I've been a regular of Out & Out for years, even since a friend brought it to my attention. Not being a Cedarburg resident it's an extra 20 minutes out of the way if I'm stopping after work or a 40 minute round trip if I'm just heading from home, but I'm happy to make the trip. Their menu consists largely of Mac & Cheese, wraps, paninis and frozen custard. Being a Wisconsinite it really resonates with me. I get the classic "original" mac and cheese every time. It's always consistently good and it's still warm after my 20 minute drive home. They use a less common noodle that is quite large and the portion is generous too. The other menu item I'm always to is the shake of the week. They always have a different one and they're always good. Oh, and I have to mention their salads. Not for me, but my mother likes them as much a salad she gets anywhere else. Another thing I appreciate is the fact they have an app. An app for a local place isn't common in my experience. This makes it easy to order in advance so you can skip the line, skip the phone call and better still earn rewards. Finally, I have to commend a few of the guys who work here. Two gentlemen in particular who both are always pleasant and personable, which alone is commendable, but they've also both been there a few years. They both seem to be managers, but I'm not sure, though I wanted to recognize them. Both are older than the general staff and both are there various weekdays. read more

This is a go-to for kids in the area. I'm not saying it's not for adults but everytime I'm in there it's 90% high school kids. Their mac and cheese options are fantastic. I've asked about the mac recipe, and was told it was completely secret and only the the owner knows the recipe. I'd give it 5 stars, but it is a bit on the pricey side. read more

Stopped in on a hot day for a sweet treat and ended up leaving with mac & cheese for dinner!! The custard was fabulous (literally get any toppings or their sweet creations) and the mac & cheese was divine! Filled with delicious fun ingredients, some healthy(ish) and some just loaded with jazz, but both options we came home with were fabulous and just the right price! When in WI, I'll return :) read more

Been here a few times now. Mac and cheese is incredible. Ice cream is also really good. We got sandwiches/wraps once and they weren't as good as the mac and cheese. Overall though, we'd highly recommend!! read more

Food was delicious. I had a turkey/cranberry wrap w/ Mac & cheese. I liked the Mac & cheese but my teenager thought it tasted too much like Kraft. Prices were decent but the entrance had a weird, unpleasant odor. read more

Out & Out - Sandwiches Near Me - Cedarburg, Wisconsin

We love this place! My son loves Mac and cheese, so we stopped by for dinner and dessert. We loved our food! My son got the regular Mac and cheese and I got the Special : Ballpark Mac which is Beer brats, stadium sauce, topped with crispy onions! Which is delicious! Then for my dessert my son got a scoop of the chocolate custard with sprinkles and I got a scoop of vanilla custard with a shot of espresso and peanut butter cups and marshmallow cream! I know it sounds weird but it's good! lol The staff is great! The restaurant is clean and the atmosphere is great! read more

Out & Out Catering / Eatery & Custard is a great experience. I was visiting relatives and had the opportunity to experience this incredible food establishment. We needed to bring food for a 5-year-olds birthday party, and he requested the mac and cheese from Out & Out. Never argue with a 5-year-old...you will lose. We placed our order online to expedite the process and were given a pickup time. We arrived a little after the lunch rush to pick up our phone order. I don't know when I have seen such an extensive menu of options. If you can't find it here I don't think you can find it anywhere. The staff was very helpful making sure that we had everything that we needed to make a birthday boy happy. We ordered a platter of wraps and mac and cheese. Love the options for protein with the wraps. The food was once again fresh and tasty. Everyone from a 2-year-old to an 80-year-old was happy. Not always an easy task. If you live in this area or nearby this is definitely a place to utilize. I can't wait till I come back. I have mac and cheese and custard memories. read more

See all

Great fast food like establishment for shakes and a bite to eat. It is very popular, so you may have to wait a bit, but you can order online and pick up when it's ready. I get the falafel wrap almost every time, and love their birthday cake shake! read more

Really fun ambience and lots of menu options. I would not recommend the falafel wrap which had no flavor, although the ranch dressing was so good and definitely the best part. The hot sandwiches are better than the cold wraps. Not impressed by the mac and cheese. The wraps are huge so it's great value for the cost. Also really fun for the kids to create their custard sundaes. read more

This is a Cedarburg staple for good reason! I've never once been disappointed. You can't go wrong with their specialty mac and cheese, different than anywhere else and particularly nostalgic if you grew up around here. My other go-to is the Americano and chicken bacon ranch wrap. Highly recommend for a quick stop or catering! read more

The macaroni is good. I got the wrong sandwich in my to-go order. I went back in a day because the phone doesn't get answered after 7:30 apparently. The manager kept my receipt because they didn't know how to refund me, and it was busy. Said I'd have a refund in a couple of days. We'll see... read more

Gave it my third shot tonight. Last two times they didn't have my phone order in process when I came to pick it up - had to place it again - ended up waiting 30 minutes for my order. Tonight I walked in at 8:20 pm not realizing they closed at 8 - my navigation app said they closed at 9. Stood at the counter with three staff members giggling and ignoring me after seeing me standing there waiting to order. No one said a word so I asked the young guy mopping the floor if they were open - he said no. I mean all the staff had to do was tell me they were closed. Why would I give the place a dime? Horrible customer service! Would give it 0 stars if I could. read more

The food is OK but a 28 minute wait for a turkey club on a Monday night when there were 9 people in the building is pretty poor service.

Leaving Strawberry Fest today I promised ice cream to my son that came with me because it was hot out and he was a trooper with all the walking around we did. We started driving towards the McDonald's in Cedarburg, but along the way I remembered previously seeing a different restaurant nearby that serves ice cream or custard. We pulled into Out & Out and hit the jackpot compared to going to McDonald's. It was so good, in fact, that we came back later in the day so my wife and other son could try it too. On our first visit my older son got a custard mixer with brownies, Oreos, and hot fudge and I got a half original mac and cheese and a strawberry lemonade float, which was their special flavor for this week. When we came back, my younger son got a chocolate custard mixer with cookie dough and brownies while my wife got the Spicy Chicken Kick mac and cheese without the red peppers. Both kids loved their custard, which was to be expected. It looks like they're pretty generous with the toppings and have a good variety to choose from on the menu. Way better than the soft serve ice cream from McDonald's. The mac and cheese was great. We both thought the cheese sauce reminded us a little of Kraft mac and cheese, but slightly more elevated in both the flavor of the sauce and the quality of the noodles. There was plenty of chicken in her mac, but it was little light on the andouille sausage. The strawberry lemonade float was otherworldly good. I've had other floats before like root beer and dreamcicle, but strawberry lemonade was a new one for me and frankly has set a new bar in my mind for ice cream/custard based drinks. I can't rave about it enough and I'm sad that it's only a one week special, but considering how good it was, I'm very much looking forward to trying other special flavors they have and having the strawberry lemonade again, assuming it's back during next year's Strawberry Fest. read more

See all

None of the gluten free options are actually gluten free. Have had multiple gluten attacks from this place. The sandwiches are not tolerated with gluten free bread for people with celiac. read more

On my list to try for quite awhile and wish it hadn't taken so long to get here! Came with my 7yr old for lunch on a Wednesday and it was busy, and now I know why. She had the original mac and cheese and loved it, and she's a picky Mac n cheese eater. I tried a few bites as well and it was great, way better than Noodles and Co. and cheaper than Noodles as well. I had the Chipotle Chicken sandwich and it was excellent. We had some custard for dessert and it was also terrific, only $3.75 for a scoop and you get 3 toppings! Service was extra friendly, seems like a family and treat you like family, the kind of place I like to spend my money at, but don't need to spend a lot because for the quality and quantity of food, it was very reasonable. I look forward to coming back soon with the entire family to try more, great spot! read more

See all

Food was all pretty unusual. Service was fast. Place was great clean interesting layout of the restaurant. We had a good meal.

I love Mac n cheese! To be completely transparent, I'm a Kraft kind of gal, and don't always like when the dish is jazzed up too much. So I went in not sure what to expect. Well, I thought this was amazing! I loved every bite of the original, just as it was. My husband had the spicy chicken (minus the bell peppers) and he was raving about his too. The staff was helpful explaining the options and it was a nice casual dining experience. I highly recommend this spot! read more

Out & Out - The original - so good just as it is! I'm drooling remembering it! - Sandwiches Near Me - Cedarburg, Wisconsin

See all

This place is a great choice when you don't have time to sit down but want something delicious and fast. The food is excellent, the service was fabulous, and I love that they have seating inside and out - but also super easy to take and go if you need to. My go-to is the thai peanut quinoa salad - yummy!! I would definitely recommend choosing Out & Out! read more

Out & Out - Thai peanut quinoa salad - Sandwiches Near Me - Cedarburg, Wisconsin

If you're going to have the kitchen in plain view of the customers you should at least make sure it's clean. The floors under the counters look like they haven't been swept or mopped for months. The back of the stove needs a load of oven cleaner and good scraping down. If you think customers don't notice that you're wrong. Food was fine, not horrible but also not special in any way. Service was friendly. read more

I am very disappointed because this has been one of my family's favorite Mac n' Cheese spots. We ordered two Spicy Chicken Kick Macs today and they both had little to no cheese sauce.. Let's just say plain noodles really kills the mood. I've also read other reviews on this restaurant recently and most seem to agree. When I order Mac n' Cheese, I don't expect to pay extra for enough cheese sauce to cover my food. read more

Out and out is always a family favorite. Their Mac and cheese (no matter which you choose) is always amazing. For a healthier option the Thai quinoa salad is amazing! So fresh! Service is always great. It's not really "fast" food so be prepared to wait 10min for your food. read more

Yummy! Great spot to sit outside with a great sandwich and shake ! The mac n cheese is the bomb and perfect for sharing. read more

Best Mac and cheese in the area, hands down. I've been coming to the place for years and never leave disappointed. The Mac and cheese never gets old. My favorites are the buffalo chicken, bacon carbonara, and surprisingly, just the ordinal Mac and cheese. They also have many other options such as soups, cold wraps, sandwiches, ice cream, and custards. A lot of seating is available and it can get busy during the weekend and during the summer. It's located in a nice, popular part of Cedarburg and close enough to Mequon and Grafton. The Mac and cheese is delicious, rich, and very full of flavor and cheesy goodness. One full size portion is more than enough for me and very filling. Great for the prices, too. Definitely check it out if you're a Mac and cheese lover! read more

Out & Out - Entrance - Sandwiches Near Me - Cedarburg, Wisconsin

See all

If you're looking for a great place to get a good meal, this should be your choice! I love going here because I can order a head, drive up, jump out, run in, grab my bag, get in the car, and drive away, No fuss and usually no mess. The best part is I usually get something fairly healthy and (unless I choose to get a milkshake), I don't end up feeling guilty about eating out. On the rare occasion that I get a milkshake, I choose the banana milkshake, and try to convince myself that it was fruit! Don't judge me! The food here is good. The workers work extremely hard so don't forget to tip. The only problem I've ever had is once in a while. While the app is wonky. If something weird happens, however, the management is usually very helpful. That makes up for everything and I end up satisfied. All in all, it's always a pleasure doing business and Out and Out. read more

I had the turkey sandwich which was just outstanding and so flavorful. My sister had the Cuban and a mint shake. Both were excellent. I would highly recommend this place. read more

It was such a cold day and this place just made all better. Warm delicious mac'n cheeses and hot subs, Nice industrial vibe decoration . Service super fast and friendly. read more

We are very disappointed in Out and Out for the second time. The Mac and Cheese was dry and the container is now less than 1/3 the original size. It is so small now that it looks like a small plate instead of a bowl at barely 1" tall. My chicken, bacon ranch wrap had no bacon. It is so sad to see the downfall of one of Cedarburg's most popular restaurants. Now that it is employee-owned, the staff/owners have decided to get greedy and cut the quality, flavor and container size to put more money in their pockets. What a shame. read more

Great place to stop for a quick lunch or dinner. Their food is so delicious and they are super accommodating for what's on their menu (plenty of veggie, vegan, and gluten free options). My favorite item is the Americano without chicken. It has so much flavor and I love the ciabatta rolls they use for the bread! The Mac and cheese is also a classic. We get the veggie Mac and it is filled with yummy peppers, mushrooms, and spinach. You of course can't leave without getting a scoop of the decadent custard! This place is a fan fav! read more

This is my personal favorite Summer picnic food and their rotating specials always hit the spot. Order to-go and head down to any Cedarburg park--a recipe for the perfect Summer date. I am obsessed with their chicken caesar wrap, but sadly it wasn't on the menu this time around, so I tried the turkey cranberry wrap and luckily it did not disappoint. It is not a trip to Out & Out without walking away with an order of their scrumptious Mac & Cheese. You can do either a half or full order, so I always get a half order to supplement my meal. My boyfriend always gets the Chicken Bacon Ranch Wrap and Mandarin Cashew Crunch Salad. I wouldn't skip their frozen lemonades on a hot day either! read more

Out & Out - Sandwiches Near Me - Cedarburg, Wisconsin

See all

Amazing gluten free menu. Tastiest chicken bacon wrap ever, would highly recommend. Also custard and just a nice experience.

I got a taste of their sandwiches yesterday including the Americano and the turkey and they were exquisite and just bursting with flavor. Very impressed. read more

Beware if you have food allergies. I'm gluten sensitive but have other serious food allergies (anaphylaxis). I've eaten here before without issue so I decided to try again. I ordered a gluten sensitive Mac and cheese with broccoli and chicken. Not long after eating I began to have swelling and thought uhoh perhaps soy was slipped in somewhere. After a long wait I managed to get someone on the phone who immediately told me soy isn't involved and I have to be honest the response seemed irritated and wanting me off the phone asap; if soy was present (like in lecithin, the noodles, or flavoring) this person wouldn't know and wouldn't bother to check. I explained I was having a reaction and trying to nail down what was happening (in case I need to go to the ER). It would be nice if they'd offer to read out the ingredients (or even better list them on the site). Clearly the allergen is present (unlikely peanuts or tree nuts are involved which I also asked about). The food itself however: great chicken and broccoli, sauce was absorbed I think within the noodles and the noodles were a lump that outside of allergic reaction, is sitting poorly in my stomach. Very much not worth the $15+ I spent. If you're allergy cautious I would not risk it here. read more

Can't you just try to be normal? Strange layout, crabby staff and weird menu items make you wonder if you're at Kopps on 76th back in the day or stuck in a barn. Custard is amazing, menu items are just weird. It's trying to be a mix between a diner, a new age Kopps and a sandwich shop yet fails on all. Please get Your menu back to basics or offer something truly unique yet delicious. read more

Out & Out. Never heard of the place before and never even knew such a place existed until wifey mentioned we should stop through here on our way into Cedarburg. I was slightly leery that this would just be another run of the mill sandwich shop similar to something fast food but wanting to be a bit more glamorous. Boy was I wrong. Out & out proved to be not only great food but also a perfect little spot to satisfy the need for a quick bite. We had the Italian sandwich and it came out toasty and flavorful. This was a great sandwich and I was really taken back at how good it was. So far on track. We also ordered the twisted Wisconsin mac n cheese spicy chicken kick style. It had andouille sausage, red bell peppers and a Cajun cheese sauce. It wasn't quite the kick I would have hoped for but the flavors were good. Being a "fast food" pasta it really wasn't bad at all. This isn't some fancy dancy restaurant I'm expecting 5 star dining at. I came here for a quick lunch and Out & Out satisfied that need on all levels. I would come back again in a heartbeat if ever in the area. Solid service, good food and very reasonable prices make this an easy winner on the place for fast and easy dining no-nonsense dining. read more

Out & Out - Out n Out - Sandwiches Near Me - Cedarburg, Wisconsin

Great food. Called and ordered ahead - the sandwiches were hot and ready on time. I had the roast beef and mushroom sandwich. It was on ciabatta bread that seems like it was a Cuban. Nice ! read more

We were passing through Cedarburg and found Out&Out for lunch. We got the Turkey Cranberry Wrap, 3 Cheese Chicken Mac and Cheese, and a mint chocolate shake. Everything was delicious, and the employees were friendly and bubbly. We will be back! read more

Pictures for this place on Yelp are what sealed the deal for us when we were looking for lunch options in Cedarburg. The Mac and Cheese is as delicious as it looks in the pictures. No table service here- order at the counter, listen for your number, clear your table and dispose of your trash. Prices are extremely reasonable with half order of macaroni and cheese for $3-$4, and full orders $6-$7. They have like 5 different types of their twisted macaroni and cheese. We went with their three cheese and chicken, delicious choices. Their wraps and sandwiches also sounded fantastic. Would love to go back and get the turkey cranberry wrap. Also, a very cool inside with a mural painted by a local artist. read more

See all

BEST MAC AND CHEESE! This is an adorable local favorite which offers delectable Mac and cheese as well as sandwiches, soups, and salads. They also have shakes & ice cream. Staff are always friendly and they have online ordering option as well as a walk up window if you prefer to stay outside. Also recommend them for catering, we used them for our rehearsal dinner-they were helpful, reasonably priced, and our order was accurate and on time. read more

Consistently delicious, speedy service, better than fast food fast food. Love the Pecan Chop salads, Thai Quinoa bowls, and chili. read more