I'll get right to the point -- order the Doctor Jones Tavern Style Pizza, and make sure to get the Pretzel Roll appetizers with the Beer Cheese dipping sauce, and you'll want to thank and hug me! This place is outstanding. Great menu, unique options, and solid servers. read more

I liked this place. Good beer selection, with some pretty good craft beer on hand. Great service (thanks Madi G. from the quiet older guy who sat at table 21 and mostly just jacked around on his phone). They have lots of TVs with the appropriate sports games on at advantageous viewing angles. I had a 12" Mac Daddy, which is basically a supreme pizza, hold the onion. It was good, not great, although when I put it in the fridge and ate the leftovers that night, it tasted like a million bucks. So I guess it was better than I thought it was. The total for a 12" pizza and two craft beers, plus tax, was $32.68, and I think I tipped Madi up to $40. So it was a $40 pizza and beer experience for one person. I think that's a little excessive, but as people seem to constantly say, "In this day and age....." I'd definitely come back and try some of the other stuff on the menu, mostly bar bites/pub fair. Overall it was a good experience. read more

This is literally the best pizza I've ever eaten. I ordered the Doctor Jones pizza multiple times and it never disappoints me. The old style peppperoni with the hot honey is a perfect match! Don't worry, it doesn't come with pineapple, it's my own additional topping. Their wings are really good too. I've tried the Korean BBQ, Thai Sweet Chili, And Garlic Parm and they're all wonderful. read more

Crafters Pizza and Drafthouse - Snack Wings (Korean BBQ, Sweet Thai Chili) - Pizza Near Me - Carmel, Indiana

See all

Had lunch here and the pizza and wings were outstanding. Our awesome server, Elizabeth, recommended the limited-time umami wing sauce and it is honestly one of the best sauces I've ever eaten. Brian, the owner, created a winner with this one. read more

With a unique menu and impeccable service, crafters is one the best places to go in the greater Indy area. Good for game day or date night, the amazing staff and food will always suprise you in the unique combinations that their chefs create. read more

This place was amazing. Our server was Mike. He was awesome. The pizza and the wings were top notch. Every suggestion he gave us was right on. We will regulars for sure. read more

This is a great pub/restaurant! The food is very consistent. Especially the pizza and wings. I haven't tried a sandwich, yet. But I will expand my choices on my future visits read more

This is my favorite restaurant. Wings are amazing and the Dr Jones pizza is the best pizza I've ever had. The Mediterranean meatballs are so good. You know it's a great place because it's always packed. read more

Still like stopping by here for pizza and wings, our 3rd visit since a Yelp event introduced us to this place. We came on a busy Saturday night and let me say, the host is a pro! He took care of everyone efficiently and was very nice. The Doctor Jones is delicious, and this time they served it with a garlic sauce which we hadn't had before. This was unique and I loved it, ask for it if you visit! read more

See all

Great service! Pizza and wings are amazing! Family friendly as well ! Kids love the wings !

The pizza is good but not great. It may be because it's of a particular style and it's not my fav. The breadsticks and beer cheese is great tho. Wings also good. Prices going up along with everyone else's read more

Great local gathering spot. Great food at good prices. Our server John was very attentive. And the bar tender Matt was on it. We will be back. read more

Saturday night we found ourselves wanting to try a new pizza joint and Crafters came up. Head there and the inside looks great, appetizer of wings good, and our server was excellent, but.... Pizza doesn't rank above any other option around Carmel. Just mediocre. Music volume increased about 15 minutes in and was horrendously loud. We couldn't talk across the table at all. Had to ask server to repeat themselves. We considered leaving it was that bad, but orders had been placed and kids were hungry. Beer temperature was awkward. Odd to say, but I don't know how to any other way. It was like the glass was colder than the beer and I couldn't tell if the beer was warm poured into a cold glass or what. The hopeful 2* is only because of the wings being good, and our server was great. read more

I have been on the hunt for good gluten free pizza and I think I finally found it! The gouten free crust is so good I had to double check to make sure it actually was gluten free. They have a huge selection of yummy toppings, and their mixed drinks are very good too! All around very impressed read more

Crafters Pizza and Drafthouse - Gluten free Margarita pizza - Pizza Near Me - Carmel, Indiana

Tasty pizza spot! Honestly need to go back again soon. We were pleased with the pizza options and the family friendly/fun ambiance. Great service & plenty of parking. Really no complaints! read more

Crafters Pizza and Drafthouse - Pizza Near Me - Carmel, Indiana

Excellent staff, location and atmosphere! We've been twice and everyone was very nice and pleasant both times. The food is superb and it's a great spot to hang out for some laughs or catch a game. It is a bit pricey but well worth it read more

We have been going here regularly for a lot of years, I can't believe we have not reviewed this yet. From the food to the service everything is exceptional. Amazing pizza with tons of options, great salads, excellent, fast Service. Wings and meatballs are great too! So many good things to say about this place. Our servers are always great, everyone seems to really care and do a great job. The decor/vibe here is really cool! Always lots of great beers on tap! One of our favorite places in the Carmel/Westfield/Noblesville area. read more

They take no responsibility for a delivery order. Ordered $100.00 to be delivered. It was delivered to wrong address and the staff members responded "not our problem " They actually new the address of where it was delivered!!! read more

Finally made it to my first elite event and I am glad I got to experience it . So here it goes Ordered the pizza over the phone, my husband wanted one to so added it to my order. Got there and immediately went to the elite event pickup! Natalie was really sweet and ready to help. I told them my maiden last name without realizing that I have my married last name in my yelp account which created a confusing situation. All through the confusion Natalie was really really helpful. There was another person who kind of thought I might not be with yelp elite at all ... haha anyways After a whole lot of confusion it finally happened .. the light bulb went on .. lol I realized my mistake and told my last name starts with T and voila there was my name .. finally got my 2 pizzas, paid for one and got one as a part of the elite event ... The pizza was ok, can't complain but not praise worthy either ..me and my husband both felt the same ... the inside however looks like a place you would definitely consider going for the weekends ..from my view point looks like a place you should visit.. and decide for yourself !!! read more

Crafters Pizza and Drafthouse - Pizza Near Me - Carmel, Indiana

See all

Been hearing great things about this place so wanted to try out! They have really good drink specials each day and a great happy hour menu as well. I went on a Thursday and all the mules were $4, so I ordered an orange one. For my pizza, I got the Porky one and added a salad. Both were very good. The sauces that the pizza came with really took it to the next level. The service was good, the drinks were strong, and the food was tasty! Excited to try their wings (as I've heard people really enjoy them) and check out their happy hour one day! read more

Friendly greeting inside. We were asked if we wanted bar, dining or patio. We chose patio. We were greeted pretty promptly even though they were pretty busy. We got Pretzel Sticks with Queso. On the menu it list SOFT PRETZELS & QUESO so in my mind I was expecting soft pretzels not sticks. I also wish it said Beer Queso, I don't like beer anything. We probably would have skipped on this appetizer. That being said the sticks were good but could have used salt. Second appetizer was toasted raviolis. They were really really good. They were served with what I think was creamy Italian Dressing and Marinara. I would have never thought Italian dressing would go with those but it did. I got the Margarita Pizza. I liked but didn't love. I think I would have liked thin slices of Roma Tomato on top instead of chopped up tomato. Husband got the SHAKE HANDS WITH MEATS, Red sauce, pepperoni, Italian sausage, ground beef, ham, and bacon. It was awesome. For an 8 inch pizza it was loaded with toppings. He ate all of it but the small bite I had. Service was very good and attentive. I talked to I'm guessing a manager. She was very friendly. Two complaints: About half way thru dinner I started getting dripped on and every now and then I was catching whiffs of sewer smell. Other than that we will be back to try other things. read more

I'm a veggie pizza fan, and I can say with confidence this was the most loaded veggie pizza I've had. It was stacked, saucy and delicious. The crust is pillowy with a slight crunch on the rim. Even with the single serving size, I paired it with a side salad and had enough for lunch the next day. My husband ordered their pizza with sausage and prosciutto and was delighted to see they use crumbled sausage. He devoured his in one sitting. I can't Wait to try out their calzones soon. Their entire menu looked delicious! read more

Yes yes yes so much yes. Life has been busy and I'm late to the punch in writing this review. But this a must stop place. Soooo good. The peppadew pepper jam and sweet cheese is amazing. Spicy but sweet on perfectly toasted garlic bread that has soft chew to it. Soooooo good. Then while just taking our time they brought us breadsticks because to many were made and the beer cheese is phenomenal. Some of the best I've had. I forgot the specialty pizza name but it had hot honey on it and thin crust. So delicious. Tons of beer on tap and liquor. Bartenders and staff were amazing. This is a repeat. read more

Yeah! Finally a good pizza place in Carmel! We ordered takeout and it was very easy. They have dedicated spots in the front for takeout and pickup customers. It's located just east of 31 off 146th st behind the movie theater. We had the 8 inch Mac Daddy and the wing plate with sweet Thai chili sauce. The pizza was loaded with topping a d the crust was crispy. My husband, the wing connoisseur, loved the wings. Their daily specials are posted on the window. Nice large dining room and an outdoor patio. read more

Outstanding, clean and beautiful place. Plenty of room and they bring water to your table without asking... Perfect... The breadsticks with queso is top notch... The margarita pizza is fabulous.. The sauce is the best on the pizza. I would say top 3 pizza place in Indiana I have eaten. We will return. read more

Crafters Pizza and Drafthouse - Must have! - Pizza Near Me - Carmel, Indiana

See all

We were on this side of town and my son wanted pizza. So we stopped in and got a their version of an all meat pizza. The pizza was outstanding with a light airy crust. The three of us devoured that thing. read more

Crafters Pizza and Drafthouse - Pizza Near Me - Carmel, Indiana

This is the best place to eat in Carmel!! Not only for the food but because of the service. The owner is there almost every night and makes sure everyone and everything is perfect. Last time I was there he brought out a complimentary dessert for my nephew because we were talking about baseball. Good food, good service, cold beer, you cannot miss with this place. 10/10. Thanks Brian! read more

Crafters Pizza and Drafthouse - Pizza Near Me - Carmel, Indiana

Best pizza we've had in the Indy area!! Highly recommend the luchador. Tasted great even as take out:

Stopped in yesterday for the Yelp Elite event. The inside is a mix of industrial rustic interior which I've always liked. I was greeted coming in the door which is also very nice. I put my order in with the bartender she was extremely nice and helpful. So I did get my order to go because I had a meeting to go to but they fixed my pizzas super fast and the bartender made sure I was all set with everything I needed before I left. I will say I didn't know if the pizza was going to make it to my next destination because it smelled so good. I'm happy to report I was able to restrain myself and it made it. So I got The Nannie which I loved the sauce is so simple and rustic. I also got the MacDaddy which was equally fantastic all fresh ingredients including fresh tomatoes which I think set off the pizza. I just love the hand tossed crust perfectly baked and nice and crisp. Both pizzas I got the hand tossed. If you want good, fresh pizza you need to stop by and get a pizza. I will definitely be making my way there again. Because the menu has so many items I want to try. Great food and great service!!! read more

Crafters Pizza and Drafthouse - The Nannie - Pizza Near Me - Carmel, Indiana

See all

We just got home from eating dinner here. It was absolutely delicious! Not many people there tonight so service was great. Tonight was $5 margarita night. Yes please! We got the pretzel with cheese dip and it was delicious! We then got the Crafters Signature salad and we added bacon and fried onions and substituted ranch for our dressing and it was phenomenal! I also want to correct something I read here in the reviews where someone said you can't substitute dressings because you most certainly can! We then got a medium HC Tastebuds pizza minus the mushrooms and we opted for thin crust and that was hands down the best pizza I've ever eaten! Most places when you get thin crust it's hard and crunchy but this pizza was nothing like that. It was perfection! We didn't take advantage of this option but you can get half and half if you want two different kinds of pizza which is cool. The restaurant is nice with large televisions each direction you turn your head. Tonight they had the basketball game on but no volume. They play music and I could have done without that but it wasn't as loud as a lot of places. We will certainly be back!! read more

See all

Friendly staff, delicious pizza, fun environment, and best skillet cookie EVER This is definitely a go-to for me.

First off, the place was very crowded so I'd definitely recommend getting there early! The host stand greeted us right away, as well as our server. He was quick and friendly. Made sure to check in the perfect amount. What I assume was also a manager stopped by our table to check in as well. Great customer service! Everyone was super kind. Pizza matches if not exceeds service. A great restaurant overall and A top ten Indiana spot for a slice! We will be back soon. One of the better first dine in experiences I've had in a long time. read more

Just came to Crafters for the first time the food was amazing, Try the wings!!! The Aurelio's Orange sauce was ridiculous and being from queens NYC I would think like most "nyc pizza in Indiana" and be let down, the pizza was AMAZING. Everything we ate was great and beers were ice cold, service was amazing Seth and Sebastian at the bar were knowledgeable and had some great recommendations! Do yourself a favor and pop in! read more

Every thing is wildly fantastic. Love the different combinations of pizza, wings and the house made chips are the best I've ever had. Keep doing things your way and the dinning room will stay full! read more

Such a great pizza place! We ordered two craft beers, double decker chips, and a large Doctor Jones hand tossed pizza. They have a decent size beer list, with a handful of local craft beers and two rotating. The double decker chips were fantastic on their own. The chips are super crisp with a layer of beer cheese and bacon. It also comes with three dips; sour cream, green salsa, and a chipotle sauce. We personally didn't think the sauces were necessary but a good addition. The pizza was next level. The pepperoni crisped up into little cups which held the hot honey perfectly. Honestly some of the best paired pizza we've had! We'll definitely be back! read more

Crafters Pizza and Drafthouse - Doctor Jones - Pizza Near Me - Carmel, Indiana

Great Tap takeover by Switchyard Brewing yesterday! Really love the updated Bourbon options, new cocktail menu, new wine list and food items! Keep it up Crafters! You're crushing it... read more

See all

My husband and I visited today and we were very impressed !! We got the pretzel breadsticks with queso (not pictured because we ate them so fast ), bruschetta salad, and Buffalo chicken pizza . Everything was absolutely delicious ! The service was great as well. We found out from the owner's wife (who came out and spoke to us ) that this is a locally owned business, rather than a chain, so we are excited to be able to support local. We will definitely be back ! read more

See all

This was a really random place for me to end up for pizza, but where I was headed had no parking but I'm glad I tried it. Right away we received friendly service and were given our choice of table. So many good sounding things on the menu but I opted for an 8" Hawaiian pizza and side chopped salad. The salad was very good and I especially loved the vinaigrette dressing. The pizza was perfect. Perfect flavor. Perfect amount of cheese. Perfect size. My dinner date got a 12" Buffalo chicken pizza with fried crust. The crust was super different in a good way but I like the original better. Don't expect to pay Domino's prices here, but the pizza and salads were dynamite. Looking forward to doing carry out sometime soon! read more

See all

This where Bombazz Pizza used to be. First, my service was fast and you can tell this place works hard. Promt on answering the phone, taking my order and repeating it back ( that matters to me), and pick up was easy. The menu is unique with your "not so typical" pizza, meatballs, sandwiches and salads. I ordered a lot to try and......my family and I went nuts! We were so pleased, everything was hot and beyond my expectations( which is hard.) I got the Dr. Jones... hot honey and old style pepperoni.... might be the best pizza I've ever had. I know, big statement.... it's true. So original! Try it.... now. My wife got the veggie stand and said it was one of her all time favorites. The neighbors came over for drinks and we heated it up. They said the same thing! Meatballs rock, just try your favorite flavor. This place is special. read more

Very cool looking restaurant with great food! The service was extremely friendly and Went out of their way to take care of myself and the entire party.. I highly recommend this place. We will be back! read more

See all