I enjoy eating here at least once a month. I would go there more often, but, it is a 45 minute drive one way for me from my home. I have never been disappointed eating here. The staff always rotates fresh pizza during my entire visit. I really enjoy the way their pizza is made and tastes; it has a great, distinct taste. The restaurant is always clean and orderly. This restaurant is managed by three young women and they do a fine job IMO. I talk to them all when I am there. They are friendly and helpful. My favorite manager is Teresa...a very young manager, but I can tell she is good with people. She always seems happy and upbeat. Most of the crew or all of the crew there are young people and they do a fine job keeping the place running; most of them are constantly busy doing something. There are a few older people who work there, but mostly it is young people. I was a senior manager in the military and I am impressed how these three young females keep the place running and in order. I observe all the employees while I am there. Alexis and Teresa always ask customers if they need anything and if everything is good. There is plenty of parking here; parking is never an issue. The bathrooms are always clean and orderly. I would love to eat here once a week, but for me the drive is too far for me to do that. Thanks to Alexis, Teresa and the other female manager (I don't know her name). The old raffle man from La Vernia, Texas read more

I went here with my son once before I lost custody of him, but he was 40 so it made sense. He loved coming here more than his dad's house. I still remember the smile on his face when I told him we were going for his 39th birthday. The food had coloring in it but it still tasted like heart attack. God Bless chicken toes. read more

It was Veterans Day and I chose Cicis for my free meal. We'd only been to one, years ago near Houston, so I expected kids, games, good pizza and a salad bar. I was not disappointed on those but their "pasta bar" left much to be desired. read more

This place has the rudest staff and management I've ever experienced and they leave their pizza out way too long. Not only did I get a hair in my pasta but when I brought it up to the bigger girl working at the register she just shrugged her shoulders and walked away. With that being said, I will not be going back or recommending this place to anyone. read more

New cooks. Pizza was burnt and brownies were too. Bad experience. Do not and will not recommend

8$ and you eat all. Staffs are super friendly. You can also build your own pizza. The pizza always hot and good.

I was hungry for Pizza, and thought I would give CICIS another try,the last time I tried CICIS, I was very disappointed, the pizza picked up the residue from the oven, when I tried CICIS again the pizza was delicious, Everything was fresh and tasty, as long as the quality stays the same, I will return. read more

Honestly this is the worst Cicis pizza I've ever been to my life there was a hair in my hot wings the second batch of hot wings the meat was pink I put money in the game center in one of the video games it took my money said error and never let me play and I told the manager Brian about it and he said there's nothing we can do and he also said first it was the wings now the games be serious man like if I was lying so disrespectful while in the middle of writing this my friend had put money in the game and it took his money as well WTF Cicis read more

"Man, I'm eating like a king!" exclaimed my nine-year-old. "I'm going to be honest, this is like the best day of my life." And, "I've had more fun, but I've never been more happy." They have lots of fresh pizzas on the buffet, the taste is fine, and the employees are great. read more

My kids wanted to try this Cici's because the one in Selma closed. We'd went to the one in Selma for years. The reviews for this location are awful. So, we were shocked when we walked up and it didn't appear to be awful. The staff is great. Everyone was friendly, busy, accommodating. We went during the dinner rush. The dining room was busy and there was a steady flow of people picking up "to go" orders. The food was fresh. We will definitely be visiting this location again. read more

A damn incredible experience! Although the the price might be deceiving to the food, I genuinely enjoyed the food. The pizza and cinnamon roll combination was the best. Not only that the staff was great. I came in with a group of friends 30 minutes before closing, and the staff kept making and offering food. Finally, they allowed us to stay 15 min over to try and get the cow machines. A great time counts be spent anywhere else. I recommend 10/10 read more

Walked in and service was magnificent,had the pizzas and deserts made in no second after running out.everyone was amazing and nice and made sure we were taken care of.Also played the arcade and it was fun.Super cheap for a buffet which is 8$ per person we were plenty satisfied.Would go again read more

Food was pretty nasty. I could have made better pasta at home. The sauce has no flavor. Salad section is also really crappy. The area around the food is greasy like it hasn't been wiped down in a while. Didn't have any veggie pizzas ready so I had to ask to have one made. Frozen pizza tastes better. Save your money and eat at home. read more

Everytime my husband and I come in here, it's clean, everyone is attentive and kind. The male manager who usually works mornings (has a man bun) is always so kind to us and he actually remembers us and asks us how we're doing and you don't get that now a days. The food is always fresh and good and if it happened to not be they'll immediately fix it and get a fresh pizza and or dessert right away. Every time we leave, we're satisfied to say the least. :) read more

My wife almost talked me out of going in here because of the previous reviews. I'm glad she didn't. From the moment we walked in we were greeted with a friendly hello and welcome to Cici's. It was clean, there was plenty of hot, fresh pizzas and they offered to make us any pizza we didn't see. The staff was friendly and I can't say enough good things about the manager, Brian. I would not hesitate to recommend this Cici's to anyone and we will definitely be back. I went to the counter to thank the manager and ask his name to share in this review. I saw his business card and he is the General Manager and his name is Brian Campos. Thank you, Brian for the excellent service. read more

Always done take out. Manager is always there and they provide great customer service. Pizza is always good and it's hard to beat the price.

This location isn't the best CiCi's pizza I've been to. The building looks old but that's not the employee's fault. While there, I noticed an young gentleman walking around trying to keep the empty tables clean as people were leaving. I didnt visit tge bathroom to see how clean it was. The pizza wasn't as good as the other locations either. 2 stars for their efforts. They were enthusiastic while greeting us when we walked in. read more

Love this place the managers are both amazing! Monica is always smiling and making us feel welcomed and always making our visit so pleasant! We'll definitely be going back because of there service! read more

My boyfriend took me here to show me the wonders that is Cici's PIzza. He admits it's crap, but it gives him a nostalgic surge from his childhood. I've never been, but I can see why he called this place crap. The concept is fun: pizza buffet. Everybody loves pizza, and this buffet cost next to nothing. I'm not where exactly my dislike for this place is surging from. The fountain drink area smelled like a really stinky bathroom, despite no bathroom being nearby it. The pizza were edible in the least. I actually enjoyed the pepperoni & jalapeño combination. Their dessert pizzas were interesting, but I did not like them. Pudding pizza anybody? When I finished my meal, as my body digested I started feeling really sick. I immediately threw up everything, and had a tummy ache for the rest of the night. : ( read more

If I could give this bootleg chucky cheese negative reviews I would. The food was actually embarrassing, the only thing that was actually edible was the cinnamon rolls. The worst part about my experience here was the staff, my friend didn't pay for the buffet because she wasn't planning on eating, but before I threw my crust away I asked her if she wanted it, because I was just gonna throw it away anyways, and then the manager got upset at me for letting her eat... MY CRUST. Then he continued to demand we pay the full buffet price because she ate MY CRUST?! We didn't pay for it because that's absolutely ridiculous. As we were walking out, the staff was all sitting at one of the tables by the exit and the manager said "We'll be fine without y'all" to my friend. It's just embarrassing for them honestly. Acting like high schools children. This was my first and last time at a Cici's. Made a Yelp account just to make this review lol. read more

Cicis is home to the cheapest buffet in town! I enjoy their thin sliced/Brooklyn style slices. I love the concept that you can request any toppings/ customize your own pizza that is not on the bar. Pizza Olé( lettuce, tomatoes, hot sauce, beef), Spicy Buffalo (Grilled Chicken, Cheese and Buffalo sauce) and their Spinach are some of my favorites! The Pizza buffet includes a Salad Bar, Pasta Bar ( most of the time only has two options) and Soup. read more

Cicis Pizza - Cicis Pizza, New Braunfels Tx, 08/16/2010 - Pizza Near Me - New Braunfels, Texas

it is almost anti-religious to skip this after a long river day. big props to Alexis for running a clean restaurant and always fun after river day :)) read more

Just passing thru. Stopped here, The manager Brian is a great guy & made me feel very welcome. All his staff were on their toes also doing a great job, Love the food here. Very home atmosphere indeed. 10 stars! Thank you. God bless. Outstanding experience :) read more

SUCH AWESOME EMPLOYEES. Our to go orders are always fresh and hot when we pick them up! Clean restaurant and tables as well. Wish I could give this place more than 5 stars! read more

I was very impressed with Brian, the General Manager, from my first encounter with him to my last. His professionalism, courtesy, work ethic, and customer service were exemplary. These are qualities I find to be lacking industry-wide. I will definitely be a returning customer. read more

Awful smell smells like old people bathrooms are not up kept tables are not cleaned pizza is cardboard salad is two days old and soggy.

This place is disgusting. The quality and selection continue to decline. They have changed the ranch that was pretty good to some oily disgusting mess. The place is filthy even though they now require the customers to clean they tables. The " busboy" spends 9 of every 10 minutes standing and talking to friends and surprise so does the manager. This place was never great but now it's awful. read more

Don't understand the negative reviews. This place is just fine to me. Eat here often enough and have no complaints. Staff is friendly and do a great job of keeping up with rushes. I recommend it. read more

My family and I went for lunch and we saw a woman and her son with their pet lizard crawling all over the games and their table. We spoke to an employee about it and they told us that their manager was aware, didn't mind, and was not going to do anything about it. That is RIDICULOUS. read more

I do not recommend this place. My dad received food poisoning from this location. Be warned!

This place was the dirtiest Cici's Restaurant I've been to.. The bathroom has poop residue on the walls.. The Alfredo sauce is yellow (it looked old). This place looks like they need to update or something. It just looks so... Used. I'd rather drive to a different town to eat at Cici's. read more

Sloppiest Ole pizza, nasty smell at the fountain drinks. Wasn't fresh, not coming back to this one...EVER!

This is the second time my husband and I have been here and have gotten food poisoning,employees are dirty and don't keep with with the simple cleaning task... they should just shut this location down,even with new management it's horrible. read more

I love cici's but there is something wrong with this particular one. the pizza crust is white rather than golden brown. its almost like the oven isnt hot enough. read more

Go to CiCis a lot first time at this location and will NEVER come back! It is extremely dirty no napkins or even salt and pepper shakers on the tables... they ran out of clean silverware and bowls twice while I was there. The drink area smells awful and I didn't even dare use the restroom. Don't waste your time or money! read more

Im at the this Cici's in New Braunfels and it's dirty. It smells like mildew dirty mop water by there fountain drink machine. I will never come back. I totally lost my appetite with that nasty smell. read more