Although there is no seating area, this Cottage Inn makes a good pizza. Good crust, good toppings and even coverage. I would definitely prefer this over the other takeout pizza chains (maybe with the exception of Jets). The staffer who helped me was kind and professional. read more

How on earth is that gluten-free jalapeño popper actually gluten free?! It's insanely delicious! I was having a rough day and decided to treat myself to this for dinner. Being gluten intolerant can be such a drag--especially when you miss those classic comfort foods. But this hit the spot. I can't tell you enough how much I loved it. Thank you! Didn't get a photo as I was too eager to gobble it up read more

Did not bring my pizza claimed to have tried and left with it. But instead decided to take it back to the store

Cottage inn is one of my top favorite pizza places !! They stay late until 3 am and they deliver in decent speed. I am big fan of (make your own pizza thing) and i like thier 2topping large pizza deal. My default topping always black olive, beef and spanish! It is perfect and super tasty . But Yesterday after midnight, i ordered cheese pizza with spanish, green pepper, mashroom and feta cheese. Omg, i swear by it! Super delicious, soft dough, cheesy and warm! Next time I will try some sandwiches and dessert. read more

Cottage Inn Pizza - Beef, Spanish and black olive pizza - Pizza Near Me - Kalamazoo, Michigan

See all

If I were to rank the pizza places on the west side of Kalamazoo, I'd say that cottage inn is a close second to Erbellis. The pizza is always great. The staff is fast and I'm never waiting longer than expected. (even when they are slammed) it's no wonder there is a constant flow of people in and out. Also, great job keeping the place clean. read more

I love the variety and quality of the pizza you can get here as well as the salads. The staff is polite and helpful, every time i visit in person. The thing that dinged a star off the review is the online ordering service. I like to order online and get food delivered, I am a nerd, it is my thing, but with a new mapping system I am told I am out of the delivery area, I call and get told 'oh no you are in delivery area, we will get it updated/fixed'. No, every time I have to call in to get a delivery it mention it and at least 3 months later still not fix. Love the food hate the tech :) read more

The pizza and it was here at assigned time. Staff were very helpful. Pizza was great. My husband loves their new pepperoni.

Just had the absolute WORST meal I've had in years! Don't EVER bother with the lasagna! Ugh! It smells like mold! It's horrid. Just horrid! I'll not be going back for quite awhile. So disgusting! read more

So good. Used to go to the one in Sturgis MI alot when I lived there. It reminds me of home and all the good memories I had. Hands down one of the best pizza places read more

Cottage Inn Pizza - Sausage pizza w alfredo sauce - Pizza Near Me - Kalamazoo, Michigan

See all

So, I'm a pizza lover and I guess you can consider me to be a trustworthy pizza critic. Anyway, let's get to it. Cottage Inn Pizza's vegetable pie IS tasty that's why I am giving it 2 stars rather than 1. Here's the problem, I have ordered 2 extra large pizza pies from this establishment. Today I decided to go with the large. I realized it was the same size pizza, just a smaller box. I have been bamboozled and I feel foolish. Next time I will order the medium and I will let you guys know what their game is. The man who took my order was very nice... maybe too nice. The man who delivered my pizza was not very friendly. I'm happy it was a no contact delivery to say the least. I'm sad because it is very difficult to find a decent pizza around here, and as previously stated, their pizza is tasty. I simply do not appreciate being tricked! read more

We are SO DISAPPOINTED in their pizza. It used to be really good. Well Not anymore. The last 2 pizzas we have had from the KL ave location have been terrible!!! Doughy,lacking any flavor and barely any toppings!!! We will not be getting pizza from them again. read more

Website promoted ordering discount on app, but site wouldn't proceed to checkout. Ordered on regular site without discount and was told there would be a 2-hour wait (Friday night). Tried to call Kalamazoo location to cancel, waited 15 minutes on hold, and then was disconnected. We've been ordering Cottage Inn pizzas for over 25 years, but will NEVER order another one again. Absolutely zero customer service! And their website is a scam. read more

the KL cottage in is my go to i love this place kiss kiss i'll go here forever and ever is my love

I was just expecting a decent pizza but wow I was blown away by how amazingly good it is! My partner and I like it more than any other pizza place we've had around here. We'll definitely return. Highly recommend! read more

Tried to have a Pizza party at FSM today and this is what they we got from Cottage Inn.... A apology would have gone a long way. I'll be sure to tell all of our WMU colleagues about our experience read more

Cottage Inn Pizza - Here's what we got - Pizza Near Me - Kalamazoo, Michigan

My favorite pizza place. It is the only pizza place that delivers gluten free pizza. It is also the only pizza chain (other than Buddy's) that I have come across that actually advertises and delivers on gluten free. They cook the gluten free pizzas on their own aluminum tray and make sure they are actually prepared separately from glutenous products in the rest of the kitchen. Especially compared to dominoes who also advertises gf pizza, cottage inn is much more reliable for someone with celiacs disease and severe gluten insensitivities. my favorite pizza place everrrrr read more

On 3/21/21 I placed an order that Cottage Inn KL Ave- Kalamazoo delivered to the wrong address. I was promised a new batch and was delivered the original batch which was over 1.2hrs old at that point. Some of this order was going to a dialysis patient and an 83yr old person. I wonder what the Health Department and the BBB is going to say about their practices. They would not even return the $10 cash I gave to the driver who lied to me and delivered open packages. This seems like classic trickledown bad management. Maybe they will do better in the future, but buyer beware for now! read more

Best chicken and pie offerings I tried yet. Many choices for sauce, deep dish pie was done right- hard to leave a town when I find this good kind of consistent dinner. Really great selection and service! read more

Cottage inn Pizza at this location is bad and runs by dishonest people. They sends out coupons but do not honor it. Stay away from this location read more

Two years and two weeks ago my boyfriend (shouldn't call him that) and I came here for a pizza with anchovies on it, the first time (and only) after 10 years of being a vegetarian that I ate fish. I don't know what anchovies are supposed to taste like. They were very salty and the texture was new - we had been dating for a little over three months and I told him I loved him while crying on his couch and trying to decide to stay in town or take a job offer in Texas and he said it wasn't fair for me to say that but he loved me too - I'm not sure how much *crunch* is emblematic of an anchovy. Being happy is potentially not real, but the gaps are filled with feelings like fulfillment and purpose and - as discussed in a previous lesson - gratefulness. Also the shared emotion of looking at a good photo of a dog. You know when you connect with someone so cool you think you'll never grow into them? And that person becomes someone who watches your face when you smell a candle and then buys you the candle when you're not looking because he thinks you deserve it? Have you also noticed the look you get when you order/pick up a pizza with anchovies? It's like the cashier is so relieved to get the pizza out of his nasal radar and also so angry with you for making him smell it in the first place but he still has to say thank you for buying the pizza. After a while it's hard to celebrate milestones, but they're not getting any smaller. Why did it have to get harder? What happens when he leaves you? Are you still worth the things he said? The holy trinity of breakups: melancholia, nausea, descent into inoperativity. You didn't deserve the candle! so you lit it 48 hours ago and let it burn to the bottom. Now you're 2,200 miles away from the nearest Cottage Inn and trying fitfully to think of a more romantic meal than pizza with anchovies. read more

Always delicious and they always have coupons! Delicious pizza and the staff are ALWAYS extremely friendly!

I've been a Cottage Inn customer for a few years now. I think they have some of the best sandwiches in town. I love their pizza sub (I get pepperoni and bacon). It's always saucy, hot and high quality. Their Cottage Inn Stix are quite good, as well their cheese sticks are very good too. Their sauce is great, their garlic butter is fantastic. I'm not a big fan of their pizza crust. Something about it is kinda chewy. I don't notice this as much in the bread or cheese sticks. Service is always great and delivery is usually on time. They have great deals for students too! read more

I ordered the veggie pizza and it was very good. The person who took my order was excellent cause I requested some special items and they were perfect. I had the thin crust...I recommend this for sure! read more

This was my first time ordering Cottage Inn Pizza, and unfortunately I was very disappointed with my experience. I ordered a salad (minus tomatoes) and pizza for delivery. The salad arrived with tomatoes, and the pizza arrived crumpled (see picture). The flavor of the pizza was okay, but I will not be ordering from Cottage Inn Pizza again. read more

Cottage Inn Pizza - a pepperoni pizza in a pizza box - Pizza Near Me - Kalamazoo, Michigan

This place absolutely stinks. Took forever to get our pizza and once we opened the box, it was a disaster. Half of the pizza was slid to one side in a big, messy pile of cheese and dough. Will never order from Cottage Inn again. read more

Great locally owned business, the pizza is great the service is friendly and they take care of the community.

You order online. You get there 5 minutes late and you still wait 15 minutes for your pie. Why order Online

Cottage Inn has delicious, hot pizza! Our driver just went above and beyond to bring us back a 2 liter of Diet Coke. Thank you for the superb service!! read more

1st order: in store - pizza. Dough was very doughy/raw-esque. Topping were good. 2nd order: delivery - calzone with 2 different dips. Took 40 minutes to arrive. Signed charge card receipt & gave a generous $5 cash tip... neither dips were there. Driver tried to say they weren't on the order - alas, they were clearly shown on the order receipt. Informed driver to return the calzone, as by the time they would get around to coming back with the ordered dips, the calzone would be cold and unfortunately, I had no oven to reward it in at my extended stay. Driver took off... WITH the $5 tip!!!!!!!!!!!!! Store did not offer to return the tip! Not cool. Buyer beware! read more

My boyfriend got a free pizza from here when moving into his apartment just down the road. We expected it to be ok, and were pretty blown away when this way flavor packed pizza came out to us at the table. We went with a basic sausage pizza, and it didn't disappoint! Do yourself a favor and get the garlic cheese bread. It's so tasty... read more

had this for delivery last night around midnight, not the worst food i've had but i've definitely had better. the boneless wings i ordered were wrong (i asked for bbq sauce and got plain wings with no sauce at all) and the pizza had no flavor and was a little undercooked. tasted like the cheapest pizza i've ever had to be honest. i've talked to management there about getting credit back for the food but still wasn't able to get a full refund, but he was friendly on the phone. i wouldn't really recommend, especially with the variety of pizza places kalamazoo has to offer. read more

I can't speak on the food but the service is horrible. I did an online order for delivery. Yes I was staying at the Red Roof Inn. 40 FORTY FULL MINUTES after placing my order, literally AFTER my order should have been delivered, they called to let me know that they won't deliver there. Sure, understandable... but you didn't NOTICE the delivery address until after the order should've been delivered. The man I spoke to was NOT helpful. Couldn't tell me when my payment would go back in my account just that it would show pending. And hung up on me when I started explaining that I wouldn't even be mad if they had just called immediately. Everything close is now closed so I can't even go get myself food. Absolutely AWFUL customer service. read more

This place has the best pizza. THE. BEST. PIZZA. That I've had in a long time. It's always fresh, tastes amazing and they're very friendly. I usually order a pizza with a side of inn-stix (get them) and I'm never disappointed. Their food tastes fresh and is affordable. Definitely try it if you're ever in k-zoo. read more

I have never had such a greasy pizza. I mean the crust from the middle right to the edge was actually soggy with grease. You could squeeze it and watch the grease drip out. On top of that the cheese wasn't even melted all the way. Took a bite and got a mouthful of cheese shreds on top of a grease soaked crust. 1st and last time trying them. read more

When I ordered a gluten free pizza I wasn't expecting much but I have to say it was absolutely delicious. Cottage Inn never fails to surpass my expectations. Best pizza place ever! Though, don't order more than u can eat in one night because it does not make for very good leftovers. read more

Very disappointed, extremely expensive for "gourmet pizza" surprising that the prices are this high in a college setting. Will not be returning read more

Something has happened since last order in Feb. 2017. This crust was not home made; it was cardboard, reminding you of a cheap grocery-store "Boboli" pizza. Toppings were good, but not hot. It was an assembly-line pizza with some sort of generic purchased crust. read more

I ordered a boatload of pizza and salads for a big family party last night. Set the delivery time at 7:30. The driver showed up promptly at 7:30 with our order exactly correct and pizzas nice and hot. I would order again in a heartbeat based on this terrific experience!! And, as per usual, it all tasted great! Thanks, Cottage Inn!! read more

They were great when they first opened, but are going downhill fast. Whatever you do, DON'T ORDER ONLINE! If anything is wrong on your order, they will tell it is a corporate website, therefore a corporate issue that they can't do anything about. Then they will offer, happily, to remake the order for you at full charge! I can only assume it will get worse from here... read more

YUMMY! Awesome pizza and super friendly delivery people! Can't wait for next time!