This place is expensive. One scoop is advertised as 4 oz, but my boyfriend's scoop is much smaller than mine (we had 2 different people serve us). The cashier laughed and claimed that everyone scoops differently. There should be more consistency. The Ice cream itself was not creamy and had chucks of ice in them (freezer burned), and they only accept cash. Not returning. read more

Some of the best ice cream I have ever had, and I always try local ice cream anywhere we go. Staff is super friendly. Butter pecan and cookies and cream were delicious! The only suggestion I have would be it is hard to see all the flavors before you order. It would help to have all the flavors posted. I recommended it to multiple people while we were there and would go back in a heart beat! read more

An ice cream drive-through! They also have two tables inside and two tables outside. The shoppe is right next to St. Augustine Beach, so if you get your ice cream there, it won't melt before you get to the beach. All of Cone Heads's containers are even 100% biodegradable! The brand they use (for the ice cream, frozen yogurt, Italian ice, & sherbet) is Working Cow, which uses all-natural ingredients, dairy from hormone-free cattle, cane sugar rather than high-fructose corn syrup, and don't use any chemicals for flavor, color, or preservation. They offer new ice cream flavors all the time. Cone Heads make their own waffle cones, which you can sample, and you can really tell the difference. They're thinner and fresher than store-bought ones, so they're easier to bite into. They sell hard and soft serve ice cream (in cones, cups, pints, and quarts), sherbet, creamy Italian ice, smoothies, frappes, chocolate-covered bananas, ice cream sandwiches, ice cream cakes, ice cream pies, ice cream floats, milkshakes, sundaes, and banana splits. "One scoop" of hard-serve ice cream is the equivalent of 3 generous scoops, so if you get a sugar cone instead of a waffle cone, you'd better eat fast before it melts all over your hands! WHAT I'VE TRIED THERE: Funnel cake ice cream in a waffle cone and Fantasia Chocolate ice cream in a sugar cone. They're so good! The chocolate has chocolate chunks in every lick. The funnel cake tastes like funnel cake if it weren't fried and if it were turned into a cheesecake. It has kind of a cinnamon and confectioners' sugar taste with crunchy things similar to Rice Krispies. read more

I was very unimpressed that counter employees were not masked. Small kids ice cream was $4.50, and the black cherry flavor was terrible. Business is cash only. But seriously, no masks?! read more

Don't bother with the $7.95 sundae. They are small and skimp on the sauce. Not worth it!

Great place to get Ice Cream and food. Their customer service is excellent. I am a youth pastor and I brought 22 kids to eat there and they had the food cooked to order and served in just a few minutes. The prices are great also. Great job! I highly recommend eating here! read more

Give 2 stars for staff lack of customer service and nasty hot dogs! Family of 6 ordered hot dogs. 3 of which was for small children. Red head girl couldn't keep up with order and then brought kids hotdogs out with ketchup and mustard when we said all with ketchup except 1 with mustard only. We simply said "wash them off and bring back for kids". No big deal. She was so rude and acted like we told her incorrectly. How many 4 and 6 year olds eat mustard? I did when I was a kid but..... Haha Anyway, she also shorted the order by 2 hotdogs. So my Dad had to get up and pay for additional order. When he did the teenage supervisor told my Dad the red head felt mistreated...... Really? Red head never returned to the front. The hotdogs were disgusting and cold. Not all beef as told when ordering. Go for the ice cream only! Anyway, there was one young lady who took our ice cream order after lunch. As small kids in an ice cream shop ..... We decided to give it a chance. She was very polite! Kids and my parents enjoyed the ice cream! I have special diet restrictions and asked for sugar free and they delivered! Was amazing! Thanks to the one young lady! read more

Omg this place is so yummy. The espresso chip flavored ice cream is out of this world

I came here on a whim one night because I was passing by and I had never seen this place. I love the name :) by the way. I went in to get my son and myself ice cream and the staff consisted of 1 guy and 2 girls and boy were they friendly and treated me like I was the most important person in the world! I got vanilla ice cream in a cup for my 4 year old and the lady behind the counter was nice enough to offer to put a lid on the cup and put it in a bag with napkins, which was very thoughtful and it worked out perfect because my son was sitting in the back of the car. I cannot remember what flavor I got but it was great and I sampled a few prior to ordering and they were all fabulous! We will definitely be returning! read more

Good ice cream. Lots of flavors to choose from. Also has soft serve. Friendly and efficient staff.

Really shocked this place is still in business with the disrespect towards employees I have witnessed first hand. Not to mention they are cash only with a $3 ATM charge?!? A place like cold cow is a place to go for quality ice cream and customer service. Rita's or Marble Slab are also WAY better. The ice cream is subpar at best but the real kicker is the lack of appreciation and respect for customers and employees alike. Please don't support this business! read more

Wow! They only accept cash...because everyone going to the beach is carrying cash right?! Give me a break! $17 for 2 adults and 1 small kids ice cream. And then I had to pay to use the ATM. NEVER AGAIN! read more

I don't understand all the good reviews, it was very expensive ($5 for one scoop) and tasted horrible. Everyone in my car threw their ice cream out. Oddly textured, terrible taste, and NOT worth the money! I'd rather spend $5 on a pint of good ice cream rather than one scoop of gross "ice cream". read more

If I could give this place zero stars I would. This was probably some of the worst ice cream my family and I have ever had. We recently visited St. Augustine and Anastasia Island for vacation and chose to get ice cream here. That was a mistake. After taking one bite of our ice cream, we all threw our cups away. There were ICE CHUNKS in the ice cream, so the ice cream basically had freezer burn. There was also NO FLAVOR (we had mint choc. chip, cookie dough, and vanilla). You don't usually come across bad ice cream places, but this was definitely one of them. Waste of money for sure. read more

A lovely small local business. Try the salted caramel, a definite must. Owner was on site and working, everyone else said they were in college and working there around their classes. Great place! read more

Cone Heads Ice Cream - Pints available to take home! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

yummmy describes it best!!!!! Now if I'm going to eat ice cream this is where I want to go and our grand children. Pricey but worth every bite. Oh my try the vanilla malt. read more

Cone Heads Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

amazing .. This place has a ton of flavored handmade waffle cones add 1$ though. They have indoor abd outdoor seating, and lots of parking. In a rush they have a drive through! My kids loved it and they eat a lot of ice cream! We will be back. It's at a perfect spot near the beach! Btw 1/2 priced ice cream on rainy days! Great staff too! read more

Cone Heads Ice Cream - Boys LOVING the ice cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

See all

Super yummy ice cream! This place is perfect for all ice cream lovers! Bring cash though

Thank goodness ice cream on the best beach ever. Kids love walking here and enjoying all flavors

I wish I could give this place a lower rating, but it's simply not possible. We went there with some friends the other night to grab ice cream after a long day enjoying Saint Augustine. What a horrible mistake, the building looks dirty and dingy. Power washing and paint are NEEDED! The drive to the back of the building, that you can barely see due to poor lighting and are guided to the microphone to order. You are completely unable to see the menu, one of our group hands to get out and read it back to us! When we pulled up to the window, we all were taken aback by the alarming number of spiders, bugs, ants and so much more! We could hear the manager making nasty comments to their employees. As if that weren't enough, it all tasted like cheap, store-bought ice cream. For the expensive cost, there should be some quality. The only quality I found with the entire business and why I didn't complain. They are kind and defined what customer service should be - articulate and willingness to help the customer. Please, invest in your what matters for your company. It looks like a trashy place, just do better and bring up the quality. . read more

BEST ICE CREAM IN ST AUGUSTINE!!! My husband and I stopped here for ice cream for breakfast on our vacation and it was the BEST ice cream I've ever eaten in my life! No joke!! I got the Cookie Monster and cake batter, with real cookie dough and Cookie chunks and real cake batter and cake chunks! My husband got the strawberry shortcake one (I think?) and the cake batter as well! We both got the handmade waffle cones, mine with sprinkles! And I got sprinkles on top! Must go here, and we will be coming back for more! read more

Cone Heads Ice Cream - Cake Batter and Cookie Monster with sprinkles on top and a sprinkle waffle cone! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

See all

Really great ice cream! Only 4 stars because it's insanely expensive! Nice staff, great flavors and really creamy ice cream

Get some ice cream or dole whips for yourself and treat your dog to a tasty hot dog on a hot day.

After driving out of my way for your delicious ice cream, I was disappointed to learn you only take cash now. Not having enough cash on me to cover the whole family we left empty handed. With no bank nearby I'm not sure this was a great business decisions on you. Very disappointing. read more

Loved this place, great ice cream and curteous people helping you choose ice cream out of a plethera of flavors. Be sure to get a home made waffle cone...it's delicious! read more

This place is such a gem. So many awesome and unique flavors -- loved key lime pie and a brown sugar bourbon one. They also have the best waffle cone I've ever had, which they sell in both a cone and a bowl shape. They serve you fast and move through any line very quickly, too. Beware that it is cash only. read more

Very good ice cream with unique flavors! Kinda pricey but you do get a lot of the cost. The medium is definitely enough for two people

Bought the snickers ice cream with waffle cone, the waffle cone was like a ginger snap which was awesome. The ice cream was very flavorful. Rarely am I happy with an ice cream shop, this place was delicious. read more

I love the ice cream here. We live within walking distance so we come frequently. The new "cash only" policy is bad business. Credit cards processing fees are part of business these days. I own a business myself so I calculated the fee cost from my purchase today. It would have been around 45 cents. The ATM which has been installed "for our convenience" charges $3.00! I will never use the ATM there again. If I don't have cash, I will bypass cone heads. read more

Man what can I say. The staff here is incredible. I was helped by a young fellow named Dillon Bot. He is a special one. He is quite the man. He let me sample every ice cream in the store. He puts the customers first as I am always right. I'm never wrong. My friend threw up outside and he helped clean all of it up. Hailey and Ava are big hosses. That's all I got. May God Bless This WONDERFUL Establishment! The only thing is that they do not have paper straws. THE SEA TURTLES ARE DYING!!!!!! But I did have the best smoothie I've ever had! read more

Bring Cash! Great little place! Their waffle cones taste like gingerbread :) Hubs got a s'mores sundae which was kind of small, and I got 2 scoops in a waffle cone. 4 stars because it is a bit expensive. Only ice cream really in the area. The girls behind the counter were super sweet and seemed to really have fun at their job- which is nice to see! read more

Very good soft serve ice cream. I wish the staff at the drive through would wear a mask since the are looking down at us when receiving the ice cream. The price is very high for the ice cream. Cash only. read more

Was debating about stopping for a vanilla milkshake at either McDonalds or Coneheads. Wanted better than McDs so I opted for CHs. The shake was $6.00 for a small 8 oz serving, which seemed very pricy. To top it off it was one of the worst vanilla shakes I've ever tasted. Should have opted for McDs as the price would have been way less and it couldn't have been worse. I'm a local and won't be going back for sure. read more

Great ice cream place! We were visiting from Tennessee and we're heading back on the way home an saw this place, the service and ice cream is amazing! They have everything from doggie Sunday's to sprinkled covered cones And a complimentary beach ball!! 5 stars! read more

Good ice creme but poor service from an employee with bleach blonde hair and thick framed glasses. Came in 5 mins before closing and it was obvious she was not interested in helping us or being pleasant whatsoever. A few other people came in 2 mins after close as we were being served and the same employee muttered "show some respect" under her breath (to our group not theres). She was cold and callous during the whole experience and clearly cared more about getting off at exactly close time rather then giving ice cream to a little girl. I understand serving ice cream requires mental prowess and backbreaking work day in and day out. Scoop after scoop piled higher and higher creating a boulder of solid mass similar to the one Atlas carried on his shoulders. No one questions that the Cone Head employee who serves 2 minutes after closing is akin to a solider in the armed forces who has made a similar sacrifice with their life. And I know that it's a great injustice that she couldn't have found a line of work more befitting for the French monarch that she is. Perhaps she was not taught basic manners during her liberal arts major. Maybe she has a medical condition that kills her to put on a positive front and not be a total loser in front of customers? read more

First time here. They have a good selection but the servers were rude and acted as though we were bothering them. They need better servers.

Awesome ice cream! My husband, 17-month-old daughter and I are staying right down the street for a few days. We went for a walk on the beach and decided to grab ice cream on our way back to the hotel. I got the chocolate chip cookie dough and my husband got a strawberry milkshake. We were both very impressed by our order. I took a sip of his shake when our daughter wasn't hogging it and it was delicious! I'm sure we'll go back one more time before leaving the area on Friday! read more

Employees were not wearing masks!! service was great but icecream was not so great. i would not eat here again, icecream flavors were really messed up and didn't taste like the actual flavors. Icecream was also wayyyy over priced. read more

Good ice cream but overpriced. $6+ for a 2 scoop waffle cone. Should have headed south to publix supermarket. Guess it's not bad for the nearly departed with a large nest egg. read more

This was the worst ice cream I have ever had. We had a party of 8 and all of us threw it away. It had a weird texture and was freezer burnt. They will not give samples and it is clear why. If you try it you will surly not buy anything. Skip it and go somewhere else read more