Sicilian Café is way bigger on the inside than it looks. The outdoor bar area was completely full when we arrived, and the interior dining room was packed too--the crowd never really let up, which I think says a lot. We had reservations and were seated immediately. We started with the garlic bread and bruschetta, both of which were excellent. The mozzarella on the bruschetta was especially rich and buttery, definitely a standout. The moscow mule was refreshing, though I wish the ginger had a little more kick, and the cool strawberry mocktail was superb, not too sweet with the mint coming through. For mains, the spaghettini had naturally sweet tomatoes and a thick sauce that clung beautifully to the noodles. The scallops were fresh and sweet, though the mushroom risotto with saffron crème they sat on leaned tangy, which might be hit-or-miss depending on your palate. The chicken piccata was also quite tart, true to style. And the pork special was good too. We ended with the spumoni that was cherry-forward, and tiramisu, which was fantastic. Decadent, yet light and airy. read more

See all

This continues to be our first choice of a "classy" dinner out in Chico. Good food, pleasant ambiance, nice people. I love the attention to detail in the quality of small things. The olive oil and balsamic that go with the excellent bread are top quality and it just goes on from there. We had a lovely time this evening and our server, Rebekah, was especially delightful. read more

We had a party of four for dinner and had a great time. Our server, Robert, was excellent and informative and the food was fine. When we arrived on an early Saturday evening, the place was full and loud. By 6:30 most had left and it became fairly quiet. We had a nice table in the back corner so it was away from most of the noise. read more

Spent my husband's b'day. The hostess was attentive and showed us to our table. I thought it was a little crowded and difficult to maneuver at places. The food and service were very good. read more

This restaurant is has a low key vibe. The food is delicious and made with care. The service really depends on the server. Some are Aces and some are not. My favorite appetizer is the bruschetta blu read more

See all

The food was incredible and the house was very romantic! Sunya and Gianna were the absolute best!!!! I messed up and made my reservation for 730 instead of 7 and my girl had to be at work that night. Gianna was so nice she got us a table even though it was really busy. Our waitress Sunya was just sweet as hell and provided an incredible experience. The food is incredible, the staff are even better! I highly recommend!!!!! read more

Great atmosphere for a date night or for a group dinner! The food is delicious and very Italian! The service is always quick and attentive!

Sicilian cafe is fantastic! The food was excellent and the service even better! Thank you for a wonderful experience.. keep up the great work read more

This was my first time at this restaurant and I have to say, I was extremely impressed!! The veal Parmesan was one of the best I've ever had, the service was impeccable and especially with a table of children! The vibe of the restaurant is really nice! It's a little hidden gem of Chico! I highly recommend this restaurant. The food was amazing. The service was just as amazing! And now has become one of my favorite spots to go! Will definitely be returning!! I wish I could give it more stars!! read more

See all

This has been a family staple for generations and they've still got it! Multiple mocktail options available! I had the strawberry mint one and it was spectacular! Antipasti came out as usual, salami, cheese, olives and carrots for all. We ordered garlic bread, bruschetta caprese and gluten free calamari which was amazing! The Caprese was the winner for those who had bread. We ordered gluten free veal piccata, veal Marsala and two scallop entrees. The green salad with half and half balsamic and bleu dressing is still as good as it was years ago! Thanks for keeping this wonderful quality establishment going for so long! The new location looks great on you! Very well deserved. read more

See all

Absolutely loved our server Rebecca. She was so full of personality and she has wonderful knowledge of the menu. When the dish I wanted was sold out, she recommended the chicken piccata which was amazing. She also recommended that I try the espresso martini. They were Devine. I had 2. Thank you for such a wonderful experience. read more

See all

Have taken the drive from RB for this restaurant several times in the last year, and each time been quite pleased! Classy interior, not stuffy, good energy- obviously people enjoying themselves! Food is first class, for everything we have tried, but keep coming back for the veal marsala-- tender slices of veal in a sauce that is just to die for! Served over pasta with enough sauce to coat the pasta as well. Extensive cocktail menu-- well made! Wine list is short but more than adequate. Last time, I caved to the description of the spumoni and OMG! It was delicious and nothing "green" about it! read more

Food: Chicken Americano = chicken nuggets covered in bottled white sauce. Dull vanilla presentation. Food service: Remarkably slow. Service: The elderly guy running around having everybody singing happy birthday to one table or another is pure annoyance. Best atmosphere for Chuckey Cheese, not where you are there for an adult dinner. Vetrans Day: A real hero was at our table. It was the table with an American flag and a US Marine Core flag displayed prominently. Not one staff member acknowledge that we had a Vetran at the table: not a birthday tool. Drinks: WEAK Too hot and too crowded. But that is usually what it is like. 11/11/2025. 8:30 pm read more

Went here during a very busy time of the year so we expected it to be packed. We waited about an hour for food so we were happy we got there early. Our server explained that a big party had come in and slowed some things down. All of the staff were very kind and attentive. The food was very good and I really enjoyed the complimentary veggie, cheese, and salami platter. read more

See all

Got served the wrong food a couple times but despite the hiccups in the service, the food was really quite good.

What an amazing spot in Chico! Had an amazing fine dining experience with a big group last night and had the most perfect meal. I got the scallops it risotto and it was delicious. We loved robert as our server, we thought he was very attentive to us especially for having so many other tables. Thanks for a great night read more

Wow! Cosi buono! Stopped in after some holiday shopping and had the most delicious lemoncello drop and the famous calamari ----and did not disappoint . The calamari were tender and breaded in a scrumptious seasoning and came with plenty of lemon slices and a delicious dip with a hint of garlic to heighten the bite. We were two and opted for a serving for three as were a tad more hungry than small appie . Highly recommend.' read more

See all

Not bad not bad. Favorite was by far the veal picatta. Savory, salty, tart, and tender. Absolutely delicious. The complimentary bread, oil and balsamic, and the little olive, meat, and cheese plate was fine, but in my opinion, they should just offer one and make them both excellent. Both were fine but nothing to write home about. The chicken soup was the best I ever had and I still think about it. The clam chowder was good but paled in comparison. Service was great. Quick and friendly. No complaints. Ambience was nice, a bit upscale. This place is really popular with elderly folks we noticed. Overall verdict is I'm glad I tried it because i had been wanting to for a long time but it also wasn't good enough for me to want to spend $93 plus tip for 2 people. read more

See all

We had an incredible meal and dining experience last night. The service was attentive and friendly. The food was amazing, especially the Caprese Bruschetta and my Prawn Scampi was the best I've ever had! We'll be back again and again. 2 big thumbs up! What an incredible setting as well. read more

I'm a fan for about 40 years. Our go to for a nice dinner evening out. All the best to these guys!

Good food, nice atmosphere, welcoming staff. They take care in preparing their dishes! I recommend the chicken picatta. Only downside is it takes quite awhile when busy and prices are high. read more

We recently went to the Sicilian Cafe with a party of 7 on a Friday night. We had reservations for 6:00 and the place was lively and busy. We were seated right away and after about 5 minutes our server showed up to take our drink orders. The cocktails were good and arrived about 10 minutes later at which time our server took our food order. we were then ignored for about 20 minutes at which time the anti pasta and bread arrived, for those of you who are good at math that is 35 minutes for the bread to show up. Our soup and salads showed up about 30 minutes after that and the entrees did not arrive until almost 8:00pm. Now we were expecting a leisurely Italian dining experience but it should not take over an hour and a half from ordering to eating. We had an engagement at 8:30 across town and had assumed that 2 hours would be more than enough time for dinner. As it was, by the time we got our food we had to request to go containers and had to leave. Didn't even get to eat our $400 meal. Quite disappointing and an evening killer as one might imagine. I would, however, like to be fair to the establishment. Our server did realize that the food was very delayed and offered to comp us a second round of drinks but since we had an engagement across town we could not take them up on the offer. I would also like to mention that the meal which I am eating as leftovers today is delicious. That said, I will not return to the Sicilian Cafe. read more

This is the second time I have eaten at the Sicilian Cafe and if I could I would give it a 10 Star Rating and our waiter, Robert, a 12 Stars. When I was here before on October 2nd it was my birthday and my daughter and her husband treated me to a fabulous birthday dinner. I have never forgotten the dinner I had, I had the Scallops and I have been waiting for the day I could drive the 50 miles to get back and have them again. I took my two daughters and their husbands for dinner at the Sicilian Cafe. Again the food was the best that you could ever find, any where. Our Waiter, Robert treated us as if we were the only ones he was waiting on. It was like he was watching us and before you could summon him he was there with what ever it was that we needed. I dropped my fork and there he was with a clean one. I watched as he was there for the several other tables he was waiting on. The food was Fantastic and the service was also. It was worth driving the 50 miles and I will do it again. Thanks Robert for a very enjoyable evening. read more

Sicilian Cafe - My two daughters, their husbands and myself, enjoying a fantastic evening and dinner. Thanks again Robert, your service was outstanding. - Italian Near Me - Chico, California

Delicious Pasta, and especially warm espresso brownie dessert. We enjoyed the evening read more

Sicilian Cafe - A warm espresso brownie - Italian Near Me - Chico, California

Um... all reviews and the website say to make reservations but the number is not working?! We triple checked and tried from two phones, a cell and a landline. Maybe a Verizon issue. Update: I appreciate the owners note on the rating. I agree. I wish Yelp had a choice to address this issue. There is no n/a choice. I'll update to 3 which is neutral. And hopefully we can come by next time I'm in Chico and actually try the food! read more

Went here for dinner for the first time on Saturday and I can't believe we waited so long. Our server was Robert and he was lovely! He had great recommendations and everything we ordered was fantastic. The calamari is a must! My husband and I upgraded our salads and they were fresh and delicious. My mom got the regular salad and the Italian dressing was a bit tangy, would order on the side. We loved our entrees! It was nice to be able to try so much. All were incredible but I will be back for the prawns scampi! You can't order wrong here. I highly recommend whatever they have on special! I had the special bolognese and it had amazing flavor. Plus the noodles are so fresh. The whole staff was amazing but especially our server Robert and Finley who helped bus and bring us bread. We came to celebrate my husband and mom's birthday and it was so sweet that they gave us two desserts! I can't wait to go back soon. I recommend a reservation. read more

See all

If I could give negative stars I would. My husband and father-in-law dined of a Wednesday evening. The food was mediocre but what sticks in my head is the service. Not just bad - awful. There were these young servers, fetching beverages, that sort of thing, and they were camped out close to our table. They were having the best time at work and made sure we all knew about it. Laughing, joking, loudly, some slightly inappropriate comments about an elderly woman who had removed her dentures prior to eating her meal. Very hard to enjoy a meal and conversation with all that going on. In addition, my father-in-law had several questions about the menu, and let's just say - our server was visibly annoyed. So, we ate, paid the check, tipped appropriately, and left. I keep seeing their ads on FB - so I blocked them only because I couldn't let the opportunity to comment go by. Sicilian Cafe continuously messages me to try to make it right, and I have asked them to stop. Our experience was so unpleasant, we don't WANT the opportunity to "try again." I have read these other reviews, so maybe my experience was just a random off-night. But for the $$$$$, I would definitely have expected a better ambiance, atmosphere, and professionalism all the way around. read more

Every dish is amazing ! How do I know? Cause when we come here we all take a sample off each other's plate ! We always have a great time here!! Drinks and service every time is on point ! read more

This heat has been relentless, decided to go for an early dinner, had not been to Sicilian Cafes new spot downtown, loved the new location, classy yet welcoming, the whole staff was very friendly and the vibe in general was enjoyable, the entree I chose was yummy and full of flavor, it was a nice self treat, highly recommend if you are looking for a nice meal w a good atmosphere, enjoyed their background music that was playing. read more

Sicilian Cafe - Italian Near Me - Chico, California

See all

i had dinner at Sicilian Cafe two nights ago. The food was outstanding. Lobster ravioli topped with spinach was so incredibly flavorful. The service was attentive and made dining pleasure. And the room is very classy. read more

Best restaurant in Chico bar none. I used to go here when it was on Walnut street back in the 80s and now they have moved but still doing everything right. I left Chico after college and raised a family in the Bay Area. My wife and I moved back to Chico 6 years ago and the first thing I did was take her to the Sicilian Cafe. It didn't disappoint. The food and service is always top notch and the elegant atmosphere makes for a wonderful "fine dining" experience. Everything on the menu is exceptional but we always gravitate towards the calamari appetizer with scampi and/or chicken Americana. This place is a solid gold winner! If you haven't tried it you're missing out. read more

Tastes good good textures nice hostess a And staff servers . We had a pesto creamy fettuccine- and Fraser salad and drinks read more

Delicious food and great service from Robert Highly recommend this place when in town read more

I went to this restaurant for my birthday with my husband a couple days ago and we both had such a great time. The restaurant is beautiful, the staff is friendly, service was great, and the food was phenomenal! Everything we tried was seriously top notch, and as a plus, there is a ton of parking outside this place, right across the street from the parking lot where the farmers market sets up Saturdays. We made a reservation but since we went on a Tuesday I'm not sure we really needed one, but we like to be safe than sorry! Def will come back again. read more

Sicilian Cafe - Spaghettini entree with meatballs, salmon plate - Italian Near Me - Chico, California

See all

THE food was absolutely delicious. I ordered the veal scallopino with pasta. The sauce was wonderful. It also came with nicely seasoned vegetables and warm bread for our little group of three. It was a lot of food and I must confess I ate EVERYTHING! No take-home box for me! My husband ordered the bolognese and he took most of it home because he was so full. The next day when he finished it he said it was fabulous. Our waiter, Robert was a terrific server, fun and delightful, but he was also efficient and always aware of our needs. Additionally, the atmosphere of the restaurant is elegant. I would like to mention to the reviewer who complained that he wasn't treated well (had to sit at the bar) because he didn't have a reservation, may have noticed that this restaurant is PACKED for obvious reasons and a reservation is recommended if you don't want to be seated at the bar! Really liked this restaurant and when we return to Chico I will definitely dine here! Recommend highly! read more

We went there on a Saturday night only to find out that if you don't have a reservation you have to sit at the bar with a limited menu. Ridiculous! We planned on going there and ordering many of their specialty dishes, appetizers, wine etc. and we were unable to do that since we didn't have reservation. They are a small restaurant in a small city. No need for that. read more

Food was decent. Sat at the bar and there was only 2 other people at bar when we did. Large CSU event going on. Bartenders failed to make any eye contact. Bar back asked us if he could assist us then bartender berated him for taking our orders. Then young male bartender was so perturbed by water spots on wine glasses he had to go outside and then proceeded to bad mouth the bar back to rest of staff. Totally unprofessional. Not impressed. Think this place could do better. read more

The scallop risotto is to die for. One of the best restaurants in town. Amazing salads, the steak is wonderful, and the alcoholic drinks are amazing. A must go for a date night. The service is very good as well. read more

I admit I LOVED the quaint little spot the Sicilian was at over the creek, but this new spot (formerly Christian Michaels) is perfect! The food was amazing. Bruchetta was on point (and I'm picky as I make my own), the muscles were perfect combined with the noodles, and Mty FAVORITE was the calamari. Just ask them to bring out real cocktail sauce, and they will accommodate. Very attentive staff. Can't wait to go back! Ps: they are not afraid of garlic....for me this is a good thing (very good thing) read more

Sicilian Cafe - Capri Brushetta & Calamari for 2! - Italian Near Me - Chico, California

See all

We had a fantastic dinner. The staff is great. Great setting for a tasty dinner. We will definitely be back! read more

Sicilian Cafe - Our pre-dinner cocktails! - Italian Near Me - Chico, California