Came to Montauk on the off season and had to get ourselves a bacon egg and cheese while we were out…read morehere. This deli has been here for as long as I can remember coming out this way, and I was thrilled to see it was still opened during off season. We ordered a bacon egg and cheese to go. Service was fast and friendly. Ambiance was giving clean, well stocked, and well organized. Prices are what they are given that it's Montauk. But my sandwich was piled high with bacon, eggs were cooked well and cheese was melted, so I really can't complain.

Excellent $10 Turkey and cheese with mayo and hot peppers sandwich. Big bag of Hal's salt and…read morepepper chips - expensive but excellent.

I went there with my family for a quick bite after the beach. Wow the baby back ribs, delicious…read more Jerk pork butt amazing and moist, iver the yellow rice with sweet plantains. Wish you were closer to home.

When grabbing lunch in Montauk this is my go-to. They have a hot buffet with lots of options. Today…read moreI got yellow rice, beans, jerk pork and cabbage (as the salad). All so good! The pork was tender and spicy! This lunch plate, a grilled cheese for my nephew and bottle of water cost $22. I didn't see a sign regarding a credit card fee but my guess is that they might have one. The employee at the register asked all customers how they were paying. No seats inside to eat. There are multiple picnic tables outside.

This review is for the ice cream. We took a wrong turn at a marina nearby while looking for ice…read morecream and happened to talk with an employee of Tony's. He had us follow him in our car and took us right to the ice cream section. OMG, what a selection. It was hard to choose. In the end we bought the half pints: original fudge ice cream sundae and rainbow cookie ice cream sundae. As we are staying 20 minutes away, the employees gave us some ice in our bag. Despite the heat, it didn't melt on the way home. The rainbow cookie ice cream sundae was far superior.

Best food out east. Everything is fresh and the meat is A+. Sandwiches are great and the Cesar wrap…read moreis the best thing on the menu. New ownership is great and it's a great buy what ever you get.

Long wait, eh bagels. Overhyped, although I'm not sure there's any other bagel spots out east…read more Service at the counter was rude. Bathroom was broken.

So fresh! I was intimidated by the prices but just posting a quick review to say I was pleasantly…read moresurprised with how much we enjoyed our order. Bagels were so fresh, perfect texture and chewy. Not too doughy. The cream cheese was so cold and the peppers were crunchy and colorful. I thought I ordered vegetable cream cheese but I must have pointed to this cream cheese I had never heard of before. It had chopped red, green, yellow, and orange bell peppers. It was so good, I'll have to look for it again. Just fyi, if you order a bagel with cream cheese, it's spread with so much cheese, enough to put on another bagel.

Read reviews that Herb's Market has the best fried chicken in town! And it absolutely was!…read more I was exploring Montauk Village Main St with my parents and we stumbled upon the market. Much to my surprise, the place was quite empty walking in maybe due to its huge space. My dad wanted deli meats, but I recommended the fried chicken. My parents sat down at these large picnic benches while I ordered a bunch of fried chicken by the piece! When I got to the counter, the guy informed me that there was only white meat left and that he would put in a new batch of dark meat now. I waited patiently for 15 minutes while the new batch was fried. Then, I ordered a bunch of wings, legs, and a thigh. I'm so happy we were able to order by piece because nobody likes white meat in my family even though it's the most meaty. I was also surprised that the white meat costs the most! The chicken was beautifully battered and flavored. Not too thick nor too salty! It was out of this world and it is what will bring me back to Montauk. The place also sells a bunch of pantry items, sandwiches, salads, and drinks. Once you order you pay at the cash register by the front door. Very friendly people!

Now that Montauk has morphed into a chi-chi destination, sourcing reasonably priced nutritious fare…read morehas become quite the challenge. Thank goodness Herb's Market is still around offering hearty deli sandwiches, freshly made fried chicken and ribs, beverages, salads and more. All served up by friendly young personnel with no sneering pretentious vibes in sight.

A health market with fresh produce and dry goods. An extensive menu offers breakfast, lunch and…read moresmoothies, as well as coffees. Take out or eat in. Many vegan options! The smoothies are delicious and you can customize with a variety of additions. The service was fine but it did take a long time to get a salad, wrap and smoothie.

It's such a lovely spot ! I highly recommend Naturally Good if you are a fan of healthy organic…read moreplaces. I love the chili here in the winter. Super tasty baked goods - big fan of the blueberry banana gluten-free muffin!! Fresh organic juices & smoothies Great coffee Star girl made me the best latte I've ever had.

It's Sunday and we're waiting to board our fishing boat…read more I'm asked, Did you bring beer? Did I bring beer, did you bring beer?? We have no beer but have no fear. Across the street is "The Market". Its a brand new mini market/deli. Think 7-11 but more upscale. Anything that you'd need for your stay in Montauk is most likely being sold at The Market: Milk, eggs, bacon, soda, chips and Bacon-Egg-Cheese on a roll, all being offered for your purchase pleasure. I grabbed a small suitcase of Montauk beer. How much!?!? Here's the thing, the Montauk brewery is right up the corner! If Bud is cheaper than Montauk, there is something seriously wrong with this picture. Thanks for the convenience but when I'm in The Market, it won't be for beer.

Come here often, the friendliest people, good options, both healthy, organic & conventional…read morechoices. They have everything you might need! Recently took my visiting son & daughter-in-law here & ordered great hero's (must have Montexan or Downeaster) & some AMAZING smoothies (try the Protein Pack !) Lots of fun stuff & even some Zen stuff! The self serve coffee counter is gorgeous! You can eat outside casually & in. I almost forgot about the Açaí & Pitaya bowls!!!

Very nice staff and a great location. It's pretty much what you would expect from a place like…read morethis. It has a nice, positive vibe, which makes it a pleasant place to stop by. My wrap was good, although it was a little dry. I just wish they had more seating, especially since it can get pretty busy at times. Overall, it's a good place to grab something to eat, have a drink, or get a quick snack.

Perfect brunch spot - delicious smoothies and food. However this review is for the "I Love Chicken"…read morewrap - holy cow, the BEST wrap I've ever had. Chicken was tender and seasoned, the wrap itself was warm, perfect mix of beans, rice, avocado.... I thought about that wrap for the next 2-3 hours.

All I can say is yum! I haven't been in the restaurant, we ordered food to be delivered, and I…read moredidn't realize how far it was, but I'm so glad we did. I had the strawberry salad with chicken, which was excellent. The goat cheese, complements the strawberries perfectly. The chicken was cooked well and it wasn't dry, like so many salads. My boyfriend had the Greek salad with chicken and he enjoyed it as well.

This is a cute place to eat or stop and do some shopping…read more There are tables in a nice outside covered area if you want to eat al fresco or inside seating if you'd prefer it. They have a grocery section with good organic foods and essentials. Vegan options, great home fries, great pumpkin pancakes, nice selection of smoothies and many others. Order your food and they bring it to your table. Good, friendly service, I would go back again.

I have been living in this town for years and I choose to go to the IGA in Amagansett due to the…read morelack of options and quality of produce compared to Amagansett IGA even though that location is not the best either. Living in such a wealthy area on Long Island you would think our grocery stores would be top of the line. That is farthest from the truth. I have been to better grocery stores in much lower income neighborhoods than the ones we have in the Hamptons. I particularly had enough tonight and could not keep this bottled up. I had a late night craving for the white cheddar Cheetos puffs. Every grocery store but the one in my town carries them. I don't ever eat junk food, but I had a desperate craving tonight. They have let me down. I hate that there is mostly self check out now. It is cold and soulless compared to the relationships you build with the people in front of you. My family and I miss the old staff... they were wonderful. Do better Montauk IGA. Bring back normal checkouts instead of this computer BS. Two self check outs stations were enough. Do better on the inventory.

Title: The Human Raincloud of the Montauk IGA…read more I've been shopping at the Montauk IGA for years and can say, without hesitation, that it's usually a shining example of small-town warmth and friendliness. The staff is famously helpful, cheerful, and welcoming -- which is why encountering Dayanara at the checkout feels like suddenly stepping into a thunderstorm in the middle of a sunny day. It's as if her job description reads: "Scowl, sigh heavily, and make customers question all their life choices." She manages to inject rudeness into the most basic exchanges, going out of her way to be curt, unhelpful, and generally unpleasant. If Montauk ever needed a mascot for passive-aggressive hostility, she'd be overqualified. This isn't a case of someone having a bad day -- this is a professional commitment to being a human sandpaper strip. The contrast with the rest of the staff is so stark it's almost performance art. For the sake of the store's otherwise stellar reputation, she should be moved into a role that doesn't involve live humans. Stock room. Night shift. Mars. Anywhere but the checkout lane. IGA Montauk, keep doing what you do best -- just maybe reassign your resident mood assassin before she convinces visitors that "Montauk charm" is a myth.