3 weeks under new ownership and we think they are on the right track -we drive over from…read moreShelbyville a few times a yr and stopped in today for dinner. Lisa was still there from previous ownership, she does a great job and is attentive and friendly. The new owner came out and spent about 5 min with us discussing other Gatti locations and his vision for improvements here in Martinsville. On our way out the owners wife spoke out from the kitchen. thanking us for coming in. Food was good as always and per request of my wife they put in a fresh BBQ Chicken Pizza. Salad bar was fresh and well stocked. We will for sure make the effort to visit again before the summer is over ! Good luck to the new owner and effort to make Gattis an even better better place to eat!

Well Mr. Gatti's is again under new management. Not Good! They are more concerned about cutting…read moretheir cost of making the Pizza than the quality (Cutting back the ingredients 'it takes to producing a quality Pizza, told your staff to use less sauce on the pizza. ) The BBQ Pizza is undoubtably the worst I have ever tasted) along with other Basic Pizzas offered on your buffet. Don't worry about your Cheese Sause and the cost of placing your lit up signs around the city use your money and improve your Pizzas!. in asking other customers of yours their opinion, they agree you suck! You can be "The Best" again instead of cheapening your products!!

First they said they didnt have an order for me then I showed I already paid then she went to back…read moreand got my pizza pizza is the worst pizza I have ever had id prefer Tony's dozen don't waste your time or money there

My husband and I went to Eddie's and we ordered personal pizzas to go . We have been here several…read moretimes but tonight was just not a good experience . Our pizzas were extra sloppy and threw on top of our breadsticks and we both asked for Mariana sauce for our breadsticks , well we got nacho cheese sauce ( yuck) and our breadsticks were soggy from being under the hot messy pizza . And while we were waiting on our food to cook the guy in front of us his food was done and the lady at the register said oh that's not what you ordered he said oh it's ok I'll just pick off what I don't like . They should have offered him a discount but nope nothing he just paid and left with the food he didn't order . I think since the new owner has taken over it's went down hill and we drove almost an hour for this pizza

We Ordered Good Food There And The Service Was Great…read moreAnd Excellent Ambiance! 10/10 I Love Pizza X

I've had nothing but good experiences here or any other pizza x location. But I had to review this…read moreas a previous manager of a restaurant because the other review is crazy. If you get a hair in cheese sauce then NO, you do not get a free meal. If you had hair in your pizza that's another thing. Yes get a free cheese and throw in some cookies or something but a free 10-20 dollar pizza is absurd. So yes, go to this location because they are good!!

Just came under new ownership. Pizza was fantastic! The service did leave a bit to be desired, and…read morethe small amount of pepperoni are the only reasons this isn't 5 stars. Hopefully they can keep this consistency

Italian sandwich was good. Pizza crust was very thin and overall not great. Service was just okay…read more Didn't expect this little place to be a full service setup especially as a pizza place. I would rather a counter service setup and not have to tip someone to fill my drinks, especially when the prices were quite high for not excellent food. All this to stay- didn't plan to pay $80 for a pizza and 2 sandwiches. Will not go back.

I've never had a baked spaghetti looks so skimpy on the cheese. It's normally covered how a baked…read morespaghetti should be.. This is just a spaghetti basically. Please get back to doing the baked. Spaghetti is the correct way with actual cheese on them. I wanted to go inside and get a refund but the energy inside is weird overall so I just said forget it.. probably not go back to this location. Also, I ordered an Italian lemon ice lady at the window said when she stirred it, she busted a hole in my cup so instead of getting me a new cup she double cup it so all the flavor was dripping into the new cup and out of the cup with the hole. So I ended up getting another cup so I could transfer it myself and then I'm trying to give them the double cup mess that I was given and then I'm being looked at like why do you want me to throw this away as if I asked for a mess when paying for an order and service.. I'll probably just go to another location. This is my second time today having terrible service. Ordering food that looks nothing how it should..

I ordered delivery Time before last I didn't get my extra breadstick. The last time before today…read morethe breadsticks were a total of two and about 3 inches long. Today it says 4 breadsticks on the receipt, but I got only two. maybe 4 - 5 inches long. The baked spaghetti was delicious. I don't know what to tell you but it is wrong to do this to a customer. Tks. p.s. You are acting like the breadsticks are not important, but if I order them, it is important to me. Carol.

We had a great experience at Tomato Pie Pizza! It's a friendly, family-oriented restaurant with a…read morewelcoming atmosphere. The staff was warm, attentive, and very helpful. Since it was our first visit, we asked our waitress what she recommended, and her suggestions did not disappoint. We ordered a small Chicken Bacon Ranch pizza, a small Deluxe pizza, and an order of breadsticks with cheese. Everything was delicious, but the breadsticks really stood out. They were perfectly baked with a wonderful crisp snap when you bit into them while still being soft and flavorful on the inside. Both pizzas were fresh, loaded with toppings, and full of flavor. If you're looking for a cozy place with excellent pizza, great breadsticks, and friendly service, I highly recommend Tomato Pie Pizza. We'll definitely be back!

Love the bread sticks. Some of the best I've had. Pizza is made from the same dough and is really…read moregood too. Friendly staff.

Our delivery experience was less than stellar. We only ordered FOUR items, and out of them ONLY ONE…read moreitem was correct. One of them being PIZZA, and we did NOT even get our pizza!

Their dining room consists of four tables with six chairs, two tables with four chairs and two…read moretables with two chairs. There are three TV screens. The chairs have cushions for extra comfort. I ordered their LunchBox deal which is a slice and a salad plus stix but I didn't ask for the bread. That deal is only $7. Add a soda and tax and it's still only $10. That's a pretty sweet deal these days. Both the salad and the slice of cheese pizza were excellent. The salad comes with lettuce, mozzarella, pepperoni, banana peppers, and tomatoes. My choice of dressing was their Balsamic Vinaigrette which was good too. Service was great as well. Step up to the counter and get waited on immediately, find a table and they bring your food out pronto.

I have always been a huge fan of this Marcos, but you need to go early in the day when there are…read moreadults running the show. I ordered online and went to the store to pickup. It was wrong. They remade the pizza and it was wrong again. The 3 guys in the store were more interested in their phones than working. I wasn't offered a discount for the exceptionally long wait or the wrong pizza.

pizza never ready on time. workers making and pulling breadsticks apart without gloves on. no thanksread more