First off the girls working here were rude and seriously took 20 minutes to make the worst sandwich of all time, with like one piece of turkey on it. See picture attached. Never again. read more

Coliseum Kitchen & Caterers - Pizza Near Me - Plainview, New York

See all

Waited over 20 min for my food which should've took 5 min. They completely forgot about my order, once I went up to the cashier to ask about my order they then went to go make it. I got the Paula Deen panini and it was absolutely flavorless. The guacamole inside the panini was brown and old. I will never return, neither will my colleagues. read more

Coliseum Kitchen & Caterers - Paula Deen Panini - Pizza Near Me - Plainview, New York

I ordered from the fat boy burrito section. I ordered under the seafood selection since I am a pescatarian. When I got back to my office there was chicken in my food. I had to throw it out. When I called I was told I'd get a refund and instead they charged me again. Had to call back and they assured me they'd take care of it. I only got refunded the second charge. Not even the first. Will never order again. I still am waiting for my first refund! read more

Food was fresh, well presented and delicious. Variety and choice was excellent. Delivery and setup was professionally carried out.

Place is awesome had the wings from new spot a wing away the Blt wings were great !!! Check them Out read more

Oh, Coliseum Kitchen, where do I begin? Unfortunately, you are the only "deli" within delivery distance of my office. I quote "deli" since a real deli does not run out of whole wheat bread, wraps, and/or rolls. You see, we here at the office are slightly health conscience and because of that, we sometimes prefer whole wheat carbs. Time and time again, I call and place an order only to have a call within a half hour stating you "ran out" of something whole wheat-related. I understand running out of sundried tomato wraps but whole wheat? Then there is the issue that is your pizza. Why oh why does the cheese constantly stick to the top of the box? Why oh why is there always at least one slice that isn't quite like the others? We constantly have to perform pizza surgery on Fridays, just to make it look edible. I hate pizza surgery, but I love pizza! Your salads....While large and tasty (is that what she said?), lack real dressing. Let me explain; your "Caesar dressing" is a hybrid of Caesar and honey mustard. I either want one or the other, not a mix of the two that makes for something I cannot define. Also when one of us asks for croutons on a salad, and the other asks for tomatoes but no croutons, why do you give the one with tomatoes 100 croutons and none on the one that actually asked for them? Last, your soups. Chicken noodle soup should be a nice, hearty mix of three things: Chicken, Noodles, and Soup. I would think these three components are easy to bring together in a pot. Each time we get your soup, there is either no chicken or a whole chicken leg. Then sometimes there are noodles, other times there are NO noodles. Sometimes I feel as though I am eating broth with some depressed-looking veggies tossed in to add color. Coliseum Kitchen, with a menu as large as yours, you would think you would have it together by now or make your menu smaller. Half the foods you offer are never tried by anyone and are just a waste to you and your bank account. Yet I am forced to stand by your side and watch you disappoint yourselves and the fine workers of Plainview. read more

Coliseum is very quickly becoming my lunch crew's go to spot. As a big deli, there are a lot of options: sushi, salad, sandwiches, hot foods, pizza and a ton of prepared foods to grab and go! We have never been disappointed. Plenty of seating - both indoor and outside too! read more

I like this place. Down the block from my work, it's convenient with ample parking and seating. The staff is pretty friendly and the food is usually great. I had a chicken cutlet sandwich on 3/24/16 and the cutlets were so fresh that steam was coming out of them... Mmm and so moist! The boy who took me for an early lunch had a BLT hero and it had a generous amt of B in it. We ate both our sandwiches with haste. The price point is a bit high, but it's convenient. There is some confusion with where to order when it's busy... Is there a certain area for certain things? Hmmm I just go to the register by the rolls since I get a sandwich and that works out well. The confections they offer are always great. I'll be back. read more

Coliseum Kitchen & Caterers - Heck yeah chicken cutlet ! - Pizza Near Me - Plainview, New York

This place is amazing!!! How can anyone say anything negative about it with all of the options they have?! Their salad bar is huge, very similar to a subway style of mix ins (only much better quality ingredients), the guy at the counter was very nice. It was overwhelming how many options there were - omelettes, a hot bar with roasted vegetables, mac and cheese, grilled vegetables, stuffed sole, meat options, vegetarian options, Italian classics, a sandwich station, a bakery section, I wish I lived close to this place! The customer service was great, the guy at the checkout was very friendly. My husband's sandwich ticket was lost so he waited 20 minutes for a panini, the guy at the checkout was very apologetic and gave us a bunch of free desserts as an apology. Great food, great service, will definitely be going back! read more

This place is gross. First of all, the colors and lighting are all wrong. I felt like I was in a high school or hospital cafeteria. I ordered an omelet. It took pretty long considering I was the only one in there at the time. Then I ordered an iced coffee. They are clearly too cheap to purchase iced coffee cups, so it was served in a pepsi paper cup. Classy. As I walked out, I noticed the fruit was all moldy. Who knows how long it had been sitting there. My omelet tasted fake. Probably egg beaters and not real eggs. The bacon was microwaved so it was dry. It was not cheap either. A platter with toast and home fries cost me about $8 bucks. I can get a delicious, fresh omelet at my work cafeteria for under $4. I'd rather go to McDonald's. read more

Coliseum Kitchen is basically a whole food court wrapped into one! It is overwhelming going there, because the menu is so large. You can get salads, sandwiches, burgers, chicken, pizza, pasta, I can go on! They even have a huge drink cooler and a huge selection of candy and chips. I've been here several times and everything I've had has been pretty good. The burgers are decent, the pizza is surprisingly on point, and the sandwiches are HUGE. HUGE. Expect to spend between $10 and $20 but you'll be getting a huge meal. read more

I've been coming here for about two years now when I travel here from out of town. This is close to the hotel I stay at but has such a wide variety of items it's worth coming nearly every day. I generally come here for dinner where they have several meal options ready to go along with a myriad of deli items. If I'm in a rush, I'll go with something on their hotplates; otherwise I am quite partial to their reubens. The disco fries are pretty awesome (not quite poutine, but close enough when you're not in Canada proper). But by far my favorite thing here are the raspberry crumbcakes. They are truly amazing and I once bought 40 of them to take home as I wasn't coming back for a while. The technically aren't from here, but CC treats them better than any other local restaurant around that carries them. They aren't dry nor do they keep them over-refrigerated. I suspect my addiction keeps their inventory fresh, but still, they keep them properly stored in plastic containers for take away. They have a selection of various drinks and beer as well. Enjoy! read more

Coliseum Kitchen & Caterers - A shot of the checkout area in the evening, about 30 minutes prior to closing. There's quite a selection of takeaway items. - Pizza Near Me - Plainview, New York

Visited for a breakfast, Whoa!!! The staff is a discombobulated mess. Here is where the cliche' Chickens with their heads cut off came from. What's hysterical is that they all appear to be really befuddled and nervous. My egg sandwich on a wrap was a mess. I asked for them to grill it, but no they had to do their own way and "Press" like a panini. I received with eggs and cheese squirting out of every direction. Where is Chef Ramsey to throw this shit back in their faces? This is also the only deli which charges $1.25 for the "free coffee with an egg sandwich" before 11:00am. Also I am set off because of their awkward POS computer system which nobody here has mastered. So with all this in mind and you don't mind waiting 18 minutes for a sloppy egg sandwich this is your place. read more

Coliseum Kitchen & Caterers - My 2 eggs, Turkey & cheese mess on a spinach wrap. - Pizza Near Me - Plainview, New York

Coliseum is a place with a huge variety of food items to chose from. These are trying times & the staff goes out of their way to ensure an excellent/safe experience. We recently had great pancakes & egg sandwiches that were enjoyable. We had positive visits before but didn't review. read more

Ordered two items shrimp bowl and a açaí bowl, açaí bowl was promptly made, the young man asked to place it in the freezer, thirty mins later I asked another employee about my shrimp bowl he proceeded to ask the kitchen about the bowl no one knew what he was speaking about. Asked for a manager for a refund for the shrimp bowl none could be found. Ive been here many times and this has never happened I'm disappointed. read more

Everything here is frozen. OK, maybe not everything, but anything that they can order pre-made and frozen, it's pre-made and frozen. They're completely unapologetic about it, too. When you order delivery from them for a number of people, you get your food in a box from one of their frozen food deliveries. I've received boxes of frozen chicken tenders, other meats, anything you can imagine, it's frozen. It should be obvious from the ridiculous variety of food they serve that they can't possibly be making things fresh every morning, but in case there was any doubt, well, these are the facts. I've been part of group orders many, many times from this place to my office. They always manage to screw up the simplest omelette orders. I'm talking about 1 or 2 items in an omelette, that's it, and they still can't get it right. Wrong type of cheese, wrong ingredient, no cheese... it's crazy. Oh, and for some reason it's cheaper to get an omelette with bacon and cheese than just bacon, riddle me that! They also screw up other things, sandwiches, etc. When you call, it's like everybody is seeing their POS system for the first time, somehow. The other problem with their omelettes is the eggs. I don't know what kind of funky egg they're using, but it's dilute and too pale yellow to be real 100% egg. I called and they claim they don't add milk to their eggs, but there's got to be something in them, even if they're just watering them down, because there's no way eggs look like that, it isn't natural. I've made myself, and ordered from many restaurants, hundreds and hundreds of omelettes and I've never seen eggs of that color and consistency. read more

Stopped by this place for lunch after checking out of the Hilton up the road. Loved the fact that they had so many selections from sandwiches, pizza, salad, burgers. They basically had everything I was craving it all smelled and looked so good. I was in NY so I had to try their grandma pizza. Two slices and a drink came to 8 bucks. The pizza was amazing, highly recommend the grandma slices if they had any. If I knew about this place sooner I would have tried more of their food during my stay. I would definitely recommend this place to others if you're in the area! read more

Coliseum Kitchen & Caterers - Grandma slice! 5/5 - Pizza Near Me - Plainview, New York

4th time , last time . Once I had a fantastic panini !! My third attempt at something edible will be my last. Got the Alton brown panini the chicken is so over fried and greasy it hurts to bite it .. The so called broccoli rabe is actually spinach ... Very strange slimy consistency Gave it three chances .. Will never go again sad because I work in the area read more

Coliseum Kitchen & Caterers - Alton brown panini - Pizza Near Me - Plainview, New York

Food is average, but staff is horrible. Rude and have no customer service. Went up to order and the girl who helped me just stared at me up and down for more than 5 seconds before I said my order, making me very uncomfortable. She was either in awe of my beauty or needs to get an attitude adjustment. Took 20 minutes to get an Italian deluxe read more

Been going there for a few months. They make a really good sandwich! Usually get Munster and turkey . Always oversized. Worth the money. And the people that work there are friendly and helpful. read more

Love their egg sandwiches and deli sandwiches too! So good. Delivery is always great and staff is friendly.

This restaurant needs a lot of help. Upon entering food is presented nicely. Not one employee greeted me or asked how they could help. After I found out what kind of soup they offered, the woman was unable to locate a laddle. After four employees searching a laddle was washed. There is a lot of businesses struggling right now to hire employees. This establishment has numerous employees standing around socializing and not eager to work or help anyone. This business would benefit by taking the time to properly train their employees how to best serve their customers to help run their business. read more

Best customer service I have ever received at a food establishment. I really felt like I was dreaming because of how nice, patient, understanding, and polite. Received mac and cheese balls on the house. Definitely would come back again. read more

We tried this place while waiting for our cat in the vet ER. Overall liked the place as it's clean, cozy seating, offers a wide variety of food (they even had poke bowls and sushi!) and good food. Not great food but good specially for the lunch crowd if you work nearby. read more

I have eaten here a few months ones for breakfast and lunch sandwiches.... awesome. Nice people too. I have used them for catering in the past and everything was accurate and good. read more

Roast Beef on Rye and Diet Coke = $10.04 4 slices of dried out roast beef (somewhere between grey and tan in color). I immediately threw it in the garbage when I got back to my office. There is not another deli around for at least a mile or more so they have no competition. Horrible, horrible, horrible + a rip off. I should have read the reviews before I went there for a simple sandwich. Are they kidding???? read more

Coliseum Kitchen & Caterers - Pizza Near Me - Plainview, New York

MAC N MELTS as the new add on to this location is AMAZING! They used to be located in garden city always traveled to get and I thought it would never come back! BEST MAC I've ever tasted always going back for more I suggest you give the Buffalo Mac N Cheese no reason of disappoint. read more

I placed an online order at 1:00 to be picked up at 3:15. I was waiting there until 3:45 for them to complete my order. If I wanted to wait. I wouldn't have ordered ahead of time. At least this time they got the order right because usually that's a crap shoot too read more

For a tru "Vegetarian" this is not a Tuna Melt! It looks like a "Slop Load of Tuna I'm a Hero" with slab of UNMELTED American cheese and tomato!!!!! I will never order nor go there to eat again! Ok, I'm sitting at work now and I had to dissect the "So Called Tuna Melt".....Yes I'm VEX @ work on a 12hr shift hungry/appetite so gone out the window!!!! read more

Coliseum Kitchen & Caterers - A Poor Excuse----Tuna melt supposedly but instead I guess he didn't care about a paying customer I got a "Unmelted Tuna Melt"! - Pizza Near Me - Plainview, New York

See all

Decided to ignore the low rating and hit this place up for lunch while working in Long Island. Wow, I'm really glad I did. I got a simple chicken cutlet melt with Swiss instead of American and ask them to put hot sauce on it. I was expecting a wimpy sandwich but got a really hefty portion with plenty of chicken. The tomatoes tasted fresh and he put the right amount of hot sauce on. Tasted great. You'd b surprised with any many places mess up a simple chicken sandwich but this deli does it perfectly. Service wasn't fantastic but who cares ? As long as the food is good I leave happy read more

The best acaí bowls in all on new york state! Hands down. I drive all the way from queens to get acaí boels from here.. that's enough said already lol everywhere else I go is never the same. The pizza is also fire! read more

I had a party where I served both lunch dinner. Lunch was the Gourmet sandwiches. These were truly gourmet and not your run of the mill deli sandwiches. A later delivery for dinner was from the Bistro menu. Everyone could not stop raving about how delicious all the food was. Finally, I everyone I spoke to at Coliseum was helpful and friendly. A special thanks to Melissa who personally oversaw and was at the delivery of each meal. She even had the chef create a special salmon dish with mushrooms because I told her my family loves mushrooms! I cannot praise them enough and would highly recommend them for any catering needs. read more

I've been meaning to post this for a few weeks - but better late than never. All too often, we take the time to complain, but rarely to compliment. This past Thanksgiving, was the first one that we have ever hosted in our home. We decided to get dinner catered - and, oddly enough, we missed the deadline for the place where we planned to get the dinner from. My wife - scrambling, found an ad for the special packages from Coliseum Kitchen - and she had heard of them before, as the company where she works had used them before. We placed the order with some very nice folks - and I even pointed out that my wife was a celiac, so extra care needed to be taken with regard to the food. They couldn't be nicer. They wouldn't even let me pack it into the car. Every detail was taken care of - from the packaging to the reheating instructions. I made it a point to call the owner the Monday after Thanksgiving, as I drove to work, as I had a need to let him (Ralph) know that they had "knocked it out of the freaking park!" Every guest insisted on seconds and thirds... even the kids who were picky eaters - loved it. The turkey was delicious and juicy - not a dry bite. The stuffing - fantastic... the veggies. Crisp and tasty... the gravy - amazing - and the garlic mashed - phenomenal. Not a single criticism here - and I am usually quite the critical guy. Amazing - you owe it to yourself -if you're thinking of using Coliseum Kitchen for a catering gig - to call and book them right now. I can, without a doubt, say that they've earned a new and dedicated client in me (and my extended family!). Worth. Every. Penny. read more

We picked up a large cheese pizza and 4 Italian subs after the recent PGA event at Bethpage for the road trip back to DC. The food was prepared quickly and we were able to breeze in and pick it up. The services was fast and courteous. They have a sit down area, and lots of food options. (See menu) I would recommend this deli if in the area. Great variety and good selection. Plenty of parking and easy in an out off the highway. Give it a try. read more

Got one of the fat boys burritos today. Amazing. the burrito was almost the size of my head. It was so big i managed to eat it throughout the day for every meal and was stuffed lol. read more

I reviewed this place after my first trip and now that I've been there 15 more times or so it's officially confirmed. This place rocks. It's pricey, yes, but not unfair and you have Craving's down the street which charges more so this is a nice alternative with a wider selection. Burgers are my favorite. They recommend you call in advance for these because it takes 10 minutes or so to make, but they are absolutely delicious (favorite is the guacamole burger with bacon, jack cheese, and chipolte mayo). Also, every sandwich I've had has been good - great. If you want to try Coliseum Kitchen on a budget, get the breakfast. They have omelets (that are fantastic) with home fries and toast for a little over $5. Also, the captain crunch french toast is great (and they also have challah french toast!) My last venture was to get wings for the Giants game last Sunday. It took way too long to make (20 minutes I think), but it worked out to my favor because I came back right at kickoff. I ordered the hot (they have mild, hot, and don't even try it). The sauce was great and had the right amount of kick. If you're looking for a deli on a budget, Quizno's is down the street and you can get a sandwich for $5. If you're looking for awesomeness, check out the Coliseum Kitchen. read more

I was excited at first but I'd pass. When this place first opened I was so excited by the menu and how close it was to work. They put out quality food but at a high price. $14 for a burger and fries is a little extreme and you would think they would get everything right. Over time you would think the place would get better and better but it's done the opposite. They are still all over the place and confused. I've waited 20min for a hamburger before and then when I ask about it they lost the order. But this has happened several times. They have also changed menu items but kept the same names which can be quite a catastrophe when you have an old menu and get something completely different than what you ordered. The food is good but for the amount of time it takes to get the food and the service I'll gladly pass. I'm over the place. read more

John B I recently used Coliseum Caterers for my wife's surprise retirement party at our home.We had used them awhile back and ran into them again at a summer party last year that planted the thought in my head to use them for my event. Let me start by saying Coliseum Caterers did everything imaginable from A-Z. The event was June 4th 2022 this past Saturday. Let's start with booking the event. I dealt with Melisa who the most polite easy going salesperson to deal with. In about 15 mins or so of conversation I knew that we would do the all-american bbq package for 50 plus people. We added tray of chicken fingers and guacamole and chips for appetizers. Our side choices were red bliss potato salad, pasta salad & grilled veggies. In addition we choose lemon chicken, sausage peppers & marinated flank steak w/mushrooms & onions. Melisa was positively such easy charming person to deal with for planning. Everything was ABSOLUTELY delicious. We ended up on the day of with 52 guests and we planned for 60 and there was not much left over because everyone enjoyed the food which was great to see. Day of staff Marty, Mike, Terry ( please forgive me if the names of staff are not correct) did an AMAZING JOB. From setup to serving to even taking left overs and placing them in our refrigerator they did it all. Even helped us with cake cutting and serving as well. They were always asking if I needed any help and always going around and taking empty plates asking if anyone needed anything. TOTALLY AWESOME staff. They did everything so I didn't have to worry about anything and could enjoy the day with family and friends. When it comes to any type of catered event Coliseum should be your only choice. They should be the number one catering company on Long Island in my eyes. From planning, booking, to day of your event they do it all with professionalism to the max. Thank you Coliseum Caterers for making a great day even better PS I am not associated or related to anyone at Coliseum Caterers. Just an extremely satisfied client. Please give them a chance at any upcoming event. read more

When this place first opened it was great. The sandwiches were piled high, the chicken soup was fresh and loaded with chicken, breakfast was so filling you would skip lunch. But then.... It all went downhill. Sandwiches are no better than any deli sandwich. The procuitto in my "flagship" hero wad salty (the salt was being released from the meat) which is a sign of old meat. We also saw a busboy use a rag to wipe down trays, the door on the garbage receptacle and a table.... the SAME rag. Yeah, no thanks. read more

Had Coliseum Kitchen cater our Thanksgiving this year and they did a great job. Everything from the butternut squash soup, stuffing and salad to the homemade apple pie was delicious. The turkey however, was outstanding. Sliced thin and delivered hot in its own juices...it was tender and very tasty. Got some great comments from our guests on how great tasting everything was. Paid for it online and simply drove there and picked it up. Every aspect of the process was easy...exactly the way we wanted it. The staff is friendly and very helpful and it was a very good value for money. read more