I'm disappointed. First off, called to order a regular white pizza, 14" medium with anchovies. The web site showed $14.99 + $2.00 for additional topping. Well, I was charged $19.14 for that 8 cut pizza. Okay, total bill comes to $24.76 (delivery and tax). Told it would take an hour, it came early...that was nice. Gave the driver an additional tip, he was gracious. Now, I'm not a connoisseur of pizza, but, I was quite disappointed in this one. I've never had a white pizza that had chopped tomatoes. The sardines were less than tasty as though they were rinsed off. The crust was so oily it wasn't baked through completely. The bottom of the box is full of oil. i'm sorry to say, I tried, but when I started the second piece, it was just not up to par. I hope this is just a one time error on baking a white pizza. $24.76 in the garbage. BTW, this was the first time I ever ordered from Milano's.... read more

Milano's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Allison Park, Pennsylvania

See all

This place is horrible for delivery. They just don't care at all about customer service. So many options will never order from them again. Almost 2 hours and no care at all read more

The pizza. And wings were hot and ready in 10 minutes! They were crispy and delicious! Ranch dressing was extra but so worth it! Love Milano's! Young employees are always kind and courteous. Thanks guys! read more

Pizza is always spot on. You can't go wrong. Steak sandwiches and the meatball sandwich is a killer. Best pizza in the Allisin Park. read more

Great pizza. Super fast. Take out only. Delicious just what we wanted. Glad we tried it. read more

Milano's Pizza - Glad we had this pizza during our short stay in Pittsburgh! - Pizza Near Me - Allison Park, Pennsylvania

See all

My favorite all time Pizza shop. The quality is the same as the first time I had it. I wish it was closer to me but luckily I can get it from Grubhub at least. The pizza and Italian hoagie are the best! read more

See all

I tried their steak and cheese sub the other day. Got it loaded with mushrooms, sweet peppers, lettuce, tomatoes, onions and mayo. The bun is from Breadworks. It was the best steak hoagie I've had in a long time. read more

I ordered pepperoni rolls on Monday 3/31/25. I called and spoke with Beth. She was supposed to replace them today, but when I called to confirm, my phone number is BLOCKED!!!! The blocked my they clearly burned my food!!! All over $16.00 read more

See all

Once again we had the gyros...they are good, as we have also had Maliano's pizza on a prior visit. Always good food and great service! Next visit we will need to try their hoagies. I recommend trying Milano's...a good, local, private owned businesses conveniently located on Rt. 8. read more

Ive been going to Milanos since they opened many years ago and I always had their outstanding pizza with pepperoni I recently started getting their manicotti and it is really delicious. I love their sauce. The staff is always super nice and accommodating read more

A surprisingly good pizza, pasta, and calzone spot in a low-key location! The food was quite cheap, service was pretty good, food made in a timely manner, and nice flavors. I ordered the small calzone as well as the funnel knots with caramel sauce. First off, their small calzone is not small at all. In fact, it's an excellent deal for a $12 calzone and is filled perfectly. I tried the plain cheese. There wasn't too much dough, which can often be an issue with some pizza shops. Also, there was a whole lot of cheese. Mozzarella, provolone, and ricotta I believe. The outside was crispy and the inside did not get too soggy. I also liked the tomato sauce it was served with. The food was served warm, even the sauce. A minor set back with the calzone was that it is a bit oily. Since there is a lot of cheese, expect it to be heavy and somewhat greasy. There was some lard or oil on the bottom of the calzone when I picked it up. The funnel knots came in an adequate portion for a fairly reasonable price. The dough itself is homemade, although I doubt the caramel sauce is. Still, it was a pretty tasty way to end the meal. Inside is fluffy, a little crispy on the outside (would have liked more crispiness to the dough), and you get powdered sugar with choice of chocolate or caramel dipping sauce. Overall, it's a nice neighborhood pizza joint. Not the best in Pittsburgh, but if you're looking for good pizza on Route 8, give it a shot. Calzone is good and funnel knots are as well. read more

See all

We get pizza from here at times with all of the options available in the area. We especially like their Sicilian pizza. Thick and full of toppings. Service is always friendly. read more

Milano's Pizza - Buffalo Chicken Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Allison Park, Pennsylvania

See all

ALWAYS the absolute best Pizza around! Hands down! Highly recommend the steak, onion, and cheese pizza! I wish I knew the receipt

Finding good pizza in the Pittsburgh suburbs can be a hard task. Milano's has been around since 1975 and they do a pretty good job. They definitely pile on the toppings and have a good crust. In my opinion, the pizza would be better if they added a bit more sauce to their pies. I've tried their Italian and chicken Parmesan hoagies and those were quite good and super affordable. A word to the wise: if you order online, you can't schedule ahead for pickup at a later time. You'll have to call or just submit the online order a bit ahead and hope the timing is right. read more

Quick update on my previous review: I was in town this past weekend and ordered from Milano's to try their gluten free pizza. I went through an app and wasn't able to add any toppings so it was just a plain cheese pizza, but it was fantastic. I don't know what crust they use, but with their sauce and cheese, it was great and the crust was solid. Going forward, this will be where I order GF pizza from when I'm in town. read more

Today was my first time ordering from this restaurant. I ordered contactless delivery through GrubHub. The delivery driver showed up at my house on time. As I had requested, he placed my food on my front doorstep and rang my doorbell. I went to the door, and from afar he thanked me for my business and wished me a good night. Here are my reviews for the food: Cheese fries - 3 stars - The fries were thick, and the cheese was congealed although it was still warm. I would recommend that they use gooey cheese. Italian hoagie - 4 stars - The meat and vegetables in this sub were fresh, and the bread was toasted and unsoggy. Stromboli - 4 stars - I got to customize the ingredients. I enjoyed the taste of the onion, green peppers, pepperoni, and crust. Traditional pizza - 3 stars - This pizza tasted "OK." The restaurant might be using slices of cheese rather than shredded cheese, and the cheese is not gooey. I recommend that they tweak their recipe a bit. Wings - 4 stars - These wings tasted pretty good. I liked the garlic butter flavor, the crispy outside, and the juicy inside. Overall, this restaurant will not be my go-to pizza place, but I will definitely order from them again in the future for their stromboli, wings, and other items that I have not yet tried. read more

This was first time trying this pizza place. Food was ready when arrived Everything was good. We had extra large pizza with half pepperoni and there was plenty of pepperoni on it and was excellent quality. My son had the eggplant hoagie and it was gigantic he could only eat a half. Also tried the bread sticks and they were good. The only negative was the dipping sauce was very watery. I would recommend this place and would put it in my rotation of pizza place's read more

So disappointed for the second time in recent weeks. We began ordering take-out during the Coronavirus outbreak. Our first 2 meals delivered were excellent. That was about 2 months ago. Tonight, for the second time, we have thrown out the Chicken Hoagie. The chopped up chicken was overcooked it was like eating erasers with cheese. Eggplant Parmesan - First, the to-go container top was smashed in with the other items ordered being placed on it in the same bag. As a result, grease all over the inside bag and over everything else in the bag. A lot of breading, some eggplant and again a lot of grease! [blech]. We may keep this and try taking some of the grease off but it's still soggy and not at all appetizing.(what a disappointment because the first time we ordered it was perfect, - crisp fried eggplant covered with a nice sauce and some cheese) Fried Zucchini - We think the problem is either old grease or not hot enough. In the past, we did get a nice order of this, - crisp hot and delicious. The last 2 times, - greasy, soggy blech! This went in the garbage too. The garbage got most of the last 4 meals we had delivered from Milano's Pizza. We are really sad because we had high hopes of a close place to order delivery from. Also, we are out over $60.00 that went into the garbage. I hope Milano's reads their reviews, fixes their issues and makes consistency one of their major goals. Others may appreciate this, but we won't be wasting any more money here. Such a shame! Totally disappointed. read more

After waiting 2 hours for delivery on a Sunday night, my pizza arrived burned and with the wrong toppings, my Stromboli had sauce INSIDE, resulting in a soggy (and cold) mess. Definitely won't order here again. read more

Why was my pizza burned when I picked it up? Why was there a hair in my ranch? Why did you not answer the phone for curbside pickup? Why did your employee touch his hair, his face, his mask and then go back to food prep without washing his hands? Pizza wasn't edible because you burned it. Lol. read more

Id like to start out by saying that we have loved milano's pizza for the last year and a half but that all changed today. My husband placed an online order for a large half pepperoni, half cheese pizza. Upon arriving home we discovered that the entire pizza was mushroom. We have two little kids who were hungry, so I picked the mushrooms off for them and gave them each piece. My husband and daughter don't like mushroom, so husbabd called the restaurant and asked if a new correct pizza could be made and delivered to our house to make up for the error. We were told that was not store policy to deliver a pizza that was originally scheduled for pickup. My husband was then hung up on by the store manager. I called back and described the situation to the (same) woman on the phone and we were then asked to drive back the original pizza to trade for a new pizza. I told her that we had two little kids who had already started to eat it. After all, they messed the order up and it was written in black and white online. I own a small business and if someone asked me for a refund I would never insult them by asking for the product back. I would just refund them, and then maybe ask what I could do to make the situation right. Not only were we insulted and told to come pick up a new pizza (but deliver back the old one), but the situation was made worse when I asked to speak with the store manager and the woman who had hung up on my husband in the first place told me that she WAS the manager. The best she could do was to offer us 20% off of our next order there. We will not be returning to this restaurant and we won't encourage everyone we know to not do so either. We know a lot of people in the area and I have a ton of local customers who I'll be happy to recommend another place to. I'd rather drive twice as far away to support a local business that cares about its customers and makes orders right when they mess something up. If in fact I was speaking with the store manager (I had the slightest feeling that she was lying, because the store manager would ultimately do what is best to make this situation right), I find it odd that this is the way that business there is conducted. So here's your one star milano's. I wish I could give you zero. Hope you enjoy it - and I bet you'll read this one correctly. read more

Poor management allows orders to be given to wrong customer. Told I needed to wait another half hour and didn't seem real interested in making mistake right. Like the food but need better management and less kids working front who aren't prepared to deal with customers. read more

I'm in the food business, nationally, and Milano's has, hands down, the BEST Philly Cheese Steak Sandwich, grilled and then baked, that I have ever tasted in any restaurant or sampled at a 'food show'. Milano's wide range of pizzas, made from 'scratch' took me back to Florence, Rome and Venice. The crust, it's taste and texture, was to die for. Buon Appetito, Guy , read more

We are never disappointed with Milano's. First off the have legit pizza shop hoagies. And if you are from Pittsburgh you know what those are all about. Messy and delicious. The pizza is excellent as well great sauce not too sweet not too acidic wonderful balance. And they ain't stingy on the toppings. If you want a neighborhood pizza joint this is the place to go. As an added bonus they always have great deals on their website as well. I'd post a picture but I am always too eager to dig in. Maybe next time. read more

Ordered contact-less delivery from Milano's & it arrived in about 30 mins & piping hot! We ordered the cheese manicotti & eggplant parm and they are both delicious! Both meals came with a huge loaf of sliced bread and plenty of butter! Highly recommending trying Milano's! read more

I love Milanos. I refuse to order pizza anywhere else. The only reason it's not a 5 star for me is EVERY time I order delivery they forget the ranch. Which is very frustrating when you order a salad or make notes for extra. I live fairly close and even drive down for it quite often since it's forgotten so much! read more

We've ordered a lot recently from Milano's Pizza - they make excellent New York style pizza and their hoagies are fantastic. Eating an italian hoagie or calzone, you can tell they are using quality meats and cheese - not your average bulk food service stuff. There's not much space if you want to eat-in, so take-out /delivery is likely a must. You can also order online via the Slice website which adds an extra layer of convenience. This has quickly become our go-to pizza joint in the North Hills - give them a try! read more

Thank you Milano's for delivering 16......yes 16 hot AND delicious 18inch pizzas to our hotel to feed our studio of 90 people. It was so good and everyone raved on your pizzas! Your service and prompt delivery was fantastic. Did I say the pizza was delicious? yummy read more

Absolutely the best pizza place in the area. Both pick up and delivery is consistent. Pizza is great (ample toppings and cheese), "wedgies" are awesome, sandwiches always stuffed and tasty. Family run business with great, polite service. After we discovered them we haven't gone anywhere else. Also, kudos on having gluten free pizza - appreciated by friends and family with sensitivities. read more

I ordered a steak salad and 2orders of cheese balls at 442 pm on Wednesday Dec 2 I understand there was a Steelers game but more drivers should have been on.... I was told an hour and a half wait time...I got my order at 715pm... Unacceptable Then I get into the salad it's warm....and my hot cheese balls are cold in the middle If I could have given 0 stars I would have... read more

Had a delicious dinner last night ! I had their pasta special.. penna pasta , meat balls, marinara sauce,and salad with Italian dressing -- garlic bread, Erin had a calzone..mushroom and provolone /mozzarella cheese . Colleen had a seafood flatbread shrimp, scallops and crab. It was a very enjoyable meal . We will definitely come back! read more

Milano's Pizza - Dinner last night. Pictures tell it all! Very good. Will definitely come back! - Pizza Near Me - Allison Park, Pennsylvania

Delivery came sooner than expected and order was correct. Steak and chicken wedgies were good a little light on the meat but amazing dough. Really good jalapeño poppers read more

I ordered Milanos for the first time ever on a Sunday night. I got the extra large one topping special for $14 that night. It was ready in 20 minutes for pick up. The pizza was hot at pick up. However, the toppings were scarce, the dough was undercooked and thin, and the pizza was so soggy and limp that the cheese and toppings slid right off. It was a greasy mess. The cheese and topping flavor were average, nothing special, nothing stood out. After reading the other positive reviews I was looking forward to good pizza, but that's not what I got. Hopefully this was an off day for them, but I probably won't order from them for a while. Sorry Milanos. read more

Delicious pizza. I wish they were closer to my house. Love the thin crust and great sauce.

Great pizza! Awesome place to stop by for a slice of pizza. Lunch special is grrat. Visiting from DC and loved this place.

Italian hoagie is the best I've ever had. Fries are crisp and delicious. Can't wait to try the pizza. This is definitely our new regular take out place. read more

Just bought a house in the area and am exploring the local places, ordered 2 large pizzas and when I stopped to pick up the food noticed the garlic knots, and decided to take 6. I changed my mind he was packing them and asked for 12 instead. He gave me a bakers dozen. Pizza was great and will definitely be ordering again. read more

I would give Milanos a 3.75. Good pizza and friendly staff. Only issues I encounter is the wait time over the weekends tend to be quite long and they add too much cheese to their pizzas. Besides that, great take out pizza shop! read more

I recently ordered over the phone for 2 small pizzas lightly baked as I stated twice to the person taking my order and I received them with a burnt crust and burnt cheese. In addition, my account was hacked right around the same time that the order was taken over the phone with my debit card. I will never do business with this establishment again! read more

Today was crazy busy for dinner and they kept it moving! Delicious pizza every time! Support small local business!