Excellent food. The croissants are luscious - right from the oven if you get there early and I…read morehighly recommend the cheese danish as well. Honestly, everything is good! All fresh and wonderful. If you want to enjoy a dinner take out, grab the fried chicken. It's not your usual highly encrusted breaded chicken but very tasty and light at the same time. The store has various fresh vegetables and seasonal items, along with expensive Eiffel t shirts ($60) and cute straw beach bags to buy along with a bank of refrigerators and freezers filled with drinks- some alcoholic. Pre made frozen food is available, as well as items such as tuna salad. All are pricey (pint of tuna salad was $16) but excellent. Smaller frozen thin pizzas (about $20) ranging from cheese to artichoke topped are available also. Great for dinner with a salad. Coffee is available in the back and delicious breakfast sandwiches are available to order also. You can dine outdoors either at tables in front of the store, or in the back on a small deck overlooking the harbor. Often lovely Marie is there, chatting with diners. All in all a wonderful place, with great food. Be aware you will be paying absolute top dollar, but worth it.

I'm giving you three stars instead of the five you deserve. My main complaint? No bathrooms. You…read morehave to go OUTSIDE to use a freaking bathroom after you pay astronomical prices for food that you can get in NYC easily CHEAPER. The food is good but my veggie burger was salty, the buns were over baked. Impossible to eat. The French Onion soup was decent but I have certainly had better. After all of this, we have to go outside for a piss.

I have had bagels all over the world and nothing beats the one's from Goldberg's Famous Bagelsread more

We stopped in for breakfast at this very busy bagel shop. It took a long time for our order to be…read morecomplete. Many people who arrived after us were served their food before ours was done and they did not serve us as they did other customers. I don't know why.....strange. We ordered two plain bagels with butter, one bagel with egg and cheese and a BEC on a flat bagel. It was all very delicious. I would give it five stars but the wait was ridiculous.

Came to Montauk on the off season and had to get ourselves a bacon egg and cheese while we were out…read morehere. This deli has been here for as long as I can remember coming out this way, and I was thrilled to see it was still opened during off season. We ordered a bacon egg and cheese to go. Service was fast and friendly. Ambiance was giving clean, well stocked, and well organized. Prices are what they are given that it's Montauk. But my sandwich was piled high with bacon, eggs were cooked well and cheese was melted, so I really can't complain.

Excellent $10 Turkey and cheese with mayo and hot peppers sandwich. Big bag of Hal's salt and…read morepepper chips - expensive but excellent.

I went there with my family for a quick bite after the beach. Wow the baby back ribs, delicious…read more Jerk pork butt amazing and moist, iver the yellow rice with sweet plantains. Wish you were closer to home.

When grabbing lunch in Montauk this is my go-to. They have a hot buffet with lots of options. Today…read moreI got yellow rice, beans, jerk pork and cabbage (as the salad). All so good! The pork was tender and spicy! This lunch plate, a grilled cheese for my nephew and bottle of water cost $22. I didn't see a sign regarding a credit card fee but my guess is that they might have one. The employee at the register asked all customers how they were paying. No seats inside to eat. There are multiple picnic tables outside.

I love writing reviews of every new place I visit... and today, I definitely couldn't wait until…read morethe end of the day to write about the tacos I just had for lunch--they had an authentic Mexican flavor. Not Texan, not Northern-style--no, simply and perfectly Mexican! The real deal, in every sense of the word. They also serve tortas, enchiladas, and other delights for breakfast or lunch! Recommended!!

I just ordered a simple turkey and cheese sandwich on a roll and it was just okay. They have a wide…read morevariety of specials and stuff that I wish I had tried because they sounded very good, next time I am in the area I will probably try it out. They also have a lot of chips and snacks that you can buy that are right next to the line area for your convenience.

Does everyone know that besides being the best bagel shop on the North Fork, GOLDBERGS actively…read moresupports the local community? YES THEY DO! GOLDBERGS continues to support the Southold Historical Museum each year for their annual "History In the Making" pickleball tournament, which takes place next Saturday, May 30. 2026, at Tasker Park in Peconic. There are still some spots left! So next weekend, as you're rushing out the door for the 9 am tournament start time, know that GOLDBERGS will have free bagels waiting for you!!! Thank you GOLDBERGS for the great food and generous support. You are invaluable to this community.

Good it's so good I love the food service is also good and the ambiance is also good toread more

Stopped by on the way out of town in the off season. Got a hobo with pork roll on a flat not…read moretoasted. Bagel sandwich was good, would order again. Have to agree with some of the reviews, staff wasn't mean but not the friendliest.

Excellent bagels with lox on my birthday! We were on our way…read moreto BlockIsland and this was the perfect spot before getting on the ferry from Montauk. Malique was kind enough to wash off our picnic table. He did a great job (ignored the other table but who's watching) and we sat outside and loved our coffee and the food.... This spot has a little motel next door that might be a great location to stay if your planning g a trip to block island and don't need to be directly on beach.... I'll be back here for sure!

Long wait, eh bagels. Overhyped, although I'm not sure there's any other bagel spots out east…read more Service at the counter was rude. Bathroom was broken.

So fresh! I was intimidated by the prices but just posting a quick review to say I was pleasantly…read moresurprised with how much we enjoyed our order. Bagels were so fresh, perfect texture and chewy. Not too doughy. The cream cheese was so cold and the peppers were crunchy and colorful. I thought I ordered vegetable cream cheese but I must have pointed to this cream cheese I had never heard of before. It had chopped red, green, yellow, and orange bell peppers. It was so good, I'll have to look for it again. Just fyi, if you order a bagel with cream cheese, it's spread with so much cheese, enough to put on another bagel.