Four stars was a really tough call, as I would love to give Chi Spacca a five. I had the opportunity to dine there on a Saturday night at the chef's table, which was an experience in itself. I got to watch them prepare the charcuterie, the salads, the sides, and those amazing flame cooked gargantuan steaks right before my eyes, and boy was I entertained! Foodie heaven fun, especially for one who is also an avid cook. While I loved my experience at the bar counter, it is also the reason for my one star deduction. I dined with my wife, who also loved everything, but dining with just two people is probably not the best idea here, as you can fill up faster than you realize, well before the prized main appears.
We started off with the charcuterie platter, and enjoyed all of it. It came with a panko crusted fried trotter cake (pigs feet meat) with a nice aioli, two thick pieces of a chunky country pate, two different salami's, and "pig butter", which is rendered, piggy fat with tiny bits of pork. This was all excellent. One of the salamis had a floral note, and the other was reminiscent of Spanish chorizo. Although this was very good, I'd skip it next time, if again dining as a pair only. Otherwise bring it on.
Next was the focaccia di recco. This is huge, like a large pizza. The crust is thin and crispy, sort of like a thin, crispier but light, croissant bread. Delicious, especially with that soft, slightly salty neutral cheese. This dish is pretty subtle, but excellent.
We ordered the much anticipated bone marrow beef pie, and our waiter suggested we add a green component. Good idea. We were presented our pie and butter lettuce simultaneously, which was a good thing. We both found that we were already craving the crisp lettuce, and it was a nice accompaniment to the heavy pie and mashed potatoes. The salad was merely a stack of nestled leaves of progressively smaller butter lettuce, each leaf dressed nicely with the vinaigrette. Seems pretty pricey for just lettuce, but it was very good.
The mashed potatoes: This was like eating potato candy. I wanted more, and more, but was already way, way too full. I had a few bites and broke into the pie, and couldn't enjoy it. Damn. The horror! I was so full, getting that ate-too-much sick thing, that I could only force down a few small bites, and I was completely defeated. Done in by heavy, rich, meaty goodness. I did try the pie nuked again the next day. The buttery, flaky crust was perfect. The filling of mushrooms and cheek was spot on, but densely rich. Too much for two, but a nice sharing meal for four or more. The base for the "gravy" was clearly a well-made uber-rich stock, reduced to heavenly, meat-flavorful, almost sweet, savory braise.
Service: Everyone, and I mean everyone, was amazing. So friendly, so attentive, so enthusiastic. Not a single sigh, grimace, or frown all night. Just smiles, laughter, and tons of attention. Our waiter was the most fun of any I can remember, ever. His name is Bobby. If you are lucky he will be yours too.
So the four star rating has nothing to do with the food or the service, or the physical space. All of those are five star worthy. I just feel compelled to bring to attention the difficulty of enjoying more than a couple of things if you are dining as a couple. The experience is more considerate of parties of four, or preferably six. I would like to see options of smaller portions, but realize that's not the intent of the experience. I knew this going in, so it's definitely on me, but just want others to know. Eating at the chef's table is fun, but be prepared to spend a lot, and bring home a ton of leftovers, if you want to try more than a few things, which you will, because everything is so darn good. read more