Great location. Love the historical building. Food was really good. Beer was cold with great service. Def recommend

This place continues to underwhelm. The food is always just okay to good. Never great, never spectacular, never delicious. On our most recent visit, however, it was the service that was horrible. We didn't get the server that we often have, but we were willing to give a different server a chance. She. Was. Horrible. It took more than 15 minutes to get our soup and salad! My husband had to flag down the hostess to ask for a refill on my water, TWICE. The server never asked if I would like a refill and my meal was buffalo chicken!! As a matter of fact she never asked me anything, only my husband. "How's your meal?". "Would you like another drink (twice)?". "Do you need a carry out container?". All directed at only him. Then, to top it all off, she didn't come back to the table for a solid 10 minutes once we got our containers. She had us, one table that needed their order taken and a third table that was still looking at menus and she was flustered. Once we finally did see her she asked if we wanted anything else, again speaking directly to my husband! He said "Just the check, please." And here comes the best part, we watched her get drinks for her third table, take orders at the second table and walk by us at least six times. We waited nearly 15 minutes for her to bring the check. It was ridiculous. As I said, the food was good, at best. The service horrendous. Usually the food is nothing to write home about but the service is good. This visit was just BAD. We live less than a mile from this restaurant and still only go 2-3 times a year. That number will go down even more now. read more

Stopped here again on our way through. Delicious food for everyone! Caesar salad with balsamic dressing, an Irish kiss (Guinness plus preseco!) and cottage pie. Great food. Great service! We didn't feel rushed. And we got to sit in one of those tucked in alcove tables. Love this place read more

See all

Decore and atmosphere is very cool rustic/antique style. It is good for groups (larger tables), as well as some intimate side cubbies. The music, if any, is low and doesn't interfere with conversation. The portions are generous and the food, though basic fair, is of solid quality. I had the fish and chips (cod) with fries, and sampled the onion rings, as well a jalapeño poppers with raspberry sauce. These were all satisfying. The service was attentive and the waiting person was very helpful read more

Excellent Irish pub and restaurant in Cobleskill, Schoharie County. I enjoyed a delicious lunch at the bar and enjoyed the atmosphere and hot food. read more

See all

Beautiful environment, good food, like actually quality GOOD food. Service is fantastic, clean, no complaints. Alfredo is fantastic, the chicken Cesar thai chili wrap, every bite is worth it even when the chicken is gone read more

Easy place to sit at the bar and grab a bite in Cobleskill. We saw a few families with kids dine in the seated dining area. Menu has a lot of options. It isn't vegetarian friendly, but they seem accommodating and can probably whip something up without meat - like a vegetable and cheese quesadilla. Servers were friendly and attentive. It was pretty quiet when we ate here. read more

Chieftans Restaurant & Bar - New American Near Me - Cobleskill, New York

See all

Great service, friendly staff, and good food. Stopped by on a chilly winter afternoon. Wasn't sure if the parking lot for the restaurant. Asked some folks we passed us. They said yes and that the we made a good choice as the food was very good. We enjoyed the fish and chips and Irish Nachos with pints of Guinness. Food was served quickly, hot and tasty. Tiramisu for dessert was excellent. Would definitely return if we are back in the area. read more

Ordered a medium WELL burger...was served raw meat. Fries were cold. VERY disappointed! read more

A big menu with wide selection of food but nothing really spectacular. Food wise, it's pretty standard so keep your expectations down. I ordered a cobb salad with grilled chicken and the chicken was so hard it was inedible. The bacon cheeseburger was overcooked and extremely dry even though we asked for it to be medium. We ordered 3 burgers for the table and none of the burgers came out being medium, everyone of them was well done. The fries were crispy and good so thankful for that. We sat outside by the porch and service was close to non-existent. Out of sight, out of mind? Took a while to get our order taken and for our food to come out so if you find yourself here and hungry, grab a table inside. read more

Chieftans Restaurant & Bar - Bacon Cheeseburger - New American Near Me - Cobleskill, New York

See all

Love their Bangers and mash. Best burger around. Best Irish coffee I've ever had. Friendly staff compfy pub atmosphere. Great specials too. What's not to like? read more

We have been sitting here for over an hour for soup, side salad and onion rings. Ready to walk out!

Cute vibe. Staff friendly, but not enough of them (our waitress was handing the entire restaurant). Irish nachos were delicious! The chicken quesadilla wasn't great (chicken was too tough). read more

Looking for a quick bite while in town for a volleyball tournament. This place was the closest and had some decent reviews. When going to an Irish restaurant get the Irish food! The Reuben was fantastic! Plenty of very good corned beef and the cheese was ooey gooey all on the perfect rye bread with just enough sour crout and thousand island dressing. Great sandwich! Service was a little slow moving and it wasn't very busy at all. I sat with an empty water all the way to the end of my meal without a single offer for a refill. read more

Chieftans Restaurant & Bar - Reuben was delicious!!! - New American Near Me - Cobleskill, New York

Met for lunch today. The portions a large so we asked to split the fish fry! No problem , it was served on two plates with fries. It did not disappoint. We all shared a tiramisu it was homemade and just enough. The service was quick and very friendly. I will return again when going through this area. read more

This Irish pub had the typical American cuisine and good service. Our waiter was a cute guy named James and he look like he ran the afternoon rush quite efficiently by himself. I had the fried cod and french fries with a tossed salad and the best damn Diet Coke with lemon that I've ever tasted. My partner had the salmon with baked potato onion rings and it was our first time trying beer cheese! This must be an up north thing because I've never heard of it here in the city. Go here for a nice afternoon lunch that is fast and effective and getting your food right away. read more

Chieftans Restaurant & Bar - New American Near Me - Cobleskill, New York

Gross, the Reuben today was loaded with fat and tough to chew. We laid all the fat and gristle loaded corned beef from the sandwich out on the plate and asked the waitress to show the cook. My wife said, what did the cook think and the waitress said he said nothing. They didn't even offer to take it off of our check. This place is horrible. A few weeks ago we had their smash burger and the beef was spoiled. The waitress took the whole thing off our check. She said this cook gets a lot of complaints. So, we are done. Never again. Where is the manager? There is never a manager in the restaurant to talk to. She is upstairs doing whatever is what they tell us. Their waitresses quit every month so you never get to know anyone. The next time you come in and they are gone. Quality has gone downhill and now we will go elsewhere. read more

We haven't had a bad meal here yet. Been here 3 times during our stay in the area. The fish fry is one of our favorites. Nice large , flaky and crispy pieces of fish. Cottage pie is also another favorite, can't eat the whole thing. The meat is very tender, the potatoes fluffy. And if you want a burger, can't go wrong here. If you prefer a Ruben, share it, it's huge. Great selection of Irish whiskey too. Ask for Irish scones, yummy. The ambiance is traditional Irish pub with dark woods and cozy atmosphere. Wait staff and bar tenders are friendly and sociable. Our favorite spot in Cobleskill. read more

Went upstate to visit Howe Caverns and stopped in Cobleskill for dinner. Can't resist an Irish Pub and Chieftans did not disappoint. My son loved his burger, my daughter enjoyed her special order buttered pasta and my Reuben was perfect. We loved the decor and even enjoyed a game of pool and darts after dinnner. read more

See all

We had THE BEST meal at Chieftans Restaurant! We're from out of town and didn't know what to expect. The service was fantastic. The food was flavorful and cooked perfectly. We will definitely go back! read more

Chieftans Restaurant & Bar - Cheesecake with raspberry sauce - New American Near Me - Cobleskill, New York

See all

Awesome atmosphere, friendly staff and locals. Food was your above average bar food. The night we were there there was a band playing a live event that played well and spilled out onto the dining room. Staff like every where else is doing triple duty. Chicken fingers were a bit over done, or the oil needed to be changed, chicken wings were meaty but the bbq sauce wasn't great. I ordered a Rachel it was perfect. An actual grilled Rachel, not a toasted Sandwich parading as a grilled delicacy. Good Guiness pour. Not like the reviews I nave previously seen. Check them out. read more

Chieftans Restaurant & Bar - Old fashion cigarette machine. At Chieftains - New American Near Me - Cobleskill, New York

See all

Stopped in on a Sunday evening for an impromptu dinner & a drink at the bar. It has the feel of a friendly neighborhood establishment. The bartender was confused by my simple order of Scotch & Soda. At first I was told that this well stocked bar had no Scotch and then once she found it I was asked what kind of soda. She took our orders which arrived fairly quickly but my dining companions side order with his burger was incorrect. I had the Fish & Chips but subbed out the fries for onion rings. The Cole slaw was good although quite vinegary. Overall it was a good meal for the price. The drinks however were a little pricey, I was given and charged for a double even though I hadn't requested such. Not sure if this is the bartender or the bars' policy, but it's not a good one. read more

Rather limited selection of food options, but still a good place to eat. Had filet of salmon, it was well seasoned and very tasty. The side of vegetables were also good but the rice was a little oily for my liking. read more

Went for a simple meal before a meeting. Waitress was very attentive till it started to fill up. Food was excellent, place was clean and everyone was friendly. I would recommend. read more

Held my Mom's 90th birthday party in the Banquet Hall. Very reasonable pricing, excellent setting, tables, linens, and service. We had a buffet luncheon with salad, meat, veg, potatoes, bread rolls. We brought a sheet cake from Price Chopper. The facility was so great about serving and hosting our special event. Big thank you to our Hostess Manager, Jayne M! read more

See all

After driving 4 hours from Niagara to the Howe Caverns, we were STARVING and wanted a good meal that would fill us for the remainder of our 3+ hour drive. Chieftans was the only place open for Memorial Day and THANK GOODNESS because we had the best service and food. All of the staff members were so kind and helped each other out in ways you don't normally see. We started with the Irish Nachos with a side of beer cheese and HOLY COW, it was the best I have ever had. We got the creamy pasta dish which came with so much pasta & a beautifully parm cheese decorated plate and the Rebeun sandwich (which my partner loved and said it was one of the best he ever had). Our drinks were strong and cheap, amazing! LOVE the atmosphere and dedication to the Irish pub culture. read more

Great food and service! Authentic Irish style food that is definitely worth a try if you're in the area.

Wings and onion rings good but fries not so. Fish from fish n chips was nice and burgers nice grill flavor. Irish stew super watery and beef wasn't very tender. Service was friendly and good. They need to change the cut and step up their fries. read more

Having just visited Howe Caverns a few miles away,  we were looking for a late lunch. It was that in betweeney time around 330pm and we found ourselves in Cobleskill. We walked into the restaurant, were greeted and promptly sat at the table. There were only 2 other diners in the restaurant who left shortly after we arrived. Staff now outnumbered us by at least 2 to 1.. ! The atmosphere was obviously quiet but this place somehow looks and feels like it rocks if you get here at the 'proper' time. We ordered a bacon cheeseburger and a Texasburger  preceded by a bacon n potato "soup du jour". The soup did feel as though it had been reheated in a microwave but was warm and homely. The burgers, which came with coleslaw and fries, were substantial and tasty, very nicely cooked as per the waitress' recommendation (medium rare). We consumed a glass of house Pino and a Nirvana IPA and departed having paid around $45 ex tip. So all round I would say worthy of 4 stars. However I had stupidly left my credit card at the table only to discover that our waitress, whose name I think was Dominique, has chased me across the street and hunted me down to return my credit card. Now THAT is FIVE STAR service. Thank you! read more

See all

Had a good experience the first time. The bartender was really nice and had great chicken stories. The food was good, nothing to write home about or crave later but it was decent. Good beer choices. The second time we went in we walked back out because it was too overly cleaner crazy and I can't breath in that kind of environment. Plus I want my food and drinks to taste like they should and not like a bottle of cleaner. Consider switching to green Eco cleaners if you're serving food. Thanks! read more

We found this great Irish restaurant to eat at and it was awesome. Not one thing to complain about. A miracle I know. The food was great, the waitresses were so sweet and patient and food came out cooked properly and in a timely manner. They had a live band playing but we had to leave before they were finished setting up. All in all it's a must try and I truly don't think you will be disappointed read more

See all

My family and I tried this place over the weekend whilst upstate (and yes I just used the term whilst.) Normally, they always go to the same two or three restaurants but I convinced them to try something new. We didn't realize this joint had just opened not too long ago. We were first seated at a long table but then were asked to move to this corner booth which was kinda cool and had its own swinging door. Only issue with the door was that the waitress had an awful time bringing the food in without risk of tripping or dropping something. I held it open for her each time and its def something the owners should remove since it makes their job harder. Anyway we had 3 diff burgers, two orders of fish and chips and one baked fish special over risotto w veg. Everyone snarfed the food. Fish was good but unfortunately the batter on the fried portions needed something in it. If not for the tartar sauce, it would have tasted like nothing. AT ALL. It was probably me and my stomach being weird but after eating the fish I had a wicked stomachache for the next two days. Perhaps the food? Perhaps my family is just coming down with something since they've all been ill the past week? Perhaps I just didn't eat well the last 48 hours? I don't know and cant blame them. Overall, I would come back and eat here again and try out some other stuff. The bar looked really nice and a like a spot I would come with friends if we head up again soon. read more

Great food and great atmosphere. One of my favorite places to eat and drink. Highly recommended

Slow service, but man, the food was great. I love Irish-American pubs. I didn't expect one in the middle of nowhere in Cobleskil to be good. I mean I expected the place to be a Mom-n-Pop establishment that just claimed to be "Irish" with small sandwiches and Guinness. On the contrary, the decor was authentic yet upscale, while still aesthetically pleasing to the Irishman's eye. The food was incredible. I saw how cheap everything was, and assumed the portion sizes were going to be small, so I ordered both the potato "nachos" and five wings. Both were huge, I mean huge, and delicious. In fact, it was one of the better meals of my adolescent life. I wish Newark would open somewhere this good. If you're within 30 minutes of Cobleskil, definitely go to Chieftan's, but hurry, Cobleskil doesn't have the population to support a restaurant this great. read more

Chieftans Restaurant & Bar - One of the best foods I've ever eaten - New American Near Me - Cobleskill, New York

See all

I considered two stars, but had to be honest to myself and other Irishmen that may read this. I'll save the most egregious error for last. We were seated within 5 minutes, dining at 6:45PM on a weekday. I note the time as it is germane to the review. We also observed there were only 4 occupied tables, three were finished with dinner, the fourth, a couple, were just served. Three waitstaff. Once seated, our waitress appeared within a minute, the wife ordered a Pinot Noir and I, of course, a Guinness. Both delivered in seconds. We immediately ordered dinner. Bangers and mash for her, cottage pie for me. The cottage pie was piping hot, but the bangers and mash were lukewarm. There were 5 sausages, but the size of little breakfast sausages. A first, but they tasted authentic, despite the tepidness. The cottage pie. Menu-described as "...stewed beef with peas, carrots and onions...". I found no carrots, but did find quite a bit of corn. While the corn threw me, it could not account for the odd flavor of the dish. It was, well, off-bland? I mean Irish food is notoriously bland, but this was just, well, off-flavor? I can't really describe it, but it did not at all taste like the ingredients portrayed or expected. I would be guessing, but I don't think it was fresh, evidenced by the lack of carrots, as they likely disintegrated. There was ample beef bits, but the absence of internal "rich brown gravy" made it curiously dry. I did poke around looking for carrots or onion bits, but found none. The peas and corn were all that I found. Along with a very peculiar woody stem that was about three inches long. I put the stem on a small, clean app plate which the waitress took away without mention. I expected a mention of it, but.... The mystery stem is what caused me to abandon all hope and share my wifes plate of bangers and mash. Dinner was over in 45 minutes. We honestly felt like we were getting the "bums' rush", as the waitresses were hurriedly cleaning tables for the close of the evening (I told you the dining time was pertinent). No one asked how was everything. Had they, I'd have told them instead of telling Yelp. Now the reason for the one-star and not two. As any Guinness purist knows, it takes two pours to properly present the perfect brew. The normal process involves a wait of 90 seconds for the second top-off, as the nitrogen cascade takes that long. Without exaggeration, my Guinness was before me well within a minute: It was still cascading fresh from pour one. I suppose this can be excused in an Applebees, but in an authentic Irish pub that boasts Guinness inside and outside (look at the bars pictures), it's a fail. I was so very disappointed. It would have been worth driving the extra hour to Colemans in Syracuse. The real deal. read more

Service is less than casual. Bar is the driving force sweeping aside culinary concerns.

A little slow when we first came in but it is a busy time of the year. I had a Southern Burger with an onion marmalade, very sweet. I enjoyed the fries they were crisp as I like them. My friend had a Ruben, fries and a cup of soup. A very nice experience for a new place. read more

I am a local and here a lot. It's my favorite local spot, but I'll stick to the pros and cons format plus lots of pictures. Pros: - the gorgeous fully stocked bar with Smithwick's and Guinness on tap - the decor, it's a beautiful remodel - when the food is good, it's REALLY good (the roast beef sandwich and burgers are spot on delicious) - the cook ... nothing had been over or under cooked - nice, varied menu (including dessert), but not too much to get lost in, which I like - both male bartenders, they're top notch with customer service - the brown bread is sensational - they offer off-street parking - there's public wi-fi you can access inside the restaurant - owner always on premises and checking on customers Cons: - putting cilantro, raw red onion, and raw tomatoes on almost everything (even onion rings!). It tastes terrible on hot dishes and masks the flavor of what you WANT to eat! - letting a young female family member use booths just to have loud phone conversations in the bar area - the shepherd's pie is not a true shepherd's pie and needs some work (again with the raw veg all over it) - waitresses seem a bit green to service (you're either rushed or forgotten and have to ask for more drinks) - the steaks and mashed have no seasoning (salt or pepper) Still, it's great if you're avoiding the college crowd and love a nice bar with good food. read more

See all

First time in Cobleskill, and in town for the college, so felt I should check this place out because it has good reviews on here. It was pretty great. Amazing food, amazing atmosphere, and amazing service! Try the Irish Stew! read more

Went here with my parents today. They both got the fish and chips and I ordered mozz. sticks with a side salad. Can you tell we're Catholics, during Lent? Anyway, everything was really really good. The fish came as 2 big pieces(they both brought their 2nd piece home for dinner) and the mozz. sticks were crispy. We had a great waitress, Dominique. She seemed proud of the restaurant and bragged about how great it is and how much the ownership plans to put in it. I walked around and also noticed a cool back room with pool tables, darts and some lounging areas. I can picture coming here with my wife and friends for a beer and pool. read more