I'm holding back the fifth star only because I've only had their food one time. However, that one time was very good. I would definitely go back. read more

A small town pizzeria. There are about 10 tables inside. They have a very extensive menu. I've had their pizza before, and it is good. However I wasn't in the mood for pizza. So I ordered a pulled pork sandwich, some mac n cheese, and a small onion rings. The Sandwich was good but ovet priced. It wasn't an $8 or $9 dollar sandwich, more like $5 or $6. Still good though. The Mac was a little soupy which worried me, however it tasted excellent. Lastly the onion rings were good, nothing special, but still very good. Overall a solid 4 stars. Would I return? Yes I will. read more

See all

I am so thankful that this is our town's Pizza restaurant because it is really good! Tons of options to choose from, excellent breadsticks (you have to try the garlic cream cheese with them), pizza is always fresh and tasty, some of my favorite potato wedges too. You have to try them out! read more

Central Lake Pizza - BLT Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Central Lake, Michigan

See all

Classic car themed pizza joint in Central Lake. If you like a good pie or a nice grinder, don't skip this little gem! I highly recommend their veggie options and I'm a meat lovers type of guy. Great crusts and tasty toppings. Their dough makes the pizza and the bread makes the grinders just wonderful! I highly suggest hitting a public lake spot nearby when enjoying this pizza! read more

See all

This pizza was so delicious. We got half pepperoni and half mushroom. Everything tasted so fresh. The dough and sauce were amazing. Excellent customer service. read more

Central Lake Pizza - Large pizza. - Pizza Near Me - Central Lake, Michigan

Really thick heavy pizza. If you like a thin crispy crust this isn't for you. Otherwise, give it a try. Very few people eat in so if you go to the restaurant and there's no one eating in be aware that you might have a long wait, there could be 10 or 15 takeout pizzas in front of you They do offer free delivery If you are local. It's $7.50 if you live quite a ways away read more

stopped at restaurant and 3 pizzas, when to pick up when told time would be ready. Pizzas were not ready as they ran out of sauce. no mention when we place order or phone call. went back 2nd time to pick up "supposedly manager sent a coworker over and gave me 2 of the pizzas they were just making the 3rd one. took the 2 pizzas as kids were hungr. went back in 10 -15 minutes to get the 3rd pizza, and was met on the sidewalk. the supreme pizza didn't have mushrooms on it but was on the bbq chicken. very dissapointed. read more

The Manager Mark, and assistant Dylan were amazing. They put together an emergency order for our 16 guys on a golf trip. Unbelievable customer service, and great pizza and breadsticks. I really couldn't believe it. Thanks guys! -George read more

This place is simply amazing! The pizza here was very fresh, flavorful, and one of the best we ever had anywhere in the country!! Highly recommend if you're in Bellaire. read more

This week I was camping at Barnes Park campground with our friends from Traverse City. They suggested pizza for our Friday night dinner and we agreed to it. So if you've read my reviews you know my wife eats Gluten Free. They said Central Pizza is good. They have a Gluten Free pizza. She had this pizza several years ago but couldn't remember if it was any good. Unfortunately this time it was terrible. I wasn't crispy at all even when she put it in our oven to reheat it it wouldn't crisp up. I give them One start for trying but that's it. Now for my pizza... I tried their "Individual " which is 10". I had the Supreme, it's loaded up with everything. Unfortunately it wasn't great the crust was just Okay the toppings were just Okay, therefore the pizza was just ok. I guess it because it's a small town pizza joint and they don't have to be good there is no competition. Maybe the town folk there think it's great because there is no other. Idk?!? If up in the Central Lake area and need a pizza all I can say is it's edible and don't expect too much. read more

Central Lake Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Central Lake, Michigan

The pizza here is insanely tasty! ,but thats not all they have pretty much anything you have a taste for , Fish? got it Chicken? Got it Salad? They got a salad bar. The dining area is big enough for a group and the whole inside has a very cute 50s decor. I would highly recommend this place over any pizza place in antrim county. read more

Central Lake Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Central Lake, Michigan

They screwed up my first pizza, then the second. Then they charged $23 for the pizza showned in their Yelp menu at $17.50. The guy said oh we raised our prices! This is after 40 extra minutes standing in their bldg. will not go their again! read more

Of course we had to stop here while we are on vacation for the 4th of July! Fast service, we feel they are reasonable on their prices! Always tastes great & never disappoints :) read more

See all

My fiance and I came out to Central Lake all the way from Los Angeles, CA for a vacation and to visit my parents. We are very much used to the fast paced style of Southern California where you can get anything anytime you want it, so coming out here even for a week was quite an adjustment for us. The second day we were here, we had a craving for Pizza. Our first inclination was to find a Papa John's or Brick Oven, but we found that the closest one was really too far away for us to bother driving. We checked the local fare and found Classic Pizza. We ordered a large half cheese half Italian sausage, and the price was totally reasonable. $14 and it was done in about 15 minutes. We really didn't mind picking it up, the extra effort was totally worth it. The flavor of the Pizza was delicious! The Italian sausage was not rubbery at all and was neither too spicy or bland. The cheese was perfectly melted and the crust was crunchy and chewy, just how Pizza should be. We've gotten pizzas from here TWICE since we came to Central Lake! In additon to that, we had some sandwiches the other day, and my fiance and I both had the Fish sandwiches. They were FABULOUS. Very fresh and full of flavor. I would not hesitate to order here! If you are looking for something delicious and quick for a reasonable amount of money, check out Classic Pizza. They WON'T dissappoint! read more

The food here is amazing. They make their own dough and not skimpy on the toppings. The garlic cheese dip is my favorite and I always order it! read more

Very disappointed. Pizza looked great but crust/dough was raw. Too much cheese so it wouldn't cook.

I always look forward to coming to Central Lake for Classic Pizza. I make sure when I am making the meal plans, this place is chosen for lunch or dinner. Their veggie pizza is amazing!! read more

Amazing pizza! Super great staff and fast service even while packed! 100% recommend for a quick vacation bite

Spare me the frozen crust. Pretty amateur guys. Toppings appeared canned as well. I want to like it because it is the only pizza in a reasonable drive from the family cabin. read more

This Place has the best pizza in the county! The menu is Car themed, and the decor is right out of the 50s. The Prices are fair for what you are getting. Buckle up and enjoy the pie! read more

Wow great pizza in a small town! Staff was awesome. We have a food allergy and they made sure everything was prepared perfect.

What an amazing place! The ladies who were working suggested a place for us to enjoy Torch Lake. They were patient and ensured we knew the directions. The pizza was so good!! Perfect, food, hospitality and atmosphere!! A small town pizza place doing it right! read more

The Z-28 (vegetarian special) pizza was excellent. Loaded generously with olives, artichokes, feta, etc. Crust was medium thickness and still good after 15 minute drive home. The leftover piece was good for breakfast the next day too :) I'd give it a 5 for take out (the pizza itself) but only a 3 for decor if you decide to eat there... read more

One specialty of this place is the grinder sandwiches. The turkey grinder is amazing and my wife and I often split a full. Very friendly staff, a great place in a great northern town. read more

What a great pizza and bargain. My husband and I ordered 2 small pizzas. The BBQ chicken and the vegetarian. Delicious and very generous toppings. We would definitely order from here again when we visit. Very pleasant person on phone when I ordered July 26 th 2014. Only request I would make would be to have choice of oils to brush pizza dough with before toppings get put on. read more

On Fridays they have all you can eat fish & fries... Yummy! We also went back for pizza and cheesy bread which was good as well! Great service and atmosphere. read more

No skimping on the toppings. Plenty of sausage and pepperoni. Sauce was good, no too sweet. Crust did not seem homemade but more like a frozen crust. read more