I would have given 1 star but the Mac and cheese, service and cornbread 5 stars, aI ordered Medium rare prime rib it was past well done. $58 and the same cut at Nightengale is $36 and 5 stars. Was hungry and ate it. If you need to serve barbecue sauce with your prime rib, don't serve prime rib. Au jus was overpowering, my guess to hide the lack of flavor of the prime rib. Love their barbecue! Don't do prime rib anymore. read more

Still coming for many years. Good BBQ, great views, and a fun bar. I got the Brisket Quesadilla and it was very good and my wife got the 1/2 chicken. She enjoyed it, and with 2 sides she had enough to bring some home for lunch. Reasonably priced food and drinks. Had one ok bartender working and one who engaged with everyone and was having fun. We'll keep coming back. read more

See all

I wanted to live this place. 2 locals recommended it. (1 other local didnt!) Service was slow. Brisket was okay. I had the Brisket quesidilla, which was very good! I also enjoyed their fried green beans ,but they may have been from a frozen bag, not fresh. The corn muffin lacked flavor, even with their special butter. Generous portions! Decent view. But if you want BBQ, go to Savor in Sister Bay. Excellent BBQ!!! About the same price. Much better ambiance. read more

Casey's BBQ & Smokehouse - Brisket quesidilla, fried green beans, cornbread, and brisket sandwich. - Barbeque Near Me - Egg Harbor, Wisconsin

See all

Most were dining on the patio, but since we needed handicap access and we had air quality warnings due to Canadian forest fires we opted to stay in the dining area. They graciously allowed us to be served in the dining room. We started with a traditional Bloody Mary and an old-fashioned made with mango habanero brandy. They were both delicious. We had the two meat combo which included a choice of any of their BBQ meats paired with 2 sides and a cornbread muffin w/honey butter. They had an option to share for an additional $10 (each party can choose their own 2 sides). The plate included beef brisket and a half rack of ribs. The meat was tender. Delightfully smoked with a sweet spicy sauce. Sides included a salad, Mac and cheese, fried green beans and coleslaw. Excellent meal at a reasonable price for an establishment in Door County! read more

Casey's BBQ & Smokehouse - 2meat combo with selected sides and Bloody Mary and Old Fasioned - Barbeque Near Me - Egg Harbor, Wisconsin

See all

We came here with a group of 8 people. We all ordered drinks and it took forever to get them. The waitress was openly complaining about the bartender in front of everyone which I found unprofessional. I don't like BBQ so the menu has limited things for people who don't like BBQ. I ordered a BLT. There was so much mayo. I honestly would never eat here again. read more

See all

Great spot to watch a football game if you are in Egg Harbor. My only regret is that we didn't have time to eat dinner here because the food smelled amazing! read more

Casey's BBQ & Smokehouse - Barbeque Near Me - Egg Harbor, Wisconsin

Nice spot for lunch with a view. I had their brisket chili and must say it was excellent! Big chunks of brisket and seasoned well (I am glad I added the sour cream and shredded cheese to balance out the heat of the chili). My hubby ordered the brisket sandwich with housemade chips. He said the brisket was a tad on the dry side, but we both agreed the house made chips were excellent and would love to buy them by the bag!!! Service was quick and friendly. We sat out on their pet friendly patios which had beautiful views of the water. read more

See all

Ok, we had a walleye fish fry and the beef brisket. Neither fabulous neither disappointing It was just ok. Had a bourbon manhattan. Because outside a plastic cup. Just ok. My spouses cherry mule was ok This is an ok place. Not a raving fan. When your cole slaw is the highlight, something is lacking. Ambience and view outside on deck is mesmerizing. Parking on street always seems available. Will come back but if you are looking for super memorable, this ain't it. read more

Great service. Nice outdoor bar and seating with a great view. The brisket sandwich was very good. Brisket was done perfectly with lots of flavor read more

Casey's BBQ & Smokehouse - Brisket sandwich - Barbeque Near Me - Egg Harbor, Wisconsin

If you are in desperate need to get BBQ while in Door County, this is an option. Not bad, but also not all that good. The beef brisket was dry and flavorless, and really needed the table sauce to make it palatable. Same could be said for the ribs. They seemed promising as the meat just fell off the bones, but again not all that flavorful. The fried corn bites were... interesting. Not bad, but not something we'd order again. Most of the food was reacted to with a shrug. Wait on a Friday evening was about 45 minutes. Total bill (no alcohol) was around $100 with tip. Service was friendly. The interior is that weirdly comforting northeastern WI tavern experience, which, well, it is. The Löwenbräu sign is cool. Too bad it's no longer imported. Appreciated the note on the drink list as to why it's no longer available. read more

We were there on a Sunday afternoon on a gorgeous sunny day. The view was spectacular. The service was..,interesting. Once we got our server she was lovely. But it seemed like everyone needed more training. Almost like they weren't sure what to do or how to prioritize things. Due to watching this we decided on splitting an order of potato skins and having water instead of each getting a meal and a drink. The food was a bit better than ok. They definitely created a cute plate by cleverly writing their name on our plate with BBQ sauce. The real positive is the patio was dog friendly! read more

Casey's BBQ & Smokehouse - Pig ears. (Potato skins with brisket) - Barbeque Near Me - Egg Harbor, Wisconsin

Wonderful shared entree. Ribs, brisket, fried green beans, Mac & cheese, Cole slaw, side salad and corn bread muffins with sweet butter. Everything was excellent! It has a handicap parking spot on the street almost in front of the entrance. Wheel chair accessible except for the restroom. Owner said building is so old, they'd have to tear it down and rebuild to make bathrooms accessible. read more

Mixed feelings. The bbq ribs, the Friday night walleye, excellent. Service always satisfactory. I am a summer resident in Egg Harbor, so I go maybe once/week, on 'off' nights, last resort when we don't want to leave town. Never on a weekend. Bad? THE MUSIC! SO MUCH NOISE!! Don't expect to hear the person next to you. Or the server. Blaring music, poor quality bands. The neighbors are not happy with this place. The group on the 4th of July was awful. Pure noise. read more

Meats smoked and barbecued onsite. The brisket is absolutely amazing. Best service I've had in Door County.

We were disappointed with our dining experience here. First, the ambience of restaurant is almost non existent. It is rather run down inside. Tables are old and beat up. It could use a good cleaning, a paint job and new flooring. The hostess was rude. Not welcoming in the least. We felt as if we bothered her asking for a table. There was only one waitress and she was lovely. We felt bad for her as she was working so hard with little or no assistance from the hostess. She kept her calm, was efficient and polite. The food was disappointing. We ordered the platter with two meats and there is a sur charge of $10 if you are sharing. But you do get two extra sides and a corn muffin. My husband ate the 1/3 slab of ribs. He said they were okay. I nibbled on the pulled pork. Very little seasoning. It was just okay. It was fatty as well. The sides were disappointing. The corn bread was stale. I would not recommend eating here. read more

*Great vibe, awesome outdoor setting with spectacular view *Great tasty cocktails *Good service, "hint" to server.. check back to see if the customer wants another or a third drink? Make more money for the owners and more tip income for yourself. *SO SO FOOD: Brisket "Dry and boring", Prime rib " Dry and boring" Pork and chicken sandwiches were ok, no "WOW" *Would we return? maybe? Only for drinks read more

Ok place. They fixed my card issue Food was good. View was better Our server was fine Blonde bigger set lady was rude read more

Wonderful place. Been coming for years now. Love the newer outdoor seating and the delicious food. Highly recommend!

Apologies if this runs on a bit, but this restaurant earned five stars for more reasons than just good food and service. We stayed at the Ashbrooke Hotel up the road and this bar was a natural stop on our walk back each night. We had dinner here the first night, and it was absolutely fantastic. The pulled pork melts in your mouth and I have never seen my mom finish an entire half rack of ribs and are still want more. The service was quick and to the point as they are very busy , but we never felt rushed and everyone was very kind. On the second night, my sister left her purse when we stopped for a drink at the bar. She realized it at 5 AM the next day and of course was in a panic. We had signed up for a trolley tour at 10 and of course the restaurant wasn't supposed to be open before that. We decided to take a chance and drive over there before heading to the trolley, and a very sweet man who was outside tending the smokers let her in, and found her purse behind the bar stashed safely away. Needless to say, this made the rest of our trip much much happier. This could have been such a catastrophe, and we really appreciate the honesty and goodwill of the employees here! read more

See all

We ordered the BBQ pulled pork to go and it was good but the portion was not too big. It's nice that they have a sitting area outside to eat. read more

After a long day of driving to Door County, this dinner hit the spot! Was greeted and shown our table quickly. Food came out fast too, which was needed! Lots of great flavor from the smoked meat and the sides were perfect! You have to stop here if you're a barbecue fan! read more

Casey's BBQ & Smokehouse - Sandwich in Texas toast with slaw and cheese. Meat was pork. This was so good! - Barbeque Near Me - Egg Harbor, Wisconsin

We stopped in for dinner based on the strong reviews online. We arrived about 5:45 pm on a Thursday during the off season and at that point only bar seating was immediately available for a party of two. The small dining room had a 30 minute wait. We opted for sitting at the bar which turned out to be the way to go because we had a view of the sunset over the water. It looks like during the warmer months Casey's has additional outdoor seating with water views. The bartender was attentive and friendly. I ordered the two meat sampler with brisket and ribs. My husband ordered the half chicken. Both meals came with two sides and a corn muffin with cinnamon butter. My two sides were green beans and corn nuggets. Corn nuggets are fried nuggets of cream corn. The center firms up in the cooking process but remains soft when you bite into it. We both enjoyed our meal but agreed the food was not worth a long wait. As long as we could walk in and sit down right away we'd stop in at Casey's again. read more

Casey's BBQ & Smokehouse - Two meat sampler with brisket, ribs, green beans and corn nuggets. - Barbeque Near Me - Egg Harbor, Wisconsin

We stopped in the other night anxious for a good BBQ sandwich. My wife and I ordered different ones as I had brisket and she had pork. Both sandwiches were good, but not what I would call outstanding. The bbq sausages was tasty and mild. The homemade chips were extremely good, and the best part of the meal. Service was fast, efficient and friendly. The inside of the restaurant is very old and dated. The table had multiple chips out of the surface and looked like it had been there for many many years. All in all it was strictly OK and we will not be in a hurry to return. read more

Disappointing. We were so excited to have bbq at Casey's BBQ & Smokehouse. We looked at TripAdvisor reviews and everyone said how great the ribs and brisket tasted. The location is perfectly situated on Egg Harbor with a wonderful patio view. The menu and portions are big. We ordered the smoked brisket platter and the half slab rib platter with salads, sweet potato fries and macaroni and cheese. The platter also comes with a corn bread muffin. The macaroni and cheese was delicious. Unfortunately, the meats were both overcooked and dry. Smoked brisket should have a smoke ring and this was grey. Maybe they had an off night; however, we didn't eat it after the first couple of bites so we ate cornbread muffin which was so-so. The waiter took our order, dropped off the food and we never saw him again. He never asked how we liked our food nor did he take away our full plates. The busboy asked us if we wanted boxes and I told him it wasn't good. The bill was nearly $60 for two plates and no drinks. I won't be going back there. read more

See all

Great bbq and the patio view is outstanding. Like most of Door County, Casey's is using staff from a pool of workers brought in from other countries to ensure they have people to serve their customers. The staff does a good job of providing customer service and speak English very well. The food continues to be high quality and it is worth stopping in for lunch or dinner. read more

Casey's BBQ & Smokehouse - New patio open for 2023. - Barbeque Near Me - Egg Harbor, Wisconsin

We enjoyed our sandwiches pon the terrace overlooking beautiful Egg Harbor, watching the boats come in and out. The pull pork and chicken were delicious and the staff was pleasant and attentive. Prices are reasonable and the place is popular with families. read more

Very disappointed I'm from the fox valley and Parker Johns has so much flavor. Not to mention the portions are very limited for the price. The mac& cheese was so overcooked. Walking out of the restaurant was telling me of why there was no flavor there was pallets by the smoker. Honestly just keep driving go to Sonny's or Sister bay bowel way better food and the price is less I could have spent 100 dollars somewhere else. read more

Casey's is my favorite place to stop for food in all of Door County! The food is always delicious, quality is great, staff is friendly, and the prices can't be beat in the area. Casey's is also a great lunch stop because the food is always super quick regardless of how busy the bar is. My go-to is the Smoked Brisket Sandwich. I tried the chili for the first time and gotta say it was very good, AND super loaded! I highly recommend Casey's to anyone visiting or driving through Egg Harbor. read more

Casey's BBQ & Smokehouse - Casey's Famous Chili (Loaded) - Barbeque Near Me - Egg Harbor, Wisconsin

See all

Overall the food was decent....however, the customer service was not very friendly. The bartender was competent and on task....just not very friendly. We felt like we were bothering her by just being there. good and friendly service makes everything better. Prolly would have stayed longer and spent more money read more

Stopped again- and once again, doesn't disappoint. Ribs were delish. Brisket had a nice smoke line, thick cut, thin line of fat. Sauce is good- has a nice kick at the end. Daughter loved the BLT, son loved the Chopper's bbq melt sandwich. Pulled pork was nicely smoked too. Homemade chips are way better than the sweet potato fries (my opinion). Corn nuggets are sweet, full of whole corn kernels. Soup of the day was Thai chicken with rice- creamy, with a little kick... Sat outside on a perfect night- sun was very warm and the umbrella hid us perfectly. So happy to have returned here. read more

See all

Casey's BBQ is a great place in Egg Harbor! First Time here with my family and did not disappoint. Grilled cheese with choice of brisket or pulled pork! Are you kidding me! Awesome food, great service. Definitely check this place out when you visit Door County. read more

Service was decent better than the food was. Food was mediocre to not so great . We're from Chicago but when heading up north next year we'll definitely skip this place. We weee not impressed. read more

Very cute space with bbq decor. The food was good and my family all had a great time.

If it wasn't for the suggestion of a resident, I would have never stopped by this unassuming restaurant/bar. It looks like your typical German bar but with a large pig on the outside. Heaven in the form of bbq food awaits you on the inside. I've been here twice, once pre-covid, and then more recently where social distancing was strictly enforced. I ordered the same item both times - because I don't think I can ever stray away from it (it had also come as a recommendation of the same resident, who had been a former employee). The holy grail of food: *BBQ*Beef*Brisket*Quesadilla* It is full, and I mean LOADED, with tender, juicy meat! I prefer the haystack onions on the side because I do not want to introduce any additional flavors into this magnificent creation. BBQ sauce also comes on the side, which is another nice touch so the consumer of the masterpiece can decided if they want their meat swimming or just wading in the homemade BBQ sauce. This dish is listed as an appetizer, however, my husband and I ordered this and a side of their amazing mac&cheese and it was plenty of food for both of us for lunch. I definitely would not be able to finish one of these quesadillas by myself. Service has always been excellent. Everything about this place is excellent! A carnivore's dream! I would drive to here from Milwaukee just to get that beef brisket. Highly recommend!!! read more

Went to Casey's on Wednesday night before the concert in the park in Egg Harbor. Sat on the deck and enjoyed the view. Ordered the three meat platter with baby back ribs, pulled pork and beef brisket, and two sides - cole slaw and baked beans. Wifey decided to split with me so for $7 she received two sides and corn bread which was served with honey cinnamon butter. Her sides were cole slaw and sweet potato fries. Everything was excellent. Meats had a heavy smoke and bbq sauce was light and spicy. Food came to the table rather quickly, but must note they only had one or two servers on at the time and they were busy. Food was good, hot and hit the spot. We were able to make the concert on time so that was an added bonus. Highly recommend without any reservations. Price was fair and value was good. Would return for another meal the next time we are in the area. read more

My husband and I arrived tonight for dinner. We were told there was a 20 minute wait, even though there were empty tables. Another employee came up to us after we asked if we could sit at a table outside , not the bar. No. We decided to leave. While we were still there, the hostess sat another couple at the empty table. They came in after us. The staff didn't seem to care that we felt wronged and didn't do anything to ask us to stay. I work in a restaurant and that wasn't cool. read more

We didn't experience expect the barbecue to be as good as we are used to and it wasn't. I got the ribs and they had a good flavor but fattier than I prefer. The pulled pork sandwich was decent but my husband was not happy with the brisket. Also, I ordered iced tea and because of Covid (whatever), they are now charging for iced tea refills. Thought that was ridiculous. read more

See all

Smells better than it tastes. Ordered ribs and pulled pork. Both very bland and lacking flavor. Service was great so was atmosphere by the bar read more

Friday night wallet fish fry was a hit. We also had a brisket quesadilla with was delicious as well. A busy Friday night and they were short staffed but we still had friendly service from a bar tender who stepped into serve. Overall, good experience. read more

Had the brisket and ribs. The brisket needed a little sauce on it but was good overall. Overall the food was solid BBQ. The view of the bay from the patio is amazing. Service was attentive and polite! read more