A Chico institution. Great place for a pint and a slice. The Godfather is my personal favorite but all the varieties are delicious The pizza is old school love read more

Need a quick slice pick me up? This is the place to go. Service was speedy and the staff was friendly. A nice corner spot to get your pizza fix- it was yummy, they don't skimp on the toppings read more

Celestino's New York Pizza - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Chico, California

See all

During my university days I was a regular here. I would probably come in for a slice once a week. Prices were always affordable and slices were always large enough to fill you up. I would always order a slice of pepperoni and occasionally tried some of their other creations. No pizza I got from there was ever anything other than delicious! Service was very fast! I would order at the counter, pay, and like that my slice would be nice and hot and waiting for me to devour it. The inside of the restaurant is cozy - it's not very big inside, but there is enough room to go there with a group of friends. They play a bunch of vintage songs, which I don't mind. read more

Celestino's New York Pizza - Pepperoni Pizza. - Pizza Near Me - Chico, California

I didn't have breakfast today, so I was a bit loopy when I arrived. By the time I realized I hadn't paid, there was a huge line. A young lady asked if she could help with anything, and I let her know I called in an order. She said they would ring me up once the calzone was done. Very clean dining area. Bathrooms require a key from counter staff. Wonderful crust on the calzone. Mozzetta and ham filling is excellent. Soda dispenser is properly calibrated. Wow! read more

Celestino's New York Pizza - Soda dispenser - Pizza Near Me - Chico, California

See all

AMAZING service loved every part of it the ambience the service the friendly employees

Really great pizza that has been here forever...Loved the little garlic knots. The warm artichoke dip was pretty good, 3 stars. But the pizza and garlic knots make up the difference! read more

Pretty good pizza by the slice in Chico, the service was fast, the ranch is good, and the ambiance is super retro! It looks like this place hasn't changed since the 90s (probably when it opened). read more

Celestino's New York Pizza - Pesto Veggie Slice - Pizza Near Me - Chico, California

See all

I'm gonna be absolutely biased because this Pizza got me through college, but it is some of the best pizza I've ever had. I remember at one point thinking as I left Chico, I had one of the best burritos I've ever had and I've also had one of the best pizza slices from this place that I've ever had. I do travel a lot so I'm not just in a closet all the time, but Chico is lucky to have a place like this. I try to make it over there every time I'm in town. read more

This place never disappoints until today called at 8:13pm and. Was told they were closed and no longer taking order over the phone sucks I was really looking forward to a tasty pizza from there Psss the slices are not the same as a whole pizza read more

Celestino's New York Pizza - Hawaiian Pizza Specialty Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Chico, California

First off, the food was amazing, hot and good portion. Secondly, I want to say that the service is terrible. The cashier was pretty rude, had an attitude, and just seemed like she did not want to be there. Honestly, she made us (me and my close friends) feel unwelcome. This was our first time there, and we will have to reconsider coming back. The cashier was the blonde one btw. read more

Celestino's New York Pizza - Garlic Knots and Traditional Cheese Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Chico, California

Best pizza in Chico! 11/10 Fast service, great atmosphere in the restaurant, solid prices as well as good student and drink deals read more

Great pizza. girl at the cash register was very rude and seemed as if she could care less. Pizza made up for it.

I don't say this lightly--this was one of the best combo pizzas I've had in my entire life. I ordered it as delivery. From the moment the first slice hit my tongue, I knew I was tasting something exceptional. The crust had a perfect balance of crunch and chew, with a gentle char that whispered of wood-fired mastery. The tomato sauce was vibrant--bright, slightly tangy, kissed with herbs, and layered with a subtle sweetness that held everything together. Every bite delivered a harmony of salty, savory, and aromatic flavors: pepperoni that curled and crisped at the edges, sausage with just the right amount of fennel, bell peppers and onions that melted into the cheese without losing their brightness. But it was the cheese that broke me--in the best way. It had that elusive balance of stretch and creaminess, browned just enough to leave a buttery, nutty note on the palate. I sat in silence after my third slice, honestly emotional. It was a reminder that food can still surprise you. This wasn't just pizza--it was a moment. One of those rare culinary experiences that etches itself into memory. I didn't just enjoy this meal--I was humbled by it. read more

Celestinos is great for lunch. The price is great for a slice of pizza and a drink. Pizza is delicious. My husband likes to go there on his lunch breaks. Very clean and people are courteous. Would recommend this pizza and noodles anytime. read more

Great pizza! Been eating Celestino's since they were a tiny hole in the wall pizzeria in downtown Chico and watched them grow to where they are now. Best pizza in Chico, bar none! read more

We tried this place downtown for the first time recently and found it to be very good. It is a simple place serving pizza and other Italian dishes. The decor inside is spare. Service is friendly. The food is very good, and enjoyable, but not excellent. We had a slice of mushroom pizza (4) and lasagna (4), both with a side salad. These were all good and well made, but both were slightly on the bland side. The sauce on both was very light on the herbs and needed actually a touch of salt. Otherwise, this was good and for a simple Italian meal or pizza, we'd go here again. They serve whole pizzas as we all as pizza by the slice, a nice option and logical for a university town. One orders at the counter as one goes in. read more

Celestino's New York Pizza - Pizza slice & salad at Celestino's in downtown Chico. Sept.2024. - Pizza Near Me - Chico, California

See all

Great food & good service! Slightly pricey but food was very good. The garlic knots were a bit on the doughy side but overall was very good.

If you like NY style pizza look no further. Old school crust with plenty of new school topping choices. Practically ON campus so great for students and faculty who want to grab a slice. Total Pizza My Heart (santa cruz) 1980s vibe which is my vibe! Go! Enjoy! Support a local bussness. read more

Pretty ood pizza, and i like that they serve by the slice. Mostly good service. Could improve their hours, as they close too early.

Best pizza in chico hands down! Friendly workers! Clean environment, would definitely keep coming back!

My husband and daughter loved all the food they delivered (on time). Margarita pizza, chicken pesto calzone, spinach salad and cheesy garlic bread. read more

Visiting from Oregon and wanted something easy to bring to the hotel room for my son and I. I searched so many pizza places and just finally chose this one. So glad I did. Tucked in a little roundabout right by Chico State. Doesnt look like anything special but the foooood! That's where it's at. The pizza great! NY style pizza. You can ask for it double cut so the slices are smaller. Perfect for my kiddo. You can purchase by the slice as well! If you're a ranch snob like me and want a good ranch to go with your pizza, THIS IS IT. read more

Celestino's New York Pizza - Medium Half pepperoni half cheese double cut - Pizza Near Me - Chico, California

Went in to order to go and will say it was fairly quick after I ordered that I was leaving with the pizza. Pizza was really good and a quality New York style that you don't find everywhere. Just so you know, the extra large is a really big pizza, almost didn't fit through the car door. Not a problem or a negative just letting you know. Nothing fancy, but just a good New York style pizza. read more

Really enjoy pizza by the slice! The pepperoni was a bit salty but the cheese was great and the sauce is on point. Love the crust too - prices are decent for single slices and they are hot and toasty! I tried one with pesto and don't remember the name but it was really good and I would order it again for sure! read more

Food is delicious and huge! I always order one slice for then and one for the next day! Only issue is the food takes a long time to come out. It is really close to campus and a great place to grab lunch after class! read more

Celestino's New York Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Chico, California

Best pizza in Chico by far!! My dad is a very picky pizza lover but he can't get enough of Celestino's. Tonight they really hooked it up with the extra cheese, the pizza was extra super amazing!! Thanks so much, from the man who likes to cut the pizza himself read more

Celestino's New York Pizza - Sorry I couldn't keep from eating this delicious slice before taking a photo!! - Pizza Near Me - Chico, California

0 stars!!!!!!!!!! service was rude and ignored me and just scoffed when i asked for the bathroom key and a two go box, they never gave it to me read more

The pizza is sooo good! The service is incredible, too. My only complaint is that their garlic knots aren't as good as they were at the Paradise location (too flat and dry here). read more

I have been coming to celestino's for over a decade (even made the 1.5 hour drive from Sac just to get pizza and bring it home for my birthday). I've had pizza everywhere (except new york) and this place still beats even Italy. I miss it and crave it regularly but the Rocklin location is terrible. I'd rather make the drive out to chico. My favorite is the godfather, my bf's favorite (he went to chico state) is tom Jones or Oscar's spicy luau. I'm not sure I've even tried their other options because of how much I love the godfather. Pesto, tomatoes, cheese, everything about it is divine. Can't wait to go back! read more

This is the best pizza in the area. Huge slices. The crust is incredible and delicious. The pies themselves are super tasty as well. Really cute interior with a mom and pop pizza shop feel to it. Their ranch is great as well. Usually pretty darn quick service as well. read more

I found the place by accidentally pizza craving. The place appears to have spikes in business making its lines intermittently long. Atmosphere: It is next to a college and has a regular student customer base. The entrance walks leads to the glass pizza case where it is available to buy by the slice. They had a paper menu but the walls above the pizza case had pictures of their popular dishes. A fountain drink dispensary, silverware, and paper plates. The interior decor is that of mix between college and cafeteria. Although they have several monitors showing sports. I thought I saw outdoor seating in the back too. 4 Service: The staff was quick to take my order. There is no table service. The environment feels a bit hurried. 4 Prices: cheese pizza slice is $3.25. Pepperoni was $3.75. I had the student special that was one slice of cheese or pepperoni and a drink, I think it was $4.50. Quality: the sauce was great, portions were larger than usual for regular pizza places. Crust was thin and had that flour taste that was good. It had been a long time since I had pizza. 5 I would repeat for the pizza over the big 4 commercial chain. I would also try the salad and sandwiches if there is a next time. read more

See all

Best pizza in Chico!! Love the Oscar's spicy! This has been my family's go-to pizza place for over 20 years. Never disappoints! Staff are friendly and work really hard. The location is super convenient and the pick up window is great for grabbing a quick slice! read more

I went to Chico State and came back recently to visit...you better believe Celetinos was on my list of food spots I had to go back to! We ordered delivery and it came hot AND was just as tasty as I remember!! read more

Celestino's New York Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Chico, California

I continue to love and appreciate having Celestino's as a fixture business with their unique to our community NY style pizza. Yes, the food is great always, but I always appreciate Enzo's smile and and warm welcome whenever I come in. There is something extra after the 25+ years Celestino's has been there that feels like being at home. read more

Very yummy thin crust pizza. Always wonderful! The staff is friendly the food is fresh and I am constantly craving the place.

This was the first time i've had Celestino's and I've got to say it was so good. For all my fellow people who don't eat the crust, you'll fasho want to eat this one. The cheese and pepperoni's were so fire but they have a variety of different pizza's by the slice. Compliments to the pizza gods in the kitchen who made this. Katelyn was also very nice when taking my order. Didn't even have to wait long either. Whatever these guys are getting paid it isn't enough, I will be recommending this to all my friends from now on. read more

Celestino's New York Pizza - Pepperoni Slice - Pizza Near Me - Chico, California

Boyfriend brought me here as it was one of his old college stomping grounds. I ordered a veggie pizza with artichokes, olives , and garlic. SO good!!! We also ordered the lunch set which comes with a slice and side salad and the salads we're ginormous. Idk if it was a mistake or they were trying to get rid of extra romaine but the salads were larger than a regular full size salad in my opinion. Not complaining!! I'll be back! read more

See all

Service was awful. Put on hold for 10 min, only took 2 min to ask questions and order two Medium Pizzas for over $60, and the gal goes to hang up but doesn't quite do it before making comments of "geez"!!! Could probably tell I was ticked about waiting for 10 min to start with but I was polite and didn't just bitch her out. Yes. It's dinner time at 5pm, but her excuse is that she's the only one available. Sounds like a staffing problem to me then. If you're selling a pizza for $35-$42 ea then you can afford another staff member to take orders at dinner rush hour!! No excuses for this. Then it's another 35 min for the order to be ready. Fair, considering the timing. But not the attitude. Next time, you'll get my attitude, or just not my business any longer. Oh, and it was only Wednesday evening. And yep, when I got there it was not all that busy, to where someone would spend 10 min on hold!! ‍ read more

I highly recommend the pie here. I was in town overnight, followed the Yelp reviews and it did not disappoint.

Holy chicken wings. Ordered some wings and a pizza, I knew the pizza was going to be good but damn, wings were best in town so far. Says they have a honey siracha but they don't, a bit of a bummer but hot was good. Also want to say they were covid prepared! Pickup window was clean, operator was masked and transaction was clean! read more