cheesesteaks are excellent as well as their onion rings. Soups are homemade and also delicious. Club sandwich is also a great go to. Cheeseburger sub is wonderful. Great hometown restaurant around! Never disappointed with anything I have ever eaten here! Definitely 5 stars! If you have room the desserts are phenomenal! read more

Good food especially their homemade chicken pot pie. Nice staff , good prices and nice staff.

This is a local, down home cooking kind of place. They have the best pot pie (Wed AYCE) & chicken croquettes (Tue), and great soups. If you want comfort food and a hearty meal, with reasonable prices, this is a good place! The service is almost always pleasant and prompt. It's not a quiet romantic location, but a cozy country-themed atmosphere. The locals eat here - just ask them their favorites. There is also a gas station out front with an attached mini-mart for to-go food, drinks, desserts and snacks. * BTW I bought turkey and filling from them for Thanksgiving, and they were fabulous!! Thanks Wagon! read more

See all

You can never go wrong with country cooking. At least not with me. So once I saw they had all you can eat chicken pot pie on Wednesdays, I had to stop through. It did not disappoint. The portions are big, so big I wasn't even able to eat a second serving lol. The service was great. Plus with such a large menu, along with different daily specials, I'll definitely be returning soon. read more

See all

They've got some great home cooked meals on their menu. A friend recommended this place, specifically their cheeseburger subs. Their sub rolls are wonderful. My husband got the chicken cheesesteak and he said "it was worth the 40 min drive here". The cheeseburger sub was delicious, except the burgers were small and sort of got lost in the bun. My kids got chicken tenders and pizza. The pizza sort of reminded me of a chewy microwave pizza lol, but he didn't mind. I'd love to return and try other menu items. Our waitress was very nice and she did a great job tending to the whole back room of tables by herself on a Saturday night. The inside of the restaurant sort of reminds me of a micro sized Cracker Barrel restaurant. There is a cute general store out front with homemade pastries and snacks. read more

See all

Great place for home style cooking. The menu seems to be primarily sandwiches but there are also salads and entrees to choose from. I had the chicken cheesesteak salad with mixed greens, tomatoes, grilled onions, cheese, croutons and a pile of meat. I also had the stuffed green pepper soup which was one of the better version and not full of grease. There is also a small store filled with sweets (long johns, Whoopi pies, shoofly bars and more). They also have sandwiches and cold meals to go. read more

See all

Solid classic American diner that's been in operation for over 40 years (since 1977) that also serves as the local gas station and convenience store. We ate here twice during our one week stay, which is saying a lot. I mean, yes, it was very conveniently next to our Airbnb®, so there's that--but, with that said, I'm not one to waste my calories on a crappy meal. Service was great both times and the prices of their meals here is unbelievably inexpensive. $5-7 in my neck of the woods barely buys one a cup o' Joe, let alone a full breakfast with the aforementioned Joe. I ordered their Conestoga Scrambler ($5.75/special $6.50/normal) and it was a terrific mash-up of eggs, onions, peppers, ham and cheese. I also "upgraded" my bread to the English muffin (25¢) and it was worth every penny. Fluffy, airy and a nice crisp. My second visit I got the Wagon Wheel Sampler ($6.50) that came w/ eggs, country potatoes and a protein of one's choosing; I chose a sausage patty. The eggs were cooked as specified, but the real star was the buttery and crisp country potatoes. I could've eaten a bucket of them. Rye bread is also an "upgrade" (25¢) but well worth it, as well. Great place to check out if you're in the area for an All-'Merican-style filling breakfast that's affordable and will fill you up. read more

Conestoga Wagon Restaurant - 🍳Conestoga Scrambler ($5.75 + 25¢/muffin)🍳 - New American Near Me - Conestoga, Pennsylvania

See all

great food, great service, what else do you need, different specials that are always tasty, great dessert items

This is a cute diner that serves something for everyone. (Although I tried to go for an early breakfast, and they were closed. They open at 11am.) They have a large menu, with plenty of options. I have food sensitivities, and was able to find plenty of things to eat. I considered getting their pulled-pork which was on special, but I got their Chicken Salad Platter Salad instead (with no cheese or croutons, since I'm gluten & dairy-free). It is a mixed-greens salad with chicken salad on top. I also ordered a side of Red Beet Eggs, and that complemented it perfectly! Service was very friendly. I can't wait to return! read more

Conestoga Wagon Restaurant - Outside - New American Near Me - Conestoga, Pennsylvania

See all

Takeout chicken Pot pie on Wednesdays = win-win. Book early. It sells out! I gladly recommend it. read more

Recommended by a close friend of mine and so we decided to have her Birthday lunch there. Located in the beautiful town of Conestoga and don't drive too fast or you'll pass right by it. Seating was spacious and everything decorated with a welcoming feel. The sweet tea is sweetened just right. We both ordered the turkey with sides and it was absolutely delicious!!! I even ordered wings and had to take home!!! ( I couldn't even eat another bite after the turkey lunch ). I will be back to try out the other options on the menu. Can't wait !!! read more

See all

They say gas station food you should eat at your own risk well this gas station restaurant I went to on recommendation of a local and when out of town eat where the locals do and they didn't disappoint. Had a simple angus cheeseburger and it was spectacular!!! Juicy and flavorful with an ice brown sear and it was a nice large 8oz burger with something special which I appreciated too bottom buns for a bun no oversized top bun which con sometimes throw off the meat to bread ratio. Spectacular eats and friendly honest staff read more

Came here for my birthday dinner because I wanted to try somewhere local but not a chain restaurant. This fit the bill just fine. I was a little surprised by its location because it's attached/with a gas station and small convenience store. But don't let its location scare you, it's a nice little place. I started with the chili and had the chicken salad melt with sweet potato fries as my entree. The chili was good, on the sweet side of chili so I had no complaints it was too spicy. The sandwich was ok, it lacked flavor unless you like tasting just mayo. However, the fries were amazing. My husband started with the ham and bean soup which he said was delicious. His entree was a pork chop with a double order of regular fries. He said it was the best pork chop he's had in a long time and the fries were good too. The service was satisfactory. Our server brought us more drinks before we had to ask but we did have to flag her down for ranch dressing for my fries and to order dessert. I got the pumpkin roll with vanilla ice cream which was okay. He had pumpkin pie which was also okay. Overall, we liked it enough to say we'll return and will recommend it to others as well. read more

Conestoga Wagon Restaurant - New American Near Me - Conestoga, Pennsylvania

Great little hidden gem here. Homey feeling, fresh made food. Always enjoy the breakfast but my real love here is the meatloaf dinner with mashed potatoes! Def a must try. A+ establishment. Never been even close to disappointed here. Staff is always super friendly as well. read more

Great cheesesteak with really cool themed / uniquely named sandwiches. My girlfriend usually gets the cheeseburger sub and loves it as well. You'll never hurt for selection here and everything we've ordered has honestly been pretty well done so far. Your experience will vary depending on who's cooking that day but that's always made it more fun to see what little variations you might get that day. A little advice though- skip the fries and stick with the chips in our opinion, they're great chips but only ok fries read more

Nice local place to get home-cooked meals. Friendly staff. Restaurant is clean. Nice place to go when I don't feel like cooking or driving far. read more

Best food in Lancaster county. It's worth the drive to this place. All you can eat chicken pot pie night is hands down the best around.

Great food. My husband and I have ordered from here a few times now as they're one of the only restaurants near our home when we want something quick and close. Large portions, delicious food. Their cheesesteak is killer. Their handcut sweet potato fries are my favorite, massive portion, they're even delicious reheated the next day. Their home brewed sweet tea is such a treat! read more

Tried batter dipped Cod, Mac & Cheese, Stewed tomatoes delicious & very reasonable. Take out only now.

Had their chicken croquettes and mashed potatoes with broccoli salad and they were delicious.

Super good home cooked food!! Even had a ham loaf special which is something I've never seen at a restaurant, so I had to get it and it was amazing. read more

The food was delicious and the atmosphere was very homey. I would recommend to anyone passing through. Oh and grab a whoopie pie on your way out read more

Pretty good local fare. I very much enjoyed the fried chicken, and the corn fritters pleased the table. Good kids meal options too. Overall, a good place to stop for a casual bite with the family. read more

Great place to eat as evidenced by the full parking lot each day/night. There are some things that are over priced but for the most part they are ok. 2 adults and 3 kids eat for about $50. I can also say after eating here quite often that I have never had a bad meal here. Staff is always friendly and the place is always clean. Decor while it may be "hokey" for some, seems down home for others (me). Don't forget to visit the gift shop behind the Wagon, they have some neat things out there. read more

I am usually at the Wagon for lunch once a week or so. Generally the wait staff is very helpful, and the decor is charming. The food is good, not great, and generally slightly overpriced. Salads in particular are a disappointment -- mostly iceberg lettuce mix, with few other veggies included. Sandwiches are good, entrees are a little worse than average -- too much grease and not always cooked the way I think they should. Yesterday, my baked potato was undercooked on one side and overcooked on another. How do you do that? The fries are good -- I guess I should give up trying to eat healthy here. read more

This is a quintessential roadside restaurant. I had the Friday fish special. The haddock was well prepared and Mac and cheese side was delicious. It may be the only place in town but it was worth the stop! read more

Came in on a Friday around 1230 for lunch. 2 adults 2 kids. Service was friendly enough, food came out pretty fast. Tuna melt and Reuben both great. Kids meals good value. Sandwiches $6.95 each, can't complain, comes with chips and a pickle. Only complaint is that we ordered food to go and it took a very long time to come. I suspect it might have been forgotten somewhere along the way. Otherwise not bad. Very family friendly, clean, decent service, very reasonable prices. read more

We ate here for the first time on a Saturday afternoon. We may have been the only people in the place. The decor is overly hokey, but in a charming way. They were playing an odd mixture of Gospel-ly Christian music and contemporary Christmas songs which was also kind of charming in its own way. I ordered the Cheeseburger Melt and it was awesome! Probably the most unhealthy thing I've eaten in months, but if I'm gonna eat something unhealthy it better be delicious and this was. I'll definitely be back when I'm in the area. read more

We came here in July while on vacation. We drove an hour today just to visit again for breakfast. Will be back to try dinner next time.

Fall is here and our family found ourselves once again eating at the Wagon. I've been here a few other times and always enjoy the atmosphere and food. It is casual. fun and family friendly. We attended last year and our friends enjoyed it so much they came back up to Lancaster county just to eat here again. I am glad to have it as a local family restaurant Not a chain and reasonable prices. read more

As the only store/ restaurant in Conestoga, The Conestoga wagon has a corner on the market. Luckily if you are looking for in-exspensive gut stuffing meat, grease and sugar this is the place. They even have a Cheesesteak salad! (basically a bowl of iceburg lettuce with a cheesesteak with no roll on top. This place is not for the gourmets. I brought my friends from Brooklyn and they had a tough time getting the grease from their specialty burgers down. try their apple fritters, green beans and chicken corn soup. Don't forget the rice pudding and their chocolate peanut butter cake. Stay away from their strawberry pie as it has more gelatin then berries. The atmosphere is country (slightly redneck) you can purchase the decorations and service is small town homey (someone at your table will be called 'hon') read more

My wife and I had the caesar salad, grilled cheese with Lays potato chips, and country fried beef with curly fries. Everything was pretty mediocre and lots of the food seem previously frozen. The ambiance was nice though and the prices were fair. I wouldn't eat here unless you don't want to leave Conestoga or have some special sentiment here. read more

A great place to have lunch or dinner. Simple food and a very varied menu. Something for everyone. Try one of their signature sandwiches. Wait staff is friendly and always helpful. This place is kid and family friendly. Prices are great and the portions are plentiful. It gets pretty busy on weekends for dinner so there can be a wait, but talking to the locals is fun and informative. read more

Favorite place to eat in Lancaster County! All you can eat wing night on Saturdays is amazing and they have the best sweet tea this side of Nashville! read more

neat little place attached to a gas station and a gift shop. Great service, large menu, and friendly people. Great decor, including old pictures of the owners, regulars, and I believe the owners report card on the wall. Food was good, with a large selection named after the regulars. Only negative were the fries, which came out a little soggy and undercooked. The place is a little out of the way, but filled with locals and regulars, which is always a good sign when I try new places. read more

Great food, local homey type atmosphere. Wings are the best around even though they're a little on the small side, Saturday is all you can eat wings so you can't go wrong there! I did not grow up around here, but I do go out of my way to frequent "the Wagon" read more

My friend and I had a girl's lunch out at this local restaurant. I had the chili and a corn bread muffin. The chili wasn't spicy but was good. The muffin was fantastic. The service was very friendly and she was very helpful with selections. The atmosphere was very cozy and the fireplace was very homey. This was a good lunch at a reasonable price. read more

Wow! Local and amazing food! Quality home cooked style foods! Great fried chicken and meal combos! Definitely will return!

We ate here before heading to pick apples. It was S great lunch stop. We got burgers. I replaced my bun with a pretzel bun. So tasty!!! Great atmosphere and excellent service! read more

Great place for down home country fresh cooking. Pleasant atmosphere and friendly staff. everything is fresh not frozen. Service is prompt. A bit pricey but you get what you pay for. Located in a charming community just outside Lancaster. Expect I will return often. read more