Decided to give them a try for the first time. The building and atmosphere is great. They also have a small patio out back behind the building. The staff was awesome and the food is great. The customer base is highly local and friendly. Overall good vibes at Chatham Tap. If you are looking for uber new or clean and polished places Mass Ave is not the place for that. If you are looking for historic feels with a bit of dive bar scene and friendly bar vibes - this is the place for you. read more

The Chatham Tap has become a semi-monthly staple for us, especially for their wings--crispy, flavorful, and easily some of our favorites when they're on point. The Reuben pizza is also a must-try, with a unique flavor you won't find anywhere else. Takeout can be hit or miss, though. Sometimes it's perfect and ready to go; other times, we've gotten sauceless wings or, as pictured, a less-than-acceptable quality. The biggest downside for us is the bar service at the Fishers location. The bartenders can sometimes seem more focused on drinking and chatting with regulars than actually helping customers, which can make for a frustrating experience. That said, when the service is good, The Chatham Tap is hard to beat for great food and a casual vibe. read more

See all

I had a gift card from a friend so we stopped in for a drink. I like the vibe here. It's UK pub + dive bar vibes. The food was phenomenal. I absolutely loved the wings. And you can't go wrong with fish and chips. Definitely a chill vibe I'd you're on Mass Ave and looking for a good hang. read more

Chatham Tap Mass. Ave. - Stopped in for a couple drinks and some football - Pubs Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Parking wasn't the best experience at first, but that quickly turned around when we walked in. Although we ordered takeout, the service was top notch during the short time we were there. Evan, the server who helped us, was the sweetest and very accommodating. We need more Evans in restaurants! All the food we ordered was delicious. A must eat when in Indy Downtown and the War Pig didn't disappoint! read more

See all

Service was very slow but friendly. Very disappointed with the food... who makes a Ruben sandwich with two strips of corned beef? The setting was alright read more

Chatham Tap Mass. Ave. - Pubs Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

If you know me, you know I love wings & they did not disappoint. I've always heard about Chatham Tap & wanted to check it out so my friend ordered us some wings to go since we were having movie night. He was just bragging that him & his friends had some so it was only right haha. We had the lemon pepper and signature sauce & they were so good & crisp. I'm not a big lemon pepper person but these were actually good. The lemon flavor wasn't overwhelming, which I can appreciate. The signature sauce is the right amount sweet & spicy & paired with ranch, chef's kiss. For it to be a to-go order, the wings were still hot & fresh. They were so good that I also went with my family this weekend haha. Kyle was our sever & he was really cool. They messed up our order but fixed it immediately without us asking. I honestly feel like they did more than they needed to but that's great customer service! I had a margarita, it was perfectly balanced, not too much liquor & not too sweet. It reminds you of any typical bar, similar to the show Cheers haha. There was TV's all over that were showing a boxing match & college football. For an early Saturday night, it wasn't overly crowded. We were able to be seated & greeted immediately. Our food took maybe 20-30 minutes to bring out but it was all delicious! We had mozzarella sticks, potato skins, fries (btw, I love French fries & these were elite!) & wings. I say all of this to say, I see why they say it's some of the best wings in Indy. I'll be back again! read more

See all

The wings are plenty and amazing. They have a welcoming staff, the scenery atmosphere is calm and relaxing. Great place to chill next time I'm there I'm trying the War Pig which is so deep fried pork chop sandwich. Met a guy there name Kevin, he's a good dude talked with him for nearly two hours. Great conversation about traveling around Indiana even shared with me some places to check out. I most definitely will. If my movie didn't start at 10:15 pm I'm certain I would have closed the place. read more

Chatham Tap Mass. Ave. - Wings - Pubs Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Much more than an soccer bar. Food, service, and atmosphere are all on point. Chatham Tap is great for watching morning Premier League soccer matches with fellow Indy soccer fans. They have a great breakfast menu which enhances the game watching experience. I had a breakfast burrito on my last visit. That plus a coffee hit the spot. This bar has an old, dark wood, warm, vintage vibe to it. I recently came by for lunch with a colleague. We both wanted to try the wings which we have heard good things about. The Prince Dean's Angel Wings with the signature sauce were very tasty with a good crunch to the exterior of the wing. We arrived right after they opened and as it became busier, the solo bartender/server did a great job at remaining attentive to each customer. Excited to try more lunch and dinner options on my next visit. Or more breakfast options when I come to watch another Arsenal game. Up the Gunners. read more

Chatham Tap Mass. Ave. - Prince Dean's Angel Wings Half Order - Pubs Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

My husband and I grabbed a late dinner here with my sister and brother-in-law on a weeknight and it was a lot more enjoyable than the other times we've stopped in on the weekend (much quieter, usually it's too loud to really hear other people at your table talking). Our server was nice and our food and drinks came out fast. 3 of us ordered wings and my sister ordered a buffalo chicken sandwich. We also ordered a round of mystery shots and their fried pickles for an appetizer. Everything was fresh and tasty and I really enjoyed the weeknight ambiance over the chaotic weekend one. read more

Chatham Tap Mass. Ave. - Pubs Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

There was trivia on going with strict phone rules so no photos :( buuuuut it was awesome. We sat at the bar with no problem and had a great time. It's a small cramped space which is fine with us. Good beer selection with a few British beer options. The portobello mushroom fries were just okay and pretty salty. The fish and chips were perfect. And the war pig was good but I couldn't taste or find the hollandaise sauce. read more

So we're in town for the Royal Rumble and honestly didn't have much planned outside of that. We had heard that Indianapolis was a quiet town with not much exciting stuff to do so we hadn't put too much time aside to explore. We had just come from Chicago and experienced all kinds of delicious staples in the area and were expecting Indy to be a considerable step down in terms of food. Boy were we wrong. The one and only place I had saved in town was Chatham Tap after a quick Google search about famous local foods. I don't think I had ever eaten a pork tenderloin, and if I had it definitely wasn't as a sandwich. The menu looked absolutely stacked with delicious creations after creation but one immediately stood out - the WAR PIG. A name can only get you so far, though. Could this well named menu item live up to its hype? A look at the ingredients would suggest yes but how would the execution follow through? This might be the greatest sandwich ever created. Perfectly fried pork tenderloin that was soft to the bite, a runny yolk dripping onto the layer of chips, thick and crispy bacon, THREE different kinds of cheese and a jalapeño hollandaise that I think I could drink with a straw. I didn't think my weekend could get any better than it already was but I can confidently say that this culinary experience was the highlight of my trip. Not the food in the other city, not even the great wrestling event I was actually there for... THIS was the gem of the weekend. Bravo, Chatham Tap and Indianapolis.. Bravo. read more

Chatham Tap Mass. Ave. - WAR PIG - Pubs Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Chatham tap is a cozy sports bar on Mass Ave that serves some fantastic food. The restaurant is seat yourself and sometimes space can be limited, but the service is great and the wings are amazing. The wings are incredibly crispy and massive. Definitely up there for some of the best wings in Indy. The nachos were ok, but tasted almost burnt and didn't have enough cheese. Best wing flavors: - House sauce: Absolute must try. Tastes almost like a tangy teriyaki sauce but even better. Can't go wrong with getting just an order of these - Hot Buffalo: classic buffalo. Can't go wrong - Chipotle apricot: definitely spicy but not as much flavor as I was expecting - Mango habanero: the sauce was a little too sweet, but another classic sauce. Overall must visit if you are a fan of wings with their signature sauce and incredibly crunchy wings. Other flavors and appetizers can be a hit or miss, but will be back just for the signature sauce wings. read more

See all

Great place on mass Ave. Me and my friend got a couple beers and some nachos. The nachos were just an appetizer, but it was HUGE so we didn't even need more food. Lots of good beers to choose from here. The food menu had many options too. The service was a bit slow, but good overall. It was very cozy inside with a TON of soccer decorations. They let us put F1 on TV to watch the race and they have the Indy Car race on another TV. Great spot for after on races on a Sunday. Check this place out! read more

Chatham Tap Mass. Ave. - Downeast blackberry cider - Pubs Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Chatham Tap is my favorite cozy bar on a chilly day. They have a decent beer selection, including some local drafts, and pretty standard pub food. The atmosphere makes this a perfect spot to watch a game or play some Euchre. read more

Chatham Tap Mass Ave never misses! I have never been disappointed and I have been there countless times. The Prince Dean wings are arguably the best wings in the city. However, the garlic ranch and chicken tenders (with the signature sauce) may be the best kept secrets. Getting the spinach artichoke dip is a MUST and it comes with the crispy pita chips. I also really love their salads! You just can't go wrong. It's a unique soccer bar and a pretty quaint atmosphere. The customer service is efficient and consistent. read more

See all

This is our fav pub in town. My husband calls it his happy place. THE best place in the city to watch a soccer (football) match if you like sharing the energy with a group of fans. With Andrew or Cory behind the bar and Evanne or Jasmine waiting tables you're sure to have great service too. If you go for an early match, my fav is the breakfast sandwich. They're known for great wings and chicken tenders. I cannot say enough good things about their fried chicken salad though! Generous portion, lots of fresh ingredients like cucumber and grape tomatoes. It's SO good. You know it's good when the three of us today all ordered it! read more

Chatham Tap Mass. Ave. - Down East Cider on tap is always good! My hubby always gets a glass of Guinness. - Pubs Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

Top drawer 21+ British mood, excellent menu showcasing a blended variety, and draft selection giving us original colony all the fun without throwing tea into a harbor. My buddy and I both did a sandwich, chicken, and Reuben. My Reuben was small and dry but paired fantastic with a Speckled Hen beer. A drink bitter forward smooth sipping alongside rather jerky textured beef, splash of sauerkraut, dressing on the iconic rye, and the British mad football voiceover in the background made for one unique dinner ideal for seeking out something special on Mass Ave. There's good seating, outdoor patio right next to the running path, and so much to try on the menu! Service was solid, bathrooms small but clean, and parking the usual annoyingly extra time to pay during the week rounded out the downtown stop. Can easily recommend Chatham as a definitive overseas eats along with my favorite Indianapolis spot right up the street: Bodhi. read more

See all

The customer service is great. The place is a kinds small inside (more like a pub) and the outdoor seating isn't big at all but the food is good. I ordered a taco salad with chicken and chipotle- ranch and asked to remove the sour cream. I have to say this was one of the best taco salads I've ever had!!! It was so refreshing and healthy, except for the fried shell was too oily for me. Overall I would recommend this dish and would order it again. read more

Chatham Tap Mass. Ave. - Chicken Taco Salad - Pubs Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Came for lunch on a Sunday and they are seriously a British Soccer Pub. The place was packed as I'm sure it usually is on soccer days. Problem was that there was one server for the whole place - based on other reviews this is common. However, it took a long time to place order and then we didnt get the wings because they were given to another table who came in after us. It really was a shit show - unless you are really into soccer - I'd go around the corner to somewhere else read more

This is a nice little pub on mass ave. There is tons of metered parking out front. They have dinning room seating, bar seating, and patio seating out back. The bar is a full bar and the patio is partially enclosed and has a little alley way behind it. They had some nice soul music playing like "she's a Bad Mama Jamma" and some Issac Hayes and Stevie Wonder songs. I really liked it. It was bumping. You will find televisions that are placed all around the pub, which are playing sports or sports news. Near the back is one of the electric juke box machines, where you can select your music, for a fee. My server was very nice and helpful. The menu is packed with pub favorite options including burgers, sandwiches, salads, tenderloins and their world famous wings. They also have a beer and cocktail menu. I ordered the wings (which I had heard so much about) and the rueben sandwich with a side of onion rings. It did not take long to get my food. I would say between 5 and 8 minutes. The onion rings were tasty. some of the best I have had. They are home made and not the frozen beer battered ones that you can get from Sams Club. They were fresh and flavorful. The wings were pretty good, not the best I have had, but up at the top. They were somewhat crispy on the outside and had a good tasting glaze. My reuben was also fresh, hot and delicious. It tasted very good. My meal as a whole was awesome. The Chatham has some very good food. The vibe in this place is nice in chill and gives off an Irish pub type of feel. It is decorated in a soccer theme. There are old pictures and soccer scarfs hanging throughout. I am glad that I was able to make it here and check this place out. It lived up to all of the hype I was hearing about it. I highly recommend checking this place out. I will definitely be back soon. read more

See all

great staff and great food. this is for the Mass Ave location. there are locations on Butler's campus and in Fishers!

Chatham Tap can do no wrong in my eyes! The food is a homerun every time. The wings will have you coming back for more and more. I don't know what is in the signature sauce but it is a perfect blend of spicy and sweet. I will be honest I haven't tried any of the other sauces for the wings because I don't know if they can live up the signature sauce. A friend and I ordered the garlic cheese chips for an appetizer and they were literally chef's kiss. Bar atmosphere isn't always my favorite but coming in on a Monday night we didn't encounter many people and we could hear each other speak. The servers were very personable and helped to make the experience even more solid. 100% recommend this place to anyone who likes wings and bar style food. read more

Chatham Tap Mass. Ave. - signature Prince Deans Angel Wings - Pubs Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

I haven't stopped thinking about these wings since I had them. And Ima say it... these are the best wings in Indianapolis. Honestly, I held off on getting these for a long time due to the price. I couldn't quite justify paying nearly $20 for 12 wings. But after having them, I understand why they cost what they do. These aren't your typical wings that don't have a lot of meat and are messily tossed in a basic bbq sauce. These wings are hearty. There's plenty of meat on each one. The sauce is absolutely delicious. I don't even know how to describe it, you just have to go try it! read more

Chatham Tap Mass. Ave. - Prince Deans Angel Wings - Pubs Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Best wings in Indianapolis hands down. Unsure how it took so long to figure this out but I'm glad I have! I always order the teriyaki wings with a side of fries. The wings are soooooooo crispy and sauced up. It's the perfect ratio. The fries are also 10/10 - perfectly crisp and seasoned. I simply cannot order anything else from here. read more

Came to Indy from AZ to visit family, my brother recommended this place and said they had great wings. It was Wednesday night so wasn't very busy at all. The guy who was our server didn't seat us for 20 min; he was doing busy work (rolling silverware, wiping down condiments,etc) while there were plenty of open tables. After we finally got a table, we had to ask for menus after waiting another 10-15 minutes. When ordering drinks my brother asked for a round of waters because we just left an event, he brought 2/7 waters requested. This guy slammed the waters down on the table and just had an attitude like he didn't want to be there. After we ordered drinks we never saw our server again. He never came to take our food order -- we had to go to the bar and ask for our checks and that's when he finally came back to our table. Needless to say I am writing this review because he took it upon himself to leave a tip after wasting an hour of our time for one drink and one person in our group never even received her drink which was just a water. I understand sometimes people have bad days and I don't know what his issue was but the tipping point was this man fraudulently leaving himself a tip! Horrible service and crooked employees who feel entitled to others hard earned money when they did not provide any service. read more

I love Chatham Tap! Great spot to catch a game and grab a beer or cocktail. I've never had food I didn't like, but I haven't tried a lot because I always get the wings. CT has the BEST wings in Indianapolis, no debate. It can get pretty crowded on weekends, so depending on your preference, visit on a week night for a more relaxed vibe. Check this place out if you're a soccer fan, or if you just want incredible wings. read more

Chatham Tap Mass. Ave. - Inside - Pubs Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

Good restaurant, food, and brews. Perfect place to come and grab a bite, a beer, and a game. I had the Buffalo chicken sandwich which was huge and chips. They were tasty. My friend had the steak sandwich which she did not enjoy. Overall, a good service, food, and a nice vibe. read more

I never thought to order pizza here but it's fire!! My favorite chicken sandwich spot overall but the pizza is really good! Service was great too. Our waiter Kyle was awesome! read more

Efficient comes to mind as I ponder my experience at Chatham Tap. It was busy when my friends and I walked in, but a small group was just starting to get up. We grabbed a high table in the back by the only restroom. The waiter, Bartender came over after a few minutes and wiped our table and got our drinks. The menu is pretty large and I was at a loss on what to get, so I opted for the chili. My wife got the Nacho's with Hummus and it was pretty amazing. My other friends were happy, and one guy couldn't finish his Reuben. The Bartender checked on us occasionally and we had a great time. read more

Chatham Tap Mass. Ave. - Most awesome Natcho platter - Pubs Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Customer service was abysmal. The server/host was basically just rude to us but actually hostile to the table next to us. The table next to us left. The only unfriendly place I've been on Mass Ave. read more

Best macaroni and cheese hands down! This was delicious! Our server was very attentive and got to us right away. Everyone at the table got something different and it all tasted great! This does give off a very sports bar vibe but it's still great to go to even if you don't care about what's playing. It's not a huge location which I kind of enjoyed. I can't wait to be back! read more

I had been hearing so much about the wings at Chatham Tap, and decided to try them out on my lunch break. I ordered online, and when I went to pick up, I was barely greeted. I didn't get friendly vibes and my wings took much longer to come out than expected. But, I must say that the wings were worth the wait. I got their signature sauce and the wings were perfect. They were crispy on the outside and very delicious. I do think that the service could be a little better, but I'd definitely return for those wings. read more

On the popular Mass avenue. The food is very good, including the pizza, and they have the best wings. Good selection of beers and you can sit either inside or outside. Comfortable place even if your by yourself. read more

This place absolutely sucked horrible service big back chick behind the bar wasnt trying to give us any type of service walked in couldnt get a drink sat for 20 minutes with no service then when we decided we where tired of waiting and tried to get the bartenders attention, we got ignored and DENIED A WATER smh read more

We experienced the most rude service I've ever encountered. I worked in the service industry for years and could not have imagined being as rude as the staff here. We used to love this place (the food is great), but we won't be returning. Unbelievable that a place could treat customers like they do. read more

Prince Wings are insane! Some sort of honey chipotle sauce on it, and wow, so good! Don't recommend bringing a party of more than 4, it gets realllly cramped. Our waiter was nice, and brought everything out just fine. Again, you need to try these wings! read more

I can't stop coming back for the house wings here, so good! Our server Kyle did great coming around to check on us and refilling our drinks. It was a great to kick it there and watch the pacers game on the big screen behind the bar. read more

Chatham Tap Mass. Ave. - Pubs Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Customer service was good. I've been here a couple of times and it's always a good time. Place is little and clustered. They also have a outside seating though it's only one table. This place is more of a sports bar and its gay friendly. To begin with the food here is pretty great I've gotten the chicken tenders and wings and they have been tasty and delicious. Also both of those platters are big portions so you'll definitely get full. In addition in big sport events they get really busy. Most of the time there's a line waiting for the place to open. Furthermore I really recommend trying this place out. read more

Had a good time! The service was good here. Quick. The food was great i had the lettuce wraps and burger as was my friends pizza and wings! It's a good pub! read more

Night crew was a vibe. Came back for more wings and they were just as good the first time I had them! Cool, friendly service and great food