Here we go; Cooky's Deli has been within this location out East for a very long time. Never a quite time at this deli. Always have volume. However their sandwiches and food is and were phenomenal. Customer service was given with a smile every time I visit . As far as the decor it's OK for a deli ,however I think its to small based on the volume received from my knowledge. Decent pricing. Yes I will visit once Im back in the area again. Happy Yelping. read more

Cooky's has been here for as long as I can remember. When I lived out here I actually worked in this industrial area and would get lunch here on the regular. That's why when my cousin's who stayed by the airport asked where they can pick up breakfast for the fam, I recommended this place. I helped them call in an order for the whole family that was to be picked up and brought to my parents. We threw a lot at them and the only mistake was my BEC had SPK and I told them I didn't want it. Did I eat it anyway? Of course I did! Was it still just as good as Shtwenty (misspelled on purpose) years ago. It totally was! Finally, the guy that took my order was a peach. After telling me that their bagel selection was sparse being that it was later in the morning, he was great at picking the best bagels for my Southern cousins. All bagels were enjoyed by all. read more

food tastes great, thats not the issue. the sandwich is smaller than my c*ck and they charged me $20 for it and a tiny bag of chips, thats the issue!!!!!! robery!!!!!! im hungry after still!!!!! go to subway or jersey mikes for your money!!!!! read more

Cooky's Deli - Italy Club - Delis Near Me - Bohemia, New York

See all

The food was good but me and my brother went in to the bathroom to wash our hands and when we came out a employee said "you guys went in the bathroom together?" and gave us a dirty look and the whole staff laughed accept one kind lady who served us read more

Cooky's deli is far from just a deli! Special orders are made upon request without any hassle and the food is delicious! Thank you!

Absolutely horrible food, tried the chicken cutlet. Disgusting and cold. Tried the philly cheese steak. The steak tasted like rubber and liver absolutely horrendous the only thing making it edible was the american cheese drizzled on it. semi cheap but not worth a dime when i can't even eat half the sandwich with wanting to throw it out. Service is also garbage got a ton of attitude for ordering a large order over the phone as if it says on their website or anywhere to seperate it per order read more

I catered 2 3 ft heroes Italian and Cbicken Cutlet with mozzarella The hero's salads were great

Just spent $30 plus on old tasteless chicken and turkey sandwiches. Even horrible would be too good for this place!! Can't give a zero star but it is nasty. read more

Parkville deli Lakeland ave Sayville makes a great egg sandwich. Cookys is skimpy on the bacon and uses the craziest cheap eggs. We will pay more. Make a better sandwich read more

I got this bbq chicken cutlet sandwich and i thought it was pretty good. There was alot of customers so that was a good sign. The workers in there were cool. They have a big selection of hot food definitely tryna come back and try something else. read more

Cooky's Deli - bbq chicken cutlet sandwich - Delis Near Me - Bohemia, New York

cookies responded to my complaint and I thank you for your response and doing what is right and correcting the problem thank you again

Place is a rip off. Been coming for over 10 years and the fact they keep raising prices is insane when most delis are lowering prices. Will not becoming back after being a loyal customer for over decade. Wild move to keep raising prices for the consumer to suffer. It's a shame... read more

The Rudest Manager I Have Ever Come Across, If Thats What She Is. You Could See Her Treating Staff Like They Meant Nothing To Her. I Feel Bad For The Employees. The Food is Over Priced For What It Is, Mediocre. read more

Cooky's Deli - the entrance to the restaurant - Delis Near Me - Bohemia, New York

Today I thought I would treat my mom to a pastrami sandwich so my neighbor referred me to cookie so I figured I'd give it a try. I entered the establishment and was greeted by a Hispanic male who took my order. I proceeded to place my order for two pastrami sandwiches both with mustard on rye bread. I then watched the man place two plates in a microwave and magically my sandwiches where done I asked originally for extra pastrami not only did he put on the sticker as he put extra and didn't I then proceeded to pay. When I got to the register their was a tall caucasian male with a ponytail working I asked him is this a sandwich that has extra protein on it he lookin at me and said I don't know I didn't make it I paid the 45$ for two sandwiches and two fruit cups I then went to the truck to check the sandwiches and discovers their was no mustard I took the sandwiches back inside and spoke to the same Hispanic male who took my order he gave me an attitude because he fucked up my order first and last time I will step foot in the place read more

Cooky's Deli - This is a 16$ sandwich - Delis Near Me - Bohemia, New York

See all

Great classic sandwiches. You can't go wrong here at all. They have just about anything you would enjoy. They do have the best rice pudding ever though. read more

Great food options , bad service and rude staff. I spend 60 dollars 2-3 times a week here getting food for my workers and still always rude staff !! Wouldn't go if your in a rush or in a bad mood !! read more

Cooky's Deli - Deli - Delis Near Me - Bohemia, New York

Hadn't been there in sometime I went there I ask for my Hero to be made a specific way apparently he wanted to make it his way not even paying attention to me and I didn't even have the right amount of meat on it meaning they're cutting back but charging more now really sad used to be a good hero shop I think I'll go to middle country Road now from now on if I could give it less than a one star I would read more

Cooky's Deli - Does that look paperthin and shredded - Delis Near Me - Bohemia, New York

Overpriced, but we knew that. But for them to charge a convenience fee to use a debit card is insane. During Covid most businesses asked for a cashless transaction due to a change shortage, yet this establishment wants to capitalize on that. Now the food.... The egg sandwiches I got today were tasteless, unless you think paper has a taste. It was dry. How is an egg dry? I've said to myself I'll just drive the extra five minutes to another deli plenty of times, for now on I'll make sure to do just that read more

2015- Son's Christening. Forgot hero. 2023- Son's Communion. Brought 1/2 wrong order, No paper goods. Went back to store keeping guest waiting. When I went to return the sternos I asked if they could do something to make it right and the manager said "sorry no, he grabbed the wrong box, there were no names on them". What kind of a way to run a business is that? Multiple orders and you don't label them? Well, sorry, this is the last time I will order here. What is enticing me to keep coming back? That is a pretty big mess up considering it's 15-20 minutes each way that we had to wait. Where is the customer service? No one gives a sh*t anymore. If there are no consequences to mistakes they keep happening. The food wasn't bad, good price for what you get. read more

Will never understand the lines in this place. The food is horrible along with their baked goods. Not to mention way over priced. I've been here a few times and given them more than enough chances. I'll be avoiding this place at all cost now. read more

My BFF overhyped this place over the phone to me for a while, so I had to visit when I came to town. Long Islanders have their spots and this is one of them on this side of town. I'm a salad girl and although I liked my salad, it was nothing I couldn't make better at home. The dressings were just okay. I like the fact that you can choose what you want to add to your salad, however as a salad connoisseur, I expect the right balance between ingredients in a salad to make it scrumptious. These ingredients were just thrown in and mixed. My pastrami on rye wasn't as hot as I would've liked...I did get fresh lettuce and tomato on it (to their defense) but I always try to get fresh veggies on a sandwich and other NY (and FL delis for that matter) have been able to pull off my request with great success and deliciousness. Being a corned beef and pastrami lover, I am very acute to what an average sandwich tastes like...and that's what this was. Just average. I do need to give the place points for variety. read more

See all

I used to love cookys but now the food is hardly mediocre the staff are some of the nasty people there's a worker Michelle there who is an absolute terrible worker. I don't understand how an establishment is okay with the way she treats customers. read more

Cooky's Deli. Hmmm. Not the easiest place to give a simple thumbs up or thumbs down; Cookys makes a great egg sandwich which is apparently hard to do, but then charges at least a buck too much for it... this pricing continues exponentially into the rest of the day, and the rest of their menu. The food is not amazing by any means but still one of the better delis around this area, offering a wide variety at a slightly steep price tag. Chilli n Mac'n'cheese are decent... the daily specials are a bit cheaper but still leave something to be desired; Cashiers are mostly friendly with one exception, and I've had various feeling about encounters with the people actually taking the orders Big place, fine service, cute counter girl always helps with a smile, I don't know what else to say about the place, I'll post a picture or two and state that the place has a great location and is always busy, definitely better than some other delis in this area and other areas too. I like that they have a wide selection so they get an extra star for that as well. Enjoy. read more

See all

My daughter went there for a pound of potato salad and was charged $15.79! Had my last Super Bowl party catered from there, only to find out I was chared $30 more then another deli. This is getting out of hand Been going there for over 20 years for all types of family events, No more.. I feel they are taking advantage of people that build their business to the success it once was. read more

Quick service , friendly staff ,, 2 ppl working the register so everything runs quickly ,,I love there homemade potato chips ,, plenty of seating ,,they have dinner specials good prices ,,and decent portions . Beef stroganoff was very good, sausage and peppers and Italian meatballs were excellent, chicken Parm was chopped up which was unusual but tasted very good you don't need a knife, turkey roll ups we're OK, Salmon was very good, overall quick service good people again will definitely be back read more

After trying everything from the cooked food to the sandwiches and wraps I thought this place was good for nothing, until I had their yogurt parfait. It was great until they started switching up the granola (sometimes it tastes like a cookie , sometimes with almonds and raisins, sometimes just oats rolled in granular sugar) and the yogurt (from a delightful texture to as thick as sunscreen lotion) to the point that it was nothing like what I first tasted. Now it's just as subpar as everything else. The last one I had was like eating flavorless, chunky sunscreen with a hint of fruit. I guess they don't know consistency is key, no one wants to buy goodness one day and crap the next. I thought you had something good, but clearly I was right the first time... thanks for leading me on read more

Cooky's Deli - The worst version of their Fruit Parfait - Delis Near Me - Bohemia, New York

The place is a hit or miss definitely not worth going the food is overpriced and depending on the day the staff on the phone are rude and treat customer like trash. Not to mention the price difference if you order a item online vs if you say each item the prices vary vastly. Atleast ones behind the counter making food are definitely overworked and still try to keep a smile. read more

over priced!!! and over rated!! $11.99 for for a hoagie size hero with 5 slices of meat and 2 slices of cheese folded over to make it look packed!!! is crazy!!!! it doesn't come with anything!, no sides, no chips, no small salad, nothingggg!!!. unreal read more

Cooky's Deli - 6" hoagie! Not hero as ADVERTISED - Delis Near Me - Bohemia, New York

See all

I ordered breakfast from there and when the delivery driver showed up, I saw him finishing off his cigarette. The food reeked of cigarettes, no way I was eating any of it. When I called to complain the woman on the phone seemed to straight up not believe me. It took about 10 minutes of holding for her to agree to refund me, but only after the driver picked up the food. Why? I'm assuming they're going to serve the unopened drinks to someone else. Yuck. I just got a message from whoever runs their facebook page and they're arguing that the drinks are"unopened cans and bottles, not a homemade iced tea or coffee"...I really think they're planning on re-serving the drinks. Going on an hour now without the driver showing up to take this rubbish back. read more

Unfortunately I will not bring my business here anymore. I've always been satisfied until I was charged almost $15.00 for 2 slices meatloaf, a spoonful of mash and some grilled vegetables. I thought I was having the days special for $9.99. It was busy so I just payed and will deal with it when I go back. Well the bald chunky man who claims he is the boss, explained to me it's on the sign when you walk in, it's after 4:00. Funny how it's not on the special chalk board when you're ordering by the counter. I told him it should be written there too. He repeated himself and offered nothing up not even the drink that was missing. I went and payed for what I bought, and stopped to tell him that I will not be back to your establishment, he loudly said have a nice day in a sarcastic voice. You should be thankful to be so blessed for a lot of years but location is a huge factor for your success not customer service. read more

Bec spk's were delicious, fresh and good, little pricey but worth ur buck. would recommend if u the person to spend 20$ on a burger when u can get the same for 2$ read more

Deli An extremely popular deli that serves breakfast & lunch - and you can order things to take for dinner as well. Cooky's is always a mob scene at or around lunch time and for that reason I tend to only order delivery from them... A huge selection of sandwiches and cooked dishes - there are standard items and daily specials, plus specials of the day - so plenty of variety to keep it from getting old. I like the fact that they deliver - and many people in my office order that way- plus their website is actually useful so ordering in is a snap. Prices are not too bad- but expect to hit at least $10 per person for lunch. Parking all around the physical location. read more

My car was damaged in their parking lot by a hit and run driver. When I asked ownership for assistance with the video footage, they didn't care. Completely unwilling to help. Karma is a btch. One day she will need some ones assistance and she won't get it. read more

This deli has an enormous selection for breakfast, lunch & dinner. First time here this morning and for a Saturday they seem really organized even though the line is really long. There is an ample amount of seating with huge Windows so it's a nice place to sit and relax for 5 minutes. We got a baconegg&cheese (in New York that's one word lol), a soup and a bagel. I asked for my bagel toasted and I sat down to the table and it was cold :(. The soup was burning hot though and that's a huge plus because I love my food super duper hot. My dad sometimes brings food home from here for dinner and I've had the chicken Cesar wraps and the quality of the products they use seems sketchy. The chicken is good MOST of the times. They use neon orange bacon bits which grossed me out so I never ordered it again. I'll probably stop back here again and try something different but for now 3 stars seems good for my rating. read more

So yesterday I wake up, and decide that it was a perfect day for a large bowl of delicious chicken soup. I live nearby to Cooky's, so figured I would go there. Wrong. The soup was watered down. Clearly it was not simmered in stock for hours. Chicken? A few tiny pieces of chicken (dark meat) in my large cup of soup. It was mainly carrots, celery, onions, and tiny pasta known as Mezze Meniche. If you know anything about chicken soup healing the body, it is actually the chicken that does the healing. The vegetables are just along for the ride. I had their clam chowder a couple of months back, and it was very good. So it sounds like Cooky's needs to teach their staff how to make homemade chicken soup. No seasonings like salt and pepper in it. Soup was bland, tasteless, and lacked everything a good bowl of chicken soup from a neighborhood deli is supposed to have. read more

This deli is close to my job so I decided to try it. The line was long but they move very fast. I got a BEC with SPK on a roll and there was the perfect amount of ketchup so it wasn't dripping out the sides. The employees were so nice, which is especially great because usually in fast paced environments employees don't always take the extra time to be friendly. My only complaints are that there is a slight fee (I think it's 3.5%) for paying with a card and that they don't have an espresso machine or any syrup flavors. I got an iced coffee with pumpkin creamer but I usually prefer an iced latte with a flavored syrup. However, they do all of the coffee stuff behind the counter which is probably good during the pandemic so not everyone is touching everything. Also the iced coffees come in styrofoam cups which is common for delis but terrible for the environment. In conclusion, I will 100% be returning because they move fast and the employees are extremely nice which makes me care a lot less about my dumb coffee opinions and a small charge for using a card. read more

Cooky's Deli - Bacon, egg and cheese on a roll with salt, pepper & ketchup - Delis Near Me - Bohemia, New York

Not thrilled with Cookys. I always get the captain Jack sandwich minus Turkey. It's often been pretty good. I am trying to eat better so decided to start getting the Panini combo. It's 1/2 a panini and a tossed salad. Someone tells me that I can't have the panini combo minus the Turkey. Why? Well because when we make the combos we only make them fresh if we don't have them already made from the morning. They make paninis in the morning, cut them In half and use them for the combos so that's why sometimes they are cold and stale. Sometimes they are the way they SHOULD be because they have none left and are made fresh. Today I spoke to someone else who took my order the way I wanted but when it was delivered it was cold, stale, had a piece of Turkey left on it... And MAYBE some remnants of cheese, 1 piece of lettuce and 1 thin slice of tomato. Pathetic. It was SO LIGHT, That I though the folded triangle of paper was garbage and not my sandwich. My coworkers and I couldn't believe it. No excuse. They have officially lost my business. You don't take an ingredient off a sandwich and serve it. That's just poor business. I'm paying a decent amount of money I should be getting fresh food the way I ask for it. As a matter of fact I am paying the same for less... Keep the turkey! Now I'll just go to Sayville Sandwich, Panera or Parkville. read more

Cooky's Deli - Cookys 1/2 captain Jack panini minus Turkey. Smallest 1/2 panini I've ever seen. Ridiculous. - Delis Near Me - Bohemia, New York

It's convenient to stop in for a fast, pre made sandwich. They have a wide variety but my sandwich has a weird taste and the pre packaged date was 5 days ago. I'm not surprised the food isn't so fresh because one time I got rice pudding and there was mold in it. Check the dates and hope for the best. read more

Their sandwiches are always great. They also have breakfast everyday. I got a Napolitano and an iced coffee.

My husband and I have been going to Cooky's for years. We loved their food! However, today we ordered an 8 egg omelet ( we have ordered this for years) and received an order of what looked like 4 eggs in our poor looking omelet. We know what an 8 egg omelet looks like and how heavy if should be. What we received was not. My husband told the cashier and even the manager. They did nothing about it at! I called the manager, the manager explained that they are now using eggs from containers... I guess this is their answer to why the omelet didn't look consistent with their usual product that they make and did not feel the right weight. Unfortunately, my husband was so displeased with his experience that we have decided that we will no longer do any business with Cooky's. From now on, we will order food from the Holbrook Dinner! read more