Visiting Cedar Key for a few days and decided to stop in for dinner on our first night. We were greeted by their door cat Frankie and then sat down in the restaurant. We had some salads, a Cubano pizza, and chicken Alfredo. Everything was fresh and delicious, and we were so full that we took home leftovers (and some key lime pie, yum!) Our server was super friendly! Would definitely return! read more

Cedar Key Pizza and Subs - Cubano Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Cedar Key, Florida

If you're wanting pizza on your tiny island vacation, this is the place to go! Amazing quality ingredients. Some of the best pizza I've had.

The best pizza. Thin crust. We had the Cedar Key. Like a supreme. Very honest about wait times. Occasionally the bakery has sent down treats to add on. read more

Cedar Key Pizza and Subs - Pizza Near Me - Cedar Key, Florida

[[HIGHLIGHT]]Stopped into this place last night with 40 mph winds and temperatures that should be banned from Florida that were blowing us off the pavement.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] Nonetheless we were greeted by a very nice young lady named Jo. She took great pains to seat us in a warmer area than we had selected. We ordered a large Reuben pizza because we were told you could not get any other size.however, the pizza was incredibly good and we brought half home. Talk about a wonderful surprise with a delicious finish! When you stop out on Cedar Key, give it a try! This is a must return type of place....ask for Jo....you will love her!! Guy and Elaine Hartford, Ocala Florida read more

Owner is so nice to visitors. You can get this delivered at Steamers, Madi & Liam's bar (recommended) as the owner here is nice to outsiders as well. Support these local businesses when you visit. read more

Cedar Key Pizza and Subs - Cats at Madi & Liam's where we met the owner of Pizza joint. - Pizza Near Me - Cedar Key, Florida

The service from Jo is always top notch! She makes sure she keeps your drinks filled, answers any questions about the dishes they serve, let's you know if there are any specials, and smiles throughout the entire process!! The food is hot, fresh, amazing, and prepared just the way you ask. [[HIGHLIGHT]]Love the decor celebrating Cedar Key's beauty and history.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] read more

The Pizza was excellent and the Key lime pie was amazing. The owner is very knowledgeable and courteous. He told us the history of the building and the survival of the building during Hurricane Helene. [[HIGHLIGHT]]Very great ambience like going back in time to a ole pizzeria[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] read more

Cedar Key Pizza and Subs - Picture of the front door showing the waterlines from Helene. - Pizza Near Me - Cedar Key, Florida

Good pizza on the island and accommodating. Staff fixed an order that went wrong and very apologetic. We'll be back

Food was good, service was great, [[HIGHLIGHT]]we went during off hours so no crowd and very quiet[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]].

We accidentally walked in 5 min before closing time and the host still sat us. After realizing and offering to take our food to go she insisted we dine in and assured us it was okay. We ordered the bang bang shrimp and cedar key special large pizza. Pizza was fantastic, their dough was light and had a good crisp to the underneath, well topped pizza and tasted very good. We smashed the whole thing out of hunger and also wanting to not stay in their hair. Great bite of food! read more

We have been dying to try this place! Good looks amazing! We got the garlic knots which are like mini knots and were delicious. The pizza looked good however I couldn't eat it. We ordered pepperoni, sausage, green pepper, & onion. When we got back to our Condo, it had mushrooms (gross). I hate mushrooms and couldn't eat it. Hubby enjoyed it. Service was great, we sat at the bar around the corner and they brought the pizza to us! Super nice people. Wish I could have tried the pizza read more

Cedar Key Pizza and Subs - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Cedar Key, Florida

See all

Fast service! Great pizza but I'll be thinking about that Greek salad for a long time. Yum!

Great little pizza shop in the heart of town. We walked up from Firefly cottages and ordered a medium Hawaiian pizza. It was really delicious thin crust and ready in about 20 minutes. Be aware that there is only 1 table behind the building so plan to take it back to wherever you're staying. They didn't offer any plates or napkins, didn't have any to grab inside either. Pizza was great though! read more

Unfortunately, this business was ravaged by Helene and won't be open for a little bit. When they do open back up and they will...GO EAT HERE. The wings are some of the best I've ever had. [[HIGHLIGHT]]The service is great, but unless you get the 1 table outside, you'll need to get it to go[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] read more

First time in Cedar Key and everyone was telling us we had to try this pizza! We were downtown walking around, walked in and order, went to our cottage and the pizza was delivered within 20 minutes! So yummy and the nicest staff! read more

Okay, pizza and ravioli were delicious but what made us eat there two nights in a row were the people. Literally couldn't have been nicer. Even took the time to deliver to us the second night. It's really good food, best sausage on a pizza ever. Crust was perfect. Just a very nice pie. But these owner and employees, top shelf. If I lived there I would live at this place. We had four different pizzas and fried ravioli. Very creative menu! Not just your usual pizza. read more

We love this place. Every time we visit Cedar Key we get at least one order from here. The pizza is very good and the family that owns it are super nice people. They were kind enough to pay my daughter a compliment when they didn't have to they made her day. Also every time we have ordered the food it's been consistently good and we have been going for years I would recommend them highly if you want pizza in the cedar Key area. read more

Ordered delivery while at the awesome bar around the corner. We loved the Margherita and Cuban pizzas! Fresh, delicious, creative options here. Friendly service, not especially fast (I mean, it's made just for you!!!) but worth the wait. We will be back next time we're in Cedar Key. read more

Really Great Pizza, friendly owners, dough fresh thin and crispy very authentic italian, fresh crispy veggies. We'll be back, do yourself a favor and stop by soon !!! read more

Wonderful food, fast and hot. Crust and toppings were perfect. Nice menu and great service

Amazing service and food! They delivered in a storm and food was outstanding! I highly recommend!

The large pizza was quite small, the calzone was adequate, but the wings were soggy and not flavorful.

OMG FANTASTIC!!!! We ordered their new Cuban pizza, the new Margherita pizza, a pepperoni pizza, a calzone and Greek salads. First off, best salad in Cedar Key. The ingredients were excellent quality and really fresh. The pizzas had great crust, fresh quality ingredients. Just delicious. The calzone was fabulous, no need for marinara for this one. Great job!!!! read more

Great food and friendly staff! We tried a few pizzas, the Philly, and garlic knots. They were all delicious! read more

Cedar Key Pizza and Subs - a half eaten pizza - Pizza Near Me - Cedar Key, Florida

Read reviews before getting pizza and wings. Reviews were great so we ordered a medium pizza and wings. Pizza and 9 wings were over priced at $49.00. That's not the biggest reason for this bad review though. The wings were wings that you get in a grocery store in the frozen isle and the pizza had absolutely no taste. Would not recommend spending this kind of money at this place. read more

People were nice. Food was 30 minutes late. They kept apologizing but it felt like they had no idea how to adapt in a tough situation Pizza was tiny and way burned. Not a little, but black crust burned. You never send a pizza that burned out, never. Wings were very tasty, except for half of each wing being stuck to the container. Never had either happen prior. Again, very nice people but I would never order here again unless they figure out how to run their business to satisfy patrons and not simply focus on taking as many orders as possible. Orders they could not reasonably fill based on staffing. read more

Amazing pizza and very quick on a busy day! Thank you! Garlic knots were good too! We didn't realize this is a take and go kinda place, but that worked too. We brought it to a bar around the corner and enjoyed it there. They offered to deliver for us even, so I believe they do that all over the island for people. read more

Maybe new owners? 4th time going there for takeout pizza, great as always. Go with CK special. Great crust and pizza was great!