I've had one good experience at this location, in July for my birthday. However, our most recent experience here was BEYOND disappointing -- poor customer service, items being left out of our order, poorly made ice cream, and pieces of paper in food items.
We ordered online and, 10 minutes after ordering, we receive a call stating that they are out of one of the ingredients my brother ordered. This isn't a big deal in and of itself, but in the grand scheme of things with this experience, it only adds to our frustration. They didn't offer an alternative or proactively try to fix the mix-up. We didn't order too late in the day, either, so I do have to wonder if the lack of peanut butter cups is an organization mishap.
We showed up 5 minutes late to pick our order up. Upon walking in, my husband was told he showed up to the wrong Cold Stone location because they didn't have his order. My husband was like "No..? I placed my order for this location." I'm sitting in the car waiting, so he calls me confused. I tell him we definitely ordered from that location and have proof in the form of his email receipt, so the Cold Stone worker calls someone from the back and more staff come out to help find our order. Low and behold, after a fiasco, our order is found.
My husband brings our order bag out to the car, and as we're driving away, I open the bag just to make sure everything is there. Shocker -- one of our three items is missing. My husband angrily drives back to the Cold Stone and heads back inside to figure out where his shake is. Apparently they "forgot to make it."
We get home and I realize one of the main ingredients in my ice-cream is totally missing. Unfortunately, this made my dessert surprisingly lack-luster -- I typically love Cold Stone (and often find the smallest size too rich to finish, which is a good thing), but this time it was the equivalent of a poorly made McDonalds McFlurry. It seems to me it was made as lazily as humanly possible. I try my very best to have grace and patience for food service workers because you never know who is brand new to the job or having a bad day...but, as my husband pointed out, it cannot be that hard to make an ounce or two of ice cream with 3 simple mix-ins, especially when you can print out the order and refer to it as you're making the food..? To make matters worse, I ended up finding a piece of paper or cardboard in the bottom of my ice cream. It isn't coconut -- I literally can't break whatever it is with my fingers. It might as well be plastic...it literally reminds me of skin and I would NOT have eaten the ice cream if I had found it earlier. *insert puking emoji* *insert crying emoji*
Usually I love Cold Stone, but this time I obviously turned to my husband and said "Next time, let's just go to Safeway and get ice cream from the frozen section." I truly don't know if I intend to ever order from this location again, and I will definitely tell friends to stay away. Most disappointing and nasty Cold Stone experience I've ever had, truly. read more