I have never written a review, let alone a bad one. But this experience has me vexed. We really wanted to like this restaurant. My girlfriend and I have heard nothing but great things from the restaurant, the service, and the food. We looked at the menu prior to our reservation, and it seemed like everything sounded good.
After being seated, we waited 10-15 minutes before our waiter came over to greet us. When he did, we never got his name, and his tone was very dry. His tone remained dry the entire night, even though we saw him being jovial with other tables.
He then came over with sparkling water, filled each glass with about 6-8oz of water, and then proceeded to never refill each glass for the rest of the night.
After ordering our first and second course, our waiter asked if we would like some sourdough bread, that we wouldn't regret it. When the bread came, immediately it looked delicious. Hearty seeded sourdough, with a whipped butter. However, the bread was not cut even halfway through. We had to resort to ripping the bread apart due to not having a bread knife. I digress.
My girlfriend ordered a mocktail which was quite delicious. The sourdough was also very tasty.
For our appetizer, we ordered the Blue Fin Tuna Nigiri, and the Hay Smoked Beet Salad. The beet salad was better suited for my girlfriend, as she thought it was good. My crispy nigiri, while it tasted good, was devoid of the flavors that I was expecting. It was supposed to have lacto-fermented siracha, and habanada peppers. There was absolutely no spice to the tuna, and it tasted like the cubed tuna was tossed in a light mayonnaise with sesame seeds. The crispy rice was far overcooked, to where the inside of the rice turned into a sticky pine tar like glue, and the outside was hard like concrete. A butter knife barely was able to crack through.
For our entrée, we ordered the Seared Scallops and the Pan Roasted Duck. The scallops, was supposed to be with cauliflower, apples, almonds, and browned butter. The scallops came out cooked good, with a decent Maillard. However, not a speck of seasoning on the entire dish. The "cauliflower" was more like a broccolini, which was rock hard, and undercooked. There was not even the slightest hint of apple on the plate. The "browned butter" was almost inedible, and had a rancid flavor to it. At the end of my girlfriend's meal, she was actually disgusted.
My duck, was cooked to a perfect medium rare. But as soon as the plate was in front of me, I was hit with an overwhelming smell of wild game. The duck proceeded to taste even more gamey. This may have been masked if there was even a granule of salt on the dish. The rest of the dish was just underwhelming. Undercooked, bland, and out-of-place wedge of purple cabbage just felt like an afterthought. The sugar plums were practically mush. The sauces were also just lacking substance, and had flavors that were just muted.
The waiter never came over to see how our meal was, never refilled our water, never asked if my girlfriend wanted another mocktail. I would expect better service at a restaurant of this caliber. He also then brought over only one dessert menu due to being "short of menus". After giving us our check, he took another 10-15 minutes to come back to take our card.
The entire experience was quite unpleasant. The food was underwhelming, and the service was poor. I cannot say that we will ever come back.