Stopped by the Chocolate Factory again for ice cream! I got my usual Zoreo which from the description is Fudge-like Zanzibar® Chocolate ice cream swirled with gooey marshmallow, Oreos and bittersweet chocolate chunks. And It's really good! My wife got the mint chocolate chip with cookie dough. My kids got the Super Man ice cream which is Cherry, Blue Moon and Vanilla ice creams. It's very blue, red and yellow! And they got the Cotten Candy as well! All good ice cream! So many flavors! The staff is great and they keep the line going when it's busy. We love this place for a quick dessert and it's nice and clean inside. read more

Quality/Quantity - Nice old school ice cream store. The ice cream was "gooey." Raspberry Lemon Italian Ice & Exhausted Parent - My daughter ordered this. I liked this better than what my wife chose below. Bang!! - Caffeinated Latte Ice Cream - I like coffee ice cream, but what my daughter ordered was much better. They are also known for their subs, sandwiches, sundaes, desserts, salads, hot dogs, etc. They also have a kids menu. Atmosphere - Open 7 days a week from 10:30am to 8pm or 9pm, Yelp hours differ, see picture. Service - Good. Price - $10 + tip. Owner Comment - Congrats on your success since 1972 with your 8 locations. read more

See all

I was born and raised in Cedarburg - the Chocolate Factory was a staple for me. So coming back at 50 years old and taking my Dad for lunch was just very special. the food was just as amazing as I remember as a high schooler - and the staff were kind which I so appreciate. I'm so glad we came today and I would definitely recommend to anyone looking for a yummy lunch and ice cream. Oh! And I had the classic club and broccoli cheddar soup. read more

The Chocolate Factory - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Cedarburg, Wisconsin

It's been years since I've gone to a chocolate factory for subs and ice cream, used to go often when they had locations on the east side but always remembered liking it so took the fam out to try it again and it's the same as I remembered. Had the Club sub and the bread was perfectly warmed, it had the right ratio of meat to toppings and came with cheese, lettuce, tomato, red onion and mayo; an excellent sandwich that hit the spot. And I was planning to just eat a few bites of my wife's ice cream (peanut butter, caramel cookie dough) but when I tried it, had to get my own dish. Great spot, will be back! read more

Terrible customer service from a girl named Evelyn did not look like she wanted to be working and did did not look happy I have come here in the past and have great customer service but Evelyn made the whole experience not welcoming read more

Very busy as an ice cream shop but they do have a menu. We order food and a cone. I remember the butter peach being something special and today was just average. My wife had cookies dough and again was Ok. I ordered a small club sub and when it was presented it was underwhelming but it was FANTASTIC. Yea added some balsamic dressing to it but the sub roll was fresh with a nice crust and fluffy and soft inside. My wife had tue chicken salad salad and liked he's too. read more

The Chocolate Factory - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Cedarburg, Wisconsin

See all

We stopped into The Chocolate Factory for a late night treat. My friends all tried ice cream and I tried sorbet. As a group, we loved everything. The ice cream was rich and creamy and my sorbet had a bright fruity flavor. The interior had a vintage soda shop vibe. This storefront stop had a casual look with a lot of vintage varnished wood behind the ice cream counter. There were booths for seating that went all the way to the back. The ice cream cases ran along the other wall. Classic rock music was playing which was fun. I wish there were just a bit more decor to add to the nostalgia. I appreciated that they offered so many choices and everything we ordered, we loved. You can also get sub sandwiches, soups and salads too. I am so happy they are open late because so many places in Cedarburg close up pretty early. The price reflects the weight of your frozen treat. You pay per ounce. I think that's great if you don't want a lot. Just let them know you'd like only a half scoop etc. read more

See all

I stopped at the chocolate factory to get a sub, I got turkey breast (boring I know) but my mom got the Sicilian and we both enjoyed. We ate inside and it gives a laid back diner feel. They also have soups and ice cream. I decided against the ice cream today but I was offered to sample a couple of flavors which I did and appreciated. This is a great spot to stop for a chill lunch, especially if you want a treat. read more

This is one of my favorite stops when I come to Cedarburg. They always have such friendly service, location is clean and plenty of seating. Really interesting pricing - they charge you by the ounce so you can request as much or as little you want. They offer all traditional flavors. I especially love all the chocolate selections they offer and sometimes they have some really interesting non traditional flavors as well. They also have different types of cones. In a world where custard dominates, I sure love finding a classic ice cream parlor!! read more

The Chocolate Factory - I'm talking chocolate - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Cedarburg, Wisconsin

5 stars because I still love the place but apparently won't be eating there any more. Where did the chicken breast and meatball subs go? These are the most classic subs you can make, been eating them for 30 years, and now gone? Like I said still love the place but without the subs I eat, no reason to go here any more :( You'll be misssed choco factory. read more

Food. OMG what happened to the quality ? This was our family favorite for 25 years. Had multigrain turkey subs last Saturday. Bread was stale. One slice of turkey on each sandwich with lots of onion and sauce. Terrible. read more

Great sandwiches and I love that they sell ice cream by weight vs scoop. That way if you only want a little you can have it any time!

we have always enjoyed stopping in Cedarburg's Chocolate Factory. Open one in Greendale, Wi. There is a perfect spot for one.

The Chocolate Factory is fabulous. Service is fast and it's a fun family environment. It's a staple in the Cedarburg community. Subs and soups. Love the sub rolls. Ice cream tops it all off. read more

We were in the area disc golfing and we were both craving a sub. I had heard that this place made a good sammich so I thought we would give it a try. The place was really cool inside, kind of an old ice cream parlor type vibe. The kids that helped us was very friendly. They had a nice selection of subs, and we both settled on the Phoenix. It was a turkey sub with bacon a chipotle mayo. We both really really enjoyed our subs. It wasn't the best sub I ever had but it was pretty tasty. If ever in the area I would go back, next time I would try some ice cream too. If you are looking for a place with that kind of old time feel I would give it a shot. read more

Great food at a good price. The Sicilian is our favorite and our go to. Good variety of ice cream.

Used to go here as a small kid and it's just as exciting to go back and visit as an adult. Very little had changed in this location since I lived there in the late 90's/early 00's so it is nostalgic to visit! I don't think I've ever really had a sub or anything from here so I can only really judge based on the ice cream. Of course, Wisconsin ice cream is nearly always delicious, but there is something special about the Chocolate Factory! I love the classic old school ice cream parlor feel, makes everything even better. I knew I had to get blue moon because that is a rare find in Arizona! And it's not quite as good in AZ as it is at ice cream shops in Wisconsin. So I got a waffle cone with one scoop of mint chocolate chip ice cream and one scoop of blue moon ice cream. They tasted very very good together. I ate the whole thing! Good quality ice cream. My friend was very excited that they had cookie dough ice cream with peanut butter, and had it in a milkshake. He said it was one of the best shakes he's had! I agree. Chocolate factory is great! read more

The Chocolate Factory - One scoop blue moon one scoop mint chip in a waffle cone - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Cedarburg, Wisconsin

See all

Stopped here for a malt on my way out of town and the shop had several teenage staff who were engrossed in their conversation and it took a minute before they even bothered to acknowledge my presence. They may have been talking about work for all I know but it wasn't welcoming at first. I placed my order and the poor kid explained he is new and had no idea how to make a chocolate malt. It took awhile before someone came over to help him. Although it was Chocolate Shoppe tasty, it was quite runny for a shake. While I waited nearly ten minutes for them to figure this out, the place filled up with customers. I got to witness the incredible chaos when you have a shop that has nobody leading the crew. No sense of urgency, a brand new team member who is lost and not trained, team members standing around and they all looked like they had no idea what to do. My first job as a teen was at an ice cream and sandwich shop so I'm no stranger. Get a supervisor in here pronto to run the shift and train your staff. read more

Excellent sandwiches. The chili is usually awesome, but last time it was a little burned - which is probably because I ordered it on a relatively hot day and it's not super popular during the summer season. Best to give it another try ASAP read more

This place is fantastic!!!! Great atmosphere, very clean and very friendly staff!!! The banana split is to die for!!!!! Soooo good!!!!

great ice cream and flavors and very nice employees who gave our dog a dish of ice cream We originally thought it was Chocolate Shop but were happy that their ice cream was almost as good! Good prices and scoops read more

The Chocolate Factory is tasty, man. Their bread is just perfect - it has a nice crunch while still being soft in the middle. They use quality ingredients and they make them pretty fast, too. This Cedarburg location has a really nice hometown feel to it and the people are really friendly. Sub-wise, I get the Phoenix. It's a turkey/bacon/jalapeno bacon/pepperjack situation. A great situation. I love this situation. I get it every time. Extra chipotle mayo please - I'm not on a diet this week. They serve dessert too... it's called The Chocolate Factory for God's sake. What I love about this place is they have dark chocolate fudge. As a dark chocolate lover, this is very special. I'll take a Dusty Road (malt) Sundae with dark chocolate fudge, please. Extra dusty. Subs and ice cream. I like it. read more

Always a good stop when in Cedarburg. The entire left side of the cabinet is mostly more unique and exploratory flavors while the right side goes more towards your core favorites. Either way, it's a good, thick, creamy ice cream. read more

We stopped in for some ice cream after a day of browsing shops in Cedarburg. There were many delicious ice cream choices, and it was hard to choose. I eventually decided on mint swirl... In a chocolate chip covered chocolate dipped waffle cone! While the end result was a sugar coma, I certainly enjoyed my treat. read more

The Chocolate Factory - Mint swirl ice cream. Chocolate chip waffle cone. - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Cedarburg, Wisconsin

The subs here are fantastic. The bread is so good. They offer traditional sundaes, along with dipped and plain cones. They weigh the ice cream so you get what you pay for. It's a fun spot to eat dinner and dessert. read more

Very expensive for just a small sandwich and the avocado on it was well past ripe. We also got a cup of soup (also expensive) which tasted like it came from a can, but later we learned it was from a plastic bag instead as it was siphoned from said bag right in front of us. The redeeming factor of the meal was the pretzel bun of the sandwich, and the fact that we were very hungry.. Overall this place is very overpriced, and probably not worth the money :( read more

This place is a Cedarburg landmark. The subs are subs, and the ice cream is ice cream. You can't go horribly wrong with either. I love getting a scoop of the blue moon from here. My boyfriend got the peanut butter cookie dough- amazing! After you been strolling around for a few hours, this is a great place to sit and relax and enjoy a sweet treat. read more

The Chocolate Factory - Peanut butter cookie dough and blue moon - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Cedarburg, Wisconsin

Want some delicious ice cream? Come here!! The best part about this place was the fact that it was practically connected to the Inn we were staying at. So after our meal at Morton's, we decided to get some ice cream and eat it at the inn. I ordered the mint one, and my husband got cookies and cream. It was cheap, delicious, and definitely hit the spot! read more

Nothing fantastic but if you need a break from window shopping, this is as good a place as any for food. I tried their new pulled pork sandwich, the only thing missing was....pulled pork, the portion was quite small. Families love this place and from what I tell they give back to the community. The ice cream harkens back to some old school flavors. Fun decor too. read more

I can't vouch for the sandwiches here but after a visit for some ice cream I was pretty impressed by the flavor and variety. The chocolate factory is located in Cedarburgs heavily trafficked downtown- there is only street parking for this location. The ice cream counter has a huge selection but no prices listed because they weigh your cone. Weird. This is rather strange to me to have an ice cream cone weighed like your in a cafeteria. Fix this chocolate factory. I did really like my bourbon pecan pie ice cream in a chocolate dipped cone. They only have milk chocolate dipped waffle cones, no dark chocolate. The counter gal looked at me like I came from another planet when I asked. Maybe she should visit some other ice cream shops to see that they have dark chocolate and prices per cone and scoop. read more

The Chocolate Factory - The cone from chocolate factory in cone protector vs cone from another local shop. - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Cedarburg, Wisconsin

The ice cream is great! but they charge by weight,, next the subs on great bread are the best, this place rocks,parking is hard to find,well worth the walk! read more

Ok, I'll admit we come here often for sandwiches and ice cream. The subs are good, the soup is decent and the salad very cream is ice cream...In a world of custard everywhere. However, I am only giving three stars because it jut isn't clean and the Service is pretty spotty. It will is run by teenagers and sometimes they are just not paying attention. I've been to a few other chocolate factory's and they are way cleaner with better service. The meatball sub will still be good here though! read more

First off I have to confess: I've never tried the Phoenix... I know, I know, horrible! Detestable! Waste of a perfectly good name/opportunity! But I just really dig their ice cream! They've always got the classics there, although I could not name them off the top of my head without looking because I'm lazy and have a bad memory when it comes to listing off flavors! But the prices are decent, especially when you consider you're having actual ice cream in what amounts to an ice cream parlor! The people who work there vary from friendly and bubbly to quiet and curt. It's a hit or miss for staff honestly. But I know that when I tried a sandwich there a couple months ago I thoroughly enjoyed it: good meats, great bread, tasty greens and toppings. Mm. To recap: I go for the ice cream, but I will have to go back to try that sandwich!! read more

Best sandwiches and milkshakes period! I like the atmosphere, too. It reminds me of an old-time malt shop.

Great place for ice cream! Mind that they do sell by weight. Also have pretty good sandwiches. Right in downtown Cedarburg!! Would highly recommend. read more

The bread is always fresh. We always order the Phoenix or Italian subs when we are working in the westbend area. I always order extra vegetables and they are always accommodating to my needs. Very professional! They even serve our food to us when they have the chance. We either go to subway or chocolate factory. I prefer the chocolate Factory. read more

The manager was very rude and constantly yelled hands up. I felt threatened and very offended. This is not a great place. An elder couple were fondling each other. Very distasteful. read more

My favorite sub sandwich by far, always love coming here! Love, Love, Love The Chocolate Factory!!!

Solid submarines, especially when slightly warmed.

Great high quality subs and snacks!! Good hearty bread, and great quality lunch meats and fresh ingredients on their subs.