What Great Service Jake provided. My first time attending a Church Lunch with the ladies and was Happy I made it. The Food was Great as well I had the 8oz Filet with Steamed veggies all cooked to perfection! Ooohhh!!! How can I forget... TTTHHHEEE ROLLS, Mouthwatering deliciousness. read more

We've lived in New Braunfels since 2021 and decided to try the restaurant for the first time on Father's Day '26. We had a 20 minute wait for a table which was in line with what we were told at checkin. Once seated, we waited ~ 8 minutes before our drink order was taken and another five before the drinks were served. We placed our order shortly thereafter. We order a NY Strip (Medium) and a Cowboy Cut Ribeye (Medium Rare). The meals arrived ~ 25 minutes after ordering. The NY Strip was thin and prepared Medium Well. It looked dead. The ribeye was more done than medium rare, but not badly so. Neither steak had an enjoyable flavor. While I received refills (sweet tea when I was drinking unsweet) my wife's refill was ignored. The server was pleasant, but clearly handling more tables than he could manage. Considering the occasion (Father's Day), the restaurant felt understaffed. All around, our experience was not positive. Given the other steakhouse options in NB, we won't be returning to Montana Mike's. read more

Our party ordered 4 mile high rib eyes. All were way overdone when medium was ordered on 3 and rare on one. The one that was supposed to be rare was sent back and everyone else was done eating before the steak was replaced with yet another overdone steak. The floors were sticky and slippery at the same time. The bathroom was disgusting, obviously had not had a thorough cleaning in a year or more...toilets had rings and dried on matter, doors were grossly dirty, trash cans had thick layer of dust and sticky grime ...you spend way too much at this place to get burned dried out steaks and deal with filthy floors and bathrooms! This used to be a nice place, what happened to it? When one of our party mentioned our concerns to the hostess as we left, she simply said "Yeah, we get that a lot". Unacceptable...will not be back. read more

Dry dry dry pork chops! I can't believe they are serving food like this! Every time we come it's a bigger disappointment. Steak had little flavor, batter on okra and chicken fried steak taste burned. read more

Montana Mike's - Pork chop dinner - Steakhouses Near Me - New Braunfels, Texas

I loved the food, the steak was awesome and I love the staff - everyone was so awesome and sweet I enjoyed it there read more

My daughter, son in law and I stopped here for lunch on Monday. My daughter ordered the chicken tenders and they were huge, she did say they were very good. Her husband ordered the chicken fried steak which was a nice size. He did mention that although the chicken fried steak was good it also tasted a little like catfish, as if the steak was fried alongside catfish or at least in the same oil. I had the cheese burger and I thought it was delicious. Just think of a steakhouse burger and this was that. The French fries are absolutely incredible. Our server was very polite and attentive and we wanted for nothing. What surprised me is that this place was not busy at all for a Monday. The food is good, but the ambiance is a little dated, Kind of a 1980s vibe. I would definitely come back and I wish them all the success. read more

I love Montana Mike for the large variety as well as delicious food and excellent service. I mostly dine in for the lunch specials and today I order chicken fried steak with mashed potatoes. The daily feature comes with a salad as well for a total of $10.99. You can no longer find fast food that beats this price and this is home cooking, delicious. read more

Montana Mike's - Lunch special, 8oz CFS and mashed potatoes with yeast roll and Caesar salad. - Steakhouses Near Me - New Braunfels, Texas

The food was fantastic! Perfect. My service was excellent . Ty Amber your a great waitress. Restraunt had a Pleasant and Welcoming environment . But, afew male wait staff's needed serious haircut's. Hair should never be hanging loose. (Either Tied up, cut.) Or hire employees that will conform to Hygiene standards around food and customers. read more

Waited 45 minutes to get a kids meal, that we ordered when we eventually got to order beverages. Food came out cold, and the pork chop was drier than the Sahara. When we asked the manager if the turn around is always this long, he told us "lots of to-go orders, it happens". No apologies, no empathy, just basically told us to kick rocks. Would put 0/5 if possible. read more

Great lunch specials but most importantly the food is consistently Good! Favorites: Chopped steak, chicken fried steak, or sirloin! Really can't go wrong with any item on the menu. Least Favorite: Smothered Chicken Breast. It's small and sometimes dry. So avoid it if possible. Waitstaff is always super friendly and attentive! read more

So they must of switched the steaks they are serving, because they are serving low grade, tough, chewy, flavorless steaks that had no marbling that I believe are mechanically tenderized low grade steaks. I left highly disappointed and still hungry due to the poor quality of the steak. The steaks hurt our stomachs immediately after consuming them. They have good appetizers, rolls and sides but don't trust any of the meat they have. read more

Montana Mike's - Sirloin steak - Steakhouses Near Me - New Braunfels, Texas

See all

It is hit or miss, and too expensive to have misses. I l9ve ribeyes, but these are too thin and overcooked. The onion rings are great though. Service is good, but the restaraunt is getting old and needs a refresh. (This thing wont let me back up and correct typos, sorry.) read more

Great place excellent location wonderful staff the food is fabulous hearty and well priced some of the best onion rings and fried zucchini I've texted a long time Had a very nice Caesar salad before my fried shrimp dinner with a fully stuffed sweet potato My only complaint was when I went to the. Handicap bathroom. The toilet paper was installed so close and low to the toilet. That you had to break your arm to try to even get it any house and it was completely full Whoever installed, it never had to use it read more

Montana Mike's - Fried zucchini and fried mushrooms - Steakhouses Near Me - New Braunfels, Texas

Great service! The steaks are delicious and always cooked the way we like them! The rolls are amazing!

Food was delicious! My mom is in a wheelchair and they were very accommodating to getting her to a table she could sit at comfortably. Also a glass of wine was accidentally dropped and the glass was broken. The manager was right over cleaning it up and super nice to my mom. He even got her another glass of wine at no charge! He was so very nice about it! read more

Start from the beginning of this adventure when we walked in it was less than welcoming from the hostess with what appeared to be a scowl. It set a negative tone but luckily the waitress was very nice and very helpful. So 50/50 for service. Next, the bar looked well stocked and the menu had enough variety. Seating was comfortable. Food was ok, the steaks were a tad dry but had good flavor. Mushrooms were great! Overall value was on the worthwhile side. Lunch prices were unexpectedly inexpensive. We would be willing to give it another try. read more

I have ordered from here several times and EVERY SINGLE TIME they screw up my order. ALWAYS missing key items to the meal (Like gravy w/beef tips) Then when I actually eat it, it's terrible. Today I spent $32 on a NY Strip that was so tough I got my cardio in just sawing bites to try to chew on. Of course, it was missing one of the sides AND the toppings to my potato. I'm furious. So far, in the past 3 orders, I've WASTED well over $100. When I called to complain they told me there was nothing that they could do. Umm ok.!! I wont waste my money here again. We have 3 other steak houses in New Braunfels...Bye Felicia. read more

Service is great food is delicious! They put Texas Roadhouse to shame. Never have to wait for a table.

My family and I decided to give this place a try. We were all in agreement that we would more than likely not be coming back. The food was decent but the service was pretty bad. It appears to be ran by college kids who are more concerned about hanging out and talking than serving people. The place was not too busy (Sunday evening) and had plenty of empty tables. No condiments not extra napkins were offered, I asked for a refill and it never arrived. Definitely not interested in going back to this place. read more

I have to acknowledge Braden, my server. He was very high-class and attentive and knows how to make a customer feel valued. I can say the same about the manager, Mark, who chatted with me about my order. I was highly impressed. There's definitely a comfortable family vibe here so i recommend bringing your family and/ or enjoying friends on the weekends. I forgot to take a photo of my meal but I had the ribeye, which is not usually what I would choose but they made sure it was just right. And that I went home completely satisfied. I seriously felt so taken care of. Oh and the broccoli is also worth coming back for! read more

Disappointed this time around , I walked into the restaurant to place an order to go, went to the bar to place the order, waited 30 minutes for someone to help me, no one came, one waiter pass by and says the bartender will be here shortly will waited another 10 minutes and no bartender, so I left, ending up sitting in my car and calling in my order, didn't even take 3 mins, guess it's quicker to call in then come into the restaurant and order in person read more

My wife and I drove over 3 hrs into San Antonio to see a friend and on our way back home we found this place and all I can say is wow what great service from Braden and the food was just remarkable. We definantly would come back again. Very friendly and a good environment. If you are traveling through this would be a great stop. If you live in the area this should be a family favorite. We got the chicken fried steak and chopped sirloin. read more

Stopped in before checking into my luxurious 5 star Howard Johnson hotel next door... They got a 9.99 lunch menu with several options which is nice in this day and age, but i opted for the messy mike burger at $13.99. im from austin so $14 for a burger is about standard. The burger wasnt bad. It was a typical restaurant burger. Nothing more, nothing less. The fries..same thing. The beer was cold. The service was good. Only thing i had a problem with was the cold air and no wifi. I needed to do work but theres no wifi like its 1995. And the air conditioner must have been set to 60 degrees. I had to leave it was too cold. Cools food off super fast too. Overall its a decent little spot from my one experience. read more

I now understand why their ratings are so low. We have sit here forty minutes and still no food. Service started good and then it just stopped. I hope the food is good. I seriously don't think it will, I'll keep yall posted. read more

We came here after tubing on lazy river. We were so very pleased. The service was incredibly attentive and kind. The menu was very reasonable. The drinks were strong, and the food was excellent. Extra bonus points for helping us celebrate our son's birthday on a very short notice, with a nice message on his plate which meant the world to him. read more

Went for the early dinner dine in option. Excellent meal with outstanding service. Quintin was one of the best service persons I have encountered in a very long time. Salad was good. Baked potato was excellent and the pork chop was tasty. We will return. read more

Montana Mike's - Chicken fried steak and 6 oz steak with baked spuds. - Steakhouses Near Me - New Braunfels, Texas

The food is severely overpriced for the quality. The ribs were dry. The only thing the steak had going for itself was the bacon and horseradish topping. The highlight of my meal was the rolls. read more

It's Mother's Day 2024 but this place is lowbrow. Staff is friendly enough but the kitchen was not up to par. This is a typical small town restaurant but New Braunfels has not been a town of 15,000 in over a decade. Burger was dry, tomato was old, presentation was lacking. Buffalo chicken salad was not great, Wilted lettuce only two pieces of chicken. Side of shrimp (6), over salted and arrived last. Atmosphere loud and decor outdated. This might be a great restaurant for the motel across the street and the people who come for the tourist season but I would not recommend it to any locals or friends. read more

I love the lunch specials at Montana Mike's. You can't beat a 6 oz steak, salad and side for $10.99. My friend ordered the chicken fried steak meal which was only $9.99. We like them both very much. The yeast rolls with cinnamon butter are soft, warm and yummy! The chocolate cake was rich, and huge! Our server kept my diet Dr Pepper full. Great lunch. read more

I used to enjoy Montana Mike's because everyone in my family was happy when we ate there. However after tonight I will never dine there again. The service was horrible! We waited over ten minutes and no one came to our table. They weren't busy and when we came in we were sat immediately. People seated after us were served. We eventually walked out unfortunately I'd rather pay more and wait long for better service. This place has never been that great but the friendliness and good service made up for it. However after tonight, never again. read more

I normally love this place. When went today we were not greeted. The young girl up from with pretty curled hair finally asked "how many". She entire aura was of someone being forced to work and her unhappiness would be shared. The food came out wrong. Got a sirloin instead of a filet and wife's potato wasn't cooked. A offer was made to replace my steak by we had waited a considerable time after ordering the first time. The whole place wasn't enjoyable tonight. I'll go back in a few months but it was not what I have come to expect there. read more

I love these guys. The food is good, fast and affordable. Tonya is our go to server, she's a peach! But on a recent visit, I was somewhat befuddled. We generally sit at a table in the bar as there is never a wait. Last night, the tables were "socially distanced," which I've never seen before here and found it quite unusual especially as we are solidly out of the so called pandemic. But at the bar, just a few feet away there were elbow to elbow patrons and not a seat available. Apparently, bar alcohol is the cure for Covid! Can't wait to go back and see what's next!! read more

Montana Mike's - Steakhouses Near Me - New Braunfels, Texas

See all

Steaks are just ok, nothing special . Loved the baked potato, will be back. Place is old and probably could use an upgrade in decor but clean read more

Decided to pick up food here as tonight is Valentines day. Big Mistake. Spent $85, and half of our food was missing. Ordered steamed veggies Received zero, ordered appetizer of fried zucchini Received No Ranch. Ordered a salad also with ranch Received no dressing for the salad. Ordered no onions, Received onions. Ordered 4 entrees, Received 3 rolls, etc. We will NEVER be eating here again sadly. Standards have gone WAY DOWN!!!! read more

Went in for lunch and was really happy with this spot! Great Service and Excellent Food! read more

Montana Mike's - Mike high ribeye, Sirloin, Fried Mushrooms and Fried Zucchini and Caesar Salad - Steakhouses Near Me - New Braunfels, Texas

See all

Good home cooking. Service with a smile! Glad we stopped by on a whim , we will be back!

Our steaks were perfect. Sides were awesome. Frozen strawberry margarita was awesome and all at a great price! Servers and waitresses were very nice and respectful. Really great atmosphere to enjoy your meal and company!!!! Highly recommended!!! read more

Today for dinner we went here and, there was no wait, we were seated fast and everything was perfect, our waiter was so great and he constantly checked on us, our drinks were always full and he was very friendly. His name was Robert. read more

See all

Poor service, waited over an hour for our food. 6 oz filet was dry and overcooked. Sent it back and 2nd one was just as bad. We won't be going back! read more

This place was recommended by a local and I can't imagine why. The meal was recommended by the server. This is not the best of New Braunfels! Probably the best part of the meal was the homemade yeast roll with butter and cinnamon butter. I'm not even a fan of yeast rolls. Everything else was just okay. The chicken fried steak is premade and frozen, not made in house. It came out hot. The gravy was thin and runny, not very flavorful. The fried okra was pretty good for frozen and came out hot and not greasy. The mashed potatoes are probably instant, not great! I wouldn't personally bother eating here again. If you are a local and need a cheap fast meal, this may be your place. It wasn't awful. read more

See all