Love our local Cicero's Pizza place. The owner is so kind, and always goes over and above on every time we have ordered from him! Highly recommend this place. As of Summer 2025, they also have a nice outside eating space. read more

Food - Pizza & breadsticks were delicious! Pizza's crust was normal but on the thinner side, just the right amount of sauce & cheese! Also, baked just how I like it so that was amazing! Break sticks had so much flavor, very yummy! Service - Quick, kind & overall fantastic! Ambiance - inside was cute & quaint, you are also overwhelmed with the smell of pizza when you walk up which we loved! We ordered & it was ready within 15min! We wanted a quick bite to eat while on vacation & this did not disappoint, we love this local place- it's definitely a must if you're visiting interlochen & we will absolutely be back!! read more

Ciceros Pizza - Large pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Interlochen, Michigan

See all

Our pizza was so good, we went back and got it again 5 days later! We are visiting Interlochen and tried Cicero's. Not only was the pizza good but the staff were friendly too. We would definitely order from here again when we come back next year! We did a regular crust, deluxe. read more

Picked up pizza before an Interlochen concert. Ordered online, which worked great. It was ready when we got there. Lots of toppings and not a ton of sauce which is just the way we like it. Super convenient, great pizza and nice people. We'll be back! read more

Great food and great service! Would definitely recommend it if you're in town looking for a pizza.

The service was amazing! The gentleman who helped me (I assume the owner?) was so incredibly nice and even walked from around the counter to open the door for me as I left. We were sadly disappointed in the food, but we will definitely be back to give it another chance read more

Husband and I camping at the Holiday RV park right down the road from Interlochen and decided to try Cicero's Pizza, take out. Ordered a medium 5 meat pizza cooked crispy. Told us 20 min and it was ready when hub arrived. Workers were very pleasant and appreciated our business. That was one delicious cooked perfect, lots of cheese and toppings, tasty crust pizza, I have one suggestion, put a little more sauce on! I recommend Cicero's Pizza, let's support our local businesses.! Debbie, Riverview, Mich read more

Order was ready really quick for a Saturday night. It was really good, we got the deluxe pizza and it was really good, the bacon was nice and crisp on it. Kids got the cheese and loved it too. We shared an order of the Parmesan breadsticks- I think we got 12 pieces and we all liked those- heavy on the shaker style Parmesan! read more

My family and I came for a quick vacation and Cicero's Pizza really hit the spot for dinner! The staff was incredibly friendly, the restaurant was very nice inside and the pizza was very well made. Overall, I definitely recommend if you're in the Interlochen, MI area! read more

Ciceros Pizza - Large pizza with bacon, pepperoni and banana peppers. Also got it well done and was perfect :) not overly saucy or cheesy - Pizza Near Me - Interlochen, Michigan

Not bad but not good.... service was fast and friendly. The crust was a tad over cooked. Ate the entire pie but I doubt I'll be going back again. read more

Ciceros Pizza - Pizza - large pepperoni, sausage, onion, black and green olive. - Pizza Near Me - Interlochen, Michigan

Great pizza and service!! We eat there a lot. If we call ahead there is no waiting when we go to pick up. Just all around great place.

Amazing food. We've been going to the same place for forever but we decided to try something new.The portion size was just right and the garlic butter sauce was delicious. I think that we have found our new place! read more

Got a couple of pizzas and a salad for dinner one night while staying not too far away in August 2020. Young lady taking the orders on the phone had no idea what size the salads were, we were trying to figure out if they were shareable. The pizza was no better than 'OK'. Very disappointing. read more

If you stop in this nice local pub, you'll enjoy the friendly staff, and I HIGHLY RECOMMEND THE HAPPY HIPPIE FLATBREAD. I included the optional meat choice of chicken. I can honestly say it is the most delicious food item I've tasted in a very long time! read more

Excellent friendly customer service and great pizzas. We were late on dinner plans and decided on pizza because this one was on of the few places open. We ordered the Mediterranean pizza, a custom pizza and the buffalo chicken pizza. Each one was delicious and my kids had a great time eating them. I highly recommend this independently owned pizzeria! read more

Ciceros Pizza - Mediterranean pizza - Pizza Near Me - Interlochen, Michigan

See all

Pizza was good. Always like to try something different in route back home. Service was friendly. We always get take out since 3 kids.

I tried to do delivery and I live about 10 minutes away. The man on the phone was willing to take my order until someone next to him said "uh yeah no that's too far." So I decided to call another pizza place that is 12 minutes away and they were more than willing to deliver! It just goes to show that this place is lazy and obviously doesn't want business. Sad sad sad. DO BETTER. I was really looking forward to trying this place. Oh well. ‍ read more

Sometime their pizzas are above average and some time below average. I guess it depends on the kitchen crew

Delicious pizza. Got the spicy Hawaiian but switched up the jalapeño for banana peppers. Reasonably priced, friendly staff. read more

Ciceros Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Interlochen, Michigan

Delicious pizza! We ordered a Monterrey (chicken, bacon, onion, mushroom, GARLIC SAUCE) for delivery. Pizza was lukewarm and on the cooked side (almost but not burnt) upon arrival (hence this bing only 4 stars...) read more

Ciceros Pizza - a pizza in a box - Pizza Near Me - Interlochen, Michigan

Ordered out (no eat in) on Friday 7/31. We ordered the Tuscan. Below average rating. Crust wasn't good. Topping quantities were minimal

We end up eating a lot of pizza on road trips and who doesn't like a nice slice of pizza with loads of cheese on it? We saw this place when we were going to our camping ground. We were making mental notes of eateries, delis and other stores nearby. On Sunday, we came here to buy some food and they had an offer going on at that time. You buy one pizza and you get any other item at 50% of it's price. We took 2 large vegetarian pizzas as a couple of guys in the group were vegetarians. We also got pineapple as and extra topping on the pizza. I was thirsty so I asked for some water and our server got me a new bottle of water, on the house :) :) That was really sweet of him as most of the places charge you for the water bottles and he gave it to me for free even though I told him that I'm absolutely fine with glass of regular water.. Their service was real quick and we got our pizzas in about 15 minutes. Cheers to the service. The pizzas were an absolute delight. The crust was nice and well cooked and so were the toppings. Great food and great service. :) read more

Ciceros Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Interlochen, Michigan

Definitely proved it to me. Better than the big chains for sure. Ordered 2 cheese and 2 veggie. Toast covered in Parmesan and garlic. Great fresh, looking forward to the leftovers! read more

Looking for a good quality pizza for carry out around traverse city. After doing some research I concluded that this will be the place to try. Well it is the best pizza I have eaten in a long time. A perfect balance of ingredients on the deluxe. A good clean flavor. Friendly people to deal with. read more

Ordered tonight first time, awesome service such a pleasant experience and the food was fantastic! Thank you for being so great and hooking us up tonight. read more

Ciceros Pizza - a slice of pizza on a paper plate - Pizza Near Me - Interlochen, Michigan

Pretty good stuff...it's not going to make your cravings' list but it's pretty solid round pie. That said we got their basic pizzas in a few varieties and it was all good. They use the balled up style sausage, their jalapeno is nice and spicy and their peperoni is the standard. Their bread had bacon on it, and their ranch is OK too. read more

A solid 3-star. Nothing to write home about, but nothing to complain about. We ordered a bunch of pizzas and a couple orders of Vinny Bread as we were staying in the area. Everything was serviceable. I thought the pizza sauce for dipping was a little on the bland side as was the crust in general. Like I said...not bad, not great. Seemed like nice people on the phone though and I always try to support local whenever I travel, so this did the trick in that regard. read more

Great pizza, best delivery option in Interlochen. We were extremely surprised with the quality and value of this pizzeria. Delivery driver was very accommodating as our cottage was off the beaten path a bit. read more

Best pizza in Traverse City and incredible service!

Good pizza, but amazing customer service earns them 5 stars. Love Cicero's!!! Their crust is a little bland, yes, but the toppings are always packed on and the breadsticks are to die for. Plus I love being treated like a friend and not just another customer. Perfect place to stop and grab pizza on the way home from work. :) read more

We usually have a household of picky eaters. We've lived in traverse city for years and never knew of this place. We tried them once during the lockdown. The employee was super nice and extremely helpful and brought the food right to our car while observing proper distancing. We got home and tried the food and it only gets better from there. Best pizza in the traverse area! I cant say enough great things about this place or its employees. Amazing service, great prices, EXCELLENT pizza! read more

Excellent pizza and excellent service. The boys working in the store were so polite and kind. Would definitely recommend this pizza place!

The people were very nice, pizza was timely. We are used to a more rich pizza. The crust was too thin and the topping were scarce. Did not hold up well overnight. Probably will spend our money someplace else in the future. read more

Card Making Class & Cicero's Pizza 2408 M 137, Interlochen, MI 49643 ONLY $25 LIMIT 10 PER CLASS pre-register no later than 7 days prior: Either email sgierok@gmail.com or phone 231-640-4138 (sherry aka tulip) I provide all you need to make 10 cards w/envelopes a package of buttons or decorations to use and take home. Free special project! Free AWESOME Pizza! A raffle for a FREE CRAFT CLASS! 3RD Saturday of the month (930 am to 1230 pm) starting: September 29th Halloween & Fall October 20th Thanksgiving & Fall November 17th Christmas December 15th Christmas January 19th Party & Congrats February 16th Baby & Birthdays March 16th Thinking of You April 20th Get Well May 18th Wedding & Graduation No classes July, July or August (summer fun) read more

Good neighborhood pizza joint. Nothing special here, but the prices are reasonable. If you are staying in Interlochen, it beats driving all the way to Traverse City. Don't expect anything spectacular. Just an average Pizza. read more

Ciceros Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Interlochen, Michigan

Very good pizza! Can't say enough about the employees... friendly, helpful and the (?owner) even offered me a bottle of water while I waited for my order. Pizza's were yummy and price was reasonable... would defiantly go back and recommend! read more

went in to get a refund because i was charged twice for a pizza kid at the desk told me i dont think my boss wants to deal with that, then i hear the owner say i dont have f**king time for that and wont deal with it right now We will not be going back there. read more

Staying in Interlochen for the weekend. Needed some pizza to watch the MSU game. Yelped for pizza in the area and these guys showed up. Ordered a large deluxe with some changes and they had it ready in 20 min. Friendly on the phone and even better at pickup. Very tasty pizza and priced fair. We will try you again next time in town. read more

Glad to see new owners but they need to figure out how to make pizza. Our pizza was the worst pizza we've ever had, no exaggeration. I'm not sure if they make a habbit out of pre cooking their crusts but it clearly was and was very burned. We even tried picking just the top off and eating that. It was bad. This is the second time we've tried this place. I think that everyone wants this pizza place to succeed but they need help with cooking. read more

This is our go-to pizza spot!! Always AMAZING pizza and the people who work there are very nice. If you haven't tried Cicero's yet, I highly recommend doing so! read more