery. Not only is the food superb but the staff as well. The ONLY pizza restaurant that serves pizza just like I remember when I grew up in the Bronx. You won't be disappointed! read more

If I could give zero stars I would! if you like a side of biotch with your pizza sprinkled with major attitude and a huge lack of customer service then youll love it there! what a joke ! we got the complete opposite of what we ordered then got an attitude when we called them out on it....customer is never right there! this place is ran by bunch of kids and the only adult there is very inexperienced in how to not only take orders but to treat customers with value . read more

AMAZING! I was NOT at all dissatisfied I never eat the crust and I ate the crust! I didn't know if I would like this place considering all the "good" pizza places around, even those rarer high, but I'm telling you the pizza was baked perfectly with a lot of everything and the bbq chicken and wings was a big portion and so good and had sauce for days unlike others you have to order extra sauce. The cheese cake was to die for and the way they packed it up was impressive as well !! They gave us silverware that actually doesn't break when you try to use it and enough for more than just two people, napkins as well ! I highly recommend this place to anyone who lives in town or coming from out of town! read more

Based solely on a few visits (eatin and take out) consisting of pizza and heroes (the edible kind not the Patriots)....this joint is decent.

Absolute best pizza hands down. They have won a number of awards for best pizza in the Hudson Valley for good reason! Once you try theirs, you can't go back to mediocre pizza. the environment is friendly and service is quick. I'm also a huge fan of their penne vodka and chicken parm! read more

Are you traveling and looking for lunch? Pass McDonald's and Burger King and grab a bite here. They have everything from salads to a full meal. Large portions! read more

I paid $20 for a large cheese pizza that I picked up from Cascarino's in Montgomery, NY. The average I've paid for a cheese pizza in Orange County are between $14-15. It was good but not any better than some others and definitely not worth $6 more. Unfortunately it's the last pizza there for me. Maybe others only care about the taste but value still matters to me. read more

The worst! first time and last time, Ordered Mozzarella Con Pomodoro, it consisted of about 10 WHOLE cherry tomatoes, 10 mozzarella balls, and about 5 slivers of red pepper Then Bruschetta, cut in half large cherry tomatoes, oil , vin and some cut up basil, about 8 pieces of itaian bread sprinkled with olive oil, NEVER AGAIN, what a waste of money read more

I tried Cascarino's for the first time tonight. Someone I know who lives in the area told me it was their "spot" to go. I was even more convinced when I heard they were voted "best pizza" in the hudson valley on a local radio station. Upon entrance I see the huge plastic sign stating that exactly. Going by that advice, I figured this will be great. Boy was I wrong...first off it is tiny! I mean teeny, tiny! I really planned to dine in, but when I saw the tables I believe there were 5 -6 were all in use. There was also a long line with not so friendly customers. Everyone seemed to have a resting bi+ch face. I waited patiently and ordered a regular pie, I figured if it got best pizza go with a plain and judge it by that. The pizza was going to take 35-40 minutes the girl on register stated (it took 52 min) I didn't get a warm feeling from any of the staff. Two guys slinging the pies seemed overwhelmed. The two girls handling customers seemed rushed and flustered. There were only two gentleman eating at a table everyone else was waiting for take out orders. That's a long cook time, any other pizzeria I know takes about 20... again still in hopes it would be memorable. Honestly, the only thing memorable was the taste I can't get off my tongue from the bug/insect flavoring I got from the bottom of the crust on the first bite. It was awful. The sauce was hot, the cheese was congealed and the cornmeal on the crust tasted toxic, just not pleasant. I would not go back again. I don't know if it was something on the counter/box/pan or a workers hands. It just was inedible and a waste of time/money and taste buds. read more

Just the best, try it! Everything I have ever tried there has been delicious, reasonably priced and even delivered to the town of Newburgh at no extra charge! read more

Good pizza for the area of Orange County. Many items from which to choose from on the menu. Customer service is really good. read more

Cascarino's - Inside of entrance seating. - Pizza Near Me - Montgomery, New York

See all

Amazing white pizza and antipasto. I get the same thing every time! The cannolis are great. read more

Came to this place since it was the closest thing to our hotel and the reviews here on Yelp were good. The place gets the job done and the food was good! Local spot for people to either order take out or actually sit down to have dinner. When entering you will face the section where you can buy pizza by the slice as well as pick up take out. On the left side there are hams and other cold cuts you can get. To the right side of the entrance is a hallways that leads to the back dining room, you'll be greeted by the waitress and taken to your seat. Pizza was very good, nice thin ny style pizza. Different options on the menu to choose from also. Calzones, pizza, pasta, salada and dessert. Definitely a nice local place to grab a bite. The staff was extremely friendly which always makes the experience better read more

I know this place is known for its pizza and it's great but if you ever crave a sub, order it from Cascarino's. It's delish.

I am a Senior Citizen and went to Cascarino's yesterday, Monday, Aug. 2nd, 2022. Reached for a menu and ordered a Veal Cutlet Parmesian Hero, which was priced at $10.00 and handed the cashier my credit card to pay the bill. Happened to look on my bank statement and there was a charge from the restaurant for $15.75. This was a mistake and I called immediately and was informed that the menu went up!!!!!!!!! I was never informed before I paid the bill that the hero was now $15.75. This is FALSE ADVERTISING, and what a way to SCREW A SENIOR- who live on a Pension!!!!!!!!!! debra m. read more

This is my GO TO PIZZA restaurant, but they have a full menu of all your ITALIAN favorite's. Never a issue and they deliver while it's still piping hot. A must try. read more

Great place, great food. Family owned and operated. Everything made in house. Pizza, calzones, clams, mussels, sandwiches, you name it. I've never had a bad dish yet. Friends catered a party from them and everything was delicious. Go there, you won't be sorry. read more

the ceaser salad had to much water making the ceaser salad watery.The chicken paninini was tough and hard to chew. As far as the roasted red peppers, a few slices. Terrible read more

This place has some of the best Italian in the Hudson Valley. They have great specials and the owner, Anthony, is very kind. I was really impressed with how far they've come. It was always good but now it's great. Well worth the stop. And the owner is a valley central alumni!!! read more

One of my favorite pizzarias in the area! Their garlic crust on the pizza is fabulous! I have never had a problem with this establishment. One, singular time we had I missing (small) order, which they gave us for free as well as a gift card for being so patient. Enomorius hospitality! read more

A few months ago I wrote a negative review and I would like to retract it. About two weeks ago my wife and I ordered pizza and wings and the owner happened to answer the phone. My name popped up on his comuter and he mentioned about the review I wrote. He was very apologetic about the things that had happened and said that he is working to improve the delievery service. To my surprise he comped the entire order. This is what customer service is about. You dont find service like this too often. Most establishments would just brush it off and keep on doing what they have been doing. Guess what, tonight we had pizza from Cascarino's and it was awesome. read more

The MOST underwhelming pizza ive ever had. The pepperoni roll was stuffed and disgusting and greasy as all hell. The garlic knots were flavorless! I have tastebuds i swear! But hot damn this meal was a dumpster fire. read more

If you want anything Italian, Cascarino's is your place. From pizza, to full dinners, to cold sandwiches, whether it's catered, delivered, or enjoyed in their restaurant, Cascarino's delivers the best bang for your buck in all of those categories. It seems everything I order from Cascarino's is bigger and better than any surrounding restaurant. Ever since the inception of their Italian deli, I've been coming back more and more frequently. I recently had their Italian combo, and it was insane. Not only was it bigger than a small child, but all the meats were freshly sliced, and, more importantly, all the toppings were freshly made in house. I've never seen fresh mozzarella served on an Italian combo before and although that may not be the traditional way to do it, now I will always want a combo with it. The pizza. Cascarino's quite possibly has the best tasting crust I've ever had in my life. There's something about it that is unlike any I've had, even in NYC. They coat the crust in just the right amount of semolina, giving a nice crunch, while also imparting a sweet flavor. At least I think that's what happens. The point is, there are so many generic pizza joints around that it can often be confusing which to pick. Some have great pizza, some have great sandwiches, some have great dinners, but rarely will an establishment deliver on every category. Cascarino's is such a place. read more

See all

We frequent this pizzeria and have never been disappointed. The employees are super nice. The owners son always remembers our names, as well as his dad "The Big Cheese", Anthony. Their food is spectacular. One thing that struck me was the courtesy. I have learned in leadership classes of how vital it is to recognize patrons as promptly as possible once they enter the premises. I noticed tonight how quickly he greeted everyone as they came through the door. Also, how cordial and personable he was. There was a sense of respect as he spoke to you. A great combination of interaction as well as great tasting food. I bring my family there, so if it's good enough for the people I love the most then you can bet I have no reservations in recommending it to you! read more

The food was delicious We arrived after 2 big parties and we were still waited on promptly and checked on regularly. Highly recommend this little place. read more

Cascarino's - a plate of pastries and a bowl of sauce - Pizza Near Me - Montgomery, New York

We were tired and hungry. Owner moved our seats away from front door. Apologized that back room had party. Garlic knots and roasted broccoli rabe brought out quickly. Knots were full of garlic,* vegetables were tender and smoky. Pizza-yummy crust. *served with a large bowl of yummy Italian gravy. Waitress was helpful. GREAT place. read more

Not a very courteous group of men. Food is mediocre, wouldn't go back to save my life

The friendliest staff around and they make a mean eggplant parm to boot! Grabbing dinner from Cascarino's is always a good decision.

Came from out of state for a special event that was catered by Cascarino's. The rice balls were beyond amazing, the charcuterie board was divine and the spread was beautifully setup and displayed. I would have taken leftovers with me for sure if I wasn't leaving town the next day! Everything was fresh and obviously made with care and love. Would certainly recommend and make it a stop on my list next time I'm in the area! read more

Really wasn't impressed because what I got wasn't close to what I ordered. My guess is it's a training issue. The place has potential though, wonder if it's absentee owners. read more

I've been going here for a few years now.... The food is always fantastic..... last night I had an amazing young lady serving us.... Thank you for making our dinner so pleasant read more

Pure artistry at work here. Food is top-flight, owners treat you with respect and great interest. I'll be back!

The food is great! Ask for the house marinara. Veggies are fresh & the portions are perfect! Customer service is the best, we're always treated like favorite relatives! Our favorite place to eat for 17 years! If you go home hungry, it's your own fault! read more

We enjoyed our food so much! The pizza is amazing...even just visually when my husband and son saw the ricotta and spinach pie you could see it looked authentic and delicious- didn't disappoint. One tiny critique: as a vegan who got veggie pizza with no cheese, the crust got sopping wet. Maybe less spinach and a layer of olive oil to separate. I admit it's tricky to pull off! read more

Awesome Italian cuisine. The best pizza in my area. Super fast delivery service. Very professional delivery service. Highly recommended.

I like their food but too overpriced to keep as a weekly pizza stop. Service is very good. If they had more specials I'm sure I would go in a little more often. They are clean and have sanitizer available, good safety measures in place. read more