4 years since my last review? Definitely time to update! My older reviews still hold true so please see those as well. We always come here when in town and it's always delicious. This is what I'd refer to as an upscale supper club. They make a great old fashioned and you have your choice of a dinner salad or cup of soup with all entrees. Most entrees come with a protein, au gratin potatoes and the vegetables of the day. I usually get either the whitefish or the duck. On this visit I had the whitefish and it was absolutely delicious. It was perfectly cooked and simply prepared with lemon and butter which is exactly what goes with really fresh whitefish. They serve it with a side of tartar sauce...but I'd never do that to this lovely fish, so just left that alone. The potatoes and vegetables were good as always. Desserts are all made in house except for the key lime pie which is actually flown in from Florida. I love all their desserts, but went with the key lime pie which was amazing. They also have boozy ice cream drinks if you prefer a drinkable dessert. Service is always excellent with a good number of servers who have been with Alexander's for many years. Definitely make a reservation if you want to dine here. It's popular for a good reason. read more

See all

Dined here about five years ago, and I just cooled off enough from that experience to talk about it. The hostess was pleasant and smiling, but the wait-staff were unprofessional through-and-through. Not a single smile was seen on a single server's face. Furthermore, the attitudes of the wait-staff made dining uncomfortable. I recall having ordered a steak, which was unremarkable. I'll never return. I suggest you avoid this place. read more

We were really looking forward to a special birthday celebration here and we were disappointed that despite informing the hostess of the birthday, it was never acknowledged, mentioned, or celebrated with a desert. Very odd. The server was also not very informative when asked questions about the menu. The salads were good but nothing special. It would be nice if they had a cherry salad dressing? The biggest disappointment were the main courses. The seafood vol-au-vent served the lobster in its shell at the bottom of a soup like concoction. It was very difficult to eat without diving in the soup with your fingers. The bottom of the puff pastry was a soggy mess at the bottom of the bowl. Having said that the lobster cream "soup" had a nice flavor. This dish would be much improved if it was served on a plate with the sauce over the seafood rather than swimming it in a bowl. The sides were inedible! The green beans were gross, overcooked, and limp with a strong taste. The potatoes were a bland pasty dish. I substituted the wild rice and it again had no flavor whatsoever. Please offer a baked potato rather than the pasty, cold, potato mixture. The scallop dish was generous with six or seven scallops in each of our orders however, there was absolutely no pesto whatsoever. In fact, there was no seasoning at all just bland breadcrumbs. I added the cream "soup" from my sister's vol-au-vent to add flavor. Again this dish would have been so much better if they had simply grilled the scallops and added butter and lemon. The setting itself was nice with beautiful flowers outside the windows however, beware it did get very noisy. I hope a few "tweaks" are made to the seafood menu. It could be so much better. I would have to see a few updates to the menu before trying this restaurant again. read more

Alexander's - Pesto encrusted scallops - Seafood Near Me - Fish Creek, Wisconsin

See all

The 2 entrees were excellent . Stuffed Shrimp my husband is still talking about it 2 days later! Duck ( so large , yet tender with cherry sauce )& wild rice . read more

My new favorite restaurant in Door County. Steaks were cooked perfect, the Alfredo had a quality richness to it, literally everything from the bread basket to the peanut butter chocolate dessert thingy was top notch. The family loved it. Our server was knowledgeable as well as entertaining to interact with! read more

Alexander's - Seafood Near Me - Fish Creek, Wisconsin

Not much to add, but always one of the most consistently delicious stop in Door County. Great service and we sat next to a window again. But many great seating options. I could sit at the bar every night and enjoy it. Had Chili-Lime salmon special tonight, and my wife had the Halibut. Both were great. Key Lime pie is a great choice! read more

Alexander's - Chili Lime Salmon - Seafood Near Me - Fish Creek, Wisconsin

We visited last night 6.24.26 had ribeye and filet steaks. They were cooked to perfection. Cherry cheese cake is also scrumptious. Highly recommended. read more

One of the best supper clubs in Door County! Not a cheap date, but always offers excellent service, generous menu selections, and a great experience. Save room for an ice cream drink desert. We loved the Nutty Irishman. Cherry glazed salmon was one of best ever had. Small fillet steak was perfect. Escargot is done differently than most and some may not like its open face presentation. But the flavor was very good. Did I mention ice cream drink for dessert? read more

Love this place! It's our "go to" supper club in Door County. We have been here probably 4-5 time and the food & service never disappoints. On this visit we started with a round of Old Fashions, had the esgargo as an appetizer, the Mushroom & artichoke soup and the sesame crusted Tuna. Finished with Key Lime pie which has an incredible crust. read more

See all

What happened? We've been coming here for years and always had an excellent meal but this past weekend was a flop. Calamari wasn't deep friend and was just cooked squid in a buttery mess. Lobster bisque was a watery liquid mess. Stuffed shrimp was decent but also a sad sloopy mess and my husband ordered steak with a cognac sauce that was disgusting. Sides are also very random, scalloped potatoes with a sesame green bean mix. Silverware and napkins were dirty....! Hopefully this was a once off bad meal but I really don't know if we will be back. There are so many awesome restaurants in door county and I heard Alexander's got new owners. Not sure if this is the case but so sad .. read more

Exceptional service, ambiance, and food! The menu is large and you can't go wrong with any dish. Seafood so fresh and steaks cooked perfectly. Portions are large and entrees come with a soup/salad and side. The servers are so nice and service is quick. It gives Wisconsin supper club vibes. A go to when in Door County. read more

Alexander's - Blackened tuna appetizer - Seafood Near Me - Fish Creek, Wisconsin

See all

We had a reservation for 6:45pm on a Friday night. We checked in and sat at the bar for 5 minutes when our buzzer rang. Our waitress was attentive and on top of everything. We started with the complimentary bread which was so good. Warm and soft! I ordered the chicken carbonara and my boyfriend ordered the cowboy steak. We both upgraded to the side Caesar salad. The salads were good. The carbonara was a very large portion but I thought it lacked flavor. It was $38 dollars and I thought that was very overpriced for the flavor. My boyfriend loved his steak. It was cooked perfectly and had lots of flavor. The side of vegetables that come with the meals were also very good. read more

See all

All can I say is WOW! What an amazing dinner I had recently at Alexander's. The place gives an up north higher end supper class vibe, I love all of the fish and seafood on the menu! I had the salmon and it was fantastic, and everyone else I was with loved their fish fry (the serving was HUGE!). The service was great as well, we never had an empty breadbasket or lacked water! definitely going back read more

Been here twice . Once for dinner in the summer and now for Easter brunch. Both times the bartenders are slow and snobby rude . Plus, they couldn't mix a cocktail to save their ass. Servers are nice and pleasant. Brunch was meh . Priced at 40 a person . Quite honestly I've had better. read more

It baffles me why Alexander's doesn't get 5 stars but after 15 years coming to Door Alexander's is a must night out. Last night was no exception. Juana our server who has been there for about 10 years was truly outstanding so engaging and friendly. The food I can't even comment on because it is always 10 stars. Consistency is key. Filet and twin tales and the Thai shrimp app. Soup salad etc you can't go wrong at Alexander's! Have had many dishes over years from seafood to the Chicken Sophia which is utter perfection. If I could order 2 dinners for myself and finish them I would. Thank you to the Alexander's team for your year after year excellence!!!! read more

Came up to Door County on a whim to catch the last of the peak fall foliage. After a day of hiking I was in the mood for a nice steak. I am so happy to have stumbled upon Alexander's. I didn't have a reservation but I came right at opening and found a spot at the bar, good thing I did because this restaurant filled up SO fast. My bartender Ian was so lovely to chat with and handled the hordes of people expertly. The bar is full service. My fillet melted in my mouth and was cooked to a perfect medium rare. The potatoes are next level. The asparagus was such a nice addition, and the mushrooms were sautéed very well and not too saturated with butter. Ended up chatting with some friendly locals that shared their crab cakes with me-- which were also fantastic. Altogether had an absolutely wonderful dinner on a crisp and beautiful fall evening. read more

Alexander's - Seafood Near Me - Fish Creek, Wisconsin

Very awkward experience... I was in the ladies restroom, I used the restroom and while I was washing my hands a young man walked in (an employee) but he didn't knock or say anything. I felt very uncomfortable but said "hello" and he said hi and proceeded to go into the stalls to put toilet paper in there. I told the hostess about my experience and she literally ignored me and asked if I had a reservation. Very awkward and somewhat rude. Not sure what else to say... I've been here multiple times before and the food has been great but this recent experience was very weird. read more

Alexander's - Broiled Door County Whitefish - Seafood Near Me - Fish Creek, Wisconsin

See all

My wife and I enjoyed a dinner here tonight. She had the Halibut and I had the Cioppino. Both were excellent! Gabby was our server. She took great care of us. read more

Delicious food, amazing service, and a delightful atmosphere! Be sure to make reservations as it fills up quickly. Our server Claudia was attentive, knowledgeable, and enthusiastic. She made the night extra memorable for us. My group adored the food. Our favorites included the blackened scallops, escargot, Oysters Rockefeller, wild mushroom ravioli, and sea bass special. You really can't go wrong with anything on the menu! I can't wait to return. read more

See all

My mom, cousin and I enjoyed an all you can eat Thanksgiving meal at Alexander's. As always the food was spectacular and the service on point. A plate full of deliciousness was brought out complete with turkey, mashed potatoes and gravy, stuffing, sweet potatoes and green beans and seconds would be available if you so desired. Choice of a salad or soup was offered first. I mistakenly assumed the pie would be included (it was not) which was disappointing (but that's on me). What really shocked me was being charged for salad dressing!! I understand my being charged as I asked for crumbled blue cheese. I did not expect to pay for my mom's salad dressing too, especially when the salad was included with the meal. read more

Alexander's - Thanksgiving dinner - Seafood Near Me - Fish Creek, Wisconsin

See all

The food here is usually excellent but we split the scampi and was extremely bland . Wine was great and my aunts steak was perfect. Is there a dog around? Dog hair in food read more

Expert service, cozy atmosphere, delicious elevated fare is what you'll find at Alexander's. The front entrance brings you into a lively, mood lit bar with plenty of bar and lounge seating. Recommend grabbing a Wisconsin old fashioned before your meal. The reservation desk is tucked across from the restrooms where you will get a tiny buzzer that will alert you when your table is ready. Alexander's is one of the finest dining experiences one can have in Door County! I loved the Saturday night special, tenderloin a la Oscar. It was cooked to perfection, with a lovely presentation of an edible flower and julianne vegetables. My husband enjoyed the ample king cut portion of prime rib. The service was exceptional with the support team consistently refilling beverages, clearing plates and the waiter checking in on our comfort. An excellent date spot or to gather with a group for an elevated night out. read more

See all

We came in to celebrate a birthday and EVERYTHING WAS AMAZING! We have been to a lot of restaurants and supper clubs and this place topped the list! Great service by Ericka! Compliments to the chef (another Happy Birthday!) and kitchen staff! Started with Thai chili shrimp. Had sea bass and mushroom ravioli. Finished with a bday carrot cake. We are pleased with quality, flavor, and served HOT! Great place! We will be back! read more

Alexander's - Sea bass with lobster mashed potatoes - Seafood Near Me - Fish Creek, Wisconsin

See all

Alexander's is just a great experience from the moment you arrive. The staff is friendly and knowledgeable. The drinks are a great pour and the food is always fantastic. We love their version and presentation of the escargot. The soups are also always outstanding. I'm partial to the chicken or pork prepared Chloe style--it's a rich but balanced creamy mushroom sauce and my husband loves the filet mignon, Oscar style. Do yourself a favor and make sure that Alexander's is in your rotation. read more

See all

This place is amazing. I haven't been here is a VERY long time. So long ago- it was their old location. They were packed on entry and were goi g to have us wait a minute for our reservation. They noticed someone in our party that was old/walker/ difficulty standing and they immediately seated upon seeing this. So kind and thoughtful. They didn't need to do this. Drink menu was great. Love the cocktail choices and they were really reasonable with pricing. Dinner- the walleye was fantastic and all the sides with it. Everyone else in the party loved their entrees too. In short, everything was off the rails - amazing. So good! We ordered three deserts too. I probably would not order the tiramisu again bc it was too sweet (yet I ate it all). Service was so kind and professional and the food was awesome. Pricing was pretty good too! A repeater for sure. read more

Alexander's - Ruby fizz - Seafood Near Me - Fish Creek, Wisconsin

...excellent casual fine dining...best NY Strip I've had in years...will be back next year! Glad I was lucky enough to get a reservation the day before...always packed! read more

*The male hostess is always rude!! *Food is always excellent. * it's IMPOSSIBLE to make a reservation because they don't pick up the phone and you can't reserve online. We'll move on to some other place because of their reservation policy read more

Great food and service. We had the artichoke dip, swordfish special. Finished it off with a chocolate cake. read more

Alexander's - Swordfish special - Seafood Near Me - Fish Creek, Wisconsin

We went to Alexander's for the first time and it was an okay experience. Our soup was good, my husband enjoyed his steak and the dessert was pretty good. I got the Chicken Broccoli Penne and was very underwhelmed. It was quite flavorless and honestly just seems like buttered noodles with broccoli. I would not recommend this meal. read more

Alexander's - Chocolate Cake and Cherry Cheesecake - Seafood Near Me - Fish Creek, Wisconsin

See all

Best service and food in Wisconsin! The restaurant was quaint, amazing service and phenomenal food. read more

See all

As supper club enthusiasts, we have been to many supper clubs, and Alexander's is near the top. We appreciate that they take reservations. We were seated promptly. For drinks we had the old fashioned and. a Door County margarita. Both were very good, with the preference going to the old fashioned. Our entrees came with salads that were tasty with good dressing g. For entrees, I had the blackened whitefish special with lobster mashed potatoes, asparagus and corn relish. Wow! Hubbie had the Wednesday night perch special with came with potatoes and fresh beans. He declared it as sone of the best perch he has had and he doesn't usually like beans! Our server was very efficient checked on us throughout the evening. They made sure our water glasses were full. For dessert we shared the banana banshee ice cream drink which was delicious. We can't wait to return. read more

See all

One of the best meals we've ever had in 20 years of Door County visits. The atmosphere was lovely and service from our waiter Romeo was perfect. This may have been the most luscious whitefish filet I've eaten in my life. I'm convinced this fish was swimming in the bay just hours before it arrived on my plate. read more

Great food. OUTSTANDING SERVICE! Steaks, seafood, and dessert were all delicious. We'll be back read more

Wonderful dinner at Alexander's in Fish Creek! The night before Easter Sunday looked like a good night to get some tasty seafood and this place never disappoints! We were seated promptly and the bar was bustling with customers. Our server was the sweetest ever! Miriam did a great job with everything and made sure we were all good:) We started with the drinks, Oysters, escargot, and shrimp cocktail. All we're so good! The escargot was my favorite! The puff pastry and mushrooms with the garlic butter were so unique and honestly even better than the classic escargot dish. The shrimp cocktail was good but not a ton of shrimp for the price. The main dishes were super yummy! Shrimp carbonara was so rich and creamy with bacon, peas and garlic. The lamb was cook perfectly although the sauce with it was a little too much and overpowered the meat but without it, it was awesome! The Cioppino was delicious too. Piled high with shrimp, scallops, lobster tails and coated in a rich tomato sauce. WOW! Would get this again next time! The portions were a bit big for the entrees so I would splurge on drinks and appetizers and an entree to share maybe. Overall though, we left happy and definitely full! read more

See all

Went twice this weekend while visiting door county with my husband and all the food was fantastic. Environment is classy and inviting. Their oysters rockerfellar were the best we ever had and we went back the next day for more. Great food! read more

Early March getaway to Door and opted to try Alexander's. We look forward to our next visit; please read all :) Although the food was nicely presented, I was hopeful for a better taste from my scallop pesto entree. I found the scallops to be lacking the sweetness and flavor of scallops. Additionally, I was hopeful for strong pesto flavor to come through, but it did not. Overall this dish was lacking flavor and depth. However, the crab cake appetizer was as expected and my husband's entree was flavorful and enjoyed (I cannot recall his choice; one of the features). Additionally, both of our salads were fresh and flavorful. But what we LOVED here at Alexander's was our exceptional service from Romeo; he was wonderful in being so prompt in all the courses, but not being overly bothersome. It has been quite some time since we had such professional service; we almost couldn't believe it! Romeo never left us wanting for anything and he did his professional part in suggestive selling, properly timed course delivery and clearing. What we also LOVED about Alexander's was the dessert list. Ohmygoodness, it was hard to choose as every one on the list would be my own personal "playlist." We had the peanut butter torte and the carrot cake--both of these were exceptional! The peanut butter one, however, I literally can't stop thinking about it and may drive to DC just to go eat that again! We love to have dessert, but so many times it's never suggested...which makes no sense. Here at Alexander's, our server, Romeo, indeed presented dessert and after dinner beverages. We definitely would return. Although I wasn't thrilled with my entree, there are far too many positives in this place to not return. It's clear and obvious they care about what they do and the experience they create for Guests. And lastly, some folks sitting at the bar shouted "thank you, have a good night!" I would assume they may be owners, but even if not, they may be regulars that recognize the importance of a farewell. I can't even tell you the number of hosts we've passed on an exit of many other restaurants and they don't even say "thank you" or "good night." We hope our second visit will be just as enjoyable. PS-no pics as we like to enjoy phoneless dining read more

Went for New Year's Eve. Food was fabulous. Two of us had the tuna (1 had the blackened tuna the other had the sesame tuna) and thought it was one of the best we've ever. Food is beautifully presented, too. read more

Extremely good food in a lovely setting. Not a mind blowing culinary experience, but delicious. We all had the broiled whitefish with a cup of lobster bisque. The scalloped potatoes were a bit salty but okay, green beans were yummy. The lobster bisque was a bit thin and shy on lobster bits, but good overall flavor. Our server was lovely and the ambiance was nice. read more

Menu looked great but never been so rudely treated by a hostess. I approached her stand and shared that I had been trying to call, but was unable to get through. She snapped at me that she was only one person, I added that I knew we were early but hoping they could accommodate. I asked how long it would be, she said an hour, that's when your reservation is. I could have understood if they couldn't accommodate, she could have stated that without being such a bitch read more

We absolutely love Alexander's! We've been here many times and nothing disappoints. There are so many wonderful options that it is always hard to choose, but you can't go wrong. read more

See all