What a great place! The owners are incredibly warm, friendly, and genuinely care about their customers. They take real pride in everything they make, and it shows. It's the kind of place where you feel like family, even on your first visit. The meatloaf sandwich was absolutely delicious, and the homemade pickled beets were outstanding. Everything is made in-house, and you can taste the difference. I'll definitely be back! read more

The positives: The atmosphere here is always amazing. It's like going home every time you walk into the door. The staff is always friendly and food is amazing. If you love large portions and hot yummy food I highly recommend it if you have time. The only issue I have here is this place NEEDS a proper staff. I really do like the folks they run the joint. But the service is inconsistent at best from visit to visit and even on a slow day with an empty dining space it can take a while to get served. Knowing that we went in today not expecting much more than large tasty portions. We took the whole family as a good bye brunch as my oldest his partner who we're visiting with my grandson. Im not sure what happened today but the single little old lady who runs the front was all over the place. She was polite and professional but you could tell she was overwhelmed. It took quite a while to get menus and waters then quite a while longer than that to get to order. She took the order and then we waited. And waited and waited. As we waited the littles started to devolve. And then, we waited some more. From the moment we sat down to the time food arrived was about an hour and a half. By then the kids were done. My wife was done and I was done. The food was hot. Some under cooked and my meal was missing the main component. That mouth watering and coma inducing pastrami. All said and done it was one of the worst dining experiences I've had. No one was happy when we left. And that's a huge bummer. The food here is too good for the experience to be so bad. There were apologies and eventually the owner came out and compensated the entire meal. But that's not a good business model. Will I go back? Absolutely. They could cuss me out and I'd go buy the pastrami even if it fell on the floor. It's that good. But I probably won't ever go back with the kids. They don't have the stamina for it and we really have enough time to truly enjoy it as we would like to. read more

First, I sat down anywhere I wanted to. The waitress came very quickly and was very nice. Then we ordered and she told us we could look around some more in the place, and it had homemade soaps , soda, body wash/lotion, tea, coffee, clocks, freezer food and ice cream, and so much more! There is also a little stand with sweets they are so yummy! The food was amazing and the place was pretty big for a lunch spot. We got mashed potatoes and a corn beefed burnt end sandwich and the were both really good. The food also came out quick The place is nice too. Overall, 5 Stars read more

See all

When you drive up it is an unassuming building, but it is nice on the inside and is very inviting. They have tables to eat at and a bar. I had the roast beef sandwich special and my wife had the corn beef sandwich. Both were very good and are recommended. The waiters was very nice and she happened to be the owners daughter. She was a delight. read more

Really glad to have found this place! Came here for an event and they were very accommodating. Food was great- they serve absolutely massive sandwiches that are really tasty too. Lots of really cool options as well that you won't find at other restaurants! read more

Craft-Eats - Glazed and Dazed - Sandwiches Near Me - Hanover, Pennsylvania

Love the vibe of this place and the food was delicious! We will definitely by coming back many times to explore the rest of the menu and sodas. read more

Craft-Eats - Soda menu - Sandwiches Near Me - Hanover, Pennsylvania

See all

Amazing food - great staff, very pleasant and helpful. Wish I lived closer to this little gem read more

Ingrid was amazing. Food fantastic, never disappoints. Loved the service. I always enjoy atmosphere. See you again soo .

Outstanding. Stopped in here on a Friday afternoon starving for something to eat after being dragged around an antique mall by my partner. Service was quick, and we were so delighted when the chef came out to greet us and ask how the food was. 5 stars on the turkey club. Ambiance is basic but clean and perfect for a quick stop. Def recommend. read more

Heck yeah!! GO HERE. Where has this been. Finally business owners raising the bar coming to the area. OAK for dinner, Craft-Eats for breakfast and lunch. The owner must be a fantastic cook and foodie. The location is kind of odd, and jammed into a weird area. It unassuming, but do not let that fool you. Also, don't come here expecting highly processed, cheap lunch meat. This is whole foods, real meat and fresh from the farm ingredients. We ordered the Ari and the Barry, and split them. The roasted beef was fresh, actual roasted high grade beef directly from Nell's Butcher. The turkey was fresh roasted, perfectly seasoned by itself and crumbled and melted in your mouth. The sandwich combo with blueberry jam was fantastic. We also tried their specialty hash and it was amazing. The corned beef was caramelized, richly flavored and crumbled apart. Beautiful!!! All the ingredients are locally sourced, including fresh baked breads and amish ice cream. I implore everyone to patronize this business, we must support people raising the bar. Hanover and the surrounding region have been plagued with low tier food, lazy owners and Sysco crap food over and over again. read more

Craft-Eats - The Barry and the Ari sandwiches, plus the house specialty hash and coleslaw. SO GOOD! - Sandwiches Near Me - Hanover, Pennsylvania

Awesome food, great people! The service was exceptionally pleasing. The food was in point!

The food is sourced locally, and you can tell by the quality of the food. The staff are very kind and when I came in it felt very local and folksy, with people casually hanging out and eating amongst themselves. There was trivia which me and my friends played while waiting for food. The cost was semi high but well worth it considering the portions, I would highly recommend to anyone who is looking for a local sandwich shop of the local variety. read more

Of course the one time I want to order here they are out of what I came for. I consider their menu limited. At least for my taste buds. Generally it's all sandwiches. They have a grab and go. But unfortunately it's different than their in house menu. They do offer soups that are homemade. Plus all of the sides are homemade. They offer a wide variety of different flavors of beverages. They even have milkshakes. This not a hamburger place . This place is higher end period. Price wise you are paying for it. And service here is good. I definitely recommend this one place. It's high end quality with a laid back atmosphere. read more

I do have to say that this place, and those that run and own it, are truly something special. My GF and I agreed that these were some of the best Sammies we've ever had. I tried the Kardiac Keith and she had the Reuben. Both were exceptional. We left with cookies, soup and pie, WHICH HAS GROUND RIBEYE. Give this family owned slice of heaven your business...you'll be so glad that you did! read more

See all

I had the Pancake Platter which came with three pancakes, two eggs, and two pieces of bacon. I decided to go for the blueberry pancakes, and they were truly extraordinary in flavor. They could've been a little bigger, but they were really really flavorful and the blueberries were fresh blueberries not out of a can or frozen. Could have used a little more syrup than the 2 oz provided. Eggs were cooked perfectly (over medium) so that's an improvement from last time. With significant prodding from the staff, I also purchased a loaf of banana bread, some of which I will have for breakfast tomorrow. As a small business/restaurant, they're definitely improving so give them a chance. I think you'll really like it. PS: I didn't give them 5 Stars because little things always become problems later. They don't sell Pepsi or Coke products but encourage customers to buy these very expensive Reading Soda or Tractor beverages??? that I'm not familiar with and I just can't justify spend $3.25 for a bottle of something to drink that I don't know what it taste like. I also took off points because the men's bathroom smelled like five guys had been taking a smoke break in the bathroom for over an hour. It made me sick just to go in there and wash my hands and I could smell it on my clothes when I walked out of there and went to my seat. Not the way to start out a new business. But the food was good. read more

Craft-Eats - Menu Side 2 - Sandwiches Near Me - Hanover, Pennsylvania

See all

Great food and very nice family who owns it. We will be back. I had Turkey and super delicious mashed potatoes. Mom had homemade tomato soup with grilled cheese. She ate it all. Reuben was also a hit. read more

This family owned restaurant is outstanding. There is a shop inside of the restaurant and small bakery. They also have the best Reuben I have ever had in my life. 10/10 recommend! read more

Good food, supports local farmers and vendors. Reasonable pricing. Love their Ruben. Corn beef hash had jalapeño that were extremely hot and ruined the dish. That's why I did not give a 5 star. read more

I can't say enough about this little shop that packs a big punch! Located in the markets in Hanover, I was searching for a warm sandwich for lunch. I came across Craft-Eats and was asked if I wanted to try a sample of their corned beef. I couldn't resist because the smell from the kitchen was amazing. The corned beef was SO good but I wasn't feeling it for lunch so I opted for the hot turkey sandwich with cheddar on apple walnut bread. This sandwich was just perfect-- warm, hearty, a little salty and a little sweet. It was just what I needed for lunch! It came with a few bread and butter pickles on the side. It was such a big portion that I had to take half of it to go. While I was waiting for my sandwich I had a chance to speak with the owners who were so lovely and from Long Island which was a nice surprise! One of the owners even gave my little one a treat which was so nice of her. Their story is a great one and their food is even better. I highly recommend stopping by to pick up either a sandwich or one of their amazing family meals if you're near Hanover-- you will be pleased! read more

See all

I was in Hanover for business. I stopped by Craft-Eats for lunch. In discussion with the waitress, she suggested that the soup and sandwich were both a good value and responsive to my questions regarding food. I had the chicken and rice soup. It is delicious and unexpectedly different. The base seems to be a thinned chicken gravy. The color was brownish. The sandwich, also delicious, was their version of a Reuben. Often the Russian dressing makes the sandwich 'sweet", which is why I rarely order it. If I return to Hanover, I will return to Ctaft-Eats. read more

Amazing breakfast. Hash is incredible. I would drive over an hour to eat here. Friendly people in a relaxed atmosphere. Will be back.

Absolutely AWESOME..... Great food and friendly staff. Can't say enough good things about this place. Highly recommend.

Excellent! Their Ruben was one of the best I ever had. Soups are all home made and delicious! Family owned and run. Very nice people.

Excellent home cooked food. We've been there for breakfast and dinner. Love their new location @ 304 Poplar Street. Great addition to Hanover, and we can walk there. read more

omg it was so good honestly the best food in Hanover! homemade everything and fresh! Ingrid was so nice telling us all about the lovely food! A calm environment and the corn beef I've ever had ( and I tho I didn't like it)! Definitely recommend! read more

Craft-Eats - Sandwiches Near Me - Hanover, Pennsylvania

See all

The Reuben was delicious. In a post-apocalyptic world, would fight zombies with a blunt rusty spoon to eat here again. Will be back to try other sandwiches. read more

Nice little space on the Market. The owners took my order and made my Pastrami sandwich with freshly sliced meat, fresh provolone and bread. They topped it off with a nice mustard. Delicious. The meat is the star of the show. Perfectly prepared. read more

Craft-Eats - Menu front - Sandwiches Near Me - Hanover, Pennsylvania

This place is a hidden gem! We came to this location looking for a different vendor not realizing this complex had a food court & bar! We wandered around to see what there was besides the one we came for! Struck up a conversation with the owners & after having the samples they offered, we ordered the Ronnie & the Allie! Both were amazing! We also ordered from the original place we'd come for! Although both places had good food, the order from Craft Eats was much better! So glad we found them! Plus, it's always nice to support a small, family-owned business! Eat here!! You won't be disappointed! read more

Delicious homemade food, served hot with generous portions. Mashed potatoes with gravy taste like Mom's food. Service is outstanding!