Went there twice last week. Sign inside circle K said CLOSED! Missing my Crazy Puffs! No indication…read morewhen they are going to reopen or when!

I mean, isn't every LC the same? All are going to be hit or miss. The times I've had it here, it…read morewas great and you can't beat the price.

Pizza descent. However, service terribly slow, facilities poorly maintained and bathroom not clean…read more Will not come back

This has to be the best pizza place in Kingsland/St Mary's, GA! I ordered four large pizzas to go…read morefor a social function and they were all fantastic! Despite being very busy on a Friday night, they were all ready when I got there. I am a particular fan of their Pesto Pizza. Delicious! The ambiance is casual. Cheers!

Great food, generous portions, fair prices, lovely staff and family friendly environmentread more

OMG! This is the best pizza I have had in years. They actually know how to make pizza the right…read moreway so you feel satisfied and experience extreme pizza delight. Generally, we end up with an upset stomach regretting we ever ate pizza, not this pizza. Perfect pizza! 5+++ is my rating.

Order: 2 teas, 1 big blue salad, 1 large vegetable pizza = $47…read moreDay of Service: Saturday @6:00pm Environment: quiet for a Pizza place that serves alcohol(in my opinion). 3 tv - no volume, but also no closed captioning running. I imagine I could have asked to confirm it wasn't an option. Eclectic array of painting on the walls and lots of stickers on some of them. You can see the staff spinning the dough for the pizzas from anywhere you sit. Staff: efficient and polite, nothing over the top. Everyone appears to know what they are doing and they enjoy it. Food: we shared 1 big blue salad. We both enjoyed it. I was surprised I would like blue cheese crumble with a vinaigrette, but it worked. However, $10 for their big salad left me thinking it should have been bigger. I wonder what the small salad would have looked like. The crust on the vegetable pizza was cooked well. Medium thinness, lots of veggies, not enough cheese in my opinion. I imagine the veggies shine when the cheese is in moderation. Good flavor, we added parmesean and red pepper flakes (they were fresh). I am glad we ate there because the crust became soggy under the veggies after 20 minutes. The crust wouldnt have survived the drive.home. Tea was fresh brewed and I enjoyed that it wasn't bottled. It was a pleasant experience, we didnt leave hungry and we could bring our service dog. Location: It is about 40 minutes from our home. We happened to be in the area. I would eat here again if I was in the area. But I dont think I would make a special effort to intentionally make a 40 minute drive for the experience when there are compatible places that are closer.

This is indisputably the most authentic NY type pizza in the state! It's as good as Raos pizza…read moreand my wife says better! You may have to wait a short while on Sunday but it's soooo worth it. Just great food! Nice people too!

Amazing food---hot and fresh Best service---…read moreFried Ravioli is a must have!! Cannoli was top notch

Great pizza! Loved our Margarita pizza. Crust was substantial but light. One of the best pizza's…read moreI've ever had. The vibe was fun with great music. Our waitress, Ashley, was friendly and very attentive. We'll be back!

Great NY style pizza, the service was top notch! The garlic butter dipping sauce is delicious! This…read morewill be a staple every time we go to St.Simons.

Very good. First time. Will be back. James was excellent…read more pizza was outstanding Just moved here and definitely will be my go to pizza place Greek salad was very good

It was a quiet night at Gooey's but we had a great time. The employees made the whole experience…read more We got a great deal for two large pizzas. In addition, I had the supreme chicken alfredo pasta. My husband loved his pepperoni and my son had the Cajun pizza. We will return very soon to try more off the menu.