Cayo Caribe Photos
CAYO CARIBE ATMOSPHERE
You might also consider
Recommended Reviews - Cayo Caribe
Start your review...
Reviews With Photos
This place gets pretty busy but the food and service was great! I got the fried red snapper, you get to pick your own fish so the price varies on weight but it was delicious. I also got the el cayo addition but wasn't a big fan of the taste. We also got the ceviche coctel and it was delicious as well. Would definitely return to get more seafood but i will say prices are on the higher side imo.
Mofongo, empanadas, cod fritters and fried cheese with guava are dishes from Puerto Rico that I really wanted to try. We ordered a total of 6 dishes and drinks. The prices were affordable compared to dishes you get at MesaPuertoRico and portions bigger. We also tried the flan and tres leches. Very small 'one person' portions but that's all you need. Service was quick and dining was casual. Great place to stop after sightseeing.
Initially wanted to bring my friend to Raices Restaurant but it was packed and the wait time was 40 minutes. It was a rainy night so we decided to try Cayo Caribe which is located nearby and so glad we did! Cayo Caribe despite being busy too they were able to get us a table right away. They were very accommodating and I'm thankful for that. The server had the best humor and super friendly. She teased us about getting the whole Puerto Rican experience meaning the rain and winds due to Hurricane Erin. Great atmosphere casual and fun. The food was amazing! We had the Asopao de Mariscos/Seafood. Great flavor and seasoned perfectly. Had big chunks of octopus, calamari, fish and jumbo shrimp. Really good generous portion for the price. We got tostones and salad with it. For dessert we had to try the Tembleque. Make sure you don't share as this dessert is sooo good you might want to get your own. Best tembleque it reminded me of the one my grandma used to make. This was a great choice and food was amazing. Will come next time I'm in PR and also recommend anytime.
Word of mouth is faster that you think . I'm in San Juan for 2 days to catch a cruise on Saturday. Talking with the uber driver on way to my hotel . I just ask some random question. A good place to eat . Cayo Caribe .Well , I truly believe that uber guy . There's a lot to Try . Get Their Tacos . Worthy . Their Ceviche. What else can I complain about.. love it.. after glancing on the next table is the special of the day . Yes we ordered a lot . But never regretted . Nadya the sever was extremely patient with us and constantly checking. Yes Highly recommended
Another tour guide recommendation. Sat at bar and asked for recommendation for dish they take most pride in. He told me beef paella. It's not bad, not comparable to what I had in Spain just a couple weeks earlier and for some reason had dry chicken breast in addition to the tender beef that I picked off. I bet the seafood menu is better but I went with server recommendation.
This Cayo Caribe is smack in the middle of Old San Juan tourist zone. There are several other locations around Puerto Rico. This location is upstairs and has a large bar surrounded by dining tables. While it wasn't our first choice for dinner, with many restaurants in the vicinity closed early on a Friday night, we enjoyed it! The Los Montaditos con Spicy Crab clusters were unique with deep fried plantains "spiders" and tasty. Max S and I shared a Whole Fried Snapper which was very good. I was afraid it would be overcooked but it was delicious. To top it off, they had my favorite Cakebread Napa Valley Chardonnay. I was shocked it was in San Juan when it's almost always sold out, or restaurants don't include it on their wine list in Fort Lauderdale. Perfect with fish! Service was good. We'd come back again.
Meh- this place was okay but not great. It has a great vibe and an expansive menu but overall the food was pretty lackluster. Our server Robert was very pleasant, but it took a long time for our orders to be delivered despite his promptness. My husband and in laws got the fish tacos which were okay. I got the coconut grouper which had potential but was just.... okay. There was very little seasoning. There a good many vegetarian options but I was pretty disappointed with the veggie arepita which was only steamed, unseasoned veggies in a pastry. My kids' empanadillas were pretty good, but not the best we've had this trip. All in all....it was fine. It won't break the bank which is a plus but there are better restaurants on the area like BARRACHINA, Cafe El Punto, St. Germain, or Mesa Verde.
This place was recommended multiple times to me and I had to try it out. I was thoroughly impressed with the red snapper and rice & peas. Everything was delicious but that red snapper is the show stopper-- it was magnificent! They had indoor and outdoor seating available. The service was excellent and I should've went back for seconds.
Everything was extremely fresh and delicious! Cruising from the east coast and this was a recommended spot for lunch by our tour guide. Calamari, empanadas, crab rice and shrimp and fish tacos were all WINNERS!! Gianna was an amazing hostess and gave top tier customer service! It is a cool vibe with a nice bar. We lucked up and hit them up during happy hour! Couldn't BEAT the 4 dollar Absolut cocktails!! Will be flying back and definitely visiting again!
Enjoyed myself here. Some colleagues and I came in to have a drink while we waited for our reservation at another restaurant. The bartender was really cool. The bar had several open seats, a chill vibe and semi crowded. Though a very extensive menu, we stuck to drinks which were good. The Tequila Gimlet and Margaritas...tasty
9 days ago
4 months ago
When you want an easy, reliable seafood lunch near the San Juan port, Cayo Caribe hits the mark. Our walking tour guide recommended this spot, and it ended up being one of the better casual lunches of the trip. It's located close to the cruise port area, making it an effortless stop if you're exploring Old San Juan. The vibe is straightforward and comfortable--think casual, sit-down seafood spot where you can relax, grab a drink, and not overthink the menu. It's not flashy or upscale, but that's part of the appeal. Just friendly service, cold drinks, and solid food. Service * Very friendly and welcoming * Easy walk-in experience * Relaxed, unpretentious atmosphere Food & Drinks * Standard beers and cocktails--perfect for a mid-day refresher * Seafood Fried Platter - especially the fried cod; crispy, flavorful, and well-executed * Tacos (Fried Shrimp & Fried Cod) - the standout; fresh, generous portions with crunchy slaw and spot-on sauce The tacos were the surprise hit--bright, crispy, and packed with flavor. Exactly what you want from a Puerto Rican seafood lunch. Verdict Cayo Caribe is a dependable, casual seafood stop near the port. Nothing overly complicated--just good service, fresh seafood, and a relaxed setting. A great lunch choice if you're in the area and craving fried seafood and tacos. Solid four stars. read more
HIGHLY RECOMMEND. We had the fried whole snapped it was excellent!! Also the beef empanadas were amazing. Great service and friendly. Inside the bar was playing Pickleball on the tv at the bar and we got to watch the finals. read more
1 day ago
I had the grouper with the savory Coco sauce and it was out of this world. I will definitely be back, especially since it's right across the street from where I live. read more
This place gets pretty busy but the food and service was great! I got the fried red snapper, you get to pick your own fish so the price varies on weight but it was delicious. I also got the el cayo addition but wasn't a big fan of the taste. We also got the ceviche coctel and it was delicious as well. Would definitely return to get more seafood but i will say prices are on the higher side imo. read more
Mofongo, empanadas, cod fritters and fried cheese with guava are dishes from Puerto Rico that I really wanted to try. We ordered a total of 6 dishes and drinks. The prices were affordable compared to dishes you get at MesaPuertoRico and portions bigger. We also tried the flan and tres leches. Very small 'one person' portions but that's all you need. Service was quick and dining was casual. Great place to stop after sightseeing. read more
The service was good the lady was attentive. Nice and spacious place picture worthy at entrance. Fish taco was 3/10 personally but my friends liked it . Shrimp taco 8/10 amazing. All come covered in coleslaw i enjoyed it. The green sauce was perfect for them. Would return for sure read more
Initially wanted to bring my friend to Raices Restaurant but it was packed and the wait time was 40 minutes. It was a rainy night so we decided to try Cayo Caribe which is located nearby and so glad we did! Cayo Caribe despite being busy too they were able to get us a table right away. They were very accommodating and I'm thankful for that. The server had the best humor and super friendly. She teased us about getting the whole Puerto Rican experience meaning the rain and winds due to Hurricane Erin. Great atmosphere casual and fun. The food was amazing! We had the Asopao de Mariscos/Seafood. Great flavor and seasoned perfectly. Had big chunks of octopus, calamari, fish and jumbo shrimp. Really good generous portion for the price. We got tostones and salad with it. For dessert we had to try the Tembleque. Make sure you don't share as this dessert is sooo good you might want to get your own. Best tembleque it reminded me of the one my grandma used to make. This was a great choice and food was amazing. Will come next time I'm in PR and also recommend anytime. read more
5 months ago
Word of mouth is faster that you think . I'm in San Juan for 2 days to catch a cruise on Saturday. Talking with the uber driver on way to my hotel . I just ask some random question. A good place to eat . Cayo Caribe .Well , I truly believe that uber guy . There's a lot to Try . Get Their Tacos . Worthy . Their Ceviche. What else can I complain about.. love it.. after glancing on the next table is the special of the day . Yes we ordered a lot . But never regretted . Nadya the sever was extremely patient with us and constantly checking. Yes Highly recommended read more
Another tour guide recommendation. Sat at bar and asked for recommendation for dish they take most pride in. He told me beef paella. It's not bad, not comparable to what I had in Spain just a couple weeks earlier and for some reason had dry chicken breast in addition to the tender beef that I picked off. I bet the seafood menu is better but I went with server recommendation. read more
This Cayo Caribe is smack in the middle of Old San Juan tourist zone. There are several other locations around Puerto Rico. This location is upstairs and has a large bar surrounded by dining tables. While it wasn't our first choice for dinner, with many restaurants in the vicinity closed early on a Friday night, we enjoyed it! The Los Montaditos con Spicy Crab clusters were unique with deep fried plantains "spiders" and tasty. Max S and I shared a Whole Fried Snapper which was very good. I was afraid it would be overcooked but it was delicious. To top it off, they had my favorite Cakebread Napa Valley Chardonnay. I was shocked it was in San Juan when it's almost always sold out, or restaurants don't include it on their wine list in Fort Lauderdale. Perfect with fish! Service was good. We'd come back again. read more
1 year ago
Meh- this place was okay but not great. It has a great vibe and an expansive menu but overall the food was pretty lackluster. Our server Robert was very pleasant, but it took a long time for our orders to be delivered despite his promptness. My husband and in laws got the fish tacos which were okay. I got the coconut grouper which had potential but was just.... okay. There was very little seasoning. There a good many vegetarian options but I was pretty disappointed with the veggie arepita which was only steamed, unseasoned veggies in a pastry. My kids' empanadillas were pretty good, but not the best we've had this trip. All in all....it was fine. It won't break the bank which is a plus but there are better restaurants on the area like BARRACHINA, Cafe El Punto, St. Germain, or Mesa Verde. read more
7 months ago
This place was recommended multiple times to me and I had to try it out. I was thoroughly impressed with the red snapper and rice & peas. Everything was delicious but that red snapper is the show stopper-- it was magnificent! They had indoor and outdoor seating available. The service was excellent and I should've went back for seconds. read more
Everything was extremely fresh and delicious! Cruising from the east coast and this was a recommended spot for lunch by our tour guide. Calamari, empanadas, crab rice and shrimp and fish tacos were all WINNERS!! Gianna was an amazing hostess and gave top tier customer service! It is a cool vibe with a nice bar. We lucked up and hit them up during happy hour! Couldn't BEAT the 4 dollar Absolut cocktails!! Will be flying back and definitely visiting again! read more
Enjoyed myself here. Some colleagues and I came in to have a drink while we waited for our reservation at another restaurant. The bartender was really cool. The bar had several open seats, a chill vibe and semi crowded. Though a very extensive menu, we stuck to drinks which were good. The Tequila Gimlet and Margaritas...tasty read more
6 months ago
Great food and excellent service! I had a fantastic experience at this restaurant in San Juan. The deep-fried red snapper was perfectly cooked--crispy on the outside and flavorful inside. The French fries were also excellent and paired really well with the fish. What really stood out was the service. Our waiter was a very friendly and knowledgeable young guy who made the experience even better with his great attitude and helpful recommendations. Highly recommended if you're in San Juan and looking for delicious seafood and warm service! read more
8 months ago
The server and other people super nice and friendly ... the food is plain and no salt . The bar is great and has tv with the games on . Is so hot ... not air circulating . The decor is nice and the music in on point . The place is clean and tightly . read more
We wanted to try some authentic food from San Juan. It was a small but busy place. We decided to try the conch empanadas. They were delicious. I only gave a four star because our food took a really long time to come. I also was disappointed that the waiter told us the beer was from Puerto Rico, only to read the can it was from Wisconsin. We would go back for sure. read more
This was our first meal in Puerto Rico, and we were grateful to have found this place by chance. We needed to pick up some supplies, like water shoes for our upcoming rainforest trip, and were directed to the Walgreens by the bay. After some shopping and waiting in a long line, we were hungry, but the restaurants I had bookmarked were all a bit farther away. My child was getting impatient, so we turned to Google and found this spot just a 3-minute walk from Walgreens--a great find! Although there was a long line with large groups, we were seated right away since there were only two of us. Our waitress was fantastic. My daughter ordered a virgin mojito, and the waitress helped us arrange a small red snapper. The deep-fried fish was a highlight--fresh and incredibly flavorful. My daughter nearly finished it all on her own! The ceviche tacos were another standout, perfectly seasoned and delicious. The "Crazy Shrimp" dish was interesting, though I didn't find it particularly "crazy" or spicy. The fake crab strips had an unusual seasoning I couldn't quite describe but had no trouble enjoying. However, my daughter wasn't a fan, so I ended up eating hers. My piña colada, unfortunately, was far too sweet for my taste. I've noticed that drinks in Puerto Rico tend to be overly sweet and sugary--not just compared to NYC bars, but it seems sweeter flavors are preferred here. Something to keep in mind! read more
The rice with crab is the best dish by far. Ceviche is a bit thick and overly citrus-y. The drinks/ juices are okay. The server Priscilla is very helpful and patient. Interior is nice and you're far more likely to get a seat here than one of the other locations nearby. Worth a quick stop for sure and the prices aren't bad. read more
6 months ago
1 year ago
When in PR this is a must try!!! Delicious mofongo... Super attentive service... The drinks are the best!!!!!! read more
3 months ago
3 months ago
Nico / Niko ? .. our server was so great! Enjoyed his service and humor. Quick service, nice ambience, good vibes! read more
The wait was a bit longer than quoted, but we did go on a Sunday evening and it's located in Old San Juan. The seafood rice was good; there was ALOT of seafood which was nice. The Mofongo wasn't the best that we've had, but not bad. read more
1 month ago
Robert was our server on a busy Wednesday night. Took some time to take our order, but it was super busy with 3 cruise ships docked. I ordered the 4 tacos (2 shrimp 2 fish) the cabbage was so delicious and fish and shrimp were so crispy. I was so full off of 2 tacos. Huge portion! Husband had the snapper the catch of the day and it was good just a little salty. Son had the skirt steak and shrimp. It was okay. Daughter had the beef steak with fries which she ate it up! read more
5 months ago
It was OK. A lot of other restaurants were packed and this one was empty and we should've known. Service was very friendly but super slow and they seem understaffed . It took a long time for us to get our food. The beer was served in a broken glass and had to get a new glass. The tacos were very salty and we had a hard time eating it. The restaurant itself is dark and has a lot of sports on. The seafood did taste fresh as they do claim that they are the freshest food in San Juan. read more
5 months ago
10 months ago
Great prices and very good food. Great service too. The drinks were reasonably priced compared to the restaurants in the area, and same with the food, and the quality of the food was excellent. read more
1 year ago
Yesterday my husband and I was strolling thru old San Juan. We stopped and had a fabulous lunch at Cayo The service was excellent!! Our waitress was so wonderful and the food was delicious!! We both had the breaded jumbo shrimp...he had rice and I had French fries...mmmmmmm yummy! We spoke to the manager and gave our waitress and the cooks a compliment. We are going back before our vacation ends read more
8 months ago
5 months ago
The mofongo (with ropas viejo) and red snapper were delicious. Homemade sangria was very tasty! read more
Page 1 of 6
More info about Cayo Caribe
Cayo Caribe Reviews in Other Languages
Review Highlights - Cayo Caribe
You might also consider
Why does Yelp recommend reviews?
2 reviews that are not currently recommended
The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.
1 year ago
2 years ago
