I placed an order online to have food ready for a big game. When I arrived to Conti's, it was busy in there. The staff were working hard keeping up with the demand. I am always on the hunt for pizza and this pizza certainly exceeded my expectations! This is that good south hills pizza!! The steak hoagie was of good quality although not for me. The Italian hoagie hit the mark. Conti's pizza was the best I've had the past year and I can't wait to order it again! read more

See all

Went here to grab a couple of slices and it was pretty average. The pieces themselves were smaller than expected for a by the sliced serving. And the people at the counter really didn't seem to care if they had customers or not. After receiving our food, one person in my party, went up to ask for cups of water, but nobody was paying any attention at the counter. Signs hanging up demand that customers be seated and not stand. This place feels like it's seen its better days. read more

Conti’s Pizzeria & Pit - Dining room. - Pizza Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

Good food , nice variety Steak hoagies and Pepperoni pizza Well run Millennial run pizzeria read more

See all

I had been hearing raves about this new local pizza shop a few months back and, being a big lover of pizza, had to try for myself. The South Hills is woefully lacking in great pizza spots imo. Well, add this one to your list of go-tos because the pizza is that good. I placed an online order, had easy parking and had to wait just a few minutes for my pizza. It came out perfectly thin with a little crispness, a slightly sweet red sauce (not at all too sweet), and the perfect amount of char. There is some inside seating if you would like to eat here. I live within 10 minutes of this spot so will be keeping it top of mind for local pickup and recommendations. read more

Conti’s Pizzeria & Pit - Inside seating - Pizza Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

Went and picked up a pizza tonight, right on time and cooked perfectly, the pepperoni has such good flavor , very good pizza read more

Conti’s Pizzeria & Pit - Pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

Nice local pizza place! They have a good amount of space to sit and eat, weather it's outside on their patio or inside main counter or upstairs. The menu is limited to the top classic pizza options, salad, calzone, and Italian sub. Despite the smaller variety, they certainly know how to make all the items they do have very well. Service was quick and our pizza was fresh out of the oven in 15mins. We ordered the Apizza Spicy, topped with plenty of pepperoni, fresh jalapeños, red pepper flakes, and hot honey. It was delicious! Not too spicy and left you full after only a couple of slices since it was packed with ingredients. Even the crust was flavorful, with the sweet sauce and mozzarella cheese pretty close to the end. Make sure to check out their weekly cash specials to save on your meal. Great experience and will come back in the future! read more

Conti’s Pizzeria & Pit - Apizza Spicy - Pizza Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

We were looking to check out a new pizza spot and my husband said he'd been hearing a lot of good things about this place. We did a takeout order but when we picked it up the place was clean and bright inside. There's a few tables to sit at inside and then they have a cute outdoor area. When we try a new pizza place we go for a basic cheese and sometimes a pepperoni. We did half and half. They use the "good" pepperoni...which to us is the kind that curls up. The crust is pretty thin but it wasn't soggy. The pizza had great flavor. When we went to pay, the cashier let us know that there's a small service charge for paying with a card. So we paid with cash. And she handed us a menu to go which had some pretty awesome cash options. There's a great lunch deal on there for 2 slices and a Turner's tea for $6.25. Definitely will be checking that out someday soon! read more

See all

Thursday is their sub night, and I HIGHLY HIGHLY recommend it!! the Italian is my absolute favorite anywhere. Hubby had the steak and meatball. the steak had the most I have ever seen; he said the meatball is now his favorite. highly recommend. Friendly employees and delicious food...you can't go wrong!! read more

We enjoyed trying this new pizza shop last week. Our takeout order of one Apizza special (sausage, bacon, onions, peppers, pepperoni, and mushroom) was ready in about 20 minutes, which aligned with their time estimate. Toppings were plentiful and fresh. The pizza was a little floppy for us - we didn't experience the crunch others mentioned - so we may ask for it to be well done in the future, or try different toppings. I was worried that the "sweet" sauce would be too sweet (like some other local pizza spots), but it was delicious. There was plenty of parking, and a few tables if you'd prefer to eat there. We've also heard they have rooms you can rent, which we'll definitely check out in the future. read more

Stopped in mid afternoon since worked thru lunch and needed a quick bite. Staff is very friendly. Nice little place with quite a few tables. Pizza had nice flavor and thin crispy crust. read more

Conti’s Pizzeria & Pit - Slice of pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

Came by as part of the Pittsburgh Pizza Passport. Came during their listed hours on the passport and they asked I come back in 10-20 minutes because ovens are still heating up. Waited 20 minutes and they asked to come back in 20-30 MORE minutes because that's when they'll have the slice then. Then why waste my time and ask me to come back in 10-20 minutes? Horrible service. read more

This was the last chance for this place. My T stops here so on a cold Friday we decided to have dinner here. Geez Louise. This place is so poorly run. Our food took forever again. The young workers there are like zombies. Shuffling around, clueless. The pizza is not great anymore. I saw two other unhappy customers. One guy must have ordered a pizza with sausage and pepperoni on the whole pizza and what he got was pepperoni on half and sausage on half. I could tell he was not pleased but he took his to go order and left. The other guy asked for his money back because his to go order was taking so long. I refuse to go back. It has been less than a year since we first tried this place and were blown away. Wow. Get it together!!!! read more

Conti’s Pizzeria & Pit - Large pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

See all

This was my second time trying Conti's pizza, and I can confidently say it's now my favorite in the area (sorry, Fiori's!). Their New York-style pizza has a fantastic cornmeal crust, is perfectly foldable, and has great flavor. The sauce and cheese balance is just right, making for a delicious bite every time. I also tried a sub, but it had too much bread and not enough meat for my taste. On the other hand, the salad was large, fresh, and well-prepared. Overall, if you're looking for top-notch pizza, Conti's delivers. read more

Conti’s Pizzeria & Pit - Thin and foldable. Great crust! - Pizza Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

See all

Mi piace mangiare il mio appizza bianco, gracie!! I like to eat my appizza white, thanks!! read more

The pizza was very good but not what I ordered, I wanted half sausage half pepperoni and they put both meats on one side and plain cheese on the other. Also I ordered an Italian hoagie and asked for dressing on the side and it came with dressing on the hoagie. And third mistake was I ordered 3 BBQ wings with ranch dressing and received blue cheese. This was a phone order so I'm not sure why there were so many mistakes, I just know next time I will check my order before taking it home. read more

Conti’s Pizzeria & Pit - Wrong pizza - Pizza Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

I've been wanting to try this place for awhile and it didn't disappoint! We ordered delivery and it came in about an hour (Sat night). The salad was fresh and had fresh ingredients, not your typical iceberg salad from a pizza shop, the lettuce was crunch and green. The house dressing was also delicious. The white pizza had a nice garlicky crust, huge globs of ricotta (heck yes) and we added pepperoni, they have the little cupping pepperonis too and that was perfection. The large pizza is pretty dang big, the box did not fit in my fridge The biggest shock to us were the pepperoni rolls, the meat was shaved/diced and even had a little spice, this put the roll next level. Also let's talk ranch bc that's important at a pizza shop (to us) and it was delicious! They also offer a garlic ranch, which we ordered but I don't think they sent it, that's ok! Can't wait to add this to our preferred pizza delivery shop. read more

See all

We ordered two large speciality pizzas at 4:45 for delivery and were given a one hour wait time. I even applied a 20% tip. An hour and a half in I tried to call for the status.....it took six attempts for the phone to be answered. We were told that the order was in process. We received the pizzas almost two hours after we had placed the order! We had a similar issue with a pick up order a month ago where we waited almost an hour for our pickup. At that time they gave us an extra pizza because other customers had abandoned there orders. Do not order online with the folks or pay in advance! Their service is unreliable. They can not scale to meet the demand. Their pizza is decent but not worth a two hour wait. read more

I learned about Conti's on a reddit thread where someone mentioned it as a place to get apizza. For those of us originally from the NYC/New Haven area, "apizza" means something unique - not NY style, usually baked in a coal oven or wood-fired oven. So I had my doubts, especially as Conti's uses gas deck ovens. Ordering online was easy. Our first pizza was a simple onion & green pepper. The prices are competitive and reasonable. There are places I consider much worse that charge the same or more. I have to admit, the crust is pretty danged close to a Wooster St New Haven style. It's thin, it's got char, it's got chew. It's the best crust I've had in the South Hills since Claudio's closed (RIP Claudio). The sauce isn't Pittsburgh sweet, and a reasonable amount of cheese is used - not the excess of most Pittsburgh pizza joints. I would like to know what cheese(s) are used as it's good, but doesn't taste like straight mozz or provolone or even a mix. At any rate, I was impressed. I just wish it were closer to me (from USC). I'll be back. read more

Stopped in on a Saturday evening and was met by a very friendly, polite young man at the register. We ordered a large pepperoni pizza and two meatballs and a hot sausage. Very nice, clean facility with the pizza kitchen in full view. All the workers were busy banging out pizzas and hoagies. The main floor is a typical pizza shop with seating for about 20 people and the upstairs(which I did not view) is for larger groups. The meatballs & hot sausage came out almost immediately. They were fresh, hot and very tasty. Would be good with a salad and garlic bread! The pizza did not take much longer and was fresh, hot and very good! Those yummy pepperonis that are little crispy cups of flavor, good quality cheese and a delicious, thin, crispy crust. The service was impeccable and very friendly and accommodating. While dining, we had the unexpected privilege of meeting the owner, Bob Conti who graciously gave us a brief history of his business and how it came to be. Bob was such a kind and down to earth man-it was a pleasure to meet him. This is a great, wholesome family business who deserves all the good things life can give. We will certainly be back-can't wait to try more items on the menu. read more

Yea we went back... This is the best pizza in Pittsburgh - I love how thin it is. Best pizza in Pittsburgh. Just opened. Mazing read more

See all

The gluten free pizza was some of the best I've had. It's a tavern style so thin crust, square cut. A homemade crust and also a huge pie. Will order again and again read more

Conti’s Pizzeria & Pit - Gluten free pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

Great pizza....will definitely try again when I'm back in town. Salad was great too. Worth the price!!

Friendly owners good place to go for pizza everything on menu was good lots of different menu items to choose from

first time customer. the pizza crust seems like it's been frozen & cooked a couple times causing it to be a little tough to eat. the team said they had to 'rip' rather than bite into it. the crust is dark & it absorbed all of the sauce making it a little dry the meatball is very dense, probably from all the bread mixed into the meat, and seems it too has been frozen which diminishes the taste a bit the fries also seem like they've been cooked a few times, they are so dark. they are in styrofoam which probably contributed to how soggy they are read more

I was there tonight and I was disappointed. I ordered a large Calzone. I asked the attendant what was on it. He told me there was chicken in it. Well at first i thought that that was strange, usually it's plain and you have to specify what you want on it. When it came about 20 min later it had no chicken on it, and no marinara sauce just a glob of cheese in it. I asked for marinara sauce and i was charged 6 bucks for it. Did you ever hear anything like that. I asked to see the owner but he never came out , he was to busy I was told. They offered to remake it or get a refund. I took the refund. My wife had a meet ball hoagie again without sauce. I won't be back read more

Ordered takeout from here for the first time and it was excellent. Got a half plain half pepperoni pizza and it was really good. Thin ish crust, crispy bottom, and the pepperoni are the small ones that cup up and they were excellent. Seasoned fries were also excellent. Very friendly service, which is so important. Will def be back! read more

Conti's is one of those places you drive past and say you're gonna try it one day and today was the day. I ordered 6 chicken wings and an order of fries. I absolutely want to try their pizza one day and their sandwich's ! I was disappointed i only received one ranch for 6 whole wings and there should definitely be 2 but i made it work. The fries were good ! I love a fresh cut fry and have had many so in my opinion they need to change their frying oil but besides that i was overall satisfied! the wings were juicy and well seasoned and i'm really excited to eat there again. read more

Pizza, hoagies and wings were very good, easy online ordering. Staff is very friendly. Castle Shannon is lucky to have a place this good.

This is such great pizza! Delicious sauce, plenty of cheese but not too much, fresh ingredients and that crust has that perfect crunch to chew ratio! Really flavorful thin crust pizza! My new favorite. I got take out this time but next time I'm going to eat in. Looks really nice! read more

We love this place! The staff are always so kind and friendly. The pizza has the perfect crisp! We are also a big fan of their hoagies!

Solid pizza for this area. Pizza seemed like it could have been cooked a bit longer, but was very good. And would definitely trying the meatballs. Next time I would probably try a sub. read more

Thank you Conti's Pizza for a wonderful experience! I have been waiting to get there and was not disappointed. The owner is a great guy, the food was wonderful and the employees were very attentive The outside seating probably could use a little TLC... it was fine for us though... read more

We ordered two pizzas and a hoagie. For whatever reason they wouldn't let us pick it up...delivery only. Weird, but whatever. The woman taking the order was a little huffy on the phone. Our order took nearly two hours to finally arrive. The pizzas were both slid to one side in their boxes. It wasn't what I would call bad pizza but it certainly wasn't worth the price. The hoagie was average. read more

My son and I ordered a large pizza, fries and a cannoli. Staff was super friendly and food was made in unde15 minutes. We really liked the pizza as it was super tasty along with the seasoned fries!! Nocely done and we'll definitely be back soon!! read more

I've been here about ten times since they opened, had something different every time and was not disappointed. They have the right cheese for their hoagie. The staff is very personable, the shop is very clean. If you go there and eat inside, go upstairs to see a museum of interesting artwork and memorabilia. 5 stars read more

The food at Conti's is superb. Fantastic longstanding family recipes put to great use. We had pizza, hoagies, meatballs. all the dishes were stellar. read more

I had to stop, close my eyes and take a moment at the first bite of the white pizza! Perfect crust, amazing mix of mozzarella,and super fresh ingredients! Definitely the best pizza I've had in a long time. Lemon pepper wings were first-rate. Service was friendly and top-notch. The cashier greets everyone like she's known them forever and she's really happy to see them. I can't wait to return! read more

Excellent pizza and service. being a huge pizza lover I figured I would try something new and just came across Conti's on a search so figured I would try it out. ordered the Apizza Spicy and is now one of my favorite pizzas around. I have gone back now 3 times since. The regular with meatball and ricotta was really good too but could have used some more ricotta on it. Service is always great for takeout and they even made a mistake and made 2 of the pizzas I ordered and gave me the 2nd one no charge which was super kind. Its my new go to now. Salad is excellent and Italian hoagie really good as well but the Apizza Spicy is a must try read more

I called early in the day to confirm that they'd deliver to the address. They said delivery began at 5:30. I called back at 5:15 to place our order. Despite being only about an 8 minute drive away our pizza didn't arrive until almost 6:30! This was tough because we had older adults and very young kids to feed, who are used to eating by 5:45. Hoagie was good, pizza was so-so. We liked the thin crust but the sauce was sparse and there just wasn't a lot of flavor. read more

One of the best pizza shops in Pittsburgh. The Italian hoagies are one of the best I've had. Highly recommended