Bar with no menu. You have to tell the the staff what you like and they will make you something according to your taste. Everything we ordered was great and fit the profiles we asked for. I asked for something along the lines of a singapore sling and I was pleasantly surprised with what was given to me. My advice? Be as descriptive as possible and be open to their suggestions. Along with double chicken please this is a must try in NYC read more

Attaboy - Cocktail Bars Near Me - New York, New York

Small renowned cocktail bar without a menu. Highlights: - Bartender led: let them know what you like and they'll make you something. Mine was uncanny as I gave him a spirit and he ended up making me one cocktail with peach and another with apricot--2 flavors I love but did not mention. - Lots of locals - #37 of best of North America list for 2026 Midlights: - He told me the name of the cocktails he made, but I didn't remember to be able to order them again. Lowlights - Can be hard to find in the dark and rain but good the door next to it has a note to guide you to the right place - I could've used some bar nuts snack to go with it read more

- 1st drink: light n refreshing, fruity or floral but not too sweet, gin based, no spices; this came out to be pretty good but not anything special nor memorable - 2nd drink: smooth n creamy, could be foamy, refreshing, tequila, something that can wake you up; highlight of the night! It really is light and refreshing with egg foam on top; i like the smooth and creamy factor; it wasn't too sweet but had a slight brightening flavor - 3rd drink: dark and stormy and that was quite of an experience; i indeed felt the storm rumbling down my throat n tummy; do not order unless you're having a tumultuous day rating: 4/5 - i like the concept of not having a menu and you just tell them what you like, because it really challenges them on how well they can deliver what you're feeling; i personally think they slayed - lively vibes and nice lighting but music was a bit too loud n poppy for my preference - vibe was cool but more for friend hangouts not so much date - the service was amazing! I felt the 100% attention from the server as he listened to my order; he was also super demure and personable - the highlight of my night was when he took my order AND when he gave us the check which was his super cutesie pirate ocean drawing - id recommend come checking out if you have strong preferences for cocktails and know what you like! IG: @nom.noms.only read more

See all

I'd prefer not to spoil the experience of this establishment if you don't already know but I loved everything about it. Came with a friend around 6:15 on Tuesday night before our dinner reservation. We were easily able to get seats at the bar and were well taken care of. In a city filled with wonderful cocktail bars, this one really stood out. I will absolutely be back. read more

See all

Attaboy absolutely lives up to the hype. From the moment we sat down, we knew we were in for something special. Our bartender, Zack, was phenomenal. Calling him a bartender almost feels like an understatement--he's a true cocktail craftsman. I was amazed watching him create drinks based simply on a few words or flavors we mentioned. It felt less like ordering a cocktail and more like collaborating on one. Of course, he also nailed the classics. The Clover Club and Gimlet were both perfectly executed, and my husband tried three different whiskey cocktails throughout the evening and loved every single one. The atmosphere is exactly what you hope for from a speakeasy: dark, intimate, and unassuming. The space is small, which adds to the experience, although the bar stools are definitely not designed for settling in for a three-hour hang (my only minor complaint). But honestly, that probably helps keep the experience moving and allows more people to enjoy this special spot. Attaboy is a great example of why NYC has such a legendary cocktail scene. The drinks, the craftsmanship, and the personal attention make it clear why this place gets so much attention. We'll absolutely be back. read more

Attaboy - Clover club - Cocktail Bars Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Have I found a new favorite bar?! I've heard nothing but good things about this place, and it still exceeded my expectations. The vibe is super chill, fun, and welcoming. The concept is simple: tell the bartenders what type of liquor and flavors you enjoy, and they create a custom cocktail just for you. I think it helps to go in with a few ideas, but if you give them some creative freedom, they can really surprise you. I honestly cannot remember all the ingredients in my drinks, but I do remember loving every sip. Such a unique spot and a fun experience. Definitely small inside so you may have to wait awhile. I only wish I lived closer! read more

Attaboy - Drinks - Cocktail Bars Near Me - New York, New York

See all

The drinks are a science! We finally made it to this spot. Pulled up at 12:30am and thought they were closed because they outside looks closed except for a guy that is standing off to the side. He walked us in and coordinated our seating so that there is no one crowding the bar. It is a small space but brilliantly managed. We ordered a Gold Rush and a Paper Plane. Our usuals! I love when a bar knows exactly what those are. The drink was so good we told the bartender to surprise us for our next few drinks. He blew us away! He made us a Beehive, Sharp shooter, Fool's errand, Mestizo Emperor penguin. I'm still dreaming about these drinks. Every single one was different and so so good! The music was great too. They were playing r&b 2000s, Beanie Man, to pop Jean Dawson. Super chill space and they close actually close at 3am. Not a minute earlier! Can't wait to come back. read more

See all

Attaboy has my heart and soul, especially after crafting, curating and creating my dream drink that will live forever in the memory of my taste buds unable to be erased from my brain's footprints. Our friends raved about this place and we of course were excited (and a bit skeptical at first) to try it. The concept: no menu + no lights + a few questions = the ultimate cocktail experience. The speakeasy vibe and the dark ambiance really makes this place feel even more exclusive. With just a few tables and the bar setting, you're in for an experience you won't forget (unless you answer the wrong questions and really end up with a drink you don't like HA). This wasn't my case. Of course I described my two favorite things: Negroni + mezcal. The obvious answer would be a mezcal Negroni, but that's not why one comes to a place like Attaboy. Our amazing curator came by to ask us all a few questions, write down a few words in the napkins, and mix up the perfect drink that our master bartender crafts, curates and creates. My drink came as I couldn't possibly imagine. It looked like a Negroni smelled like Oaxaca, with all the smoke simmering up and preparing my sensory experience, leading to the best first sip. Ladies and gentleman, I introduce you to The Devil's Backbone. A perfectly balanced drink I'll never forget, one that is sipped slowly and enjoyed thoroughly. It's sexy, it's smoky it's sipped. Attaboy gave the best mixology experience and we can't wait to be back. Pro tip: be sure to be as vocal as possible, even with ice, so you don't end up with a tiki drink if that's not your vibe. read more

See all

The concept and the drinks r good. But the price is indecent and needs to be reevaluated. ILL TIP YOU GOOD I PROMISE but don't bring the drinks into this read more

Attaboy - Cocktail Bars Near Me - New York, New York

This is one of the must-try bars in NY. You describe the flavor profile of the drink you want and the bartender whips up something for you. I only said I wanted something "floral" and I got the best water lily drink curated for me - never had anything like it. Others in my group asked for "something spicy", "something smoky, nutty, and creamy" and something "refreshing". We were all extremely impressed. Our bartender was Steven and he was awesome! He even chatted with us for a bit after to tell us more about attaboy. I'm rounding up to 5 stars but I will say our experience with the "bouncer" was a bit unpleasant. He called us to let us know our table was ready but we missed the call (our fault). We returned the call immediately and got there within a couple minutes anyway. We were ready to patiently wait for the next availability but were met with some attitude and unnecessary comments from him during the waiting experience. Regardless, we had a great time inside to make up for this. Highly recommend, but just be sure to make a reservation or be on alert and on time when getting off the waitlist. read more

Attaboy - Our curated drinks! - Cocktail Bars Near Me - New York, New York

Came on a Thursday and didn't have to wait that long. The vibe is so cute, we sat in a booth. Nice concept! no menu, the bartenders comes by and asks what you liked and makes a drink. I liked mine, wouldn't say I'd order it again but it was fun to try and see their concoctions. Each drink was $25. read more

Attaboy - Cocktail Bars Near Me - New York, New York

This place is a must try if you can get in. I suggest going as close to opening as possible and with no more than a party of 3 or 4 people. It's intimate, cool, classy, and fun. Dave took care of my date and I and we had so much fun. He made drinks we loved and he was so friendly. We'll definitely be back as soon as possible to this absolute GEM in NYC. Long live Attaboy. read more

Attaboy - Two Step - Cocktail Bars Near Me - New York, New York

See all

The place really looks like an old speakeasy, the vibe was cool! The barmen was really nice and talked with us for a while. The drinks were good too! read more

Attaboy - Cocktail Bars Near Me - New York, New York

Getting into Attaboy on a Friday will be one of my crowning 2025 achievements. That said it was a chillier evening which may have played a little into our luck. I arrived around 8:30p, put my name on a list for 2 and we were in by 9:15p. They run a smooth operation, with the host taking down names and another individual making sure seats are filled. The bar is cozy with not too many seats. We went up to the bar and were given the rundown - no menu, and you discuss what type of drink profile you were looking into. It took about 15-20 minutes. I ended up getting their take on a toreador (not sure what my friend got) but that was probably one of my top 10 cocktails I've ever had in my life. Absolutely worth the wait. read more

Attaboy - Fun receipt! - Cocktail Bars Near Me - New York, New York

See all

I was so excited to finally visit this iconic bar and overall it did not disappoint. Very tasteful design without being overdone. The sound system is amazing and the attention to detail is evident the more you look around. I never know what to order at these places but luckily our bartender was a psychic and he showed me the way. My only complaint is the door guy with the ponytail had such a disturbing energy it kinda killed our vibe. The place is super tiny so it was hard to avoid and he was really patrolling the place. Next time I'm in town I will return for the cocktails but just a heads up something is way off with that guy. Eeek. read more

Really nice bar! Drinks were great, vibe is very dark and sultry. Service was so so--two of the bartenders were really nice, but the doorman and the main waiter were clearly in bad moods and soured the vibe, which was disappointing for a place where a big appeal is talking about your drink preferences. read more

made us wait outside 20 minutes to tell us 45 minute wait and never called us back. Just waste peoples time no respect.

This officially broke into my top 3 cocktail bars I've EVER been to in my life. And I'm super picky with cocktails-- for the longest time, the only 2 cocktail bars that truly wowed me were Lyaness (London) and Silver Lyan (Washington DC). When I go to a cocktail bar, the most important thing I look for is: are the cocktails well balanced? Attaboy was probably one of the only cocktail bars I've been to this year the that's met this "well balanced" standard. Note: there is NO menu!!!!!! But omg how are the bartenders sooooo talented?? They literally just read your mind and make the most exquisite cocktails that you would've only dreamed of. Ambiance is very cozyyyyyy-- def a small space so plz come and put your name early!!! We were able to snag the only spot around 6:50pm on a Tuesday. - Strawberry bourbon sour: 100000000000000000000/10 (literally like the best cocktail I've ever had in my life!!?! First sip and it tasted like a super refreshing strawberry smoothie... and then you can feel the scent of bourbon creeping up on you!!! Like this is literal magic) - Elderflower cucumber gin sour: 100/10 (super refreshing yet creamy cocktail) - Penicillin: 100/10 (I heard that this bar was the birthplace of the penicillin so ofc I had to order it. And omf it was THE cocktail. Like it's strong, but you can really feel the smokiness of the cocktail when you swallow it, so it doesn't feel as strong/spirit-forward???) - Gin and sin (apricot martini): 10000/10 (as someone there trying to become a martini galll this was literally like one of the best beginner renditions of martinis I've ever been to) Literally best bar in NY and top 3 bars I've ever been to in my whole life. read more

See all

One of the coolest bars to experience! Of course as all of the other reviews explain, there is no menu & you order the vibe/flavor of drink you want. They make great dessert drinks! Like raspberry chocolate or strawberry banana. The wait to get in can be long sometimes but also you can get in within 10 minutes. Nevertheless, I love it here & really cool to brag about lol! read more

See all

Great experience! Inventive drinks, classy ambience. It was memorable to allow bartender to create a drink from your preferred ingredients.

Was recommended this speakeasy bar while I was in town for work, so decided to give it a try. I was so confused on if I arrived at the location as the entrance isn't well marked. My bf and I got there early enough that there wasn't a line, but also didn't realize we needed to wait outside for someone to bring us in. After waiting about 5 min someone happily let us in and sat us at a booth. The inside is dark and moody but beautifully done. The bartender came right over to ask our drinks and made them quickly. Note, they don't have a drink menu. You tell them what liquor you want and they create a craft cocktail to your liking. My martini was fantastic and my bf's spicy marg was made with such craftsmanship you can tell their bartenders love what they do. We stayed for another round and weren't sure what to order. I opted for another gin drink and my bf another tequila drink. After asking what flavors we were feeling (sweet, sour, Smokey etc) the bartender delivered two delicious cocktails. Both were refreshing and exactly what we wanted. I totally see why this place is highly recommended! read more

See all

We were eating empanadas down the street and my husband found this spot while searching what was nearby and I'm so glad we did ! We got in luckily with no reservations and we were so happy ! We sat at the bar where all the magic happens . I love the no menu concept and just describing what flavors you like and what alcohol you're into . Mine was tequila and refreshing and it was sooo goooooooddddddd I think it was called the Chinatown rookie lol which I am indeed a rookie . I loved the dark ambiance and it's one of the top bars we've ever been too read more

Attaboy - Cocktail Bars Near Me - New York, New York

This speakeasy in the LES is a great spot for a chat with a friend or a date night. The inside of the bar is cozy, intimate, and space might be a bit tight for a large group. Service is attentive and kind here. Cocktails are amazing. read more

Attaboy - Cocktail Bars Near Me - New York, New York

Having just returned from visiting Attaboy in Nashville, I decided to pop in to this location when I returned home. This location is much smaller, and I really only saw bar seats available (maybe ten or less). I showed up solo on a Tuesday night and had to stand. I ordered the same drink I had in Nashville (the troublemaker) which is a refreshing take on a Pimms Cup. The drinks here are $5 more than the drinks in Nashville but that's to be expected. Staff were friendly. The vibe here is chill. Would def go back but probably not on a busy weekend due to the limited seating. No food is served here. Space is pretty narrow and I don't think it would be considered ADA accessible. Didn't use the restroom so can't comment on it. read more

Attaboy - Small space but good vibes - Cocktail Bars Near Me - New York, New York

Love the concept You tell the Bartender what you like and they make you the drink Drinks $25 but for the quality and ambience worth it. The average drink price in the city is $18-22 for sub par drinks Weekends + Thurs / Fri nights can have a wait so prepared. Good for 1-4 people given the size. I like the bar seating so you can the magic in person. Booths in the back. Turnover is quick since it isn't a place to spend 4 hours cannot recommend enough read more

We came around 6pm, waited about 20mins outside, before we were seated right by the front window. Service was friendly, we were told they had no vodka at the bar. 5/5 "Orange Moon" -- I requested a G&T variation with some passionfruit and tropical vibes and the bartender absolutely delivered. One of the best tasting cocktails I've had in recent memory. The gin was mellowed out with the addition of aperol, passionfruit flavor was bright and refreshing! Wanted to note, bar seating was full by this time, but I couldn't help but notice they allowed another couple in by the bar but expected them to stand (no seats) -- thought this was a strange practice. read more

Attaboy - Orange Moon (G&T variation) - Cocktail Bars Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Former spot of milk and honey. Remains a fav. Small bar. Small menu. Easy to choose what you want. Good people and vibes whenever I go. Especially on weekday nights. read more

Absolutely loved the ambiance. Beautiful decor and super cozy. Pretty small so it can be difficult to get in. We waited an hour. Tried the downhill drink which was good, didn't taste enough amaro and it was too sweet with the orange. They do freshly squeeze their own juices though so it's all fresh. The da Vinci which is their take on a Negroni was really good. Would highly recommend! The service was awesome and drinks were all good. Would definitely recommend this bar! read more

Attaboy - Cocktail Bars Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Possibly the snobbiest establishment I've been to. Every employee we spoke to, including the manager, seemed upset we even entered the bar. We asked why they didn't serve vodka simply out of curiosity and the bartender basically scoffed in our faces and just said "it's not part of our program". The drinks were good but the vibes of the staff were extremely off putting. read more

Very cool place ! They don't have a menu but they ask you what you like to drink and then they make you a drink Drinks are pricey $24 ... but good ! read more

Attaboy - Cocktail Bars Near Me - New York, New York

(Overall: F) - I was so eager to try this top bar in the world, but it quickly turned into immeasurable disappointment as everything and more fell short. The premise of this bespoke bar is that there is no menu and you can describe your preferences not limited to flavor, texture, and aesthetics, and the bartender would come up with something special. Unlike the positive experiences I've had at bespoke bars in Asia, I felt like this was just an absolute disaster. I ordered a drink that was fruity and floral, but received something that was acidic and medicinal. Honestly, by the time i was handed the drink, I was already underwhelmed as the drink looked bad, but tasted even worse. Now, one bad drink may be an outlier, but my friend described a fruit-forward drink and felt so sour after hers, both figuratively and literally. What added further salt into the wound is it was clear that the bartenders knew we were unhappy with our drinks, and then proceeded to chat with other guests instead; not that we wanted to bring this up since I am quite confident they could not do better that night. The bar itself does not have many seats, and the standing room only portions is actually quite in the way of the staff members, which is an inconvenience to everyone involved. People line up for this place a solid 30 minutes before it even opens, and if you're a smaller group, then you may be doomed very early on. What I didn't like though is that if there are multiple groups of two, the receptionist can actually those groups if they'd like to share a table instead of skipping them completely and going to a group that is behind them in line. From this experience, I don't see the appeal of this establishment and would not personally recommend to anyone, there's just no reason to wait in line for such disappointment. Nevertheless, it seems like many other people do think this wait is well worth it, so I can let them enjoy whatever they see that I don't. Food: -2 Presentation: -1 Price: E Atmosphere: -2 Service: -1 Menu: E Overall: 0 stars Insta/Yelp/Beli/TikTok: @amei_eats read more

Attaboy - Insta/Yelp/Beli/TikTok: @amei_eats - Cocktail Bars Near Me - New York, New York

Delicious cocktails Good staff Comfortable bar Too bad no nibbles available First in line Monday 4:30 A few behind us by 5 when bar opens. Saw fancy Polynesian drinks in jugs on the bar. Friend said bathroom was nice. read more

Was really looking forward to checking out the OG Attaboy seeing as how we spent our time at the Nashville Attaboy and it was absolutely phenomenal; that was not the case here. We walked in when a couple had been leaving and was greeted with an attitude by the hostess. Apparently you're supposed to ring the doorbell and wait to be let in. She walked us to what she referred to as "standing room" but was literally just us standing at the bar. My wife went to the bathroom and said there were empty tables with no reservation notices or anything. The drinks were good and the bartenders were accommodating, but that's where the good in this place ended. I wouldn't come back for a drink here again. read more

Attaboy - Cocktail Bars Near Me - New York, New York

The service and depth of knowledge of these bartenders is unmatched. Love that there is no menu - and you simply describe what you want. The bartenders deliver! I asked for something briny - he served me a Ginsberg. Hands down the best drink I've ever had. My boyfriend asked for a cocktail made with Suze, that didn't taste citrusy. He was served a cocktail that looked dark and dirty, but was light and herbally. The three person team works seamlessly to create an individualized moment for each guest. Tip: don't request cocktails. Ask for moods and flavors read more

Yummy drinks and good vibes. Didn't have to wait too long, bartender and guy at door were both super cool. Got a tequila drink read more

Attaboy - Cocktail Bars Near Me - New York, New York

Roy was amazing. Best bartender ever. Drinks were fantastic. So glad to be able to have a Penicillin cocktail in it's birthplace. Perfectly balanced and tasty! read more

Attaboy, on the Lower East Side, is one of the best cocktail experiences I have had in a long time. Our recent trip to New York was chock full of fantastic bars, but Attaboy was my favorite. I know it sounds pretty geeky, but it is truly hallowed ground in the world of cocktails. Attaboy opened 22 years ago replacing the original Milk & Honey, the ground-breaking speakeasy from cocktail pioneer Sasha Petraske. Milk and Honey won best cocktail bar in the world in 2008 and Attaboy won best bar in North America in 2022. Two of Petrakse's proteges. Sam Ross and Michael McIlroy reopened the 500 sq. ft. space as Attaboy and created some of the modern era's defining cocktails. Ross created the Penicillin and Paper Plane and McIlroy the Greenpoint, an iconic Manhattan riff. Don't look for them on the menu because there isn't one. The model is designed around the experience. There are no menus because each cocktail is custom made by skilled and friendly bartenders. They ask a few questions to determine what you enjoy and the wizardry starts there. I've been to many no-menu bars, but this was by far the best execution I've had because both of my cocktails were exceptional based on what I asked for. It's not easy to find. Look for a simple steel door with small sticker letters announcing the legendary bar. It is a welcoming environment from the moment the locked door opens and you are greeted for an open seat. Given the small space, great care is given by the host to each of the 22 seats. There are no reservations so there is usually a wait. It's worth it. My first cocktail was a Manhattan variation. I asked for a fun spin on this classic and they nailed it (photo #2) Rye Apple Brandy Amaro Nonino Peychauds bitters My second absolutely blew me away (photo #5). I asked for a scotch based cocktail with banana and a fun Amaro. This well-balanced, velvety lovely was: Speyside Scotch Amaro Braulio Banana Liqueur Pear Brandy It's worth the effort next time you're in NYC because you're truly among legendary history. Salute read more

See all

This place is a little hard to find which in true fashion of a speakeasy, is the point yea? Luckily my friend and I were able to get seated right away on a thursday night. The drinks were tasty and the cups were cute read more

Pretty fun place to grab a drink. The wait is just really long but the space inside is small so I get it. I found the drinks to be interesting but only if you give a more interesting prompt. The umami spicy drink the bartender created was really unique. read more

Attaboy - Cocktail Bars Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Attaboy is a unique and awesome spot in the east village, but very hard to get into. We waited 2-3 hours for a phone call that never came, only to realize the host wrote the number down wrong. He then assured we'd be next on the list, but another hour passed and no phone call. We went back, and he promised we'd be next, but there are limited spots (only 1-2 tables) that fit 6 people and they don't rush people. I get it, it's busy, but don't BS. We definitely weren't at the top of the list the first time. Host was BS'ing. Anyway, once we got in it was a worthy experience. Our server was cool, an absolute expert on bartending, and he brought us some really unique drinks that seemed to truly fit everyone's vibe. No menu, just vibes. Everyone enjoyed their drinks and they were pretty strong. Pricy, but that's to be expected. The vibe in Attaboy is dark, social, and semi-loud music. Because of the darkness, didn't get any pictures. Anyway, I recommend trying this place. Just put your name down, go to a bar very close by, and wait for the phone call. Make sure they get your number right! read more