I had a delivery order from Conestoga Style Pizza. We ordered a couple of pies including plain, pepperoni and Buffalo chicken. I had two slices of the plain pizza, which was very solid. I liked how the base of the pizza and the crust had a buttery flavor. There was a good ratio of cheese to sauce. There was nothing spectacular about either, but it went well with the crust. The delivery driver was a nice guy, who made sure everything about the order was good and he gave us utensils and napkins. Conestoga Style Pizza is a solid pizzeria that and I may order from there again. Altogether, Conestoga Style Pizza is a good pizzeria serving tasty pies and I would recommend them. read more

Pizza is ok, nothing special. Mushrooms are canned, not fresh. The worst though are the onion rings. 10 very small, packaged, not store made rings costing 5.25 plus delivery, tax, service fees and tip. Total rip off. read more

Conestoga Style Pizza - Photo makes them look larger than they are. - Pizza Near Me - Bryn Mawr, Pennsylvania

Solid pizza. Crispy crust and perfectly cooked. Would grab a pie again! Prices are also pretty reasonable too read more

Conestoga Style Pizza - Cheese pizza - Pizza Near Me - Bryn Mawr, Pennsylvania

They really did pay attention to the preparation of my small pizza. It came out perfectly baked the crust was perfect. Apparently they have been in business for 47 years, that is a solid indicator of quality and loyalty. read more

Delivery took nearly 1.5 hours. When we called after an hour to check on it, we were met with a somewhat rude "we are busy. It will be another 30 minutes." The pizza was lukewarm and undercooked. Not worth the $ or the wait. read more

Very good, very old school pizza shop cheese steak. You walk in and you know these guys have been making cheesesteaks together for a long time. I am 99% sure it was a Conshohocken Bakery roll. I like my Conshohocken Bakery rolls. They melted the cheese onto the role in the pizza oven, yummy. I love that. They season the meat nicely so it had a nice flavor. It was $8.50, you know I didn't hate that. It was on the small side. Very good overall experience and the winner of my mini Bryn Mawr looking across Conestoga Road at each other cheesesteak Showdown. read more

See all

Ever since I moved from NYC been looking for a pizza place. Workers were kind and pizza was delicious. Best I've found since moving here last May. read more

Tried them a few times now. Everything lacks taste. Pizza is bland. Cheesesteaks are just ok not much flavor. Would go to if nothing else was open but much better options in the area read more

Guys the manager. Maybe the owner. Either way, the old guy in the front is a tool. Not a nice person. Always has his bare hands under his shirt without wearing gloves. Got angry at my friend and I for showing up for a pickup 3 minutes early. Will not be giving this guy my money ever again, I recommend you don't either. read more

Fantastic pie! Been looking for a solid basic pizza in the area that wasn't over priced and cooked to order. The request of lightly cooked was spot on and delivery was fast enough the pizza was still hot. They have just become my go to in the area! read more

Let me start by saying I these guys make a half descent cheese steak. I ordered extra meat and extra cheese bc they're pretty light on the steak and cheese but the taste is on point. The cheesesteak was a light as ever which I would have normally swallowed if I didn't pay 13$ for it. I took the steak back thinking they made a mistake and they told me that was extra. You could feel their frustration with me and I tried to apologize saying "I'll pay for 3 cheese steaks if you just put it on one roll. " They rolled their eyes at me then tried to take the exact same steak and use it to make me another steak. When I noticed this I kindly said that they could keep the cheesesteak and walked out without a refund. I have worked as a cook making cheesesteaks for a living, I would never treat a customer like that. This guy lost a regular customer over 0.40$ of cheesesteak. It's honestly a shame read more

We ordered a white pizza, cheesesteak, and fries in person tonight. I wish we had checked the pizza before we left (shouldn't they do that?), because when we got home we discovered they had given us the wrong pizza. When we called to point out the mistake, they balked at delivering the correct pizza. However, we persisted, and, 40 minutes later, they delivered the correct pizza to us--which was now stone cold. They also took back the wrong pizza--what, are they going to re-sell it? I am underwhelmed at the lack of customer service and order accuracy. We probably won't return. read more

Love this place and their cheese steak hoagies with fried onions! Been getting cheese steaks from there since we were little. Live in Atlanta, but every time we in the area it is our 1st stop!! read more

Where would I be without Conestoga Style Pizza? It's my favorite pizza in this area and the subs rock, too. Pizza steak. Chicken cheese steak. The Greek salad, gyros and hoagies aren't bad either. It's been tough for me to explore the rest of the menu when those are all so good. When it comes to sub shops, I find something I like and stick with it for a while. It's my comfort food. And Conestoga Style is where I go to get that reliable, tasty goodness. There are a dozen pizza places in this area, but after a few from here, we stopped looking around and made this our default. For me, their pizza beats out Garrett Hill and Pacilio's. Been disappointed at both those places, but not Conestoga. Consistency goes a long way with pizza, and they've got it locked down. Highly recommended. read more

I've ordered pizza from this place for years I've never had a bad Pizza.you call it in 15 minutes later it's ready to go it's hot. They never skimp on toppings. And best of all their large pizza is an actual large pizza not to be confused with all the local places that sell a medium as a large. read more

Ordered food from Conestoga Pizza.Waited and hour and fifteen minutes.They forgot one soda and the food was disgusting. Will never order from this place again! read more

Love love love conestoga pizza! I've been coming here since I was young and they truly have the BEST cheesesteaks in the area! Toasted roll always makes a big difference. Everything I've had here is great including the gyros, strombolis, and pizza. It's an absolute favorite in the community! read more

In most kitchens, a ham-and-cheese stromboli is just that. But in the apparently unwashed hands of Conestoga Style Pizza, it becomes a lethal weapon. Seriously, I nearly had to be hospitalized after my run-in with this beast a few hours before closing on the Tuesday night before Thanksgiving. I will spare you all the gory, gruesome and painful details but just know that A) it was not fun and that B) there was something very, very, very dirty in there. So why give them two stars and not just one? Because for 30 years while I lived nearby, this was my go-to spot. Great baked grinders, and better pizza than GH across the street. It's a shame it had to end this way but "never again" as they say. And to the careless person who made and sold me that stromboli, GFY. And that's not short for "Gulliftys" read more

I have to completely agree with Joseph M. here. This place serves BELOW average food and the people running the place are absolutely MISERABLE. They act as if you are the ENEMY, not the customer. So with a combination like that, so so food and jerks running the show, there's NO reason to EVER go here. There are so many better pizza places in the area. read more

Food is just ok. They never get the delivery order correct. Something is always missing. Latest order of pizza was cold. Gave this place more than enough tries but I'm done. Too many good places around to waste time and money here. read more

Very polite delivery guy. Small amount of fries, but good seafood combo dish and gyro but the gyro has sauce on the side :,(.

Excellent service from our favorite pizza shop. The pizza always seems to impress, and you can't go wrong with their fries. I highly recommend stopping in. You won't regret it read more

Already knew they had great pizza but found out tonight they make a damn good cheesesteak too

Always excellent food and the service is great. We order off of grub hub a lot and always get the perfect meal. The pizza is the best on the mainline. Great food! read more

First of all, despite the delivery time being listed as 45 to 60 min, our pizza took nearly 2 hours to arrive. Then, the pizza tasted stale already. I don't know how you cook stale pizza, but they managed to do it. The mushrooms on top were a very strange color and likely from a can. I've never seen canned mushrooms that yellow. On top of all of that, the garlic bread was just butter (but not enough butter) and oregano. Not a fan. Not a fan at all. read more

Has anybody else noticed that so many pizza places have miserable staff? This place is no different. Just grumpy people working there. As for the pizza, just plain, boring and tasteless. It's just typical canned sauce and oily cheese that you get at so many below average pizza places across the country. read more

I love Conestoga Pizza! For the last 8 years it has been my favorite pizza on the main line - for 4 years of college at NOVA and as an alum in the area I still order 1/2 plain and 1/2 pepperoni for my family! read more

Now a days if you order out your most likely paying for over priced food that you could cook better yourself. But there are only a few places I choose to give my money to and conestoga pizza is one of them! Throughout all the years, they've always had good take-out and not pricey at all. I am very picky who I order from now and Conestoga pizza and Yang-ming are definitely my go to places when I don't cook:) read more

I moved to the area a year ago and have been searching for a good pizza place since the night I moved in. Last night after trying almost every place that would deliver to my apt, I finally found a delicious, wonderful location, Conestoga Style Pizza. FINALLY, the search is over, and I will be ordering from them from now on. Fast delivery and delicious food. read more