This was our first visit. They only have carryout at this location. The staff and owner were…read morevery friendly. The food was ready on time. When we arrived at home we dug right in and the food was fantastic. The pizza was cooked perfectly, as was the canzone! The Italian sub sandwich was very good, but I would have liked a little more red sauce. That's just me and I will order it next time. We will be ordering again. If you are looking for quality Italian food at a very affordable price, order from Michaleno's!

Very average. Not the best pizza around but not bad in a pinch. Delivery and carry out only. Fish…read morewas ok. Calzone was very thick with pizza dough, very little filling.

I've had good food and decent service, comparable to other fast food restaurants.. none of which…read moreask for a tip. So when I saw the register line for a 20% or 25% tip on a $12 half a sub, I entered zero, but common, the tip begging really has gone too far when they are begging at Cousins, and charging a boat load for the food.

First time I have given rating for this place. We are snowbirds so only use this during summer…read moremonths. I am commenting on last night service. Called at 729pm to place order. phone rang for 4 plus minutes with no answer. I hung up and called back. Phone kept ringing so I let it ring. I live in Port and decided I would drive over to see this large group of customers that must be there. I was 2 blocks away when a young man answered to tell me they had closed at 745PM because they ran out of bread, I told him I had been trying to place order since 730 and no answer on phone. This time I looked down and saw time was 748PM. and I had been on phone for more than 15 minutes with no one answering it. He responded "No way man" I told him I was just around the corner and would stop and show him my proof on the phone. He said NO, Were closed. I asked him why he could not just answer phone earlier and let me know so I wouldnt have to continue coming to his store. He told me there was no way I was on phone. I lost my temper at that time and said the F word. I told him I would tell the owner / manager know of the service. He said what ever, thanked me, said he was sorry, and then hung up. Luckily Arby's was open and no problems there. Not a good experience for Cousins.

I hate to write negative reviews but this place was atrocious. Tried it once and you could not pay…read moreme enough to return. The food was not good. Dishes lacked seasoning and just about everything was smothered in or served with ranch dressing. My family ended up leaving most of the food on their plates when normally we consume everything we order. The front house staff tried their best, and most were pleasant, but this place was sinking fast and you knew they were aware. There were flies buzzing around, dirty floor, seats and tables, old crusty food left on the bottom of one of our plates... I mean, just an awful place to eat all around. Very poorly managed. It's sad to see a restaurant fail but honestly I'm glad this one is now permanently closed.

This would be a great place to start a restaurant. It use to be ok but after walking out for the…read moresecond time in two weeks I can only feel the there's a severe management problem. Service is terrible right from the time you walk in the door, when you finally get seated and finally someone comes and takes your order, brings your drink you have 20 minutes invested. After another 20 minutes a waitress asks if you want a refill, 10 minutes later you get the refill. The waitress disappears and still no food so with an hour spent, no food in sight we left. Second time, a sign now says seat yourself, we did, waited 10 minutes before a waitress showed up, took a drink order, water, 10 more minutes go by she comes back and we ask about their fish fry that they only have on Fridays, this is Friday. Waitress says she will have to check and goes to the kitchen. We wait but decide if we have another problem we will just leave. She comes back and says " a fish fry will take one hour "!!! We said we are going to leave, she seemed relieved. We had a $25 gift card so not wanting to ever come back we gave it to a couple who were waiting for their food and celebrating a birthday. We hope that they did finally get their food. WE WILL NOT BE BACK

We stopped by before checking out the cute downtown Cedarburg scene and grabbed lunch. It's a very…read morecute vibe with the old anvils and bellows throughout as it used to be a blacksmith. The high vaulted ceilings and exposed beams were great. Our group we seated upstairs and it was pretty quiet. Everyone loved what they had. We all mostly got sandwiches/burgers and the various sides were delicious. We really liked the onion rings, potato salad and seasonal veggies. Our server was patient with us when we didn't know what we'd have with both drinks and meals. The team was quick to get our orders out and whisk away used plates/silverware. Would recommend if you're in the area. It was too cold for the patio to be opened yet but we will definitely come back for that in the summer. Great views.

The wife and I stopped by the Anvil Pub & Grille for dinner on Wednesday evening, and I was…read moresurprised by how busy they were. We loved the ambiance, and the service we received was excellent. For starters we ordered the cheese bites and the mushroom "soup of the day" For main course, she had the Short Rib Sandwich and I had the Cedarburg Cranberry Salad with blackened Salmon. For desert, the flourless chocolate cake. The Rib Sandwich and soup were good. (3.5 Stars). The Salad/Salmon were okay (3 stars), and the cake was awful. (Probably put in the microwave for two minutes and then brought to the table) It even looked ugly sitting there on the plate. My drink special was weak. All the customers seemed to be having a good time. The place was lively and it's probably worth a visit for the service and ambiance. However this is not a place to go for good/tasty food based on our experience.

Never any breakfast sandwiches, but are absolutely overflowing with wings in the morning. No one…read morewants that in the AM.

Great place for a fast fill on gas and fuel on breakfast. Can't complain about the service that's…read moregreat people there

Super yummy local spot! Haven't tried much of the food, mostly just go for the custard! It is super…read morecreamy and if you get mix-ins they give very generous amounts! Service has always been good, and never too long of a wait!

I can only speak to the cheese curds but these are at least tied, if not outright the best fried…read morecurds I've ever had. Jalapeño and garlic, two orders were maybe not even enough. Big fresh curds, lightly fried, infused with flavor. Excellent portion for your money. My friend and I both agreed on this. A cute homey ambiance inside and friendly customer service (they are local so give them a minute if interacting with someone else) all adds up to a huge win and I may have to accidentally route myself back through Port Washington next vacation for some more... and some custard... nah I'll go get that right now!

When you got one customer in the store and you manage to not only mess up the order but I walked…read moreout with no food cause they said they didn't get my online order. I was charged for it as well. Handle business cause I genuinely like subway and I shouldn't have to get screwed over like that for just trying to go there on my lunch break

The young man making my sandwich was absolutely wonderful. I am a vegetarian and he made sure that…read morethere was absolutely zero cross contamination while making my sandwich and my non vegetarian friends sandwich, changing gloves, using separate ingredients, and even washing the knife used to cut the sandwich without me even having to ask! The store is clean the food is good and the staff are very friendly and accommodating.

Surprisingly good. Best subway I've been to hands down. I swear my sub was perfectly made loll. The…read moreveggies were super fresh. The staff was nice and the place was really clean. Deff recommend.

they tweakin, I walked in at 9:04 pm when the hours clearly state 10 pm they had the floors all…read moremopped up and two workers just standing around. They claimed the store was closed, it was pretty frustrating considering I was just one person clearly in the hours of business and I apologized.