I love the building. In fact, if the menu were better, the building would add another star, maybe even two. Or at least truth in advertising: Caribbean cuisine, not "Creole"?
I was disappointed with the selection of Haitan ("Creole") food. It is more of a Caribbean melange, and we were expecting Haitian meals. And seeing Jamaican jerk on the menu was kind of a turnoff. When we asked about the lack of Haitain options, we were told that so much of the food took a long time to prepare and could not be made and held. I agreed, for a minute, and then thought about the traditional meals we make at home. We eat the leftovers; they reheat fine. While restaurant cooking is different than home, I'm not buying it. My guess is more that the market just doesn't do well enough with a true Haitian menu. That said, I need to give this place some credit. They serve goat which is a turnoff for some, and it is good. They also serve seafood, though, no red snapper (traditional Haitian cuisine). Also, I would have loved to see Haitian names with English descriptions on every dish.
We went on Saturday after checking out the butterflies at Frederik Meijer Garden. There were three tables with customers when we arrived. One had ordered, two had not. There was one waiter, who may very well be a son or other relative of Olga. He was young and not entirely comfortable responding to questions from my Haitian companion. He handled them okay, but since I expect Chez Olga is somewhat of an outpost for Haitians that end up in Grand Rapids, I thought he would have done better. He was a pleasant waiter, though not overly attentive, and frankly the restaurant could have used another set of hands in the dining room. Thankfully, he wasn't surly like the staff we have experienced at other Caribbean restaurants.
We were considering taking home pate, so I am glad we started with the combinationa appetizer. The pate were not Haitian-style. They actually reminded me more of Jamaican patties, fried. I was longing for the super flaky crust of Haitian pate, but no. The plantains, shrip and accra were good, solid, fried, nothing fancy. I enjoyed the strawberry sauce with the accra and shrimp. The pikliz (Haitian cole slaw) was mediocre. It was far too salty for my taste, and I couldn't pull out all the flavors. The level of spiciness for it was fine for me, but the salt was over the top.
For main courses, we ended up with goat curry and goat ragu. They were fine. Unfortunately, we were so excited for Haitian entrees that they were just okay. The goat was well cooked, and both dishes were well sauced. The ragu had mushrooms, which were good.
For me, the best items were the corossol, which was incredibly fresh and homemade, and Haitian coffee. The coffee was beautifully thick and rich.
Overall, this restaurant seems to serve its market well. As we were eating several groups of college kids, some with their parents, arrived, and it was easy to see that they love this place. The food is good. I think we may have hyped it up too much in our heads and were just expecting more Haiti. read more