We've been to this place several times and sent friends and family there as well. The food has always been good but tonight was a disaster. We had to wait over an hour for our food - a gyro sandwich and some hot wings - nearly two hours total. My wife asked to speak to the manager and all he asked was "how was your food?"; didn't care that we were spending our 48th wedding anniversary there to have a memorable time. We're going back one more time to use the rest of our "gift card" and we're done with this place; it's 35 miles from our home. read more

2nd try here and once again disappointed. Getting good service is the first problem Waitresses both times hard to find and forgets to bring items repeatedly and slow so slow They tell me their garlic cheese bread appetizer is great- it wasn't It was a sub roll cut in half and cheese melted on top - it was a poor example of good garlic bread So what can I say The pan pizza was just a disappointment too. Crust was bland Anyway lots of others choices in this area- may not come here again read more

My wife is from Chicago and loves the Pizza here. We love to order the pizza for family nights. We were extreme disappointed when we arrived at 8:40 pm for a date night. The restaurant was listed online as closing at 10:00 pm. When we arrived the servers were slow to help us. After several min a server came to tell us the restaurant changed the closing time to 9:00 pm. We asked when they changed the time and the server responded, "uh...just today". We walked out the door to see the restaurant hours open till 10 painted on the door!! Very disappointed in this type of service. Don't know if we'll be back. read more

I am a huge pizza fan and always look for new places to eat it. This was a place I found because I saw my coworker at lunch with a slice of their Chicago deep dish. I was skeptical because this is North Georgia! So I got their number and called in an order of my own deep dish. It was really great. These guys do it right. It really is the real deal. The crust is correct. The sauce, the toppings(pepperoni), and it was cooked perfectly. It was even great when reheated. Reminded me of my old favorite, the Upper Crust in Buckhead. I returned 3 weeks later and got their biggest pizza; the Double Decker XXL Meat Lovers. This beast has 5 toppings, two crusts, is 18 inches across, and weighs seven pounds. It takes both hands to hold a slice and I could only eat two slices and I was done. I wish I had found this place sooner, but now I will make up for lost time. It's the best pizza in our area. read more

Chicago's Pizza - Double Decker XXL Meat Lovers. - Italian Near Me - Demorest, Georgia

See all

Wings were cooked to perfection along with the pizza. Alfredo pasta was bland. I had to add extra seasoning once we got home. Overall, I enjoyed my first visit. read more

Our hostess was polite and friendly and our server an absolute delight. We had a lovely three course meal of salads, appetizer and deep dish pizza and she did her best to ensure they were staggered just right to give the pizza the needed time to bake while still keeping the dinner from feeling like we were waiting. She was friendly and attentive, anticipated our needs perfectly. The food itself was delightful, with reasonable portions for the dinner salads, amazing flavor on the parmesan fries, and the pizza itself when it arrived was everything we hoped for. Will definitely be back. read more

Chicago's Pizza - Deep dish pepperoni pizza - Italian Near Me - Demorest, Georgia

The food was subpar - no sauce or ricotta in calzone, pepperoni tasted off, gyro didn't include cuke or lettuce, they were out of their "special soup". The stars were for the service and the food was edible. read more

After a week away from home I wanted some really good wings. It had to be Chicago's! Not disappointed! Big, meaty, cooked perfectly, just what I wanted. The fans were on out on the patio. The scent from the roses and flowers wafted through. Emilee (our server) was so pleasant. We didn't have to ask for a thing, she was there for whatever we needed, refills, extra napkins, etc. Another terrific dining experience at Chicago's Pizza. read more

See all

Thin crust and it was sublime. We had some veggies and italian sausage. The sausage was high quality, and I was a bit surprised at how crisp the crust was in spite of the wife loading it down with veggies. The beer they have on tap is crap, they should up date that with some nice craft beer. read more

We are blessed to have Chicagos in Habershsm County. Their pizza is amazing. Have not had better even in New York. Loved the mozzarella sticks and loaded fries for appetizers. Their calzones are delish!! read more

Love their calzones! The Greek is so good! They have something for everyone. My daughter got the chicken tenders and they were huge. The food proportions way exceeded the prices. Great Italian Resturant! read more

Chicago's Pizza - Greek calzone and kids chicken fingers - Italian Near Me - Demorest, Georgia

This was our second stop to eat dinner and after the excellent service and food, it should have been our first. The Restraunt was very busy. We were told that there would be a 15 minutes wait and after 5 minutes were were seated at our table. With 90 seconds we were greeted by bout server Wendy. Wendy was cheerful, pleasant and attentive. This service, food and experience was excellent. After dinner the owner Carlos stopped by to check on us. We will definitely be returning guests to this Restraunt. read more

Chicago's Pizza - Italian Near Me - Demorest, Georgia

The reason for the one star is the price I was charged was more than what is shown on your websites' online menu. Upon picking up my order, which was placed on Wednesday evening, August 24, 2022, I inquired about the difference in price. The black haired young lady at the pick up desk RUDELY explained that food prices change daily and they did not have time to update their online menu. I was flabbergasted as to her response! This is very unfortunate as I love your food, but I will not be back. I would think that most guests expect to be charged the pricing as shown on the businesses online menu and not more when their order is picked up. read more

Omg!! This place was absolutely delicious!! We ended up stopping for a bite after a football game.. We live 30 minutes away.. Is worth a drive back & have been craving the taste!! I'm originally from Northwest Indiana & this was a taste of home for me!! Will definitely be back!! Thin crust was amazing!! read more

We went for lunch. We had salads and calzones. The crust is thin and kinda crispy. The Greek salad and Greek calzone were delicious. The wait staff was helpful explaining the lunch special. They allowed us to sub some toppings at no extra charge. I love the building. We plan to return to try the deep dish. read more

We love everything about Chicago's pizza- the food is amazing, the service... all top notch. We have never had a bad experience at Chicago's. read more

Great atmosphere and friendly staff. Calzone had a beautiful crust tasting of house made dough and filled with fresh ingredients. Highly recommend their wings as well. Crispy and juicy with House made sauces that harken back to streets of Buffalo. Food here is prepared to order so don't expect fast food wait times. They have a decent wine selection and draft beer. read more

Chicago's Pizza - Italian Near Me - Demorest, Georgia

We went to Chicago's for my dad's birthday and were disappointed. I got the chicken pesto tortellini pasta, and both of my parents got calzones. We had the jalapeño poppers for an app. They were okay, not homemade. Marinara on the side was bland. Bland seemed to be the theme for the night. I had a Caesar salad with my meal, but was brought a bowl of iceberg with a tomato wedge and shredded Parmesan, plus a plastic cup of dressing. The dressing was good, but it certainly wasn't the Caesar salad I was expecting. After a pretty long wait, our food arrived. My pasta was so bland, and it should not have been, with pesto sauce. The grilled chicken was definitely the tastiest part of the dish. But I added salt, parm from the shaker, and red pepper flakes - still bland. I was bummed. My parents both got the veggie calzone, add fresh garlic. Not sure there was any fresh garlic, but there was definitely not much flavor. The veggies seemed fresh...it was just like the person making it didn't season anything. The cheese was minimal as well. There were okay parts to the meal, but overall, everything lacked flavor. I don't anticipate we will be back. read more

We came during lunch hour in the middle of the week. There was one other customer there. We waited almost an hour for our deep dish pizza. Which was fine because we know those types take longer. But, when the pizza came out, it wasn't even hot. And the only thing deep dish was the crust. The entire pizza was so thin all the toppings ran off and was soggy. The appetizers were no better. Seemed like frozen cheese sticks. We had high hopes but we won't be back. read more

I've never been disappointed with the food at Chicago's. Always hot and made with fresh ingredients! Because of that, it may take a little while to get your food, so don't go expecting a quick meal. read more

Great Chicago style Pizza. The best I've found outside Chicago! Service was great, food was great as well. Great on presentation and great on taste. Can't wait to go there again. read more

Authentic Chicago deep dish pizza! Since I've been living around the Atlanta area for 15 yrs, I've searched for Deep dish pizza like UNOs in Chicago. Well we finally found it here in Demorest. So good! read more

Chicago's Pizza - Specialty deep dish pizza. Just like UNO's in Chicago. Does not disappoint! So good and we will be back. - Italian Near Me - Demorest, Georgia

Pricey and seating is crowded otherwise excellent food and service! Busy place usually so get there early. One of our families favorite places to gather for food . read more

This place seems to be getting worse and worse, service is getting slower and slower, back when the old restaurant was around service was on time and speedy! Never had to wait for refills or salads, food is ok not the best, I know this is home town and loved to death but service has got to get on board. Don't worry so much with making it bigger, get better service then build! read more

First visit yesterday. Mid afternoon, had the place to myself. Every positive thing you read about the service - it is true. Not only was the staff friendly, but they were also quite competent. I started with a draft beer in an icy cold glass. They quickly responded to my request to change the channel to golf - all great so far. As tempting as several of the menu items were, I finally decided on a 12" thin crust pizza with sausage, onions, and fresh garlic. (No date planned for after dinner) It arrived as promised : hot crispy crust, fresh ingredients, and very tasty. Good value and clean surroundings rounded out my experience. I will definitely return and give several other menu items a try. read more

Chicago's Pizza - Thin crust, Italian sausage, onions, fresh garlic. Very good. - Italian Near Me - Demorest, Georgia

Delicious pizza. But my favorite is actually the Philly cheese steak sandwich. The au juis on the side is a great idea. Finding it the first time was a bit of a surprise, but trying it made me appreciate it. read more

I was born and raised in Chicago and this pizza reminded me of Leona's pizza from Chicago. Very good pizza. Friendly and nice staff. Even talked to one of the owners for a little bit. If I am in the area again will be a stop for sure! read more

Darned me! I went to try to pizza last week and I didn't even get it! I will next time for sure! They have a gyro on the menu and I just couldn't pass it up. It was very, very good. My g/f and I also shared cheese bread and poppers. All very good. We visited a little after 1:00pm and we were the only ones there. It took a little time to get our orders but I'm sure everything is made to order because it was all so fantastic. The menu is quite large with additional boards hanging above the register showing even more items. I'm sure this place must sell a lot of pizza because I've heard the pizza is so good. Next time I will give that a try and update my review after that. I'm still kicking myself for not having tried the pizza! read more

This was one of the best deep dish pizzas I've ever had. The service was polite, efficient, and quick. Another unexpected surprise was how good the wings were. We got the teriyaki hot and they were so good. Sweet and just spicy enough. We even got some entertainment with our meal as the couple sitting across the room from us was clearly having the worst day of their lives. I'm pretty sure he cheated on her. Some might not like the added character, but my life partner and I are pro-level people watchers. If you're in the area, this is definitely worth a stop for lunch or dinner. read more

The best pizza. And the meatball sandwich is so good. Not too much cheese. Just enough!Really good spaghetti. And I'd swear the meatballs are homemade. Order to go all the time and have always gotten the orders right. The buffalo chicken dip is so good. That is never a bad decision! The wings are good. We order for dinner for night shift ER. So the entire menu has be tried between all of us. So good. read more

Food is fantastic! My favorite is the Greek Calzone! Service is great and I ordered it to go on the way home and found it just as wonderful as if I had dined in! Love this place! read more

Never disappointed as pizza was great. All fresh ingredients and lots of cheese and toppings. Staff really friendly and professional read more

What a fun night - haven't been awhile but the staff treated us like we go in there all the time - Wings were great and will give the other place we frequent some competition! Calzone was okay crust a bit blah - We found that with the pizza (why we haven't been back in awhile) - We love the ambiance though so will go back :-) Great salads!! read more

Service was good, building great... pizza not so much. We had the thin crust and expected homemade crust... what came out was preformed freezer crust. Cambell soup type sauce, very little and flavorless and barely any cheese. Totally caught off guard as reviews led us to believe was made in house.. I had buffalo chicken salad, salad greens were great, tenders were skimpy and again premise frozen, not in house. Sauce on tenders was good. I'm from Chicago and not used to having sub par crust sauce etc. on a pizza, was disappointed.. read more

I usually only eat the wings, never really tried the pizza but I will get around to it soon enough!

Pizza isn't the only thing worth trying here! Pastas were great and the pizza is definitely a must try! Parmesan garlic fries were bomb! We will be back! read more

Absolutely great food. I had the fettuccine chicken Alfredo and my wife the lasagna. Both had great flavors. The server was very cordial and attentive. We will definitely be going back. read more

See all

Best. Wings. In. Habersham. County. We order from a pizza establishment probably once a week in our household, and we have had an issue (didn't get what we ordered, waited for an extreme amount of time for delivery, food sucked, etc) at least once with every single pizza place, EXCEPT CHICAGO'S. Every time we place an order, it's large, but they nail it every time. Their lemon pepper wings are our favorite. But we've never had anything bad- even down to the simple kid's spaghetti. Their caesar dressing tastes homemade & is amazing. Their sandwiches & pasta are delicious too. read more

SUPER PIZZA! The absolute best pizza around NE GA. Even the crust is mouth watering. The brothers that own the restaurant are very cordial and friendly and remember your face. If you can stand to wait an hour, the Chicago Deep Dish is worth it. If you can't wait an hour, the pan pizza is devine. Our children LOVE LOVE LOVE Chicago's Pizza. Go any weekday around 2:00pm and it's not busy, but the food is still fast and sooooo good! read more

So wonderful. I have had pizza, calzones, and the wings. The buffalo wings are so delicious and tender, literally make my mouth water! Definitely try the wings! I got a meat lovers calzone and it really surprised With how good it was. Give Chicago's a try!! read more