Decent spot if you're in South St. Seaport area. Pretty casual -- beer served in plastic cups; chairs were a little stained/dirty -- but it's nice to be by the water. They were out of frozen margaritas the Saturday night that we went. Bathroom is in a trailer-like structure. read more

Food and staff was amazing! The kitchen went above and beyond to make sure the order came out correctly. Highly recommend! The Venezuelan chefs there deserve a raise and/or promotion read more

The good stuff first: My server was prompt, polite, and kept us in the loop on how our food was going. The greeter (manager? owner?) was welcoming and brought us to a table quickly and was very pleasant. The food was also fine for what I'd expect at a barbecue or food truck. The less than great stuff: It took our food like 40 - 45 minutes to come out. That's a long time after you've put in your order, gotten your drinks, etc. Our waiter was decent enough to apologize, twice, to us, so credit is due there. But honestly, for a shrimp po' boy, two fish tacos, a hot dog wrapped in cheese (kids menu), and a cheese quesadilla (kids menu) it should not take that long to get one's food. The place had a decent amount of people, but most of them were drinking, not eating. And a shrimp po' boy, two fish tacos, a cheese dog, and a quesadilla, an order of fries, plus one fruit punch and a large bottle of water cost $75 without tip. Read that again. I get that it's NYC and this is in Seaport, but this was food truck caliber food at best (presentation: Everything arrived in individual cardboard trays). In fact, the kitchen structure of this boardwalk bistro is like a literal food truck. After tip it all came out to like $85+, for the above. Coupled with how long we waited, if it wasn't for the solid waiter and the fact that the food was decent, I would say I was extremely disappointed. But it's a nice place with a solid atmosphere and a good staff. I recommend going there to relax and have a cocktail by the water, but only order food if you're not starving and it's more like bar food for you to accompany your drinks. We went for dinner, so that was our problem. I would not go back for dinner again. read more

Delicious food and very friendly staff. Colleen particularly really took care of the huge party we had and got every order correct. Would definitely recommend this place on her strengths alone, but the area around the bar being right on the pier has a great breeze even in the height of summer. Worth a visit. read more

They had really good service and the food was really good. Great outdoor spot! Cozy and great view. read more

Cobble Fish - Lobster roll and seafood paella. - Seafood Near Me - New York, New York

What a beautiful evening last night! The food and drinks were amazing I highly recommend the sliders!! The drinks were made well check out the blond haired blue eyed bartender. Service was on point. I highly recommend checking out this chilled, low key spot on Pier 16. read more

Drinks are the best lobster roll the best atmosphere and view. Great. Don't miss it. We had a great time.

Great location right on the Pier with great water views. The service is courteous. Really enjoyed the lobster rolls and croquets. Must visit!!! read more

Views for days, an absolute laid back vibe, strong drinks and fantastic food - What more could you want? This is a South Street Seaport must visit for after work al fresco decompressing. The owners are all locals and regulars so when you're there you feel like you're in their backyard. This place is a total gem on Pier 16! read more

no sane NYer voluntarily visits tourist area like South St Seaport Here you should make an exception. Getting out of your cramped flat,....and onto Pier 16 is easy here. The drinks are cheap, the food is tasty and the breezes from the East River soothing. From the shrimp sandwich to the lobster roll, the salads to the paella, and oh those croquettas -reminded us of the best in Spain.....friendly service, warm atmosphere, cool breezes. What other places seem to promise Cobble Fish delivers on. read more

Food was good. Never brought us waters despite asking twice. Left on a weird note when I asked if they had candles or did anything for birthday desserts. Was only hoping to end my boyfriend's birthday dinner with a candle in dessert we were going to pay for lol. They told me they'd give the birthday boy a free shot at the bar. I clarified the shot was for someone else, not for me, and they said to bring him over. Then I brought him to the bar and the bartender said "I promise you I never said that" when he offered it to me to my face and the hostess/other bartender was there to bear witness. Why offer if it's not a real one? Awkward end to a birthday dinner and left a sour taste in my mouth, so I won't be back. Plenty of better options on Pier 17 read more

My favorite summer spot. They have an amazing po boy sandwich. The drinks are also great. I don't believe they are open during the winter, which is a disappointment but other than that this place is a great. read more

If you don't make this place your go-to this summer, you're missing out. The views are so beautiful, and the food was great, I had the chicken wrap, delicious. The DJ was also great, playing good classics. I need to highlight the service. The staff was just so attentive. Colleen, you are a jem!!! Jeff and Victor (owners), your hospitality is just top-notch! I'll be back for sure!!! read more

Small portion for big money nice view slow service dirty bathrooms much better places to go

My boyfriend and I came here for my birthday. The food was extremely small and overpriced, like INSANELY small amount of food for the cost. I got the shrimp and my boyfriend got the fish tacos. The wait staff took 20 min to bring the bill after the table was completely emptied and we were never asked if we wanted a second round of drinks. We could see the waitress playing on her phone while we waited even though there was only two other tables in the whole place. If this wasn't bad enough we both with in 24 hours had food poisoning. Don't eat here. read more

Hannah (trainee) and Ryan took fantastic care of me and my business guests. And on top of it, the food was great and the breeze was amazing. This place is a gem. Eat, drink, enjoy here. read more

First time to Pier 16, not sure how I've missed out all these years in the city. Cobble fish was amazing. We were walking by when the bartender/manager got our attention. Boy was he smooth. Knew exactly the right words to get us. I think frozen margaritas is where my wife was hooked- me, the lobster roll and fish tacos. Very nice setup, they have with couches and a formal looking dining room. My only negative was the plastic serving containers- though I get they are on a pier with a small shack of a place- so I get it. Great views. Great margaritas. Food was incredible. Thank you to Joshoa, Zach and Casey. It was a great time. Will be back. read more

Food and drinks was great, my only complaint was the music wasn't loud enough. Service was great also.

I called for a reservation, they emailed me that it wouldn't be a problem, they were happy to have us celebrate my husband's birthday. We get there at 7:45 and told us they would be closing in 30 mins. Nobody told us they were closing early when we called the first time or on the email confirmation. But decided to stay since we had traveled from Bk and were hungry. It was too late to go find another place. Once the food arrived- lobster roll and guac and chips. They were not the greatest - we've had better. We felt rushed since some people from NyU were having a party. We should have left and tried other restaurants in the area. Try a different place if your down by south street seaport. read more

Had a great night out with friends at Cobble Fish. Great drinks and food. The owners are great and greeted us to help us find a table and seats! Love Neil and Renee! Felt like we were in the Hamptons and dining al fresco! Great music, vibe and really nice crowd! Will definitely go back soon! Great for locals as super decor, atmosphere and fabulous location.. read more

Someone opened a tourist trap on Pier 16. SHORT VERSION: Pass on the food -- at least the paella. And maybe go back for happy hour when beers are ~$7 and cocktails around $12. Better yet, try Luchadores across South St., Watermark Bar at Pier 15, or anywhere on Front St. (Jeremy's Ale and Coco are our regular spots). LONG VERSION: Went with my wife last week. We're local to the area. And we probably won't be back, save for maybe happy hour. We ordered the Seaford paella at $24. Portion was just about the size of my fist. And it was barely edible. You can't serve food that's expensive, small, and bad -- that just doesn't work. Plus, it came in this cheap plastic dish + plastic utensils. Also ordered two drinks. A beer at $12 and a cocktail at $15. The cocktail was pretty good, and kudos to the bartender back there! But can we get an actual glass for our drinks, and not a cheap plastic cup? And really, $12 for a beer (in a plastic cup). Welcome to the tourist trap. To boot, when we tried to pay the check with the two free bartenders at the bar, we waited for ~10 minutes because our server was busy (understandable) -- and apparently, because of the way their computer system works, only she could close out check. We flagged down the owner, and he stood there for a little while before actually taking action to try to help us. (And then he didn't even offer us anything in recognition of this silliness -- not expected at all, but certainly would have been nice to end on a good note.) This place has a lot of potential -- and I'm hopeful that they can do better going forward. read more

Ordered our drinks and food. The receipt had tip already on the bill. Without even saying that a tip would already be billed. WORK for your tip, don't steal it. Go elsewhere read more

Awesome spot on the pier and the drinks were really good! Our waitress was fantastic and definitely made it a super fun along with relaxing environment! We had the shrimp and fish tacos which didn't disappoint. Give them a try! read more

We were visiting NY this past weekend and stumbled across this cute little spot. Great service and amazing seafood!! Everything tasted really fresh and had great flavors. We had the calamari, fries, fish tacos, and lobster roll. Definitely a must when u are visiting the area! read more

I threw my engagement party here with around 40 people. It was everything and more. My family and friends were so thrilled with the service from the staff. The food was absolutely delicious, especially the lobster rolls and the jam croquets. The location was incredible, nothing better than being on the water in NYC as the sun was setting. Thank you Cobblefish! read more

Great mahi fish tacos and the owner Victor couldn't be more hospitable! Great views of the bridge. Wave chaser on tap clinches the deal.